Advances in Agriculture
Volume 2018 (2018), Article ID 6042495, 13 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/6042495

Research Article

Association of Chocolate Spot and Faba Bean Rust Epidemics with Climate Change Resilient Cultural Practices in Bale Highlands, Ethiopia

Gosaye Eshetu, Yekedem Bimrew, and Hassen Shifa

Department of Plant Science, College of Agriculture and Natural Resource, Madda Walabu University, P.O. Box 247, Bale Robe, Ethiopia

Correspondence should be addressed to Hassen Shifa; hasanb2020@gmail.com

Received 14 October 2018; Accepted 6 December 2018; Published 23 December 2018

Academic Editor: Zhongxu Lin

Copyright © 2018 Gosaye Eshetu et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract.

Field survey was conducted in south eastern Ethiopia to determine the disease intensity of chocolate spot and rust and to investigate the association of disease intensity (incidence and severity) with environmental factors and crop cultural practices. A total of 280 faba bean fields were surveyed in eight districts, and type of cropping system, weed management practices, crop growth stage, previous crop in the field, and sowing date were recorded. The associations of disease intensity with independent variables were evaluated using logistic regression model. Mean disease incidence of chocolate spot varied from 70.9 to 93.2% in most fields while percentage severity index (PSI) ranged from 10.5 to 47.1%. In a reduced multiple variable model, chocolate PSI ≤ 30% showed high probability of association with mixed cropping system, good weed management practices, late planting, and when faba bean was rotated with vegetables and cereals. The mean disease incidence of faba bean rust was varied from 23.6 to 78.2%, while the mean PSI of rust was varied from 4.8 to 37.9%. In Gasera, Dinsho, and Agarfa districts, poor weed management practices, fields planted in the month of July, and when previous crop was legume had a high probability of association to (>20) rust PSI in a multiple variable reduced model. In contrast, soil types, fertilizer applied, and fungicides sprayed were not associated with disease intensity. The present study has identified cropping system, planting date, previous crop, district, and weed management practices as important variables that influence faba bean chocolate spot and rust epidemics in diversified fields. Therefore, proper weeding management practices, late planting, crop rotation habit, and other related farm practices should be carried out to reduce chocolate spot and rust impact until resistant faba bean genotypes are developed and distributed to the area.

1. Introduction

Faba bean (Vicia faba L.) is an important pulse crop produced all over the world for humans as a source of protein and carbohydrate and for animal feeds [1]. It is also an excellent crop for fixing atmospheric nitrogen and as green manure [2, 3]. In addition, faba bean is used as a source of cash crop to farmers and foreign currency in Ethiopia [4]. Faba bean is the sixth most important grain legume with 4.3 million tons of annual production worldwide. Next to China, Ethiopia is the second largest producer of faba bean [5, 6] with annual production of 0.88 million tones and nearly covers 0.43 million hectares of lands counting about 31.2% of total pulse production of the country [7].

In spite of its various importance, the productivity of faba bean in Ethiopia remains far below the crop’s potential (3.8t/ha), which has been constrained by several biotic and abiotic factors [8–11]. Climate change (variability), edaphic factor, water stress, and colds are among major abiotic constraints of faba bean production. Moreover, climate variability due to increased temperature and erratic precipitation over time has increased susceptibility of faba bean which also favoured disease development [12]. As a result of climate change different fungal pathogen evolved, seriously affecting the production of faba bean [13, 14]. Thus, climate change and associated factors of disease scenarios demand changes in crop and disease management strategies.

More than seventeen pathogens have been reported so far on faba bean from different parts of Ethiopia [11]. Of them the most important yield limiting diseases are chocolate spot (Botrytis fabae), rust (Uromyces viciae-fabae), and black rot (Fusarium solani). Particularly, chocolate spot and faba bean rust are the most serious and economically damaging diseases that affect the foliage, limit the photosynthetic activity, and reduce the productivity of faba bean, globally [15–17]. Chocolate spot is a major limiting factor in the main faba bean growing regions of Ethiopia resulting with yield losses ranging from 34.1 to 61.2% [14, 18]. Faba bean rust is also a severe disease which causes about 70% of faba bean yield losses across the world in general [10] and in the Middle East, North Africa, Ethiopia, and parts of Australia in particular [16, 19, 20]. In Ethiopian context there is rust devastating disease following chocolate spot, which causes 2 to 15% and 14-21% seed yield loss, respectively, in lower and intermediate altitudes [12]. Together, rust and chocolate spot may cause total crop failure under severe epidemic conditions, resulting with more than 50% yield losses [16, 21].

Sahile et al. [22] reported that different production practices such as planting date, weed management, cropping system, and previous crop can influence disease occurrence, epidemic development, and the damage caused to the crops. The disease severity can also be influenced by certain farming systems, field location, and/or season. Management options for chocolate spot and rust disease in Ethiopia include use of resistant cultivars, chemical control (Mancozeb), and late planting, but these options were neither widely disseminated nor adopted by end users (farmers) [8].

Information concerning the distribution and importance of chocolate spot and rust has not been systematically analyzed in major faba bean growing areas of the country; especially in the south eastern parts the information is totally lacking. Accordingly, as the diseases become a recurrent problem in the major faba bean production areas of the country, it is imperative to develop an effective integrated chocolate spot and rust management package, which is sustainable in agricultural yield development, knowledge of the relationships of the disease with different variables [23]. Thus, the information obtained from survey work is necessary for planning management strategies; the present study aimed at investigating (i) the incidence and severity of chocolate spot and rust diseases and (ii) association of chocolate spot and rust with farmers cultural practices in the major faba bean growing areas of Bale Highlands, south eastern Ethiopia.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Survey Areas

The survey was conducted in eight districts of Bale highlands (i.e., Agarfa, Dinsho, Gasera, Goba, Gololcha, Goro, Ginir, and Sinana) during the main cropping season of 2017. The selection of the districts was based on faba bean production and productivity across south eastern Ethiopia as well as their accessibility to road. Mainly the districts were differed in altitude, weather, and soil characteristics (Table 1). The rainfall data of the surveyed districts were obtained from meteorological stations. A total of 280 faba bean fields were inspected to assess the magnitude of chocolate spot and rust disease. The time of survey was chosen so as to coincide with the time of flowering, podding, and late podding stages of faba bean, when the diseases reached its maximum [10, 22]. The districts surveyed were shown in Figure 1.

Table 1: Characteristic features of surveyed faba bean fields in eight districts of Bale highlands, south eastern Ethiopia.

District
Altitude (m. a. s. l)
Annual total rainfall (mm)
Temperature (°C)
Soil type

Agarfa
2328-2505
907
10-24
Vertisol

Dinsho
2528-2599
1170
5-20
Clay

Gasera
2341-2428
878
8-24
Vertisol

Ginir
1889-2289
983
14-27
Loam

Goba
2445-2600
935
9-23
Vertisol

Gololcha
1993-2102
994
12-27
Vertisol

Goro
1805-2237
920
9-32
Loam

Sinana
2374-2456
878
6-24
Vertisol

Figure 1: Map of Ethiopia and the Bale highlands showing the surveyed districts.

2.2. Sampling and Disease Assessments

Fields were sampled randomly at the interval of 5–10 km along roads. Depending on the topography and the relative importance of faba bean cultivation within each district the distances between fields were determined. In each sampled field, four quadrants (2m×2m) 10m away from each other were sampled by making diagonal moves with four throws in order to represent four replications per field. Following each throw, the number of healthy and infected (chocolate spot and rust) leaves of 12 plants within the area were recorded. A subsample of twelve leaves per plant and four leaves per canopy layers (upper, middle, and lower) were selected from the main stem, yielding a total of 144 leaves per field. Mean of canopy layers was determined per plant and then averaged per field for data analysis. Chocolate spot and rust incidence were rated as mean percentage of diseased plant leaves within the quadrant. Severity was rated on leaves from the same 12 representative plants in each quadrat, using a 1–9 scale [24], in which 1 indicates no visible symptom and 9 represents disease covering more than 80% of the foliar tissue. Disease severity scores were converted into percentage severity index (PSI) for the analysis [25, 26].

During the survey, cultural practices like soil type (vertisol, loam, and clay), cropping system (mixed or sole), weed management practices, type of fungicide applied, previous crop, planting date, and crop growth stages of every sampled field were recorded.

2.3. Data Analyses

Disease incidence and PSI were classified into distinct groups of binomial qualitative data. Thus, ≤75 and >75% were chosen for chocolate spot incidence yielding a binary variable and class boundaries of ≤30 and >30% were chosen for chocolate spot PSI data (Table 2). Class boundaries of ≤50% and >50% for rust incidence and ≤20 and >20% were chosen for rust PSI data.

Table 2: Independent variable by disease contingency table for logistic regression analysis of chocolate spot and rust during 2017 main cropping season in eight districts (n=280) of Bale highlands, south eastern Ethiopia.

Independent variable
Variable class
Total number of fields
Number of fields in different chocolate spot and rust categories

Chocolate spot
Rust

Incidence
PSI
Incidence
PSI (%)

≤75
>75
≤30
>30
≤50
>50
≤20
>20

Districts
Agarfa
35
-
35
21
14
28
7
27
8

Dinsho
35
2
33
7
28
21
14
18
17

Gasera
35
1
34
14
21
1
34
4
31

Ginir
35
4
31
32
3
31
4
35
-

Goba
35
3
32
13
22
18
17
21
14

Gololcha
35
5
30
19
16
26
9
31
4

Goro
35
20
15
31
4
35
-
35
-

Sinana
35
6
29
21
14
31
4
32
3

Total no. of fields
280
41
239
158
122
191
89
203
77

Planting date
July
104
5
99
33
71
62
42
60
44

August
55
4
51
20
35
25
30
22
33

September
121
32
89
105
16
104
17
121
-

Previous crop
Legume
18
5
13
3
15
5
13
1
17

Cereal
219
3
216
112
107
147
72
161
58

Vegetable
43
33
10
43
-
39
4
41
2

Altitudes
Low
123
32
91
89
34
114
9
113
10

Medium
40
-
40
26
14
25
15
34
6

High
117
9
108
43
74
52
65
56
61

Cropping system

52
35
17
41
11
23
29
36
16

Sole
228
6
222
117
111
168
60
167
61

Growth stage
Flowering
15
7
8
4
11
2
13
3
12

Podding
106
25
81
56
50
77
29
66
40

Late podding
159
9
150
98
61
112
47
134
25

Weed management
Poor
94
8
86
24
70
36
58
37
57

Good
114
22
92
103
11
98
16
102
12

Intermediate
72
11
61
31
41
57
15
64
8

Soil type
Clay
40
3
37
8
32
27
13
28
12

Vertisol
114
23
91
74
40
87
27
90
24

Loam
126
15
111
76
50
77
49
85
41

Fertilizer
Fertilized
135
15
120
70
65
94
41
98
37

Unfertilized
145
26
119
88
57
97
48
105
40

Fungicides
Sprayed
69
8
61
34
35
53
16
55
14

Unsprayed
211
33
178
124
87
138
73
148
63

Percentage severity index.

Faba bean intercropped with cereals (wheat, mai, and oats) and vegetables (potato, garlic, and onion).

Logistic regression analysis was used to determine the association of faba bean rust and chocolate spot incidence and PSI with independent variables (climate change resilient cultural practices) using SAS Procedure GENMOD [11, 22, 27–29]. Logit link function was used to determine the effects of climate change resilient cultural practices to the response variable. The importance of independent variables was evaluated three times for their effect on the response variable. At first, all the independent variables were tested with faba bean rust and chocolate spot incidence and PSI in a single variable model. Second, the association of an independent variable with disease incidence or PSI was tested when entered last into the model with all other independent variables. Third, those independent variables which showed high significant association to the disease incidence and PSI were added in to a reduced multiple variable model.

Furthermore, parameter estimates and standard error were analyzed in both single and multiple models. Odd ratio was obtained by exponentiating the parameter estimates for comparing variable classes based on reference point. Analysis of deviance and likelihood ratio statistics were used to compare single and multiple variable models. The difference between likelihood ratio tests was used to examine the importance of variables and tested against a Chi-square value. Data analysis and interpretation were done as described by Yuen [30].

3. Results

3.1. Characteristics Features of the Surveyed Fields

The altitude of surveyed fields ranged from 1805 in Goro district to 2600 m.a.s.l. in Goba district (Table 1). Aggregation of independent variables were used to analyze the survey of faba bean chocolate spot and rust into distinct variable classes within a number of corresponding fields for each class as presented in Table 2. Out of the total surveyed 280 faba bean fields, 81.43% of them were sole cropped, while 18.57% had been intercropped with wheat, barley, maize, and oat. Fields having poor weed management showed the highest incidence and severity of chocolate spot and rust compared to other respective variable classes. The weeds commonly observed during the survey were species of Trifolium, Rumex, grasses, and Solanum nigrum. Faba bean fields were at three growth stages during the survey, with 5.4% at flowering, 37.8 % at podding, and 56.8% at the late podding stages. About 37% of faba bean fields were sown in the month of July, while 19.6% and 43.2% were sown in the months of August and September, respectively (Table 2).

3.2. Chocolate Spot Disease Intensity and Its Association with Climate Change Resilient Cultural Practices

Chocolate spot was prevalent in across the faba bean fields surveyed. Different levels of chocolate spot incidence and PSI were recorded among the districts. Highest mean disease incidence of chocolate spot was recorded in Gasera (93.2%), Goba (92.1%), Agarfa (90.7%), Gololcha (89.3%), and Dinsho (87.6%), whereas the lowest was observed in Goro (70.9%) district (Table 3). Also, the highest mean PSI of chocolate spot was recorded in the districts of Agarfa, Dinsho, Goba, and Gasera (32.9-47.1%), as the lowest was in Ginir (23.3%) and Goro (10.5%) districts.

Table 3: Mean incidence and percentage severity index (PSI) of faba bean chocolate spot and rust for different independent variables during 2017 main cropping season in Bale highlands, south eastern Ethiopia.

Independent Variable
Variable class
Chocolate spot
Rust

Incidence
PSI
Incidence
PSI

Mean ± SD
Mean ± SD
Mean ± SD
Mean ± SD

Districts
Agarfa
90.7 ± 9.0
32.9 ± 11.5
43.8 ± 25.1
18.2 ± 17.1

Dinsho
87.6 ± 12.2
44.0 ± 10.7
45.8 ± 17.1
24.5 ± 7.3

Gasera
93.2 ± 8.9
47.1 ± 16.1
78.2 ± 18.9
37.9 ± 17.1

Ginir
80.2 ± 6.8
23.3 ± 7.2
56.5 ± 20.5
18.6 ± 3.3

Goba
92.1 ± 12.2
34.1 ± 12.2
56.6 ± 25.8
20.2 ± 10.6

Gololcha
89.3 ± 13.4
26.1 ± 6.6
54.6 ± 6.4
21.6 ± 1.2

Goro
70.9 ± 18.9
10.5 ± 4.1
23.6 ± 13.4
4.8 ± 4.3

Sinana
86.9 ± 18.2
29.2 ± 9.7
36.1 ± 16.2
11.6 ± 7.7

Planting date
July
90.4 ± 16.8
37.5 ± 14.7
53.5 ± 14.9
26.4 ± 17.3

August
89.0 ± 13.6
32.9 ± 13.5
52.7 ± 18.9
23.7 ± 13.3

September
85.2 ± 12.3
23.4 ± 12.5
39.4 ± 34.0
11.2 ± 11.2

Previous crop
Legume
89.0 ± 18.8
33.0 ± 16.0
50.2 ± 34.2
21.2 ± 16.0

Cereal
88.2 ± 14.5
30.4 ± 15.0
48.1 ± 23.7
17.3 ± 16.3

Vegetable
76.0 ± 14.5
31.6 ± 14.0
48.4 ± 30.7
17.3 ± 12.6

Altitudes
Low
85.5 ± 16.8
26.0 ± 16.9
45.3 ± 32.4
18.1 ± 22.1

Medium
81.7 ± 8.3
34.0 ± 10.9
54.3 ± 25.6
21.6 ± 15.4

High
91.5 ± 13.5
35.4 ± 12.8
56.8 ± 33.9
24.6 ± 10.9

Cropping system
Mixed
87.5 ± 12.2
30.1 ± 13.2
47.7 ± 19.8
19.4 ± 16.4

Sole
90.5 ± 15.2
35.0 ± 15.2
60.9 ± 33.7
25.3 ± 15.6

Growth stage
Flowering
88.6 ± 14.5
30.9 ± 16.4
73.3 ± 24.3
17.2 ± 12.9

Podding
86.4 ± 14.6
31.4 ± 13.4
43.1 ± 25.9
21.3 ± 15.6

Late podding
87.9 ± 14.9
36.2 ± 13.0
52.6 ± 35.7
36.7 ± 14.9

Weed management
Good
86.4 ± 15.0
25.7 ± 13.0
42.7 ± 19.7
12.1 ± 10.8

Intermediate
86.5 ± 17.9
30.1 ± 14.1
38.8 ± 27.5
12.7 ± 9.9

Poor
91.5 ± 10.2
37.9 ± 14.8
63.2 ± 30.8
28.9 ±16.3

Soil type
Clay
86.3 ± 17.7
32.7 ± 11.0
48.8 ± 30.2
22.4 ± 9.8

Vertisol
88.0 ± 15.7
37.0 ± 15.0
47.7 ± 31.3
17.6 ± 17.3

Loam
87.7 ± 14.0
29.0 ± 14.0
56.0 ± 30.7
23.8 ± 15.1

Fertilizer
Fertilized
84.7 ± 13.6
26.0 ± 12.6
49.2 ± 29.4
20.1 ± 14.2

Unfertilized
89.4 ± 15.6
35.0 ± 16.0
52.4 ± 35.3
20.9 ± 17.8

Fungicides
Sprayed
90.0 ± 11.7
29.5 ± 13.0
50.6 ± 27.3
20.4 ± 15.5

Unsprayed
97.6 ± 15.5
35.5 ± 15.0
52.0 ± 43.9
20.6 ± 16.1

ercentage severity index. tandard deviation.

The highest chocolate spot mean disease incidence of 90.4% and PSI of 37.5% were recorded from fields planted in the month of July, while the lowest incidence (85.2%) and PSI (23.4%) were recorded in September (Table 3). On the other hand, the highest mean incidence (91.5%) and PSI (37.9%) were recorded from fields highly infested with weeds when compared with field managed in a good way. In some fields, faba bean was planted along with other crops such maize, barley, wheat, oats, potato, garlic, and onion. Consequently, a relatively lowest (87.5%) mean incidence of chocolate spot was recorded from such mixed fields, contrary to faba bean planted as sole cropping system with the highest mean incidence of 90.5%. The highest (89%) mean incidence of chocolate spot was recorded from fields planted with legume crop in the preceding year. The highest (36.2%) mean PSI was observed at late podding stage and the lowest (30.9%) at flowering stage.

The association of all independent variables with chocolate spot incidence and PSI is presented in Table 4. The independent variables such as district, planting date, previous crop, cropping system, and weed management practices were highly associated with chocolate spot incidence and PSI when entered into the logistic regression model as a single variable. However, when all variables entered last into the regression model, soil type, altitude, and growth stage showed significant association with chocolate spot incidence in addition to other variables. Among the independent variables, district, previous crop, altitude, growth stage, weed management, planting date, and cropping system were the most significantly important variables that are associated with chocolate spot incidence as a result of the reduced multiple variable model indicated.

Table 4: Independent variables used in logistic regression modeling of chocolate spot incidence and percentage severity index (PSI) and likelihood ratio test (LRT) for ten variables entered first and last into a model.

Independent variable
DF
Chocolate spot incidence, LRT
Chocolate spot PSI, LRT

VEF
VEL
VEF
VEL

DR

DR

DR

DR

Districts
7
51.7
<0.0001
47.8
<0 .0001
67.3
<0.0001
31.2
<0.0001

Planting date
2
18.8
<0.0001
9.6
0.0080
30.3
<0.0001
32.7
<0.0001

Previous crop
2
43.5
<0.0001
31.0
<0 .0001
67.3
<0.0001
17.4
0.0002

Altitude
2
4.4
0.1100
22.8
<0.0001
4.7
0.9700
12.2
0.0023

Cropping system
1
21.9
<0.0001
21.9
<0.0001
6.9
0.0085
6.9
0.0085

Growth stage
2
2.2
0.3400
7.6
0.0220
3.3
0.1952
0.2
0.8900

Weed management
2
17.2
0.0001
12.9
0.0016
36.3
<0.0001
15.7
0.0004

Soil type
2
0.0
1.0000
26.4
<0.0001
2.7
0.2595
3.3
0.1889

Fertilizer
1
8.0
0.0050
0.0
1.0000
2.6
0.1055
2.0
0.1549

Fungicides
1
0.0
1.0000
0.1
0.8081
0.7
0.3987
0.3
0.6090

DF, degrees of freedom; LRT, likelihood ratio test; DR, deviance reduction; Pr, probability of χ2 value exceeding the deviance reduction; VEF, variable entered first into model; VEL, variable entered last into model.

The analysis of deviance for the variables added one by one to the reduced model showed the importance of each variable and variable class. The parameter estimates resulting from the reduced regression model and their standard error are given in Table 5.

Table 5: Analysis of deviance, natural logarithms of odds ratio, and standard error of added variables in a reduced model analyzing chocolate spot incidence.

Added variabl
Residual devianc
DF
LRT
Variable class
Estimat

Odds Rati

DR

Intercept
233.2

0.97
3.00
2.64

District
181.5
7
51.7
<0.0001
Agarfa
2.50
2.34
12.18

Dinsho
2.28
2.13
9.78

Gasera
3.25
3.22
25.79

Ginir
1.29
3.34
3.63

Goba
2.70
2.06
14.88

Gololcha
-0.34
3.23
0.72

Goro
-.0.33
3.28
0.72

Sinana

1

Previous crop
131.9
2
43.5
<0.0001
Cereal
1.98
0.81
7.24

Legume
3.53
1.46
34.12

Vegetable

1

Altitude
133.5
2
4.4
0.1090
High
-1.76
2.30
0.20

Low
-4.31
3.60
0.02

Medium

1

Growth stage
131.4
2
2.2
0.3411
Flowering
-4.53
2.35
0.01

Late podding
-1.74
0.88
0.20

Podding

1

Weed management
113.6
2
17.8
0.0001
Good
-2.88
1.52
0.06

Intermediate
-1.69
1.50
0.19

Poor

1

Planting date
107.7
2
5.9
0.0527
July
4.20
1.63
66.70

August
2.21
1.27
9.12

September

1

Cropping system
94.4
1
21.8
<0.0001
Mixed
-0.27
0.88
0.76

Sole

1

DF, degrees of freedom; LRT, likelihood ratio test; DR, deviance reduction; Pr, probability of χ2 value exceeding the deviance reduction. , reference group.

Variables are added into the model in order of presentation in table.

Unexplained variations after fitting the model.

Estimates are from the model with all independent variables added.

Standard error of the estimate. Exponentiating the estimates.

High chocolate spot incidence has a high probability of association to Gasera district, when previous crop was legume, late podding stage, poor weed management practice, July sowing, and sole cropping system. In Gasera district, there was about twenty-six times greater probability of chocolate spot incidence observed that exceeds 75%. Again, among the independent variables, such as district, sowing date, previous crop, cropping system, and weed management were found as the most important variables in their association with chocolate spot PSI when entered first and last into the model with other variables (Table 4). A chocolate spot PSI of ≤30% showed high probability of association with cereals and vegetable as previous crop, faba bean planted late (September), mixed cropping system, good weed management practice, and low altitude (Table 6).

Table 6: Analysis of deviance, natural logarithms of odds ratio, and standard error of added variables in a reduced model analyzing chocolate spot percentage severity index (PSI).

Added variabl
Residual devianc
DF
LRT
Variable class
Estimat
S
Odds Rati

DR

Intercept
383.5

-7.13
1.54
0.001

Districts
316.2
7
67.3
<0.0001
Agarfa
5.20
0.62
181.30

Dinsho
4.77
1.54
117.92

Gasera
5.95
1.62
383.75

Ginir
1.16
0.64
3.32

Goba
4.72
0.95
112.16

Gololcha
0.31
1.44
1.36

Goro
3.50
1.72
33.12

Sinana

1

Previous crop
248.8
2
67.3
<0.0001
Cereal
2.27
0.88
9.68

Legume
3.65
1.03
38.50

Vegetable

1

Altitude
244.2
2
4.7
0.0974
High
0.75
0.67
2.12

Low
-2.20
1.05
0.11

Medium

1

Weed management
206.4
2
37.8
<0.0001
Good
-2.01
0.61
0.13

Intermediate
-0.98
0.46
0.40

poor

1

Planting date
175.0
2
31.4
<0.0001
August
3.89
0.84
48.90

July
4.30
0.92
73.70

September

1

Cropping system
139.3
1
5.7
0.0170
Mixed
-0.30
0.68
0.74

Sole

1

DF, degrees of freedom; LRT, likelihood ratio test; DR, deviance reduction; Pr, probability of χ2 value exceeding the deviance reduction; , reference group. Variables are added into the model in order of presentation in table. Unexplained variations after fitting the model. Estimates are from the model with all independent variables added. Standard error of the estimate. Exponentiating the estimates.

3.3. Rust Disease Intensity and Its Association with Climate Change Resilient Cultural Practices

The highest mean incidence of faba bean rust was recorded in Gasera (78.2%), Goba (56.6%), and Ginir (56.5%), whereas the lowest was recorded in the districts of Goro (23.6%) (Table 3). The highest mean rust severity was recorded in Gasera (37.9%) and Dinsho (24.5%). The highest mean incidence (53.5%) and severity (26.4%) of rust were observed on fields sown in July while the minimum mean incidence (39.4%) and severity (11.2%) were in September. The highest (56.8%) mean incidence of faba bean rust was recorded from fields found at high altitude (>2500m a.s.l.) and the lowest (45.3%) was recorded from fields found at low altitude (<2200). The highest mean incidence of faba bean rust was recorded from fields highly infested with weed (63.2%) than fields with less weed population. The highest mean incidence of rust (50.2%) was recorded from fields planted with legume crop from the previous year. Rust severity was found to increase with the advancement in growth stage, in which maximum mean rust severity was recorded at late podding stage (36.7%) and on fields sown faba bean alone (25.3%) compared to their respective other variable classes (Table 3).

The independent variables varied in their association with rust incidence and PSI (Table 7). Of them, district, planting date, previous crop, growth stage, and weed management showed significant associations (P < 0.01) with rust incidence. These independent variables were tested in a reduced multiple-variable model. The parameter estimates resulted from the reduced regression model and their standard errors were presented in Table 8. A rust incidence of ≤50% showed a high probability of association with good weed management, late sowing (September), and rotation of faba bean with cereals and vegetables. Conversely, a high rust incidence was associated with poor weed management practices, early sowing, flowering stage, and continuous monocropping of faba bean (Table 8). However, the fertilizer, fungicides, soil types, and altitude were not significantly associated with the rust incidence.

Table 7: Independent variables used in logistic regression modeling of faba bean rust incidence and percentage severity index (PSI) and likelihood ratio test (LRT) for ten variables entered first and last into a model.

Independent variable

Rust incidence, LRT
Rust PSI, LRT

DF
VEF
VEL
VEF
VEL

DR

DR

DR

DR

Districts
7
117.8
<0.0001
69.5
<0.0001
114.1
<0.0001
19.2
0.0067

Planting date
2
34.9
<0.0001
3.1
0.2192
104.9
< 0.0001
17.5
0.0002

Previous crop
2
12.6
0.0018
2.8
0.2500
34.9
< 0.0001
0.0
1.0000

Altitude
2
0.7
0.7110
1.5
0.4771
4.5
0.0100
0.5
0.7800

Cropping system
1
3.2
0.0762
0.4
0.5200
0.4
0.5600
0.2
0.7100

Growth stage
2
17.3
0.0002
2.3
0.3180
52.5
<0.0001
0.8
0.6800

Weed management
2
51.4
<0.0001
23.4
<0.0001
123.2
<0.0001
1.1
0.5900

Soil type
2
6.1
0.0481
3.9
0.1400
5.5
0.0650
0.0
1.0000

Fertilizer
1
0.1
0.8150
0.01
0.9100
0.1
0.8140
0.2
0.7100

Fungicides
1
2.6
0.1047
0.00
1.0000
1.2
0.2750
3.7
0.0530

DF, degrees of freedom; LRT, likelihood ratio test; DR, deviance reduction; Pr, probability of χ2 value exceeding the deviance reduction; VEF, variable entered first into model; VEL, variable entered last into model.

Table 8: Analysis of deviance, natural logarithms of odds ratio, and standard error of added variables in a reduced model analyzing faba bean rust incidence.

Added variabl
Residual devianc
DF
LRT
Variable class
Estimat
S
Odds Rati

DR

Intercept
350.14

-4.83
1.30
0.01

District
232.35
7
117.8
< .0001
Agarfa
3.30
1.24
27.11

Dinsho
-0.23
1.04
0.80

Gasera
6.2
1.25
492.75

Ginir
1.22
1.25
3.37

Goba
3.30
1.03
27.11

Gololcha
1.10
0.83
3.00

Goro
0.21
1.88
1.23

Sinana

1

Previous crop
218.1
2
14.3
0.0008
Cereal
0.47
0.70
1.60

Legume
1.57
0.90
4.81

Vegetable

1

Weed management
198.9
2
29.4
<0.0001
Good
-2.53
0.62
0.08

Intermediate
-2.37
0.63
0.09

Poor

1

Planting date
171.5
2
7.5
0.0130
August
1.89
0.75
6.62

July
1.98
0.88
7.24

September

1

Growth stage
208.3
2
9.8
0 .0073
Flowering
0.03
0.58
1.03

Late podding
2.14
1.08
8.50

Podding

1

DF, degrees of freedom; LRT, likelihood ratio test; DR, deviance reduction; Pr, probability of χ2 value exceeding the deviance reduction;, reference group. ariables are added into the model in order of presentation in table. Unexplained variations after fitting the model. Estimates are from the model with all independent variables added. Standard error of the estimate. Exponentiating the estimates.

Five variables, district, planting date, previous crop, altitude, growth stage, and weed management practices were associated with rust PSI when entered as single variable into the model (Table 7). The significance of district, previous crop, growth stage, weed management, and planting date were tested by adding these variables into a multiple reduced model (Table 9). Analysis of deviance for the variables, parameter estimates, and their standard errors is given in Table 9. Gasera, Dinsho, Agarfa, and Goba districts, fields sown in the month of July along with poor weed management, had a high probability of association to high (>20%) rust PSI. There were about 150 times greater probabilities that rust PSI would exceed (>20%) in Gasera district than Sinana district and 19 times higher in the fields planted during the month of July compared to September.

Table 9: Analysis of deviance, natural logarithms of odds ratio, and standard error of added variables in a reduced model analyzing faba bean rust percentage severity index (PSI).

Added variable
Residual deviance
DF
LRT
Variable class
Estimate
SE
Odds Ratio

DR

Intercept
329.4

-4.46
1.31
0.01

District
215.3
7
114.1
<0.0001
Agarfa
2.87
0.81
17.64

Dinsho
3.30
0.72
27.11

Gasera
5.01
1.54
149.90

Ginir
1.02
1.16
2.77

Goba
2.60
0.88
13.50

Gololcha
1.60
1.51
4.95

Goro
2.26
1.76
9.58

Sinana

1

Previous crop
183.4
2
31.9
<0.0001
Cereal
1.02
0.73
2.77

Legume
1.64
0.96
5.16

Vegetable

1

Growth stage
174.94
2
8.41
0.0149
Flowering
0.42
0.70
1.52

Late podding
0.89
0.82
2.44

Podding

1

Weed management
129.0
2
45.1
<0.0001
Good
-2.14
0.72
0.12

Intermediate
-1.97
0.57
0.14

Poor

1

Planting date
107.8
2
17.7
0.0001
July
2.93
0.99
18.72

August
2.12
0.87
8.30

September

1

DF, degrees of freedom; LRT, likelihood ratio test; DR, deviance reduction; Pr, probability of χ2 value exceeding the deviance reduction; , reference group. Variables are added into the model in order of presentation in table. Unexplained variations after fitting the model. Estimates are from the model with all independent variables added. Standard error of the estimate. Exponentiating the estimates.

4. Discussion

Faba bean chocolate spot and rust were found to be widely spread across all the studied districts and the incidence and severity were varied among altitude ranges, cropping systems, and other cultural practices. Furthermore, the higher total annual rainfall (878 mm-1170 mm) as well as the temperatures (5-32°C) of the area (Table 1 and Figure 2) has created favorable environmental condition for both diseases. When temperatures are mild (15-22°C) and relative humidity is high, chocolate spot can kill the plant [31], while rust is favored by warm temperatures and cloudy weather conditions [20]. Therefore, chocolate spot and rust seriously damage faba bean and their spread which were strongly influenced by climatic conditions [32].

Figure 2: Monthly rainfall in bars and monthly minimum and maximum temperature (curves) during main cropping season (July–November) in 2017 in eight surveyed districts in Bale highlands.

Evident from the finding of this study is that intercropping faba bean with cereals (barley, wheat, maize, and oats) and vegetables (potato, garlic, and onion) appears to be an effective strategy to control chocolate spot and rust. These also concur with the results of previous researchers who found that intercropping reduced disease severity relative to monocrops in 79% of studies involving fungal pathogens, 72% of studies of virus diseases, 100% of bacterial studies, and 37% of nematode studies [33]. The advantages of diversification may accrue to smallholders in the developing tropics, where intercropping is still widely practiced [34]. Due to the high tillering capacity of cereal crops as compared to legume, intercropping cereals and vegetables with faba bean resulted with modifying the microclimate in favour of disease epidemic and reducing effective spore population by trapping. Besides, cereals could act as a physical barrier by intercepting spores carried by wind from neighbouring infected faba bean plants thereby reducing the amount of effective inoculum available to infect new tissue [35]. Similar effects have also been reported in pea-cereal intercrops intercepting Mycosphaerella pinodes spores [36]. Sahile et al. [9] have found chocolate spot reduction in faba bean-maize and faba bean-barley intercrops and not in a faba bean-pea intercrop. However, Dillon Weston [37] stated that faba bean intercropped with pea, barley, and oats was almost chocolate spot-free. Schoeny et al. [36] considered that reduction in host density was responsible to a large extent for reductions of M. pinodes dispersal in pea-barley intercrops, with a significant contribution of non-host plant by providing a physical barrier.

Throughout the surveyed areas it was observed that plants were infected by chocolate spot and rust in poorly weeded fields. Thus, high weed population not only severely reduces the yield of the crop but also favours the development of disease epidemics (Agegnehu and Fessehaie 2006). This might be in fields with dense weed populations; there was competition for space, moisture, and soil nutrients as a result of which the faba bean plants were less vigorous and prone to the disease. Similarly, white rot of garlic [38] and root rot of faba bean [39] have been reported that high weed density in non-weeded fields increased disease severity. Besides, the presence of a high weed population in a field increases the humidity within the crop canopy (microclimate) which is more favorable for B. fabae infection and the development of chocolate spot disease epidemics [22].

Maximum chocolate spot and rust incidence were observed from fields sown legume crop in the previous year particularly in Gasera and Agarfa districts. The farmers of surveyed area produce faba bean crop continuously and the preceding crop residual appears to be a source of inoculum. This continuous growing of faba bean leads to accumulation of plant haulms in the field; as a result, there was an increase in the inoculum level, as well as rapid amplification of the disease. In cooler production regions, the uredospores are important means of survival between cropping seasons for faba bean rust (Shifa et al. 2011). Secondary spread is by means of uredospores, which can readily germinate on plant surfaces under humid conditions and dispersed by wind [20]. In support of this, Zewude et al. (2007) reported that continued growing of garlic leads to accumulation of the white rot sclerotia in the soil that increases the occurrence of white rot. The importance of crop rotation is also affirmed by Belete et al. [39] who stated that faba bean cultivation is declining steadily due to root rot, as farmers substitute this crop with other legumes, mainly grass pea (Lathyrus sativus).

Planting date was also found as another factor influencing the incidence and severity of faba bean chocolate spot and rust in the study area. Accordingly, high mean disease incidence of chocolate spot was recorded from fields sown in July (early season). This particular period of time is characterized by high rainfall and humidity that favour leaf wetness which caused infection on plant leaf, due to the extended infection period of the pathogen in the air. Early infection produces typically dark-brown spots that do not pose a serious threat to the crop. However, when environmental conditions become more favourable for the development of the disease (that is, mild temperatures and high humidity) aggressive lesions may appear. In this case, a rapidly expanding necrosis takes place which may eventually lead to defoliation and death of the whole plant [31]. Hence, in agreement with the literatures more severe epidemic occurred at Gasera, Agarfa, and Dinsho districts by the milder temperature favouring epidemic development. Similar results were also found by Belete et al. [39] that high root rot incidence occurred in the faba bean plants sown in early season. Likewise, Shifa et al. [1] showed high faba bean rust severity in fields sown between June and July, a time considered as an early sowing period in Hararghe highlands. Outside the Ethiopia context, Hawthorne et al. [40] have indicated that early sowing faba bean may result in a bulky crop, which creates an environment most conducive to rust disease in Australia. Therefore later sowing reduced the disease risk in faba bean fields.

5. Conclusions

This study indicated that chocolate spot and rust diseases were widely distributed and major challenging diseases in faba bean growing districts of Bale highlands. The survey data analyzed using logistic regression model identified climate change resilient cultural practices that are associated with rust and chocolate spot epidemics either singly or in combination. The present study has identified that intercropping of faba beans with cereals and vegetables reduced the impact of chocolate spot and rust development on faba bean. In addition, the study has identified the importance of sowing dates, previous crop, and weed management practices as climate change resilient cultural management components in chocolate spot and rust management strategies. Therefore, proper weeding practices, sowing at appropriate time, crop rotation with non-legume, mixed cropping system, and other related cultural practices should be carried out to reduce rust and chocolate spot impact on faba bean production and productivity until ecofriendly integrated management strategies are developed for the faba bean growing districts of Bale highlands.

Data Availability

If raw data is required, it is possible to get it from corresponding author upon request.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge Madda Walabu University for financial support.

References

A. M. Mousa and S. A. El-Sayed, “Effect of Intercropping and Phosphorus Fertilizer Treatments on Incidence of Rhizoctonia Root-Rot Disease of Faba Bean,” International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 850–863, 2016.

E. S. Jensen, M. B. Peoples, and H. Hauggaard-Nielsen, “Faba bean in cropping systems,” Field Crops Research, vol. 115, no. 3, pp. 203–216, 2010.

A. A. Ali, K. M. Abd El-Hai, and M. A. M. Atwa, “Management of chocolate spot disease of vicia faba using nutritional elements,” Asian Journal of Plant Pathology, vol. 8, no. 2, pp. 45–54, 2014.

G. Keneni and M. Jarso, “Comparison of three secondary traits as determinants of grain yield in faba bean on waterlogged vertisols,” Journal of Genetics and Breeding, vol. 56, no. 4, pp. 317–326, 2002.

G. Agegnehu and R. Fessehaie, “Response of faba bean to phosphate fertilizer and weed control on nitisols of ethiopian highlands,” Italian Journal of Agronomy, vol. 1, no. 2, p. 281, 2006.

T. Abebe, T. Birhane, Y. Nega, and A. Workineh, “The prevalence and importance of faba bean diseases with special consideration to the newly emerging, faba bean gall , in Tigray,” Ethiopia. Afr J Agric Res, vol. 9, no. 50, pp. 3627–3631, 2014.

Agricultural sample survey for 2016/2017 report, Central Statistical Agency, Addis Ababa, 2017.

G. Agegnehu, A. Ghizaw, and W. Sinebo, “Yield performance and land-use efficiency of barley and faba bean mixed cropping in Ethiopian highlands,” European Journal of Agronomy, vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 202–207, 2006.

S. Sahile, C. Fininsa, P. K. Sakhuja, and S. Ahmed, “Effect of mixed cropping and fungicides on chocolate spot (Botrytis fabae) of faba bean (Vicia faba) in Ethiopia,” Crop Protection, vol. 27, no. 2, pp. 275–282, 2008.

H. Shifa, H. Temam, and P. K. Sakhuja, “Association of faba bean rust (Uromyces viciae-fabae) with environmental factors and cultural practices in the Hararghe Highlands, Eastern Ethiopia,” East African Journal of Sciences, vol. 5, pp. 55–58, 2011.

A. Anteneh, E. Yohannes, G. Mesganaw, G. Solomon, and T. Getachew, “Survey of faba bean (Vicia faba L.) diseases in major faba bean growing districts of North Gondar,” African Journal of Plant Science, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 32–36, 2018.

H. Terefe, C. Fininsa, S. Sahile, and K. Tesfaye, “Effect of integrated climate change resilient cultural practices on faba bean rust (Uromyces viciae-fabae) epidemics in Hararghe Highlands, Ethiopia,” Journal of Plant Pathology & Microbiology, vol. 7, no. 8, 2016.

H. R. Khan, J. G. Paull, K. H. M. Siddique, and F. L. Stoddard, “Faba bean breeding for drought-affected environments: A physiological and agronomic perspective,” Field Crops Research, vol. 115, no. 3, pp. 279–286, 2010.

S. Sahile, M. M. Abang, C. Fininsa, S. Ahmed, P. K. Sakhuja, and M. Baum, “Pathogenic and genetic diversity of Botrytis fabae Sand. isolates from faba bean fields in different agro-ecological zones of Northern Ethiopia,” Archives of Phytopathology and Plant Protection, vol. 45, no. 10, pp. 1218–1236, 2012.

HA. Awaad, AH. Salem, AM. Mohsen et al., “Assessment of some genetic parameters for resistance to leaf miner, chocolate, rust and yield of faba bean in F3 and F4 generations,” Egypt J Plant Breed, vol. 9, no. 1, p. 15, 2005.

A. M. Torres, B. Román, C. M. Avila et al., “Faba bean breeding for resistance against biotic stresses: Towards application of marker technology,” Euphytica, vol. 147, no. 1-2, pp. 67–80, 2006.

S. Sahile, C. Fininsa, P. Sakhuja, and S. Ahmed, “Effect of mixed cropping and fungicides on chocolate spot (Botrytis fabae) of faba bean (Vicia faba) in Ethiopia,” Crop Protection, vol. 27, no. 2, pp. 275–282, 2008.

G. Dereje and H. Yaynu, Pest Manage Ethiopia, vol. 5, Yield loss of crops due to plant diseases in Ethiopia. Pest Manage Ethiopia, 55–67, 2001.

Z. Yemataw, K. Tawle, M. Bolton, R. Kebede, and G. Blomme, “Integration of shade-tolerant forage legumes under enset [Ensete ventricosum (Welw.) Cheesman] plants in south-western Ethiopia,” Fruits, vol. 73, no. 6, pp. 365–375, 2018.

F. L. Stoddard, A. H. Nicholas, D. Rubiales, J. Thomas, and A. M. Villegas-Fernández, “Integrated pest management in faba bean,” Field Crops Research, vol. 115, no. 3, pp. 308–318, 2010.

G. Yitayih and Y. Azmeraw, “Adaptation of faba bean varieties for yield, for yield components and against faba bean gall (Olpidium viciae Kusano) disease in South Gondar, Ethiopia,” Crop Journal, vol. 5, no. 6, pp. 560–566, 2017.

S. Sahile, S. Ahmed, C. Fininsa, M. M. Abang, and P. K. Sakhuja, “Survey of chocolate spot (Botrytis fabae) disease of faba bean (Vicia faba L.) and assessment of factors influencing disease epidemics in northern Ethiopia,” Crop Protection, vol. 27, no. 11, pp. 1457–1463, 2008.

R. Edema, E. Adipala, and D. A. Florini, “Influence of season and cropping system on occurrence of cowpea diseases in Uganda,” Plant Disease, vol. 81, no. 5, pp. 465–468, 1997.

J. Wamatu, M. Louhaichi, C. Rubanza, A. Khatib, A. Alkhtib, and B. Rischkowsky, “Seasonal Preference of Awassi Sheep for Atriplex shrubs suitable for Mediterranean Rangelands,” Journal of Experimental Biology and Agricultural Sciences, vol. 5, no. Spl-1- SAFSAW, pp. 76–85, 2017.

BEJ. Wheeler, An Introduction to Plant Diseases, Wiley Sons, London, 1969.

C. Fininsa, “Relationship between common bacterial blight severity and bean yield loss in pure stand and bean-maize intercropping systems,” International Journal of Pest Management, vol. 49, no. 3, pp. 177–185, 2003.

J. Yuen, E. Twengström, and R. Sigvald, “Calibration and verification of risk algorithms using logistic regression,” European Journal of Plant Pathology, vol. 102, no. 9, pp. 847–854, 1996.

SAS. Institute, SAS Version 9.1, pp. 2007-2008, 2008.

C. Fininsa and J. Yuen, “Association of maize rust and leaf blight epidemics with cropping systems in Hararghe highlands, eastern Ethiopia,” Crop Protection, vol. 20, no. 8, pp. 669–678, 2001.

J. Yuen, “Deriving Decision Rules,” The Plant Health Instructor .

J. G. HARRISON, “The biology of Botrytis spp. on Vicia beans and chocolate spot disease-a review,” Plant Pathology, vol. 37, no. 2, pp. 168–201, 1988.

A. M. Villegas-Fernández, J. C. Sillero, A. A. Emeran et al., “Identification and multi-environment validation of resistance to Botrytis fabae in Vicia faba,” Field Crops Research, vol. 114, no. 1, pp. 84–90, 2009.

M. A. Boudreau, B. B. Shew, and L. E. D. Andrako, “Impact of intercropping on epidemics of groundnut leaf spots: Defining constraints and opportunities through a 7-year field study,” Plant Pathology, vol. 65, no. 4, pp. 601–611, 2016.

A. S. Lithourgidis, C. A. Dordas, C. A. Damalas, and D. N. Vlachostergios, “Annual intercrops: an alternative pathway for sustainable agriculture,” Australian Journal of Crop Science, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 396–410, 2011.

M. Fernández-Aparicio, M. J. Y. Shtaya, A. A. Emeran, M. B. Allagui, M. Kharrat, and D. Rubiales, “Effects of crop mixtures on chocolate spot development on faba bean grown in mediterranean climates,” Crop Protection, vol. 30, no. 8, pp. 1015–1023, 2011.

A. Schoeny, S. Jumel, F. Rouault, E. Lemarchand, and B. Tivoli, “Effect and underlying mechanisms of pea-cereal intercropping on the epidemic development of ascochyta blight,” European Journal of Plant Pathology, vol. 126, no. 3, pp. 317–331, 2010.

WAR. Dillon Weston, “Chocolate spot of beans,” J Ministry Agric, vol. 51, pp. 325-326, 1944.

T. Zewde, C. Fininsa, P. K. Sakhuja, and S. Ahmed, “Association of white rot (Sclerotium cepivorum) of garlic with environmental factors and cultural practices in the North Shewa highlands of Ethiopia,” Crop Protection, vol. 26, no. 10, pp. 1566–1573, 2007.

E. Belete, A. Ayalew, and S. Ahmed, “Associations of biophysical factors with faba bean root rot (Fusarium solani) epidemics in the northeastern highlands of Ethiopia,” Crop Protection, vol. 52, pp. 39–46, 2013.

WA. Hawthorne, T. Bretag, M. Raynes et al., Faba bean disease management strategy for southern region GRDC, URL, Pulse Australia, 2004, http://www.pulseaus.com.au/.