The combined effect of spin-flavor precession (SFP) and the nonstandard neutrino interaction (NSI) on the survival probability of solar electron neutrinos (assumed to be Dirac particles) is examined for various values of ϵ11, ϵ12, and μB. It is found that the neutrino survival probability curves affected by SFP and NSI effects individually for some values of the parameters (ϵ11, ϵ12, and μB) get close to the standard MSW curve when both effects are combined. Therefore, the combined effect of SFP and NSI needs to be taken into account when the solar electron neutrino data obtained by low energy solar neutrino experiments is investigated.
1. Introduction
After first observation of the solar neutrino oscillation in Homestake neutrino experiment, serious solar, atmospheric, and reactor neutrino experiments were established to confirm it during the last decades. Both KamLAND experiment detecting reactor neutrinos [1, 2] and the combined analysis of the solar neutrino experiments (high precision water Cherenkov experiments SNO [3, 4] and SK [5, 6] and the radiochemical experiments Homestake [7], SAGE [8], GALLEX [9], and GNO [10]) strongly pointed out the so-called large mixing angle (LMA) region of the neutrino parameter space [11–16]. One of the implications of the physics beyond the Standard Model (SM) is the neutrino oscillation. Since neutrinos have a mass in a minimal extension of the SM, they have also magnetic moment [17]: (1)μν=3eGfmν8π22=3eGfmemν4π22μB,where Gf is Fermi constant; me and mν are the masses of electron and neutrino, respectively; and μB is Bohr magneton. While Majorana type neutrinos can only have off-diagonal (transition) magnetic moments, Dirac type neutrinos can have diagonal and off-diagonal magnetic moments [18, 19]. If the neutrinos have magnetic moments, they can be effected by the large magnetic fields when they are passing through the magnetic region. Their spin can flip and the left-handed neutrino becomes a right-handed neutrino [20–24]. Thus the combined effect of the matter and the magnetic field called as spin-flavor precession (SFP) can change left-handed electron neutrino to another right-handed neutrino. This yields two other transitions (νeL→νμR or ντR) in addition to the left-handed ones (i.e., in this scenario, the conversion probability is mainly affected) [24]. In the Dirac case, since the right-handed neutrinos are considered as sterile, they are not detectable by the detectors. On the other hand, if the neutrinos are of Majorana type, this conversion yields a solar antineutrino flux which is detectable by the detectors. These conversions for both Dirac and Majorana cases can also be responsible for the solar electron neutrino deficit. So far several studies related with the SFP have been studied in different aspects [25–31]. Astrophysical and cosmological arguments [32], Supernova 1987A [33, 34], solar neutrino experiments looking neutrino-electron scattering [35], and the reactor neutrino experiments [36, 37] provide some bounds on the neutrino magnetic moment. The new limit recently was obtained by GEMMA experiment: μν<2.9×10-11μB at 90% CL [38]. However, another strong bound on neutrino transition magnetic moment was obtained in the presence of nonstandard neutrino-nucleus interactions by Papoulias and Kosmas [39]. Detailed discussion on neutrino magnetic moment is also given elsewhere [40–45]. In addition to the knowledge about neutrino magnetic moment, the thorough information of solar magnetic fields is needed for the SFP analysis in the Sun. Despite the limited knowledge about it, some plausible profiles can be found in the literature [46, 47]. Standard solar model [47, 48] limits the solar magnetic field: ~20 G near the solar surface [49], 20 kG–300 kG at the convective zone [47], and <107 G at the solar center [47]. In this study the magnetic field profile is chosen as given in [46]. It has a peak at the bottom of the convective zone as shown in Figure 1.
Magnetic field profile.
Solar neutrinos can also be used for analyzing the physics beyond the Standard Model of the particle physics such as nonstandard forward scattering [50], mass varying neutrinos [51, 52], and long-range leptonic forces [53]. The probe of nonstandard neutrino interaction models is expected to observe in the transition region between 1 MeV and 4 MeV where the low energy solar neutrino experiments such as SNO+ will examine. Even though the data is poor in this region, the studies comparing the effects of nonstandard models on the neutrino oscillation to the standard MSW-LMA oscillation show that these effects modify the survival probability of neutrinos [50–56].
In this paper, the combined effect of nonstandard neutrino interactions (NSI) and SFP is examined in the case of two neutrino generations by assuming that the neutrinos are of Dirac type. The best fit LMA values are used for δm122 and θ12 [57]. It is shown that the neutrino survival probability curves affected by SFP and NSI effects individually for some values of the parameters (ϵ11, ϵ12, and μB) get close to the standard MSW curve when both effects are combined. Therefore, one can say that the combined effect of them needs to be taken into account when the solar electron neutrino data obtained by low energy solar neutrino experiments is investigated. Another analysis on the SFP effect in the presence of the NSI is examined for Majorana type solar neutrinos in [58].
2. Spin-Flavor Precession (SFP) including Nonstandard Neutrino Interaction (NSI)
The evolution equation including NSI matter effects in the SFP scenario for Dirac neutrinos can be written as (2)iddtνeLνμLνeRνμR=HL+HNSIBM†BMHRνeLνμLνeRνμR,where HL, HR, HNSI, and M are the 2×2 submatrices and B is the transverse magnetic field [24, 50]. For the Dirac neutrinos one writes down (3)HL=Vc+Vn+δm1222Esin2θ12δm1224Esin2θ12δm1224Esin2θ12Vn+δm1222Ecos2θ12,and HR=HL(Vc=0=Vn). The matter potentials here are given as (4)Vc=2GFNe,Vn=-GF2Nn,where Ne and Nn are electron and neutron density, respectively [59–61]. The magnetic moment matrix for the Dirac neutrinos in (2) is written as [24] (5)M=μeeμeμμμeμμμ.The NSI contributions in (2) can be parametrized by four-fermion operator as given in [50]:(6)L=-22GFναγρνβϵαβff-Lf-Lγρf-L+ϵαβff-Rf-Rγρf-R,where ϵff-P denotes the strength of the nonstandard interaction between α and β types of neutrinos and the P (left- or right-handed) components of the fermions f and f-. Since the neutrino propagation can only be effected by the vector components where f=f- of the nonstandard interaction (ϵαβf=ϵαβffL+ϵαβffR), one can define ϵαβ as the sum of the contributions from electrons, up quarks and down quarks in matter: ϵαβ=∑f=e,u,dϵαβfNf/Ne. Then, the three-flavor NSI Hamiltonian can be written as (7)HNSI3×3=Vcϵeeϵeμ∗ϵeτ∗ϵeμϵμμϵμτ∗ϵeτϵμτϵττ.After performing a rotation to HNSI3×3 by using the two factors of the neutrino mixing matrix, T13T23, (8)T13†T23†HNSI3×3T13T23,and decoupling the third flavor as in the standard three-flavor neutrino oscillation calculations, one can find the 2×2 neutrino nonstandard interaction (NSI) part in (2) as (9)HNSI=Vc0ϵ12∗ϵ12ϵ11,where ϵ11 and ϵ12 are the contributions from the new physics related to the original vectorial couplings, ϵαβ, given as (10)ϵ11=ϵμμc232-ϵμτ+ϵμτ∗s23c23+ϵττs232-ϵeec132+s13e-iδϵeμ+eiδϵeμ∗c13s23+e-iδϵeτ+eiδϵeτ∗c13c23-s132ϵμτ+ϵμτ∗s23c23+ϵμμs232+ϵττc232,ϵ12=c13ϵeμc23-ϵeτs23+s13eiδϵμτs232-ϵμτ∗c232-ϵμμ-ϵττs23c23.Here cij=cosθij and sij=sinθij and δ is the CP-violating phase that we will ignore in our discussion [54].
The direct bounds on the NSI parameters come from atmospheric neutrino experiments (Super-Kamiokande, Ice-Cube-79) [62, 63], accelerator neutrino experiments (MINOS) [64], and some phenomenological studies [65–68]: ϵee≲0.5 [62], ϵeτ≲0.5 [62], ϵμτ≲6×10-3 [63], ϵττ-ϵμμ≲3×10-2 [63], -0.067≲ϵμτ≲0.023 [64]. The effects of NSI were also studied by using data of reactor neutrino experiment, Daya Bay, [69] and solar neutrino experiments [70]. Detailed analysis on the nonstandard neutrino interactions and their limits is given in [71, 72].
3. Results and Conclusions
In this analysis the combined effect of the nonstandard neutrino interaction and SFP on the survival probability of solar electron neutrinos (assumed to be Dirac particles) is examined for various values of ϵ11, ϵ12, and μB. Results presented here are obtained numerically by diagonalizing the Hamiltonian in (2). In the calculations, the magnetic field profile given in Figure 1 is chosen as a Gaussian shape extending over the entire Sun [46] and the MSW-LMA best fit values are used: δm122=7.54×10-5 eV2 and sin2θ12=0.308 [57].
Electron neutrino survival probabilities plotted as a function of neutrino energy are shown in Figure 2 for all situations: MSW-LMA prediction alone (solid lines), SFP alone (dotted lines), MSW-LMA + NSI (dashed lines), and SFP + NSI (dotted-dashed lines). In this figure, different from the SFP effect seen for all neutrino energies, the new physics effects change the standard MSW-LMA curve especially at the energies of E≳1 MeV in which the region of E≳3.5 MeV is well examined by the solar neutrino experiments SNO and SK. When the combined effect of them (SFP + NSI) is considered, the curves get closer to the standard curve than the curves affected by them individually for some values of the parameters (ϵ11, ϵ12, and μB). A similar result was found in another analysis examined for Majorana neutrinos for only one NSI parameter, ϵ12 [58]. However, compared to the Dirac case presented here, SFP effect is seen at almost ten times larger μB values in the Majorana case.
Survival probabilities for MSW-LMA prediction alone (solid lines), SFP effect at different μB values (dotted lines), NSI effect alone (dashed lines), and the combined effect of the NSI and SFP (dotted-dashed lines). Each column uses the same ϵ11 and ϵ12 values, and each row uses the same μB values.
The allowed regions obtained by using the SNO results [73] are shown in Figure 3 in the (ϵ11, μB) and (ϵ12, μB) planes at 90% CL for 10 MeV neutrino energy. Even though the values of NSI parameters are expected to be very small (≲10-2), the large values of them are in the allowed regions when considering the SFP and NSI effects together. It is seen that the current solar neutrino data constrain the μB and (ϵ11, ϵ12) values poorly. A practical limit on them can be expected from the data obtained by the new low energy (1MeV≲E≲4MeV) solar neutrino experiments such as SNO+ [74] probing the evidence of new physics effect. However, as it can be seen from the analysis presented here, the combined effect of SFP and NSI needs to be taken into account when the solar electron neutrino data obtained by new solar neutrino experiments is analyzed.
Allowed regions in the (ϵ11, μB) and (ϵ12, μB) planes at 90% CL for 10 MeV neutrino energy.
Competing Interests
The author declares that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.
EguchiK.EnomotoS.FurunoK.First results from KamLAND: evidence for reactor antineutrino disappearance20039002180210.1103/physrevlett.90.021802ArakiT.EguchiK.EnomotoS.Measurement of neutrino oscillation with KamLAND: evidence of spectral distortion200594808180110.1103/physrevlett.94.081801AhmadQ. R.AllenR. C.AndersenT. C.Measurement of the rate of νe+d→p→p+p+e- interactions produced by 8B solar neutrinos at the sudbury neutrino observatory200187707130110.1103/PhysRevLett.87.071301AharmimB.AhmadQ. R.AhmedS. N.Determination of the νe and total 8B solar neutrino fluxes using the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory Phase I data set20077504550210.1103/physrevc.75.045502FukudaS.FukudaY.IshitsukaM.Solar 8B and hep neutrino measurements from 1258 days of super-kamiokande data20018625565110.1103/physrevlett.86.5651FukudaS.FukudaY.IshitsukaM.Determination of solar neutrino oscillation parameters using 1496 days of Super-Kamiokande-I data20025393-417918710.1016/s0370-2693(02)02090-7ClevelandB. T.DailyT.DavisR.Jr.DistelJ. R.LandeK.LeeC. K.WildenhainP. S.UllmanJ.Measurement of the solar electron neutrino flux with the homestake chlorine detector1998496150510.1086/305343AbdurashitovJ. N.BowlesT. J.CherryM. L.Measurement of the solar neutrino capture rate by sage and implications for neutrino oscillations in vacuum19998323468610.1103/physrevlett.83.4686HampelW.HandtJ.HeusserG.GALLEX solar neutrino observations: results for GALLEX IV19994471-212713310.1016/S0370-2693(98)01579-2AltmannM.BalataM.BelliP.GNO solar neutrino observations: results for GNO I20004901-2162610.1016/s0370-2693(00)00915-1BalantekinA. B.YukselH.Global analysis of solar neutrino and KamLAND data200329466510.1088/0954-3899/29/4/305BahcallJ. N.Pena-GarayC.A road map to solar neutrino fluxes, neutrino oscillation parameters, and tests for new physics2003200311410.1088/1126-6708/2003/11/004Gonzalez-GarciaM. C.Peña-GarayC.Three-neutrino mixing after the first results from K2K and KamLAND200368909300310.1103/PhysRevD.68.093003de HolandaP. C.SmirnovA. Y.Homestake result, sterile neutrinos, and low energy solar neutrino experiments2004691111300210.1103/physrevd.69.113002FogliG. L.LisiE.MarroneA.PalazzoA.Evidence for Mikheyev-Smirnov-Wolfenstein effects in solar neutrino flavor transitions20045831-214915610.1016/j.physletb.2003.12.045BahcallJ. N.Gonzalez-GarciaM. C.Pena-GarayC.Solar neutrinos before and after neutrino 2004200420048, article 01610.1088/1126-6708/2004/08/016MarcianoW. J.SandaA. I.Exotic decays of the muon and heavy leptons in gauge theories197767330330510.1016/0370-2693(77)90377-X2-s2.0-20444401516SchechterJ.ValleJ. W. F.Majorana neutrinos and magnetic fields19812471883Erratum: Physical Review D, vol. 25, pp. 283, 1982ShrockR. E.Electromagnetic properties and decays of Dirac and Majorana neutrinos in a general class of gauge theories1982206335937910.1016/0550-3213(82)90273-5OkunL. B.VoloshinM. B.VysotskyM. I.Electromagnetic properties of neutrino and possible semiannual variation cycle of the solar neutrino flux198644440Yadernaya Fizika, vol. 44, pp. 677–680, 1986AkhmedovE. K.Resonant amplification of neutrino spin rotation in matter and the solar-neutrino problem19882131646810.1016/0370-2693(88)91048-9AkhmedovE. K.KhlopovM. Y.Resonant amplification of neutrino oscillations in longitudinal magnetic field19883545145710.1142/s0217732388000532BarbieriR.FiorentiniG.The solar neutrino puzzle and the vL→vR conversion hypothesis198830490992010.1016/0550-3213(88)90661-x2-s2.0-0001545956LimC.-S.MarcianoW. J.Resonant spin-flavor precession of solar and supernova neutrinos19883761368137310.1103/PhysRevD.37.13682-s2.0-0001441192BalantekinA. B.HatchellP. J.LoretiF.Matter-enhanced spin-flavor precession of solar neutrinos with transition magnetic moments199041123583359310.1103/PhysRevD.41.35832-s2.0-0000103845BykovA. A.PopovV. Y.RashbaT. I.SemikozV. B.Resonant spin-flavor precession solution to the solar neutrino problem and electron antineutrinos from the sunhttp://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0002174AkhmedovE. K.PulidoJ.Solar neutrino oscillations and bounds on neutrino magnetic moment and solar magnetic field20035531-271710.1016/S0370-2693(02)03182-9ChauhanB. C.PulidoJ.Torrente-LujanE.KamLAND, solar antineutrinos, and the solar magnetic field200368303301510.1103/PhysRevD.68.033015BalantekinA. B.VolpeC.Does the neutrino magnetic moment have an impact on solar neutrino physics?200572303300810.1103/physrevd.72.033008YilmazD.YilmazerA. U.Global analysis of the data from solar neutrinos having transition magnetic moments together with KamLAND20053115710.1088/0954-3899/31/1/006YilmazD.YilmazerA. U.Global analysis of solar neutrinos (assumed to be Majorana particles) together with the new KamLAND data2005311123113110.1088/0954-3899/31/9/013RaffeltG. G.New bound on neutrino dipole moments from globular-cluster stars199064242856285810.1103/PhysRevLett.64.2856LattimerJ. M.CoopersteinJ.Limits on the neutrino magnetic moment from SN1987A1988611232610.1103/physrevlett.61.23BarbieriR.MohapatraR. N.Limit on the magnetic moment of the neutrino from supernova 1987a observations1988611273010.1103/physrevlett.61.27LiuD. W.AshieY.FukudaS.Limits on the neutrino magnetic moment using 1496 days of super-kamiokande-i solar neutrino data200493202180210.1103/physrevlett.93.021802WongH. T.LiH. B.LinS. T.Search of neutrino magnetic moments with a high-purity germanium detector at the Kuo-Sheng nuclear power station200775101200110.1103/PhysRevD.75.012001DaraktchievaZ.AmslerbC.AveniercM.Final results on the neutrino magnetic moment from the MUNU experiment20056153-415315910.1016/j.physletb.2005.04.030BedaA. G.BrudaninV. B.EgorovV. G.Gemma experiment: the results of neutrino magnetic moment search201310213914310.1134/s1547477113020027PapouliasD. K.KosmasT. S.Neutrino transition magnetic moments within the non-standard neutrino-nucleus interactions201574745445910.1016/j.physletb.2015.06.039BeacomJ. F.VogelP.Neutrino magnetic moments, flavor mixing, and the Super-Kamiokande solar data199983255222522510.1103/physrevlett.83.5222BellN. F.CiriglianoV.Ramsey-MusolfM. J.VogelP.WiseM. B.Magnetic moments of Dirac neutrinos2006842187487610.1063/1.2220408GorchteinM.BellN. F.Ramsey-MusolfM. J.VogelP.WangP.Model independent naturalness bounds on magnetic moments of Majorana neutrinos2007903128729010.1063/1.2735181BalantekinA. B.Neutrino magnetic moment847Proceedings of the Origin of Matter and Evolution of Galaxies: International Symposium on Origin of Matter and Evolution of Galaxies 2005: New Horizon of Nuclear Astrophysics and CosmologyNovember 2005Tokyo, Japan128AIP Conference Proceedings10.1063/1.2234393StudenikinA.Neutrino magnetic moment: a window to new physics2009188220222BrogginiC.GiuntiC.StudenikinA.Electromagnetic properties of neutrinos201220124745952610.1155/2012/459526DasC. R.PulidoJ.PicarielloM.Light sterile neutrinos, spin flavor precession, and the solar neutrino experiments2009797907301010.1103/PhysRevD.79.073010CouvidatS.Turck-ChièzeS.KosovichevA. G.Solar seismic models and the neutrino predictions200359921434144810.1086/3796042-s2.0-0347301656BahcallJ. N.PinsonneaultM. H.What do we (not) know theoretically about solar neutrino fluxes?20049212412130110.1103/PhysRevLett.92.121301AntiaH. M.ChitreS. M.ThompsonM. J.The Sun's acoustic asphericity and magnetic fields in the solar convection zone2000360335344FriedlandA.LunardiniC.Peña-GarayC.Solar neutrinos as probes of neutrino-matter interactions20045943-434735410.1016/j.physletb.2004.05.047CirelliM.Gonzalez-GarciaM. C.Peña-GarayC.Mass varying neutrinos in the Sun20057191-221923310.1016/j.nuclphysb.2005.04.034BargerV.HuberP.MarfatiaD.Solar mass-varying neutrino oscillations20059521421180210.1103/PhysRevLett.95.211802Gonzalez-GarciaM. C.de HolandaP. C.MassóE.Zukanovich FunchalR.Probing long-range leptonic forces with solar and reactor neutrinos200720071, article 00510.1088/1475-7516/2007/01/005BonventreR.LatorreA.KleinJ. R.Orebi GannG. D.SeibertS.WasalskiO.Nonstandard models, solar neutrinos, and large θ13201388505301010.1103/physrevd.88.0530102-s2.0-84884853883PalazzoA.Phys. RevD.201183arXiv:1101.3875101701BalantekinA. B.MalkusA.Solar neutrino matter effects redux2012851901301010.1103/PhysRevD.85.013010OliveK. A.AgasheK.AmslerC.Review of particle physics201438909000110.1088/1674-1137/38/9/090001YilmazD.SFP effect on Majorana type solar neutrinos in the presence of nonstandard neutrino interactions20153930931310.3906/fiz-1506-3WolfensteinL.Neutrino oscillations in matter19781792369237410.1103/physrevd.17.23692-s2.0-33744724581MikheevS. P.SmirnovA. Yu.Resonance amplification of oscillations in matter and spectroscopy of solar neutrinos198542913917Translated from Yadernaya Fizika, vol. 42, pp. 1441–1448, 1985MikheyevS. P.SmirnovA. Yu.Resonant amplification of ν oscillations in matter and solar-neutrino spectroscopy198691172610.1007/BF02508049MitsukaG.AbeK.HayatoY.Study of nonstandard neutrino interactions with atmospheric neutrino data in Super-Kamiokande I and II2011841111300810.1103/physrevd.84.113008GroßA.IceCube CollaborationAtmospheric neutrino oscillations in IceCube2013237-23827227410.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2013.04.107AdamsonP.BarrG.BishaiM.Search for flavor-changing non-standard neutrino interactions by MINOS2013887607201110.1103/PhysRevD.88.072011DavidsonS.Pena-GarayC.RiusN.SantamariaA.Present and future bounds on non-standard neutrino interactions2003200331110.1088/1126-6708/2003/03/011BiggioC.BlennowM.Fernandez-MartinezE.Loop bounds on non-standard neutrino interactions20092009313910.1088/1126-6708/2009/03/139PapouliasD. K.KosmasT. S.Nuclear aspects of neutral current non-standard ν-nucleus reactions and the role of the exotic μ-→e- transitions experimental limits201472848248810.1016/j.physletb.2013.12.028LeitnerR.MalinskyM.RoskovecB.ZhangH.Non-standard antineutrino interactions at Daya Bay20112011, article 110.1007/JHEP12(2011)001GirardiI.MeloniD.PetcovS. T.The Daya Bay and T2K results on sin22θ13 and non-standard neutrino interactions2014886314210.1016/j.nuclphysb.2014.06.014Gonzalez-GarciaM. C.MaltoniM.Determination of matter potential from global analysis of neutrino oscillation data20132013, article 15210.1007/JHEP09(2013)152MirandaO. G.NunokawaH.Non standard neutrino interactions: current status and future prospects201517909500210.1088/1367-2630/17/9/095002OhlssonT.Status of non-standard neutrino interactions201376404420110.1088/0034-4885/76/4/044201AharmimB.AhmedS. N.AnthonyA. E.Combined analysis of all three phases of solar neutrino data from the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory20138822702550110.1103/PhysRevC.88.025501KrausC.PeetersaS. J. M.The rich neutrino programme of the SNO+ experiment201064227327710.1016/j.ppnp.2009.12.027