Synchronization of Time Delayed Fractional Order Chaotic Financial System

The research on a time delayed fractional order financial chaotic system is a hot issue. In this paper, synchronization of time delayed fractional order financial chaotic system is studied. Based on comparison principle of linear fractional equation with delay, by using a fractional order inequality, a sufficient condition is obtained to guarantee the synchronization ofmaster-slave systems. An example is exploited to show the feasibility of the theoretical results.


Introduction
In micro-macroeconomics, the study on the dynamics of financial and economical systems is an interesting and important topic [1].The features of economic data were presented in view of the dynamical behaviors of systems.Many nonlinear continuous models have been introduced to study complex economic dynamics, such as the IS-LM model [2], Goodwin's accelerate model [3], the forced Vander-Pol model [4], and Behrens-Feichtinger model [5].And the same as the other systems in world, financial system, as a nonlinear system, displays many complex dynamical behaviors, such as depending on initial value sensitivity, the complex phase portraits, positive Lyapunov exponents, and fractal properties.Chaotic phenomena in financial systems mean the systems will have inherent indefiniteness; it is difficult to make effective decision-making by makers, which threats the safety of investment.Therefore, to study the dynamical behaviors in economical and financial systems is indispensable.
Compared with classical integer calculus, the merit of fractional calculus is that it provides an excellent instrument for the description of memory and hereditary properties of dynamical processes [6][7][8].Meanwhile, the financial variables such as interest rates, stock market prices, and foreign exchange rates possess long memories, which make it more appropriate to use fractional models compared with integer order ones in financial systems [9][10][11][12].Furthermore, the author found that there existed many attractors in fractional order financial systems, such as fixed points, limit cycles, periodic motions, and chaotic attractors [9].
It is known that time delay can affect oscillation and instability behavior of dynamical systems.Time delay means that the policy from being made to taking effect will have to need some time in financial system, and its influence cannot be neglected.It dominates the decision which makes the policy intervene the economy.Since the pioneering work [13] that time delay was introduced to economic dynamics, the research on the delayed financial system has become one of the hot issues which has received more attention [14][15][16][17].The synchronization of fractional order financial chaotic system with time delay is worth discussing.Recently, there are some works about synchronization on fractional order financial system without delay [18][19][20][21]; for example, synchronization and antisynchronization of fractional chaotic financial system via active control strategy were investigated in [18]; control and synchronization of fractional order financial system based on linear control were studied in [19].However, the problem of synchronization for fractional order chaotic financial system with time delay has not been investigated in the literature.
Given the above discussions, in this paper, based on comparison principle of linear fractional equation with delay, by applying a fractional inequality, a sufficient condition is achieved to ensure the synchronization of fractional order time delayed chaotic financial systems.The result is simple and extremely effective.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows.In Section 2, some necessary definitions and useful lemmas are introduced, and the model description is given.In Section 3, the synchronization schemes are presented, and sufficient conditions for synchronization are obtained.Numerical simulations are presented in Section 4. Some conclusions are drawn in Section 5.

Preliminaries and Model Description
There are some definitions of the fractional order derivatives.Riemann-Liouville fractional derivative and Caputo fractional derivative are mostly used.The main advantage of the Caputo derivative is that its Laplace transform only requires integer order derivatives for the initial conditions; the definition of Caputo derivative is given in this paper.
In this paper, we consider a fractional order financial system with time delay, which is described by where 0 <  < 1, , ,  are three state variables,  stands for the interest rate,  represents the investment demand,  denotes the price index,  is the saving amount,  is the cost per investment,  is the elasticity of demand of the commercial markets and parameters, , ,  are nonnegative real constants, and  > 0 is time delay of the system.When  = 0.9,  = 3,  = 0.1,  = 1, and  = 0.1, system (3) displays chaotic attractors with the initial value (0) = 0.1, (0) = 4, and (0) = 0.5, which is shown in Figure 1.
In order to get main results, we give some lemmas as follows.

Main Results
In this section, we discuss the synchronization of fractional order delayed financial system.The main aim is to design a proper controller to achieve synchronization between master system and slave system.Without loss of generally, the master system is chosen as The slave system is selected as where   () ( = 1, 2, 3) are the external control inputs to be designed.
Remark 6.Recently, there are a few works about the synchronization of fractional order chaotic financial systems [18][19][20][21], but these results are without considering time delay.Here, we consider a fractional order delayed chaotic financial systems.
Remark 7. Compared with [18,19], in this paper, comparison principle of linear fractional equation with delay is used, and the sufficient condition of the synchronization between master-slave systems is achieved; from Figures 3-5, the controllers are effective.

Conclusions
Time delay is a sensitive factor for the financial system.In this paper, we study the synchronization of a generalized financial system which takes time delay into consideration.The sufficient condition for synchronization is established according to comparison principle of linear fractional equation with delay.The numerical simulations indicate that the method designed for synchronization is effective.