A Compact Experimental Planar Antenna with a USB Connector for Mobile Phone Application

A practical antenna design combined with a universal serial bus (USB) connector in close vicinity is proposed. In the proposed arrangement, the antenna unit consisted of two planar inverted F antennas (PIFAs) placed on the two sides of the USB connector. The antenna is located at the bottom of the mobile phone to avoid the crowded space on the top side of the phone where various mobile phone accessories are usually assigned. A diplexer is incorporated in the unit to alleviate the adverse effect of the metal USB connector on the radiating efficiency of the antenna. A prototype antenna was fabricated and tested and showed good coverage for GSM850/900/1800/1900, UMTS2100, and LTE700/2500 multibands operation. The overall performances demonstrated the good design of the proposed unit for mobile phone application.


Introduction
With the rapid development of wireless communication technology, the studies on multiband antennas for mobile phone applications [1] are demanded.Wide bandwidth and compact structure are important requirements for the antenna design.The planar antennas can provide wide operating bands for wireless wide area network (WWAN) [2].The PIFA is generally implemented [3], and it can be easily integrated onto the mobile phone [4].
Several developments on the design of promising internal antenna covering the WWAN/LTE operations in the 824-960/1710-2690 MHz bands for smartphone application have been demonstrated [5][6][7][8].In [5,6], the antenna occupied an area, respectively, of 435 mm 2 (15 × 29) and 375 mm 2 (15 × 25), while that of [7] implemented a compact T-slit monopole antenna with slotted ground plane covering 824-960/1710-2170 MHz bands occupying an area of 470 mm 2 (10 × 47) mm 2 .In [8]  More recent works on the miniaturization of the antenna area have also been carried out by proposing a novel bending strip to reduce the effective width of the antenna to give a small antenna area of 375 mm 2 (15 × 25) in [9] and 450 mm 2 (15 × 30) in [10].In the literature, the gains and radiation efficiencies at the respective operating bands are quite high.For instance, in [10], for the lower band of GSM850/900 (824-960 MHz), the antenna gain is 0.03-0.89dBi with radiation efficiency of about 50%-65%.For the upper bands of DCS/ PCS, UMTS2100, and LTE2300/2500, which covered a frequency range of 1710-2690 MHz, the obtained antenna gain is 0.56-3.13dBi with corresponding radiation efficiency larger than 65%.However, these values were achieved without considering the more realistic circumstances of the presence of other accessories such as USB connector and camera lens, which would depreciate the performance of the radiator.The aforementioned issue is always ignored in most studies [5][6][7][8][9][10] on the performance of compact size antenna for slim smart phone application.In this study, particular attention is being taken in the design of the radiator to include the effect of metal accessory, namely, the USB connector, in close proximity.
In the present proposed design, we have also considered the particular aspect of a commercial smartphone in which the top side of the phone is usually overcrowded with many accessories such as camera, audio jack, and receiver [5,6].Therefore, it is proposed that the antennas together with a USB connector, typical size 350 mm 3 (10 × 7 × 5), are to be colocated on the bottom side of the mobile phone.Two noground regions of areas 150 mm 2 (15 × 10) and 250 mm 2 (25 × 10) located on two sides of the USB are available for coating the antenna radiators.This particular arrangement can be easily implemented in a practical smart phone and also ensured that the radiator unit and the USB connector have no crossover region which would otherwise degrade the radiation efficiency of the antenna.The antennas were designed to cover the GSM850/900/1800/1900, UMTS2100, and LTE700/ 2500 bands.Furthermore, antenna placed at the bottom side of the mobile phone also has the inherent advantage of reduced phantom effect and hence a lower effective SAR.
The antenna characteristics were simulated using Ansoft's HFSS simulation software.The antenna measurements were performed in a far-field anechoic chamber equipped with ETS-Lindgren AMS-8500 Antenna Measurement System.The resonance frequency and input impedance of the antenna were optimized.The bandwidth referring to VSWR value of 3 : 1 demonstrated good coverage over 700-1000, 1700-2200, and 2500-2700 MHz range.The simulated and measured results including return loss, gain, and radiation efficiency were presented and discussed.

Antenna Design
The antenna unit consisted of two radiating elements located at the bottom side of the mobile phone and separated by a USB connector.The two radiators are constructed of copper and coated on a plastic carrier which is made of 1 mm thick Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (relative permittivity 3.0 and conductivity 0.01 S/m).The FR4 substrate of the mobile phone is 60 mm × 120 mm × 0.8 mm (relative permittivity 4.4 and conductivity 0.005 S/m).One radiator is for the GSM850/900 and LTE700 bands; and another one is for DCS/PCS, UMTS2100, and LTE2500 bands.A model DPX202690DT diplexer manufactured by TDK Corporation, which has a low insertion loss of 0.24 dB from 704 to 960 MHz, 0.38 dB from 1710 to 2170 MHz, and 0.83 dB from 2170 to 2690 MHz, was used in the circuit board to combine the two signals of low and high bands.The practical internal antenna design of compact size is for multiband operation and used in 2G/3G/4G communication system [11,12].In order to enhance the antenna performance, two ground regions are removed from the printed circuit board under the antenna area.The two no-ground regions have areas of 150 mm 2 (15 × 10) and 250 mm 2 (25 × 10).The ground area of 70 mm 2 (10 × 7) under the USB connector is kept intact.For practical application, the dimension set for compact mobile phone design is reasonable by comparing to the sizes of the literature [5][6][7][8][9].The geometry of the proposed planar antenna located on the bottom side of the mobile phone is shown in Figure 1.The two internal antennas occupied a total area of 400 mm 2 , which is attractive for slim mobile phone applications.With a unit height of 6 mm (USB height of 5 mm and the thickness of the PCB at 1 mm), the setup is well suited for mobile phone thickness of less than 10 mm.
In Figure 1, the port V 1 is a feed point of radiator for high band and port V 2 is for low band.The two feeding ports are connected to a diplexer, which served to combine the signal with the RF port (point V 0 ).The PIFA radiator has a shorting pad.The slot of the radiator is used for attaining the effective length of the required resonance frequency.The feeding port is connected to a 50-ohm microstrip line for testing.
The practical prototype antenna for multiband operation is shown in Figure 2. The length  1 + 2 + 2 + 1 from point  1 to point  is ∼40 mm corresponding to a quarter wavelength at 1900 MHz.The length  3 +  3 +  4 +  4 +  5 from point  2 to point  is ∼80 mm which is about a quarter wavelength at 900 MHz.The photograph of the fabricated unit containing the high and low band antennas with a USB connecter is shown in Figure 3.

Results and Discussions
The practical antenna unit containing the USB as shown in Figure 3 was fabricated and tested.The simulated and measured results of the return loss of V 1 port for the high band and V 2 port for the low band are shown in Figures 4 and 5, respectively.
A comparison of the results as depicted in Figures 4  and 5 shows good agreement both for the high and low bands.The signals of V 1 and V 2 are combined with V 0 by the  diplexer.The return loss of V 0 port, which includes the insertion loss of the diplexer, is shown in Figure 6 and indicated good performance both in the low and high bands, by referring to VSWR value of lower than 3 : 1.The bandwidth which ranged from 700 to 1000 MHz covered the GSM850/ 900 and LTE700 bands, from 1700 to 2200 MHz covered the DCS/PCS and UMTS2100 bands, and from 2500 to 2700 MHz covered the LTE2500 band [9].The measured and simulated optimal antenna peak gains at V 1 and V 2 are shown in Figures 7 and 8, respectively.The simulated and measured results also showed excellent match.The measured gain and efficiency at V 0 which includes the insertion loss of the diplexer are listed in Table 1.For the low band (700-1000 MHz), the antenna gain varies from radiation efficiency is about 34-41%; for the high band (1700-2700 MHz), the antenna gain varies from −0.6 to −1.4 dBi and radiation efficiency is about 34-43%.The gain performances in the low and high bands indicated good coverage of the GSM850/900/1800/1900, UMTS2100, and LTE700/2500 for practical application in mobile phones.The lower values for the gain and radiation efficiency by comparing to the results of the literature [5][6][7][8][9][10] reflect the more realistic situation of the present work with the presence of a USB in close vicinity.Moreover, it is also noted that if a USB dongle is in place, further degradation of ∼0.5 dB at the low band and ∼1 dB at high bands will occur.Nevertheless, this will not affect the overall good performance of the antenna unit.
The antenna characteristics of the radiation pattern were studied as well.The measured radiation patterns for 900, 1800, and 2500 MHz are shown in Figures 9,10,and 11, respectively.For the radiation pattern at 900 MHz, it shows a dipole-like pattern with good omnidirectional radiation, which indicates the stable radiation characteristic over the The 1-g SAR of the proposed antenna was also measured using DASY5 system manufactured by SPEAG.The head and body tissue liquid information provided by SPEAG are listed in Table 2.The measurements were taken with the fabricated unit placed close to the phantom ear with zero distance.The SAR results tested by an input power of 23 dBm for 900, 1800, 2100, and 2500 MHz are shown in Table 3.The test shows that the SAR of the present design is well within the limit of 1.6 mW/g for the 1-g head tissue.

Conclusion
A practical multiband planar antenna with a USB connector has been proposed for mobile phone applications.The resonant modes are formed by two wide operating bands for the low and high bands to cover GSM850/900/1800/1900, UMTS2100, and LTE700/2500 operation.The obtained results including VSWR, gain, efficiency, and radiation pattern were presented.The specific absorption rate (SAR) of the antenna design was also measured.The proposed antenna design showed high efficiency with low SAR value.The bandwidth of the proposed antenna makes it very suitable for 2G, 3G, and 4G mobile communication applications.

Figure 1 :Figure 2 :
Figure 1: Geometry of the proposed antenna of the mobile phone for multibands operation.

Figure 3 :Figure 4 :
Figure 3: The fabricated model of the proposed antenna.

Figure 5 :Figure 6 :
Figure 5: Simulated and measured VSWR of the proposed antenna at V 2 port.

4 Figure 7 :Figure 8 :
Figure 7: Simulated and measured antenna gain of the proposed antenna at V 1 port.

Figure 9 :
Figure 9: Radiation pattern of the proposed antenna at 900 MHz.

Figure 10 :
Figure 10: Radiation pattern of the proposed antenna at 1800 MHz.

Figure 11 :
Figure 11: Radiation pattern of the proposed antenna at 2500 MHz.

Table 1 :
Measured antenna gain and efficiency of the proposed antenna at V 0 port.

Table 3 :
The radiation patterns at 1800 and 2500 MHz show more variations.The variations are caused by the size of the ground plane which is comparable to the working wavelength of the high band.Nevertheless, the overall radiation patterns indicated reasonable omnidirectional characteristics for both the low and high bandwidths.