Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine
Volume 2018 (2018), Article ID 6409389, 15 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2018/6409389

Review Article

Acupuncture on Obesity: Clinical Evidence and Possible Neuroendocrine Mechanisms

Kepei Zhang,¹ Shigao Zhou,² Chunyan Wang,¹ Hanchen Xu,¹ and Li Zhang¹

¹Institute of Digestive Diseases, Longhua Hospital, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China
²Department of TCM Demonstration, Longhua Hospital, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, China

Correspondence should be addressed to Li Zhang; zhangli.hl@163.com

Received 12 January 2018; Revised 14 May 2018; Accepted 27 May 2018; Published 14 June 2018

Academic Editor: Meng Zhang

Copyright © 2018 Kepei Zhang et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract.

Objective. Acupuncture, as one of the complementary and alternative medicines, represents an efficient therapeutic option for obesity control. We conducted a meta-analysis to investigate the effectiveness of acupuncture in obesity and also summarized the available studies on exploring the mechanisms. Design. We searched six databases from the inception to April 2017 without language restriction. Eligible studies consisted of acupuncture with comparative controls ((1) sham acupuncture, (2) no treatment, (3) diet and exercise, and (4) conventional medicine). The primary outcomes consisted of BMI, body weight reduction, and incidence of cardiovascular events (CVD). Secondary outcomes included waist circumference (WC), waist-to-hip ratio (WHR), body fat mass percent, body fat mass (kg), total cholesterol (TC), triglyceride (TG), glucose, low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-c) reduction, high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-c) increase, and adverse effects. The quality of RCTs was assessed by the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool. Subgroup analyses were performed according to types of acupuncture. A random effects model was used to adjust for the heterogeneity of the included studies. Publication bias was assessed using funnel plots. Main Results. We included 21 studies with 1389 participants. When compared with sham acupuncture, significant reductions in BMI (MD=-1.22, 95CI=-1.87 to -0.56), weight (MD=-1.54, 95CI=-2.98 to -0.11), body fat mass (kg) (MD=-1.31, 95CI=-2.47 to -0.16), and TC (SMD=-0.63, 95CI=-1.00 to -0.25) were found. When compared with no treatment group, significant reductions of BMI (MD=-1.92, 95CI=-3.04 to -0.79), WHR (MD=-0.05, 95CI=-0.09 to -0.02), TC (MD=-0.26, 95CI=-0.48 to -0.03), and TG (MD=-0.29 95CI=-0.39 to -0.18) were found. When compared with diet and exercise group, significant reduction in BMI (MD=-1.24, 95CI=-1.87 to -0.62) and weight (MD=-3.27 95CI=-5.07 to -1.47) was found. Adverse effects were reported in 5 studies. Conclusions. We concluded that acupuncture is an effective treatment for obesity and inferred that neuroendocrine regulation might be involved.

1. Introduction

Obesity is a chronic disease characterized by the rise of body fat stores. It is caused by the interaction of genetic, dietary, lifestyle, and environment factors. The prevalence of obesity among children, adolescents, and adults has been dramatically increased during the last decades. Obesity and overweight are closely related to type 2 diabetes, hypertension, and coronary heart disease [1]. The World Health Organization (WHO) indicates that more than 1.9 billion adults, 18 years and older, were overweight. Of these, over 650 million were obese in 2016. According to a report in the JAMA Journal of Internal Medicine, more than two-thirds of people in the United States are considered to be overweight or obesity [2]. Data from China’s fourth national physical fitness survey in 2014 showed that the morbidity of obesity in adult and the aged reached 10.5% and 13.9%, respectively, which showed 0.6% and 0.9% increase in comparison to the data in 2010. Moreover, the epidemics of obesity and overweight are not limited in developed countries, and the prevalence also increases among people in developing countries.

Obesity can be defined by BMI. According to the WHO definition, a BMI over 25kg/m² is taken as overweight and over 30kg/m² as obese. In terms of the physique of the Asia-Pacific population and the characteristics of obesity-related disease, the WHO obesity adviser group agrees that BMI over 23kg/m² is defined as overweight and over 25kg/m² as obese. In addition, other guidelines also include parameters such as WC and WHR to define obesity.

Numerous people cannot manage the weight only through dietary change and increasing physical activity. Although pharmaceutical treatments for obesity such as Fenfluramine and Sibutramine are effective, there exist various limits due to security reasons [3–6]. As an alternative intervention for obesity, acupuncture is relatively easy, cheap, and safe and has been widely used in clinical practice [5–8] in both China and other countries. Although efficacy of the acupuncture therapy has been reported, the underlying mechanisms have not been completely illustrated. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to evaluate the effectiveness of acupuncture in obesity and also summarized the present studies on exploring mechanisms under acupuncture treatment in obesity animals.

2. Methods

2.1. Search Strategy

To identify studies of acupuncture on obesity, retrievals were implemented in three English databases (PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library) and three Chinese databases (VIP information database, Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure, and Wanfang Data Information Site) from the inception to April 2017. The search strategies were (weight loss OR overweight OR obesity OR weight control OR simple obesity OR weight reduction OR weight increase OR weight decrease OR weight watch OR overeat OR overfeed OR slim) AND (acupuncture and moxibustion OR acupuncture OR embedding therapy OR acupoint catgut embedding OR electro-acupuncture OR EA OR auricula-acupuncture OR ear seed pressure OR auricular plaster OR auricular acupuncture OR auricular acupressure OR fire needle OR moxibustion OR herbal acupuncture OR dermal needle OR aqua acupuncture OR body acupuncture OR meridians OR abdominal acupuncture) AND (clinical trial OR clinical study OR efficacy OR effectiveness) AND (random OR random$). Conference proceedings, dissertations, and reference lists of retrieved articles were also searched manually for additional relevant studies.

2.2. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria

2.2.1. Types of Studies

Published randomized controlled trials (RCTs) compared acupuncture with control (no treatment, placebo acupuncture, western medicine, diet or exercise, etc.) and assessed the efficacy of acupuncture on obesity and overweight. We excluded quasi-randomized studies, such as those allocated by using alternate days of week. No restriction was imposed on blinding. Comments, case reports, technical reports, animal studies, self-control studies, or non-RCTs were excluded. No language restriction was made for selecting the studies.

2.2.2. Types of Participants

We included participants with no limitation of age and gender. All appropriate definitions of overweight or obesity including BMI, body weight, or percentage of weight excess compared with ideal weight were accepted. A diagnosis of simple obesity patients was included. The secondary obesity which was complicated with hypothalamus disease, anterior hypopituitarism, hypothyroidism, hypercriticism, hypogonadotropic hypogonadism, pregnancy, lactation, polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS), menstrual disorder, amenorrhea, or other serious medical conditions was excluded.

2.2.3. Types of Intervention

We recruited trials with various acupuncture therapies. The acupuncture therapy included classical acupuncture, electroacupuncture (EA), laser acupuncture, catgut embedding, auricular acupressure, and auricular acupuncture, which could be analyzed in subgroup. Studies that combined acupuncture with other therapies such as medication, moxibustion, or message were excluded; the studies with lifestyle intervention such as diet and exercise in treatment group were also included. Based on the different acupuncture therapies, we performed the subgroup analysis. The control inventions were divided into four types, sham acupuncture ((1) needle inserting into skin but not penetrating the exact acupoints; (2) needle inserted into an area where it is near the exact acupoints), no treatment, diet, and exercise therapy, medicine.

2.2.4. Types of Outcome Measures

The primary outcomes consisted of BMI, body weight reduction, and the incidence of CVD. Secondary outcomes included WC, WHR, body fat mass percent, body fat mass (kg), serum cholesterol (TC), triglyceride (TG), glucose, low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-c) reduction, high density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-c) increase, and adverse effects.

2.3. Study Selection, Data Extraction, Management, and Analysis

According to the prespecified inclusion and exclusion criteria, two authors (Kepei Zhang and Chunyan Wang) separately identified the eligible studies by reading the title, abstract, and full text of every paper and then extracted the data. A discussion with the other authors was conducted to solve any discrepancies.

The following information was abstracted from all included publications: year, country, number of included patients, interventions of treatment and control groups, basic treatment, duration of treatment, adverse reactions, and outcomes. Authors of studies were contacted for clarification when necessary.

The quality of RCTs was assessed by the Cochrane Risk of Bias Tool, including seven domains: generation of a random sequence, allocation concealment, blinding of participants and personnel, blinding of outcome assessment, completeness of outcome data, selectiveness of reporting, and other biases. A score of 1 or 0 was given for each item depending on the information provided by study (1, low risk of bias, the information of the domain was adequate in the text; 0, high risk of bias, the information of the domain was inadequate in the text). The studies with the cumulative score of at 3 or more were included in our study.

Cochrane Review Manager (RevMan 5.3) software was used for statistical analysis. Binary data were reported as risk ration (RR), and continuous data were reported as mean difference (MD) when the outcomes were measured in the same way among different trials. For trials reporting the same outcome measures but used different methods, the standardized mean difference (SMD) was reported. 95% confidence interval (95%CI) was used as an effective size for the combined analysis. A random effects model was conducted to analyze pooled effects. We tested heterogeneity using the Chi² statistic (with significance being set at P<0.1) and the I² statistic. I² value above 50% was set as substantial heterogeneity. Possible sources of heterogeneity were assessed by sensitivity and subgroup analysis. The existence of publication bias was checked using a funnel plot.

3. Results

3.1. Study Description and Quality Assessment

A total of 3261 potentially relevant papers were retrieved. 514 duplicate records were removed. 737 articles were remaining after the scan of titles and abstract. 2010 articles (including not relevant, animal studies, review, conference abstract, and irrelevant with the efficacy of acupuncture for obesity) were excluded. 150 articles were selected after screening full-text articles. 587 articles (including studies which combined acupuncture with other therapies in treatment group, inappropriate intervention therapy in control group, quasi-randomized studies or not real RCTs, and Cochrane score<3) were excluded. Finally, we included 21 studies [9–29]: 7 [9–12, 17, 20, 25] in English and 14 [13, 16, 18–21, 21, 22, 22, 23, 23, 24, 24–26] in Chinese. 19 studies [9, 10, 12, 13, 15–29] were included in meta-analysis. The screening process is summarized in Figure 1. The sample size of the included studies ranged from 9 to 43, enrolling a total of 1389 participants altogether, 760 patients in the treatment group and 629 patients as the control. Meanwhile, among these studies, the study by Han 2016 [13] included two independent experiments, so we divided this study into Han-1 2016 and Han-2 2016. The study by Darbandi et al. 2014 [11] included one experiment, which contributed four independent comparisons. Descriptive analysis was used in this study. The basic characteristics of studies included are summarized in Table 1. Of these 22 records, there were 12 records [9–12, 15, 16, 18, 21, 24–26, 29] reporting the effect of acupuncture versus sham acupuncture, 5 [13, 17, 19, 27] acupuncture versus no treatment, 4 [20, 22, 23, 29] acupunctures versus diet and exercise, and 1 [14] acupuncture versus medicine.

Table 1: Characteristics of the included studies.

Included studies
Country
Number of participants 
Trial Control
Interventions Trial Control
Basic treatment
Duration of treatment 
(week)
Adverse reactions
Outcomes

Darbandi 
et al., 2012 [9]
Iran
43
43
Auricular acupressure
Sham auricular
Low-calorie diet
6
None
BW, BMI, BFM, plasma leptin

Darbandi 
et al., 2013 [10]
Iran
42
44
Electro-acupuncture
Sham acupuncture
Low-calorie diet
6
None
BM, BMI, BFM, plasma leptin

Darbandi 
et al., 2014 [11]
Iran
20/20
20/20
Body electro-acupuncture/ Auricular acupuncture
Sham body electro-acupuncture/ sham Auricular acupuncture
Low-calorie diet
6
None
Height, WHR, BMI, trunk fat mass, Cr, Albumin, Uric acid, FBS, HLD-c, LDL-c, WBC, RBC

Gucel 
et al., 2012 [12]
Turkey
20
20
Body acupuncture
Sham acupuncture
None
5
Not reported
Weight, BMI, insulin, leptin, ghrelin, cholecystokinin

Han-1, 2016 [13]
China
36
37
Body electro-acupuncture
No treatment
Dietary and exercise
4
2 Subcutaneous bleeding and hematoma
BMI, WC, hip circumference, WHR and spleen dampness improve the situation of symptom score

Han-2, 2016 [13]
China
40
41
Body electro-acupuncture
No treatment
Dietary and exercise
4
3 Subcutaneous bleeding and hematoma
BMI, WC, hip circumference, WHR and spleen dampness improve the situation of symptom score

He 
et al., 2008 [14]
China
40
40
Body electro-acupuncture + Auricular acupuncture
Sibutramine
None
8
No reported
Body weight, BMI, waist and hip circumference and WHR

Hsu 
et al., 2009 [15]
Taiwan
23
22
Auricular acupuncture
Shame auricular acupuncture
None
6
1 Minor inflammation, 8 mild tenderness
Body weight, BMI, WC, obesity-related hormone peptides

Hung 
et al., 2016 [16]
Taiwan
32
30
Verum laser acupuncture
Sham laser acupuncture
None
3
None
BMI, BFP, waist-to-buttock ratio

Kim 
et al., 2014 [17]
Korea
25
24
Auricular acupressure
No treatment
None
4
None
Weight, BMI, body fat mass percentage, WHR

Lien 
et al., 2012 [18]
Taiwan
48
23
Auricular stimulation
Sham auricular acupuncture
None
8
1 dizziness
BMI, weight, obesity-related hormone peptids, life quality scores

Luo, 2006 [19]
China
40
20
Electro-acupuncture / only acupuncture
No treatment
None
3
Not reported
WHR, MBI, TC, TG, HDL-c, LDL-c, LEP, Adiponectin(ADI)

Nourshahi 
et al., 2009 [20]
Iran
9
9
Acupuncture
No treatment/diet and exercise
Diet and exercise
8
Not reported
Body weight, skin fold thickness, BMI, fat mass

Tong, 2011 [21]
China
76
42
Acupuncture
Placebo-acupuncture
Diet
5
None
BMI, TC, TG, Glucose, BUN, Uric Acid and adverse reactions

Xing, 2009 [22]
China
31
30
Electroacupuncture
Diet and exercise
Diet and exercise
8
No reported
Body weight, BMI, TG, TC, LDL-c, HDL-c, WHR, Leptin

Xiong 
et al., 2016 [23]
China
29
21
Acupuncture
Exercise
None
4
No reported
Body weight, BMI

Yeh 
et al., 2015 [24]
Taiwan
36
34
Auricular electrical stimulation +auricular acupressure
Same manner but at sham acupoints
Diet
10
No reported
BMI, blood pressure, TC, TG, Leptin, Adiponectin

Yeo 
et al., 2014 [25]
Korean
43
15
Ear acupuncture
Sham acupuncture
None
8
No reported
BMI, WC, weight, body fat mass (kg), percentage body fat and blood pressure

Zhang 
et al., 2012 [26]
China
15
15
Electro-acupuncture
Sham Electro-acupuncture
None
4
1 Bleeding
Weight, BMI, body fat mass %

Zhang, 2012 [27]
China
29
28
Catgut embedded
No treatment
Diet and exercise
8
The bleeding rate was 18.75% in treatment group
Weight, BMI, waistline, hipline, circumference, quality of life

Zhao 
et al., 2011 [28]
China
35
35
Electro-acupuncture
Sham Electro-acupuncture
None
4
No reported
BMI, Weight

Zhao, 2010 [29]
China
30
30
Electro-acupuncture
Diet and exercise
Diet and exercise
8
No reported
BMI, waist, FBS, 2hPG, FINS, 2hFINS

Figure 1: Flow diagram or the number of studies included and excluded.

The quality assessment of the included studies is summarized in Table 2. The majority of studies included had more or less methodological weakness according to the quality criteria applied. Of the 22 records, 1 [20] fulfilled three, 11 [9–12, 15, 17–19, 23, 24, 28] fulfilled four, 4 [14, 22, 25, 28] fulfilled five, 3 [16, 21, 27] fulfilled six, and 3 [13, 26] fulfilled seven. All records had random allocation, 14 [9–11, 13, 15, 18, 20–28] in used random number table, 4 [14, 17, 19, 29] employed draw lots, 1 [12] used urn randomization, 1 [16] performed permuted block randomization, and 1 [20] randomly listed names and assigned them to three groups. Moreover, 10 [11, 13, 15, 16, 18, 21, 24–26] mentioned blinding of participants and personnel and 7 [13, 14, 21, 26, 27] mentioned blinding of outcomes. In addition, 8 [13, 16, 22, 24–28] reported the plan of allocation and concealment. Two [20, 28] had no information about withdraws but provided complete outcome data. Three [15, 24, 25] had a loss to follow-up more than 15%.

Table 2: Risk of bias of the included studies.

Included studies
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
Total

Darbandi et al., 2012 [9]
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
4

Darbandi et al., 2013 [10]
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
4

Darbandi et al., 2014 [11]
1
0
1
0
1
0
1
4

Gucel et al., 2012 [12]
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
4

Han-1, 2016 [13]
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
7

Han-2, 2016 [13]
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
7

He et al., 2008 [14]
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
5

Hsu et al., 2009 [15]
1
0
1
0
1
0
1
4

Hung et al., 2016 [16]
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
6

Kim et al., 2014 [17]
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
4

Lien et al., 2012 [18]
1
0
1
0
1
0
1
4

Luo, 2006 [19]
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
4

Nourshahi et al., 2009 [20]
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
3

Tong, 2011 [21]
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
6

Xing, 2009 [22]
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
5

Xiong et al., 2016 [23]
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
4

Yeh et al., 2015 [24]
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
4

Yeo et al., 2014 [25]
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
5

Zhang et al., 2012 [26]
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
7

Zhang, 2012 [27]
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
6

Zhao et al., 2011 [28]
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
5

Zhao, 2010 [29]
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
4

Note: A, adequate sequence generation; B, concealment of allocation; C, blinding of participants and personnel; D, blinding of outcome assessment; E, incomplete outcome data; F, selective reporting; G, other bias; 1, low risk of bias, the information of the domain was adequate in the text; 0, high risk of bias, the information of the domain was inadequate in the text.

3.2. Effectiveness

3.2.1. Acupuncture versus Sham Acupuncture

A total of 12 records [9–12, 15, 16, 18, 21, 24–26, 29] showed significant difference in BMI reduction between the acupuncture and sham acupuncture. The random effects model was used (MD=-1.22, 95CI=-1.87 to -0.56); the high heterogeneity was detected (heterogeneity: Chi² =60.16, df =10 (P<0.00001); I²=83%). Sensitivity analysis was conducted to explore potential source of heterogeneity, which yielded I²50% results after the omission of each individual study. Subgroup analyses were performed based on different acupuncture therapies. Results showed that both auricular acupuncture and EA significantly reduced BMI compared with control group (MD=-0.56, 95CI=-0.98 to -0.15; MD=-1.43, 95CI=-1.83 to -1.04; Figure 2(a)). The funnel plots were bilateral asymmetry, suggesting the publication bias may exist. A total of 7 records [9, 10, 12, 15, 18, 25, 29] reported the data of weight loss. There was significant difference between two groups. The random effects model was used (MD=-1.54, 95CI=-2.98 to -0.11); high heterogeneity was detected (heterogeneity: Chi² =31.83, df =6 (P<0.00001); I²=81%). Subgroup analyses showed that EA significantly reduced weight compared with control group (MD=-3.71, 95CI=-4.82 to -2.60; Figure 2(b)). Two records [16, 18] showed no difference in WHR loss between two groups. One record [26] showed that EA significantly reduced WHR compared with control group. Three records [15, 18, 25] showed no difference in WC loss between two groups. The random effects model was used (MD=-0.56, 95CI=-2.03 to 0.91; Figure 2(c)); high heterogeneity was detected (heterogeneity: Chi² =4.41, df =2 (P=0.11); I²=55%). One record [11] showed auricular acupuncture and EA significantly reduced WC compared with control group. Three records [9, 10, 25] showed that the acupuncture significantly reduced body fat mass (kg). The random effects model was used (MD=-1.31, 95CI=-2.47 to -0.16; heterogeneity: Chi² =0.14, df =2 (P=0.93); I²=0%). Subgroup analyses showed that auricular acupuncture significantly reduced body fat mass (kg) compared with control group (MD=-1.32, 95CI=-2.55 to -0.10; Figure 2(d)). Three records [16, 25, 26] showed no significant difference between two groups in body fat mass percentage reduction. Two records [15, 24] showed that the auricular acupuncture significantly reduced serum total cholesterol (TC) in patients. The random effects model was used (SMD=-0.63, 95CI=-1.00 to -0.25; heterogeneity: Chi² =0.05, df =1 (P=0.81); I²=0%; Figure 2(e)). Two records [15, 24] showed no significant difference in reducing TG in patients between groups. The random effects model was used (SMD=-0.35, 95CI=-0.72 to 0.02; heterogeneity: Chi² =0.49, df =1 (P=0.48); I²=0%; Figure 2(f)). Two records [15, 21] showed no significant difference in reducing glucose in patients. One record [15] showed no significant difference in HDL-c and LDL-c between two groups. One [26] case of bleeding after treatment was reported in 1 record. A few participants developed minor inflammation and had mild tenderness at the acupuncture sites during the treatment in 1 record [15]; no major adverse effects were seen during the study. A subject in treatment group experienced dizziness immediately after auricular acupuncture in 1 record [18]. Slight bleeding was observed in 1 record [27].

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

(e)

(f)

(g)

(h)

(i)

(j)

(k)

(l)

(m)

Figure 2: The forest plots of the efficacy of acupuncture for obesity. (1) Acupuncture versus sham acupuncture: (a) analysis of BMI in obesity patients; (b) analysis of weight loss in obesity patients; (c) analysis of WC in obesity patients; (d) analysis of body fat mass (kg) in obesity patients; (e) analysis of TC in obesity patients; and (f) analysis of TG in obesity patients. (2) Acupuncture versus no treatment: (g) analysis of BMI in obesity patients; (h) analysis of weight loss in obesity patients; (i) analysis of WHR in obesity patients; (j) analysis of TC in obesity patients and (k) analysis of TG in obesity patients. (3) Acupuncture versus diet and exercise: (l) analysis of BMI in obesity patients and (m) analysis of weight loss in obesity patients.

3.2.2. Acupuncture versus No Treatment

Five records [13, 17, 19, 27] showed acupuncture significantly reduced BMI. The random effects model was used (MD=-1.92, 95CI=-3.04 to -0.79); high heterogeneity in the data was detected (heterogeneity: Chi² =17.51, df =4 (P=0.002); I²=77%). Subgroup analyses showed that EA significantly reduced BMI compared with control group (MD=-2.69, 95CI=-4.93 to -0.45; Figures 2(g) and 3). Three records [13, 27] reported the data of weight loss. There was no difference between two groups. The random effects model was used (MD=-3.08 95CI=-6.91 to 0.74); heterogeneity in the data was detected (heterogeneity: Chi² =4.52, df =2 (P=0.10); I²=56%). Subgroup analyses showed that there was no difference between EA and control group in weight loss (MD=-5.25, 95CI=-10.58 to 0.08; Figure 2(h)). Five records [13, 17, 19, 27] showed acupuncture significantly reduced WHR. The random effects model was used (MD=-0.05, 95CI=-0.09 to -0.02); high heterogeneity in the data was detected (heterogeneity: Chi² =22.16, df =4 (P=0.0002); I²=82%). Subgroup analyses showed that EA significantly reduced WHR compared with control group (MD=-0.06, 95CI=-0.11 to -0.02; Figure 2(i)). One record [27] showed acupuncture significantly reduced WC compared with control group. Two records [13, 19] showed the acupuncture significantly reduced TC. The random effects model was used (MD=-0.26, 95CI=-0.48 to -0.03; heterogeneity: Chi² =0.64, df =1 (P=0.42); I²=0%; Figure 2(j)). Two records [13, 19] showed the acupuncture significantly reduced TG. The random effects model was used (MD=-0.29 95CI=-0.39 to -0.18; heterogeneity: Chi² =0.01, df =1 (P=0.90); I²=0%; Figure 2(k)). One record [19] showed the acupuncture significantly changed LDL-c in patients. One record [19] showed no significant difference in HDL-c between two groups. Subcutaneous bleeding or hematoma after treatment was reported in 2 records [13].

Figure 3: The funnel plots of the efficacy of acupuncture for obesity. Funnel plots of the effect of acupuncture on BMI between acupuncture and sham acupuncture.

3.2.3. Acupuncture versus Diet and Exercise

The efficacy of acupuncture was compared to diet and exercise in 4 records [20, 22, 23, 29]. The pooled effect on BMI outcome in 3 records [22, 23, 29] showed no significant difference in BMI decrease. The random effects model was used (MD=-1.24, 95CI=-1.87 to -0.62); heterogeneity was detected (heterogeneity: Chi² =4.11, df =2 (P=0.13); I²=51%). Subgroup analyses showed that EA significantly reduced BMI compared with control group (MD=-1.39, 95CI=-2.25 to -0.53; Figure 2(l)). One record [20] reported BMI, but the data of control group was not given. Therefore, description analysis was used and it suggested that no significant difference was found between the two groups. Three records [22, 23, 29] showed the acupuncture significantly reduced weight. The random effects model was used (MD=-3.27 95CI=-5.07 to -1.47); heterogeneity was detected (heterogeneity: Chi² =3.53, df = 2 (P=0.17); I²=43%). Subgroup analyses showed that EA significantly reduced body weight compared with control group (MD=-3.71, 95CI=-6.21 to -1.20; Figure 2(m)). One record [22] showed the acupuncture significantly changed WHR in the first duration of treatment, but no significant difference was found in the last two durations between two groups. One record [29] showed the treatment group was more effective than the control group in WC loss. No significant difference in body fat mass (kg) was found between two groups in 1 record [29]. One record [22] showed no significant change between two groups in serum TC, TG, LDL-c, and HDL-c.

3.2.4. Acupuncture versus Medicine

Acupuncture was compared to medicine in 1 record [14]. There was no significantly different between two groups in BMI and weight decrease. Control group was more effective than the acupuncture group in WC and WHR reduction.

3.3. Possible Mechanisms of Acupuncture on Obesity

Acupuncture is believed to be involved in neuroendocrine axis regulation. Modulating eating habits and energy metabolism are the promising strategies for obesity, and it is an immensely complex process involving the gastrointestinal tract, many hormones, and both the central and autonomic nervous systems (Figure 4).

Figure 4: The potential neuroendocrine regulation under the efficacy of acupuncture in the animal studies.

The arcuate nucleus of the hypothalamus (ARH) is the main regulatory organ for appetite in human. In diet-induced obesity (DIO) rats, EA treatment significantly decreased food intake and reduced body weight compared with the untreated rats. Further analysis revealed that EA treatment increased peptide levels of α-MSH and mRNA expression of its precursor proopiomelanocortin (POMC) in ARH neurons. In addition, α-MSH in cerebral spinal fluid (CSF) elevated upon EA application. However, the lesion in ARH could abolish the inhibition effect of EA on food intake and body weight, suggesting the beneficial effects of EA treatment are acted through ARH, and that the stimulation of α-MSH expression and release might be involved in the process [30]. In 14-week high-fat diet feeding rats, 4-week EA treatment causes a reduction of both in body weight and energy intake, along with the upregulation of the cocaine and amphetamine-regulated transcript (CART) peptide, an anorexigenic peptide in the arcuate nucleus (ARC) [31].

Activating the satiety center tends to be one of the effective methods in preventing obesity. Su et al. [32] have shown that acupuncture can raise the frequency of neural discharge in the hypothalamic ventral medial nucleus (VMH), indicating acupuncture could improve the excitability of the medial nucleus in experimental obese animals. Liu et al. [33] have found that the frequency of spontaneous discharges of nerve cells in VMH and the levels of tyrosine (Tyr), dopamine (DA), tryptophan (Typ), and 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT)/5-hydroxyindole acetic acid (5-H1AA) ratio were elevated, along with the decrease of 5-HT level upon 12 days of consecutive acupuncture treatment. Lateral hypothalamic area (LHA) is the main neuroregulator in triggering ingestion. Acupuncture is reported to reduce excitation of LHA, inhibit hyperorexia, and regulate the activity of 5-HT, the catecholamine neurotransmitter, and ATPase activity in the LHA [34, 35].

Some studies [36, 37] believed that acupuncture could improve the frequency of spontaneous discharges of nerve cell in the paraventricular nucleus (PVN) and reduced the activity of hypothalamic perifornical nucleus (PeF) neurons. Ji et al. [38] concluded that an upregulation of anorexigenic factor POMC production in the nucleus tractus solitarius (NTS) and hypoglossal nucleus (HN) regions were generated by EA Zusanli (ST36), thus preventing food intake and causing weight loss. Signal transduction of EA stimuli included expression of transient receptor potential vanilloid type-1 (TRPV1) and neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS) in the ST36 and the NTS/gracile nucleus through somatosensory afferents-medulla pathways. Kim et al. [39] found that stimulation of auricular acupuncture point affected the expression of NPY expression in the ARN and PVN in rats. Fu et al. [40] suggested that transcription factor STAT5 in the central nervous system plays different roles in the hypothalamus and white fat tissue during gene transcription, and acupuncture could regulate a large amount of differentially expressed genes toward their normal expression, especially genes in the hypothalamus. Thus, the weight loss effect of acupuncture might be attributed to its functional gene regulatory mechanisms. Upregulation the transcription of adenosine 5′-monophosphate-activated protein kinaseα2 (AMPKα2), promotion protein expression of liver kinase B1 (LKB1) and AMPKα1, and inhibition acetyl-CoA carboxylase (ACC) protein expression in the hypothalamus were observed after 4 weeks of EA treatment [41]. However, auricular acupuncture stimulation is reported to be associated with satiation formation and preservation in the hypothalamus but fails to work on anorexia activity [42].

Certain hormones including insulin and ghrelin may influence appetite in the hypothalamus [43]. One study [44] showed that downregulation of ghrelin in the stomach and neuropeptide Y (NPY) in the hypothalamus was in line with the reduction in food intake in rats receiving EA stimulation once every day. Liu et al. [45] speculated that, in high-fat diet (HFD) animals, EA treatment (ST36 and LI11, 20 minutes per day for 28 days) could reduce the body weight, homeostasis model assessment-insulin resistance index, adipocyte diameters, and neuroprotein Y/agouti-related protein and protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B levels. In db/db mice, Liang et al. [46] found that EA treatment (five times per week for eight weeks) contracted the increase of fasting blood glucose, food intake, and body mass and maintained insulin levels via stimulation of skeletal muscle Sirtuin 1 (SIRT1)/peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor γ coactivator 1α (PGC-1α), suggesting the role of EA in improving insulin resistance. Gong et al. [47] applied EA stimulation to diet-induced obese rats for four weeks and observed the reduced body weight, plasma levels of leptin, and increased expression of leptin receptor in the hypothalamus. In addition, Shen et al. [48] discovered that four weeks of EA treatment caused remodeling white adipose tissues (WAT) to brown adipose tissue (BAT) via inducing uncoupling protein-1 (UCP1) in EA group. Besides, acupuncture also adjusted the intestinal flora, achieving the balance of brain-gut-bacteria axis [49–51].

4. Discussion

Here we selected 21 RCTs including 1389 patients suffering from obesity to evaluate the efficacy of acupuncture. We found that acupuncture was more effective than shame acupuncture in BMI, weight, body fat mass (kg), and TC; acupuncture was more effective than no treatment group in BMI, WHR, and TG. In addition, acupuncture is showed to be more effective than diet and exercise group in BMI and weight loss. To a limited extent, we concluded that acupuncture is an effective treatment for obesity.

Currently, the etiology of obesity has not been defined yet; many factors such as neuromodulation, viral, immune, endocrine, free radical, and genetics are reported to be involved [52–57]. Each indicator can affect a wide range of factors, hormones, and even genetic changes, so the mechanisms of acupuncture on obesity tend to be the simultaneous adjustment of multiple systems and targets. So, we reviewed the potential mechanisms under the efficacy of the animal studies and highlighted neuroendocrine regulation to be essential in the process.

The limitations of this work are as follows:

(1) Bias risk exists because most studies do not describe the allocation of hidden methods or use blind methods [58], which might result in performance bias and detection bias.

(2) The number of samples of each trial is relatively small, which might cause the insufficient sample size for analysis and test efficacy.

(3) The researchers are evaluated by different diagnostic criteria; inclusion and exclusion criteria, forms of acupuncture (acupuncture, EA, ear needles, ear pressure, and embedding), the course of treatment (different acupoints, duration of treatment), basic intervention (diet and exercise), and the confounding factors are different, which might increase heterogeneity.

(4) Some researchers do not mention the methods used in dealing with missing data although they have a loss to follow-up more than 15%. Most studies lack following course and fail to understand the long-term effects of auricular acupressure treatment, which might increase attrition bias.

(5) There are some objective factors like language and limited search resource, which may lead to the incomplete searching.

In conclusion, acupuncture is a reasonable and effective treatment for people who suffer from obesity. However, according to CONSORT Declaration and STRICTA Standard, some researchers point out that the efficacy of acupuncture on mild obesity is not significant, which is difficult for readers to understand the rationality of the study design, the correctness of the implementation, the authenticity of the results, and the clinical applications [59]. Obesity is a chronic condition, requiring long-term treatment. However, the treatment period of obesity is rather short in many studies, varying from 3-8 weeks. Follow-ups are needed to observe curative effect since the bodyweight might be easily rebound. In clinical, obesity is the major risk of cardiovascular events, so we put the incidence of CVD as the primary outcome; however, no included studies set CVD as primary outcome. More researches need to be done to evaluate CVD as the curative effect of acupuncture treatment for obesity in clinical. This systematic review was conducted to critically assess evidence from RCTs regarding the efficacy of various types of acupuncture therapies on obesity. We analyzed the outcomes which were related to obesity comprehensively. In the future, larger number of samples and higher-quality randomized controlled trials are required to verify the clinical effectiveness in treating obesity by acupuncture. Moreover, understanding the mechanisms under the efficacy of acupuncture on weight loss provides reliable experimental basis, thus convincing the patients with obesity with the application of acupuncture.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declared no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Shanghai Rising-Star Program (no. 17QA1404000) and Shanghai Municipal Population and Family Planning Commission “Excellent Youth Talent Training Program” (no. 2017YQ036).

References

I. Kawachi, “Physical and psychological consequences of weight gain,” Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, vol. 60, supplement 21, pp. 5–9, 1999.

L. Yang and G. A. Colditz, “Prevalence of overweight and obesity in the United States, 2007–2012,” JAMA Internal Medicine, vol. 175, no. 8, pp. 1412-1413, 2015.

The Cooperative Group Will Be Evaluated after the Listing of Sibutramine Center, “Clinical curative effect and safety research in treatment of the simple obesity with sibutramine hydrochloride capsule,” Chinese Journal of Clinical Pharmacy, no. 15, pp. 17–20, 2004 (Chinese).

A. Ballinger, “Orlistat in the treatment of obesity,” Expert Opinion on Pharmacotherapy, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 841–847, 2000.

Z. Liu, S. Yan, J. Wu et al., “Acupuncture for chronic severe functional constipation: a randomized trial,” Annals of Internal Medicine, vol. 165, no. 11, pp. 761–769, 2016.

X. K. Wu, E. Stener-Victorin, H. Y. Kuang et al., “Effect of acupuncture and clomiphene in Chinese women with polycystic ovary syndrome: a randomized clinical trial,” Journal of the American Medical Association, vol. 317, no. 24, pp. 2502–2514, 2017.

J. P. Briggs and D. Shurtleff, “Acupuncture and the complex connections between the mind and the body,” Journal of the American Medical Association, vol. 317, no. 24, pp. 2489-2490, 2017.

Z. Liu, Y. Liu, H. Xu et al., “Effect of electroacupuncture on urinary leakage among women with stress urinary incontinence: A randomized clinical trial,” Journal of the American Medical Association, vol. 317, no. 24, pp. 2493–2501, 2017.

M. Darbandi, S. Darbandi, A. A. Owji et al., “The effects of Electro Acupuncture on leptin hormone in Iranian obese and overweight subjects,” Clinical Biochemistry, vol. 44, no. 13, pp. S127–S128, 2011.

M. Darbandi, S. Darbandi, M. G. Mobarhan et al., “Effects of auricular acupressure combined with low-Calorie diet on the leptin hormone in obese and overweight iranian individuals,” Acupuncture in Medicine, vol. 30, no. 3, pp. 208–213, 2012.

M. Darbandi, S. Darbandi, A. A. Owji et al., “Auricular or body acupuncture: which one is more effective in reducing abdominal fat mass in Iranian men with obesity: a randomized clinical trial,” Journal of Diabetes & Metabolic Disorders, vol. 13, no. 1, article 92, 2014.

F. Gucel, B. Bahar, C. Demirtas, S. Mit, and C. Çevik, “Influence of acupuncture on leptin, ghrelin, insulin and cholecystokinin in obese women: a randomised, sham-controlled preliminary trial,” Acupuncture in Medicine, vol. 30, no. 3, pp. 203–207, 2012.

Y. P. Han, Spleen Tune with Acupuncture on Simple Obesity Female Patients with Spleen Dysfunction and Dampness Syndrome, Heilongjiang University Of Chinese Medicine, 2016 (Chinese).

L. He, X.-L. Gao, H.-X. Deng, and Y.-X. Zhao, “Effects of acupuncture on body mass index and waist-hip ratio in the patient of simple obesity,” Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion, vol. 28, no. 2, pp. 95–97, 2008 (Chinese).

C.-H. Hsu, C.-J. Wang, K.-C. Hwang, T.-Y. Lee, P. Chou, and H.-H. Chang, “The effect of auricular acupuncture in obese women: a randomized controlled trial,” Journal of Women's Health, vol. 18, no. 6, pp. 813–818, 2009.

Y.-C. Hung, I.-L. Hung, W.-L. Hu et al., “Reduction in postpartum weight with laser acupuncture: a randomized control trial,” Medicine, vol. 95, no. 34, p. e4716, 2016.

D. Kim, O. K. Ham, C. Kang, and E. Jun, “Effects of auricular acupressure using Sinapsis alba seeds on obesity and self-efficacy in female college students,” The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 258–264, 2014.

C. Y. Lien, L. L. Liao, P. Chou, and C. H. Hsu, “Effects of auricular stimulation on obese women: a randomized, controlled clinical trial,” European Journal of Integrative Medicine, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. e45–e53, 2012.

H. L. Luo, Study on Effect and Mechanism of Electroacupuncture on Simple Obesity, Chongqing Medical University, 2006 (Chinese).

M. Nourshahi, S. Ahmadizad, H. Nikbakht, M. A. Heidarnia, and E. Ernst, “The effects of triple therapy (acupuncture, diet and exercise) on body weight: A randomized, clinical trial,” International Journal of Obesity, vol. 33, no. 5, pp. 583–587, 2009.

J. Tong, J. X. Chen, Z. Q. Zhang et al., “Clinical observation on simple obesity treated by acupuncture,” Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion, vol. 31, no. 8, pp. 697–701, 2011.

H. J. Xing, The Clinical Research on Acupuncture Combined with Dietary Adjustment and Aerobic Exercise for Treatment of Simple Obesity, Hebei Medical University, 2009 (Chinese).

W. Xiong, H. J. Yuan, S. Y. Luo, and Y. H. Pan, “The effect of acupuncture in 29 obese,” Hunan Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, no. 5, pp. 115–117, 2016 (Chinese).

M.-L. Yeh, N.-F. Chu, M.-Y. F. Hsu, C.-C. Hsu, and Y.-C. Chung, “Acupoint stimulation on weight reduction for obesity: a randomized sham-controlled study,” Western Journal of Nursing Research, vol. 37, no. 12, pp. 1517–1530, 2015.

S. Yeo, K. S. Kim, and S. Lim, “Randomised clinical trial of five ear acupuncture points for the treatment of overweight people,” Acupuncture in Medicine, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 132–138, 2014.

L. Zhang, X. L. Zhou, H. M. Zhang, and M. Q. Hong, “Clinical observation on simple obesity treated by electroacupuncture,” Journal of Sichuan of Traditional Chinese Medicine, no. 11, pp. 134–136, 2012 (Chinese).

J. S. Zhang, Clinical observation on simple obesity treat by catgut embedded therapy combine with diet adjustment and aerobic exercise, Chengdu University of TCM, 2012 (Chinese).

Y. Zhao, J. Liu, Y. Yao, and M. Q. Lin, “Clinical research of using acupuncture, which can invigorate spleen and eliminate phlegm, to treat simple obesity,” Journal of Sichuan of Traditional Chinese Medicine, no. 4, pp. 123–125, 2011 (Chinese).

L. Q. Zhao and Y. Shi, “Electroacupuncture combined with diets and exercises in treatment of simple obesity complicated with excess heat syndrome of stomach and intestine,” Journal of Anhui University of Chinese Medicine, no. 4, pp. 33–37, 2010 (Chinese).

F. Wang, D. R. Tian, P. Tso, and J. S. Han, “Arcuate nucleus of hypothalamus is involved in mediating the satiety effect of electroacupuncture in obese rats,” Peptides, vol. 32, no. 12, pp. 2394–2399, 2011.

D.-R. Tian, X.-D. Li, F. Wang et al., “Up-regulation of the expression of cocaine and amphetamine-regulated transcript peptide by electroacupuncture in the arcuate nucleus of diet-induced obese rats,” Neuroscience Letters, vol. 383, no. 1-2, pp. 17–21, 2005.

J. Su, Z. C. Liu, and M. Zhao, “Research on the effect of satiety center in the reduction of weight by electropuncture,” Shanghai Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, no. 6, pp. 30-31, 1999 (Chinese).

Z. C. Liu, F. M. Sun, J. Su et al., “Study on action of acupuncture on ventromedial nucleus of hypothalamus in obese rats,” Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, no. 3, pp. 220–224, 2001 (Chinese).

Z. C. Liu, M. F. Sun, Y. Han et al., “Effect of acupuncture on level of monoamines and activity of adenosine triphosphatase in lateral hypothalamic area og obese rats,” Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine, no. 7, pp. 521–523, 2000 (Chinese).

M. Zhao et al., “Effect of acupuncture on feeding center of hypothalamus in experimental fat rats,” Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion, no. 5, pp. 49–51, 2001 (Chinese).

Z. C. Liu, M. F. Sun, M. Zhao et al., “Effect of acupuncture on paraventricular nucleus of obese rats,” Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, no. 7, pp. 1031–1033, 1059, 2003 (Chinese).

Z. Sun, Z. C. Zhang, L. Ma, and Z. C. Liu, “Effect of acupuncture on expression of hypothalamic neuropeptide Y gene in obese rats,” Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research, no. 15, pp. 135–138, 2006 (Chinese).

B. Ji, J. Hu, and S. Ma, “Effects of electroacupuncture Zusanli (ST36) on food intake and expression of POMC and TRPV1 through afferents-medulla pathway in obese prone rats,” Peptides, vol. 40, pp. 188–194, 2013.

E.-H. Kim, Y. Kim, M.-H. Jang et al., “Auricular acupuncture decreases neuropeptide Y expression in the hypothalamus of food-deprived Sprague-Dawley rats,” Neuroscience Letters, vol. 307, no. 2, pp. 113–116, 2001.

S.-P. Fu, H. Hong, S.-F. Lu et al., “Genome-wide regulation of electro-acupuncture on the neural Stat5-loss-induced obese mice,” PLoS ONE, vol. 12, no. 8, Article ID e0181948, 2017.

J. Xu, L. Chen, L. Tang et al., “Electroacupuncture inhibits weight gain in diet-induced obese rats by activating hypothalamicLKB1-AMPK signaling,” BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine, vol. 15, no. 1, article 147, 2015.

T. Shiraishi, M. Onoe, T. Kojima, Y. Sameshima, and T. Kageyama, “Effects of auricular stimulation on feeding-related hypothalamic neuronal activity in normal and obese rats,” Brain Research Bulletin, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 141–148, 1995.

I. Paspala, N. Katsiki, D. Kapoukranidou, D. P. Mikhailidis, and A. Tsiligiroglou-Fachantidou, “The role of psychobiological and neuroendocrine mechanisms in appetite regulation and obesity,” The Open Cardiovascular Medicine Journal, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 147–155, 2012.

N. Tian, F. Wang, D.-R. Tian et al., “Electroacupuncture suppresses expression of gastric ghrelin and hypothalamic NPY in chronic food restricted rats,” Peptides, vol. 27, no. 9, pp. 2313–2320, 2006.

X. Liu, J.-F. He, Y.-T. Qu et al., “Electroacupuncture Improves Insulin Resistance by Reducing Neuroprotein Y/Agouti-Related Protein Levels and Inhibiting Expression of Protein Tyrosine Phosphatase 1B in Diet-induced Obese Rats,” JAMS Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 58–64, 2016.

F. Liang, R. Chen, A. Nakagawa et al., “Low-frequency electroacupuncture improves insulin sensitivity in obese diabetic mice through activation of SIRT1/PGC-1alpha in skeletal muscle,” Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, vol. 2011, Article ID 735297, 9 pages, 2011.

M. Gong, X. Wang, Z. Mao, Q. Shao, X. Xiang, and B. Xu, “Effect of electroacupuncture on leptin resistance in rats with diet-induced obesity,” American Journal of Chinese Medicine, vol. 40, no. 3, pp. 511–520, 2012.

W. Shen, Y. Wang, S.-F. Lu et al., “Acupuncture promotes white adipose tissue browning by inducing UCP1 expression on DIO mice,” BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine, vol. 14, no. 1, article 501, 2014.

L. P. Zhou, The Acupuncture Regulate Mechanism of the Intestinal Flora of Obesity Patients, Chengdu University of TCM, 2011 (Chinese).

M. Liang, The Clinical Studies of Acupuncture Treatment on the Effects of Gut Microbiota of Patients with Simple Obesity, Guangxi University of TCM, 2016 (Chinese).

Y. C. Si, W. N. Miao, J. Y. He, and W. J. Ding, “Regulation mechanism of acupuncture method of invigorating spleen and replenishing qi on the intestinal flora and TLR4 of obesity mice based on the ‘brain-gut-bacteria’ axis,” Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, no. 10, pp. 4457–4460, 2017 (Chinese).

J. Yamamoto, J. Imai, Izumi T, H. Takahashi, Y. Kawana, K. Takahashi et al., “Neuronal signals regulate obesity induced beta-cell proliferation by FoxM1 dependent mechanism,” Nature Communications, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 1930, 2017.

M. Tanaka, M. Itoh, Y. Ogawa, and T. Suganami, “Molecular mechanism of obesity-induced ‘metabolic’ tissue remodeling,” Journal of Diabetes Investigation, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 256–261, 2017.

M. S. Ellulu, I. Patimah, H. Khaza’ai, A. Rahmat, and Y. Abed, “Obesity and inflammation: the linking mechanism and the complications,” Archives of Medical Science, vol. 4, pp. 851–863, 2017.

A. Engin, “Diet-induced obesity and the mechanism of leptin resistance,” Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology, vol. 960, pp. 381–397, 2017.

M. W. Schwartz, R. J. Seeley, L. M. Zeltser et al., “Obesity Pathogenesis: An Endocrine Society Scientific Statement,” Endocrine Reviews, vol. 38, no. 4, pp. 267–296, 2017.

K. E. Bouter, D. H. van Raalte, A. K. Groen, and M. Nieuwdorp, “Role of the Gut Microbiome in the Pathogenesis of Obesity and Obesity-Related Metabolic Dysfunction,” Gastroenterology, vol. 152, no. 7, pp. 1671–1678, 2017.

Q. Yu, “Choice of blindness and placebo evaluating the efficacy of acupuncture,” Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine on Cardio/Cerebrovascular Disease, no. 4, pp. 196–198, 2003 (Chinese).

P. Sun, Y. H. Du, J. Xiong et al., “Assessment of the reporting quality of randomized controlled trials on acupuncture for simple obesity with CONSORT statement and STRICTA,” Lishizhen Medicine and Materia Medica Research, no. 4, pp. 943–945, 2010 (Chinese).