Low-Profile Repeater Antenna with Parasitic Elements for On-On-Off WBAN Applications

A low-profile repeater antenna with parasitic elements for on-on-off WBAN applications is proposed. The proposed antenna consists of a planar inverted-F antenna (PIFA), two parasitic elements, and a ground planewith a slot. Due to the slot, the impedance matching of the resonance formed by the PIFA is improved, which makes the proposed antenna operate in the 5.8GHz industrial, scientific, andmedical (ISM) band. To cover the 5.2 GHz wireless local area network (WLAN) band, a dual resonance characteristic is realized by the slot and the two parasitic elements.The first coupling between the PIFA and the slot not onlymakes the slot operate as a resonator, but also forms secondary coupling between the slot and the two parasitic elements.The two parasitic elements operate as an additional resonator due to secondary coupling. The antenna has the enhanced near surface radiation in the 5.8GHz ISM band due to addition of the slot and radiation toward off-body direction in the 5.2GHzWLAN band. In order to evaluate antenna performance considering the human body effect, the antenna characteristics on a human equivalent phantom are analyzed.


Introduction
In recent years, wireless body area network (WBAN) systems, communication systems transmitting or receiving a considerable amount of information near the human body, have been studied for various applications including medical, healthcare, automotive, and military services [1][2][3].The antenna for WBAN systems should meet specific requirements, such as low-profile, low specific absorption rate (SAR), and stable performance, because the WBAN devices including the antenna are placed around the human body [4].By establishing the proper communication link among WBAN devices, the vital signs of patients can be observed and transmitted [5].In order to monitor the health status of patients, it is necessary to ensure robust on-off body communication between the wearable device (on-body device) and the monitoring device (off-body device) [6].To improve on-off body communication performance, an on-on-off body repeater antenna suitable for on-on body communication (on-body device to the repeater antenna) and on-off body communication (the repeater antenna to off-body device) is needed.For on-on body communication, the antenna should strongly radiate along the surface direction of the body like a vertical monopole, that is, the monopole mounted vertically with respect to the ground [7,8].However, since a vertical monopole has the largest height, it is not appropriate for on-body applications.For on-off body communication, the maximum radiation of the antenna should be in the normal to the surface of the body [9].To satisfy the previously mentioned features, low-profile repeater antennas for on-on body and on-off body communications are researched [10][11][12].These repeater antennas consist of two radiators and two substrates: a half-circular patch (on-on body) and a slot (onoff body) [10], a long stripline (on-on body) and a patch (on-off body) [11], and a circular patch (on-off body) and a T-shaped patch (on-off body) [12].However, these repeater antennas have the largest height due to the two substrates, which is not suitable for on-body applications.To overcome this problem, the repeater antenna is designed using a single substrate in this paper.
A low-profile repeater antenna with parasitic elements for on-on-off WBAN applications is proposed in this paper.By adding a slot and two parasitic elements, the antenna has a wideband characteristic covering the 5.2 GHz wireless 2 International Journal of Antennas and Propagation  local area network (WLAN) band (5.15 GHz-5.35GHz) and the 5.8 GHz industrial, scientific, and medical (ISM) band which is defined as 5.725 GHz-5.825GHz [13][14][15].Due to the slot, near surface radiation is enhanced in the 5.8 GHz ISM band for on-on body communication.In the 5.2 GHz WLAN band, the antenna has on-off body radiation characteristics.The antenna performance is investigated by using a human equivalent phantom to include the effect of the human body.

Antenna Configuration
The proposed antenna consists of a PIFA, two parasitic elements, and a ground plane with a slot as shown in Figure 1.The PIFA with two parasitic elements is located on an FR4 substrate (  = 4.4, tan  = 0.02).The dimension of the substrate is 41 mm × 48 mm × 1 mm.The ground plane with the slot is placed on the bottom of the substrate.The slot is used to improve the impedance matching of the PIFA and operates as a resonator through the electromagnetic coupling between the PIFA and the slot.The two parasitic elements act as an additional resonator due to the secondary coupling between the slot and the two parasitic elements.
Figure 2 shows the simulation set-up of the proposed antenna on the phantom with a dimension of 200 mm × 270 mm × 60 mm.The antenna and the phantom are separated by a distance of 10 mm.To analyze the performance of the antenna on a human body, a phantom of human muscle tissue with electrical properties of   = 48.2 and  = 6 S/m is used [16].Figures 4 and 5 illustrate the simulated surface current and electric field distributions of the proposed antenna, respectively.As shown in Figure 4, the PIFA mainly acts as a resonator at  3 = 5.77 GHz.In Figure 5, the first coupling between the PIFA and the slot not only makes the slot operate as a resonator at  2 = 5.4 GHz but also generates the secondary coupling between the slot and the two parasitic elements.At  1 = 5.18 GHz, the two parasitic elements act as a resonator due to the secondary coupling.the two parasitic elements, the length of the two parasitic elements decreases by increasing .In turn, the resonance frequency  1 moves to the higher frequency side.By choosing  = 0.4 mm, the proposed antenna simultaneously satisfies the 5.2 GHz WLAN band and the 5.8 GHz ISM band.

Parametric Analysis and Optimization
Figure 8 shows the simulated reflection coefficients for various values of length .As  decreases, the impedance matching at  1 and  3 deteriorates and the resonance frequency  2 decreases.When  is 20 mm, the performance of the antenna is optimized to cover the 5.2 GHz WLAN band and the 5.8 GHz ISM band.
Figure 9 shows the simulated reflection coefficients for various values of distance  between the antenna and  the phantom.As  increases, the impedance matching of  2 mainly deteriorates.When  is 10 mm, the wideband characteristic covering the 5.2 GHz WLAN band and the 5.8 GHz ISM band is achieved.Also, regardless of the change in , the −10 dB reflection coefficients bandwidth covers fully the 5.2 GHz WLAN band and the 5.8 GHz ISM band.

Simulated and Measured Results
In Figure 10, the manufactured prototype antenna is shown.In order to analyze the prototype antenna performance  considering the human body effect, a manufactured human equivalent phantom [18] is used as shown in Figure 11. Figure 12 illustrates the simulated and measured reflection coefficients of the proposed antenna.The simulated reflection coefficient is well matched with the measured one.The manufactured prototype antenna has a wide bandwidth (5.1 GHz-5.86GHz) that can fully cover the 5.2 GHz WLAN band and the 5.8 GHz ISM band.
Figure 13 shows the simulated and measured radiation patterns of the proposed antenna.The simulated radiation patterns agree well with the measured ones.At 5.18 GHz, the antenna mainly radiates towards the direction which is normal to the phantom surface for on-off body communication.Because the antenna has maximum radiations along the  = 30 ∘ direction in the -plane and the  = 45 ∘ and 330 ∘ directions in the -plane at 5.77 GHz, the proposed antenna is suitable for on-on body communication in the 5.8 GHz ISM band.Therefore, the radiation characteristics of the proposed antenna are suitable for on-on-off WBAN repeater application.According to [19], the PIFA generally has maximum radiation towards the direction normal to the PIFA surface, whereas the proposed antenna has maximum radiation towards the surface due to the slot in the ground plane.The measured peak gains are 1.2 dBi and 1.91 dBi at 5.18 GHz and 5.77 GHz, respectively.Figure 14 shows the simulated average SAR distributions of the proposed antenna when it is placed on the human equivalent phantom.The SAR value should be lower than 1.6 W/Kg over a 1 g volume of tissue in a partial body [20].When the input power of 65 mW is applied, the average SAR values are 0.55 W/kg at 5.18 GHz and 0.25 W/kg at 5.77 GHz.
Figure 15 illustrates the simulation set-up of the onbody to on-body communication link.The two proposed antennas are placed on the human equivalent flat phantom with a dimension of 200 mm × 800 mm × 60 mm.A distance between two proposed antennas is 500 mm. Figure 16 illustrates the simulated -parameters of the on-body to on-body communication link.The simulated peak  21 value is −55.6 dB at 5.77 GHz, which is suitable for the on-body to on-body communication link, described in [21].
In Table 1, the size comparison between previous repeater antennas and the proposed antenna is given.The proposed    [11] 148500 mm 3 5.5 mm (0.045 0 @ 2.45 GHz) [12] 4320 mm 3 3.2 mm (0.026 0 @ 2.4 GHz) Proposed antenna 1968 mm 3 1 mm (0.017 0 @ 5.18 GHz) antenna not only has the thinnest thickness but also occupies the smallest volume among the four repeater antennas in the comparison.Therefore, the proposed antenna is suitable as a low-profile on-body repeater antenna.

Conclusion
A low-profile PIFA antenna with parasitic elements for onon-off WBAN repeater applications is proposed in this paper.By using the slot and the parasitic elements, the antenna on the phantom has a wide −10 dB reflection coefficient bandwidth of 0.76 GHz covering the 5.2 GHz WLAN band and the 5.8 GHz ISM band.The near surface radiation of the antenna is enhanced by the slot for the 5.8 GHz ISM band on-on body communication.In addition, the antenna mainly radiates towards the direction normal to the phantom surface at the 5.2 GHz WLAN band.Consequently, the proposed antenna is a promising candidate for on-on-off WBAN applications.

Figure 1 :
Figure 1: Configuration of the proposed antenna: (a) top view and (b) bottom view.

Figure 2 :
Figure 2: Simulation set-up of the proposed antenna on the phantom.

Figure 3 Figure 3 :Figure 4 :
Figure 3 shows the simulated reflection coefficients of the proposed antenna in air and on the phantom and those of the antenna without the slot.The proposed antenna has three resonances and a −10 dB reflection coefficient bandwidth of

Figure 5 :
Figure 5: Simulated electric field distributions on the ground plane of the proposed antenna: (a) 5.18 GHz and (b) 5.4 GHz.

Figure 6 Figure 6 :
Figure6illustrates the simulated reflection coefficients for various values of width .As the width  of the PIFA decreases slightly, the impedance matching of  1 and  2 deteriorates greatly.In contrast,  3 formed by the PIFA remains relatively unchanged.The reason why the reduction of  has an impact on  1 and  2 is that the electromagnetic coupling between the PIFA and the slot is affected substantially by the change in width of the PIFA.To achieve the wideband characteristic covering the 5.2 GHz WLAN band and the 5.8 GHz ISM band,  is chosen to be 10 mm.In Figure7, the simulated reflection coefficients for various values of gap distance  are shown.As  increases,  1 increases with the degraded impedance matching, which confirms that the resonance at  1 is formed by the two parasitic elements.Because  is the gap distance between

Figure 7 :
Figure 7: Simulated reflection coefficients for various values of gap distance .

Figure 8 :
Figure 8: Simulated reflection coefficients for various values of length .

Figure 9 :
Figure 9: Simulated reflection coefficients for various values of distance .

Figure 10 :
Figure 10: Manufactured prototype antenna: (a) top view and (b) bottom view.

Figure 11 :
Figure 11: Measurement set-up of the prototype antenna on the manufactured phantom.

Figure 12 :
Figure 12: Simulated and measured reflection coefficients of the proposed antenna.

Figure 14 :
Figure 14: Simulated average SAR distributions of the proposed antenna when placed on the human equivalent phantom (input power: 65 mW): (a) 5.18 GHz and (b) 5.77 GHz.

Figure 15 :Figure 16 :
Figure 15: Simulation set-up of the on-body to on-body communication link.

Table 1 :
Size comparison between previous repeater antennas and proposed antenna.