Early cancer detection has been playing an important role in reducing cancer mortality. Optical coherence tomography (OCT), due to its micron-scale resolution, has the ability to detect cancerous tissues at their early stages. For internal organs, endoscopic probes are needed as the penetration depth of OCT is about 1–3 mm. MEMS technology has the advantages of fast speed, small size, and low cost, and it has been widely used as the scanning engine in endoscopic OCT probes. Research results have shown great potential for OCT in endoscopic imaging by incorporating MEMS scanning mirrors. Various MEMS-OCT designs are introduced, and their imaging results are reviewed in the paper.
1. Introduction
Cancer has been one of the deadliest diseases in America and all around the world, killing over 7 million people each year [1]. To detect cancer at the stage when it is still curable has been found to be the most effective way to reduce its death rate. The traditional method for cancer detection is biopsy. It suffers from several drawbacks, such as long diagnosis time, random sample selection and invasiveness. Several noninvasive imaging methods have been employed for clinical use, including ultrasound, CT and MRI. But the resolutions of these modalities are on the order of 100 μm, not enough to resolve the precancerous lesions, which are normally 5 to 10 μm in size. Other issues involved with these methods are low contrast, high costs, and radiation problems.
Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is a relatively new optical imaging modality [2]. By using the short coherence length of a broadband light source, the resolution of OCT can reach 1 to 15 μm depending on the light source employed. The penetration depth of OCT is normally 1 to 3 mm, which is sufficient to image the depth of the epithelial layer, where most cancers are originated. In addition to that, OCT is an optical fiber-based system, and thus it is compact, portable, free of radiation, and affordable. Since its introduction in the early 1990s, it has been employed extensively in dermatology and ophthalmology [2–9]. It has also been used for imaging internal organs such as the GI tracts, bladders, and esophagus [10–19].
Figure 1 shows the schematic representation of a frequency domain OCT system. It employs a Michelson interferometer. The input light from a broadband frequency sweeping light source is divided into the reference arm and sample arm. The light beams on both arms are reflected back and form an interference signal at one port of the beam splitter. This interference signal is picked up by a photodetector and provides the depth information of the sample through inverse Fourier transform. And depth resolution is determined by the bandwidth of the light source. To realize 3D imaging, 2D lateral scan needs to be realized by a moving stage or a scanning mirror. One of the main challenges of imaging internal organs is to realize fast lateral scans in small endoscopes that must be able to fit into narrow lumens whose diameters typically are only a few millimeters. Several groups have attempted to solve this problem. Rotating a fiber-prism module at the distal end has been used to realize side view imaging [20]. Fiber bundle [21], rotating paired GRIN lenses [15], or swinging a fiber tip can be used for front view imaging [16–19, 22]. Galvanometric actuation [17], electroactive polymers [18], and piezoelectric cantilevers [19, 22] have all been used to swing fiber tips. When used at its resonance, a piezoelectric cantilever can scan fast enough to realize real time imaging [19]. However, several drawbacks are associated with these approaches. First, manipulating light beam at the distal fiber end limits the scan speed; second, for rotating optical components, the gears employed hinder further miniaturization of the probes; third, piezoelectric cantilevers have hysteresis problem, and when used at resonance, scan uniformity and coupling efficiency cannot be guaranteed, especially at large scan angles. As a result, an alternative technique, which is based on microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) technology, becomes popular.
OCT system schematic.
2. MEMS-Based OCT Endoscopic Imaging
MEMS technology is an enabling technology that makes devices and systems at the scale of micrometers to millimeters [23, 24]. MEMS sensors and actuators have been widely used in automotives for airbag deployment and in other consumer products, such as cell phones, projectors and video game controllers. Recently, MEMS technology has shown great potential in biomedical engineering especially for endoscopic imaging. There are several reasons. First, MEMS devices are small; therefore, miniaturization of the probes are possible. Second, MEMS scanners can operate at high speed for real-time imaging. Third, MEMS scanners are easy to integrate with the rest of the imaging system. Fourth, the cost of MEMS devices is low due to the mass production capability. Fifth, the power consumption is low for MEMS devices. The first MEMS-based OCT endoscope was introduced by Pan et al. employing a one-dimensional (1D) electrothermally actuated MEMS mirror [25]. Two-dimensional (2D) porcine bladder cross-sectional imaging was demonstrated. After that various forms of MEMS mirrors have been developed as the scanning engine in endoscopic probes for OCT systems.
Figure 2 illustrates the concept of MEMS-based front-view and side-view OCT probes, in which MEMS mirrors are placed at the distal ends of the probes, and their angular rotation directs the light and generates lateral scans on the sample. Combined with the OCT depth scan provided by the reference mirror scanning, 3D images can be obtained with 2D MEMS mirrors. Several features are highly desirable of MEMS mirrors for this application. Firstly, the footprint of the MEMS device must be small to fit into small endoscopes; secondly, the mirror aperture must be large and flat for easy optical alignment and high optical resolution; thirdly, the mirror must be able to scan large angles to realize large imaging area; fourthly, the driving voltage must be low to ensure safe use inside human body; finally, the linear control of the scan should be easily implemented to simplify signal processing and image interpretation. Single-crystal-silicon (SCS) or silicon-on-insulator (SOI) substrate can provide large flat and robust device microstructures, and thereby are predominantly used for making MEMS mirrors for endoscopic applications. There are four actuation mechanisms employed for generating the scanning for MEMS mirrors: electrostatic, electromagnetic, piezoelectric, and electrothermal. The following sections review OCT systems using MEMS mirrors driven by each of these mechanisms.
3. Various MEMS OCT3.1. Electrostatic MEMS Mirrors
Electrostatic actuation has been one of the most popular choices for MEMS mirrors. Electrostatic actuation is based on electrostatic force which exists between electrically charged particles. The first MEMS mirror based on this principle was demonstrated by Petersen in 1980 [26]. By employing a parallel-plate structure, the maximum rational angle of the micromirror reached ±2° at resonance and 300 V driving voltage. This parallel-plate structure has been adopted by many other researchers and rotation angles as large as ±8° have been achieved with lower driving voltages in the range of 40 V to 200 V, but the reported mirror aperture diameters are normally smaller than 500 μm [27–34]. What limits this structure from realizing larger scan angle is the pull-in effect. To overcome this problem, vertical comb drive actuation structures were employed [35–40]. The vertical or angular displacement of the comb drives is converted into mirror tilting through a torsional beam which supports the mirror plate. Mirror aperture size as large as 1.5 mm × 1.5 mm has been reported based on this structure [36]. Both 1D and 2D micromirrors have been realized using this structure, and the mechanical deflection angle has reached ±5.5° at only 16 V resonance [36] and ±6.2° at 55 V resonance [37]. For 2D mirrors, two gimbals are used to support the mirror plate in orthogonal directions. To further increase scan angles, Milanović et al. proposed a new gimbal-less SOI-based micromirror [38], the static optical deflection for both axes are increased to ~ ±10° with ~150 V driving voltage.
A series of endoscopic OCT probes employing electrostatic micromirrors have been reported by Jung and McCormick [41, 42]. Figure 3(a) shows the SEMs of two of the MEMS mirrors they reported. The one on the left has a 1 mm × 1 mm mirror size on a 2.8 mm × 3.3 mm footprint, while the one on the right has a mirror aperture diameter of 800 μm. The devices employed 2D gimbal-less vertical comb structures. The mirror plate and actuators are fabricated separately and then bonded together. Optical scanning angles of the mirrors can reach 20° at resonance when a 100 V driving voltage is applied. Resonant frequencies as high as 2.4 kHz and 1.9 kHz on two axes have been reported. Electrical connection was done through wire bonding, and injection mold was used for probe body. The diameters of the endoscopic probes range from 3.9 mm to 5.0 mm. 3D in vivo OCT images of healthy rabbit rectal tissue have been obtained at 8 frames/sec. The image volume size is 1 mm × 1 mm × 1.4 mm, and the resolution of the image is 20 μm × 20 μm × 10 μm. Important tissue structures can be clearly seen here.
Electrostatic MEMS OCT from UC-Irvine/UC-Berkeley. (a) SEMs of two MEMS mirrors, (b) Electrical connection through wire bonding, (c) packaged MEMS probe, (d) 3D image of rabbit rectal tissue.
Reprinted with permission from (W. Jung, et al; “Three-dimensional endoscopic optical coherence tomography by use of a two-axis microelectromechanical scanning mirror,” Applied Physics Letters, vol. 88-163901, pp. 1–3, 2006). Copyright (2006), American Institute of Physics
Aguirre et al. from MIT have also reported an electrostatic MEMS mirror-based endoscopic OCT probe [43]. In their paper, they demonstrated a gimbaled 2D MEMS mirror design based on angular vertical comb actuators, which allows larger scan angles compared to other vertical comb drives with the same dimensions. The mirror has a circular aperture, whose diameter is 1 mm and the device footprint is 3 × 3 mm2, as shown in Figure 4(a). Mechanical scan angles of ±6° have been achieved on both axes at more than 100 V. The reported a side-view probe with an aluminum holder housing the MEMS mirror. The probe has a diameter of about 5 mm. The optical components packaged inside the probe include a fiber, a GRIN lens and a small achromatic lens (Figure 4(b)). Incorporated in a spectral domain OCT, the probe scans at 4 frames/sec over the range of 1.8 mm × 1.0 mm × 1.3 mm. 3D hamster cheek pouch images have been obtained to demonstrate the capability of the probe.
Electrostatic MEMS OCT from MIT. (a) SEMs of the MEMS mirror with angled vertical comb (AVC) actuators. (b) design and packaging of the probe. SMF, single mode fiber. FC, fiber collimator. AL, aluminum. (c) 3D image of hamster cheek pouch. Reprint permission granted by OSA.
As is shown in Figure 3(b), the probe size is limited by the footprint of the MEMS mirror. For electrostatic mirrors, much space of the device is taken by the comb drive actuators. This results in a small ratio of the mirror aperture size to the device footprint size, or small fill-factor for electrostatic mirrors, which may limit further miniaturization of endoscopic probes. High resonant frequencies make them ideal for fast scanning applications, but working at resonance can cause nonlinear scan. High driving voltage required may also be a concern for endoscopic applications.
3.2. Electromagnetic MEMS Mirrors
To further increase the scanning range and lower the driving voltage, electromagnetic mirrors are also explored for endoscopic OCT applications. Electromagnetic actuation is based on Lorentz force, and larger driving force can be realized with lower driving voltage. By controlling the current flowing direction, both repulsive and attractive driving force can be realized [44]. The magnetic field for electromagnetic actuation is normally generated by permalloy [44–46] or active electric coils [44, 47, 48]. A 1D micromirror with over 60° deflection angles has been reported by Miller and Tai [44]. A 2D micromirror with a mirror plate as large as 3.5 mm × 3.5 mm has been demonstrated, and, with a 20 mA driving current at its 2 kHz resonance, the mirror scan angle can reach ±1.51°, and the movable frame can scan ±5.71° [49]. Yang et al. proposed a coilless design, in which the optical scan angle can reach 20° with a 2 mm × 2 mm mirror plate when the mirror is operated at an input power of 9 mW [50].
Kim et al. demonstrated a 2D electromagnetic MEMS mirror based endoscopic OCT probe [51]. A 2D gimbaled mirror design was employed. A permanent magnet was glued to the backside of the mirror plate, and wire-wound coils were placed inside the probe body for each scan direction. The mirror plate was 0.6 mm × 0.8 mm and the device footprint was 2.4 mm × 2.9 mm, as shown in Figure 5. About ±30° optical scan angle was obtained with ±1.2 V and ±4 V driving voltages for the inner and outer axis, corresponding to 50 mA and 100 mA current respectively. A probe with a 2.8 mm diameter and 12 mm length has been demonstrated with SD-OCT. 3D images of finger tips were obtained at 18.5 frames/s. ±2.8 V and ±0.8 V voltages were applied on the inner and outer axis, covering 1.5 mm × 1 mm lateral scan range and consuming a 150 mW power in total.
Electromagnetic MEMS OCT reported by Kim et al. (a) (b)SEMs of the MEMS mirror, (c) (d)design and packaging of the probe, (e) (f) 3D image of finger tip. Reprint permission granted by OSA.
Watanabe et al. have recently demonstrated another electromagnetic MEMS OCT probe [52]. The fabricated mirror module is shown in Figure 6. The mirror plate size is 1.8 × 1.8 mm2, and the device chip is as large as 10 × 10 × 0.2 mm3 due to the large electrical coil required. The entire device was placed on a 15 mm × 15 mm × 1 mm PCB, which is fixed on the holder with a magnet inside. The MEMS mirror was used in a Fourier domain OCT and 3D human finger images were obtained.
Electromagnetic MEMS OCT from Yamagata Research Institute of Technology, Japan. (a) MEMS mirror module, (b) MEMS probe in OCT system, (c) 3D image of human finger tip. All rights reserved by the Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan.
One of the drawbacks of electromagnetic mirrors for endoscopic application is its high power consumption. The other drawbacks lie in the fact that external magnets are required for actuation, which not only greatly complicates the packaging process, but also constraints the further miniaturization of the probes. Electromagnetic interference is also a concern.
3.3. Piezoelectric MEMS Mirrors
Piezoelectric actuation has also attracted some attention. It takes advantage of the piezoelectric effect and realizes bending motion by applying electric field across a piezoelectric material such as lead zirconate titanate (PZT). The advantages of piezoelectric actuation include fast response, large bandwidth, and low power consumption. Piezoelectric actuators are usually composed of metal/PZT/metal sandwich [53–56] or double layered PZT materials [57]. Scanning angles as large as 40° have been reported, using voltages up to 13 V [58].
A piezoelectric MEMS based OCT probe has also been reported [59]. Piezoelectric MEMS mirrors with aperture sizes of 600 μm × 840 μm and 840 μm × 1600 μm have been fabricated. Mechanical scan angles up to ±7° and resonant frequency up to 1 kHz were measured for the mirrors. A prove-of-concept probe design is shown in Figure 7(b). The 600 μm × 840 μm mirror was used in an FD-OCT system to demonstrate its imaging capability, and a 2D image (Figure 7(c)) of an IR card was obtained.
Piezoelectric MEMS OCT reported by Gilchrist et al. (a) SEM of MEMS mirror, (b) 3D MEMS probe design, (c) 2D image of IR card. Reprint permission granted by IOP.
However, the mirrors are only one dimensional and two mirrors scanning at orthogonal directions are required for 3D imaging. Also, the large initial tilt angle will complicate optical alignment and probe packaging. Furthermore, for piezoelectric MEMS mirrors to be used for in vivo OCT imaging applications, charge leakage problems and hysteresis effect still need to be overcome.
3.4. Electrothermal MEMS Mirrors
Electrothermal actuation is studied to further increase the scanning range at low driving voltage. Electrothermal actuation can be realized by using bimorph beams. A bimorph beam is formed by two layers of materials with different thermal expansion coefficients. The bending motion of the beam is induced by the expansion difference of the two materials in response to a temperature change. The actuation force typically is larger than that of electrostatic or electromagnetic actuation. Electrothermal micromirrors also have almost linear response between the scan angle and applied voltage, simple structure design, and easy fabrication. One of the most important features of electrothermal mirrors is the high fill factor. For the same mirror aperture size, the device can be smaller, which is crucial for making smaller endoscopic probes. Different materials have been explored for bimorph beams [60–67], including silicon (Si), various metals, such as aluminum (Al), polymers, and dielectrics. The most popular choice is Al and SiO2. It was first demonstrated by Bühler et al. in 1995 [61]. Then, Jain et al. demonstrated 2D micromirrors based on Al/SiO2 bimorph beams and polysilicon as the heating material with rotation angle up to 40° on a 1 × 1 mm2 mirror plate at 15 V [68].
Electrothermal actuation was the first of the four actuation mechanisms to be used in endoscopic OCT imaging [25, 69]. Xie et al. reported a 1D SCS MEMS mirror. The mirror aperture size was 1 mm × 1 mm, and 17° rotation angle and 165 Hz resonance frequency were measured. A forward-looking probe was demonstrated and applied for in vivo imaging of porcine urinary bladders. A 5 frames/s imaging speed was achieved, while the imaging area covered was 2.9 mm × 2.8 mm. Due to the mesh actuator design employed, a 10° scan discontinuity was observed. Later in 2003, the actuator design was improved by replacing it with a paralleled actuator beam structure, resulting in continuous angular scanning with the scan angle increased to 37° [70]. 2D ex vivo imaging of a rabbit bladder, as shown in Figure 8(e), was obtained to demonstrate the probe capability.
Electrothermal MEMS OCT reported by Pan et al. (a) SEM of 1D MEMS mirror, (b) meshed actuator structure, (c) parallel beam structure, (d) OCT system with forward looking endoscopic probe design, and (e) 2D OCT image of rabbit bladder.
More recently, Xu et al. also reported an electrothermal actuation-based MEMS OCT probe [71–74]. They have demonstrated a series of MEMS mirrors with both straight and curled shaped electrothermal bimorph actuators formed by Aluminum and Silicon. The largest mechanical deflection reported was 17° at an operation voltage of ~1.3 V [71]. The device has a 500 μm diameter mirror aperture on top of a 1.5 mm × 1.5 mm chip. The mirror showed good linearity between driving voltage and scan angle after the initial critical voltage, and the 3 dB cutoff frequency was 46 Hz. The probe assembly was based on silicon optical bench (SiOB) methodology for self-alignment of the optical components, and the electrical connection from the MEMS mirror to the copper wires on the substrate was made through solder balls. The probe was then inserted into a transparent housing. The diameter of the probe was less than 4 mm, and the rigid length was about 25 mm. The probe was used in a swept source OCT system at a frame rate of 21.5 frames/sec for 3D imaging, and the imaging results of an IR card were shown in Figure 9(c).
Electrothermal MEMS OCT reported by Xu et al. (a) two-axis electrothermal MEMS mirror, (b) probe design and assembly demonstration, and (c) 2D and 3D OCT image of an IR card. Reprint permission granted by IOP.
The authors have also reported a series of electrothermal MEMS mirror-based 3D endoscopic OCT probe [75–77]. In these MEMS mirrors, Al/SiO2 bimorph beams are employed with platinum as the heating material. The actuators are designed in a folded fashion and symmetrically placed on four sides of the mirror plate to reduce the actuator space and realize lateral shift free scan motion. In one design, as shown in Figure 10(a) the mirror plate is 1 mm × 1 mm and the device footprint is 2 mm × 2 mm, resulting in a 25% fill factor. The scanning angle of the mirror reaches ±30° at only 5.5 V. Electrical connection was made through wire bonding. By using rigid or flexible PCB, two probe designs with respective outer diameters of 5 mm (Figures 10(b) and 10(c)) and 2.7 mm (Figures 10(d) and 10(e)) have been demonstrated. 3D imaging was demonstrated with a time-domain OCT system at 2.5 frames/s. The image shown in Figure 10(f) is of a mouse ear obtained using the 5 mm probe, and the image volume is 2.3 × 2.3 × 1.6 mm3.
Electrothermal MEMS OCT reported by Sun et al. (a) SEM of electrothermal MEMS mirror, (b) 5 mm probe 3D model, (c) 5 mm assembled probe, (d) 2.7 mm probe 3D model, (d) 2.7 mm assembled probe, (f) 3D OCT image of mouse ear obtained by 5 mm probe shown in (b) and (c).
A newer MEMS mirror design has been developed to improve the probe assembling. As shown in Figure 11(a), the mirror device has through-silicon vias (TSVs) for electrical connections [77]. Four metal pads are located next to the TSVs. As shown in Figure 11(b), copper wires carrying control signals come from the backside of the probe, pass through the TSVs, and then are connected to the pads using silver epoxy. This wire-bonding free design simplifies the assembly process, and enables a larger fill factor. The size of the mirror plate is 0.8 mm × 0.8 mm and the device footprint is 1.5 mm × 1.5 mm, giving a fill factor of 28.4%. A 16° optical scan angle was measured at only 3.6 V DC. The packaged probe size is 2.6 mm. 2D and 3D imaging of microspheres embedded in PDMS was obtained, as shown in Figure 11(c).
Electrothermal MEMS OCT reported by Liu et al. (a) SEM and schematic of through vias electrothermal MEMS mirror, (b) 2.6 mm probe 3D model and assembled probe, and (c) 2D and 3D OCT image of microsphere embedded in PDMS. Reprint permission granted by SPIE.
4. Summary
Of the four actuation mechanisms, electrostatic actuation has fast response and lowest power consumption, but it requires large driving voltage which may not be safe for imaging human internal organs. Electromagnetic actuation can realize large scan angle, at low driving voltage, but the permanent magnet required poses difficulties for further probe miniaturization. Piezoelectric MEMS mirrors can also be fast and consume low power, but it must overcome the large initial tilting issues, the hysteresis effect and charge leakage problem for OCT imaging applications. Electrothermal actuation can scan large angles at low driving voltages, and it also has the largest fill factor compared to all three other kinds of MEMS mirrors. Thermal response is relatively slow, but it is capable to realize real-time imaging. Overall, electrothermal MEMS mirrors are the better choice for endoscopic OCT scanners. In the future, for endoscopic imaging applications, the fill factor of MEMS mirrors still need to be increased and better packaging schemes must be designed. Combining MEMS technology with OCT to realize real time in vivo endoscopic 3D imaging has shown great potential. The clinical application of this technology for early cancer detection of internal organs will benefit millions of people worldwide.
American Cancer Society2010Atlanta, Ga, USAAmerican Cancer SocietyHuangD.SwansonE. A.LinC. P.SchumanJ. S.StinsonW. G.ChangW.HeeM. R.FlotteT.GregoryK.PuliafitoC. A.FujimotoJ. G.Optical coherence tomography19912545035117811812-s2.0-0026254046PuliafitoC. A.HeeM. R.LinC. P.ReichelE.SchumanJ. S.DukerJ. S.IzattJ. A.SwansonE. A.FujimotoJ. G.Imaging of macular diseases with optical coherence tomography199510222172292-s2.0-0028883206SchumanJ. S.HeeM. R.AryaA. V.Pedut-KloizmanT.PuliafitoC. A.FujimotoJ. G.SwansonE. A.Optical coherence tomography: a new tool for glaucoma diagnosis19956289952-s2.0-0028914826FujimotoJ. G.Optical coherence tomography for ultrahigh resolution in vivo imaging20032111136113672-s2.0-024232253210.1038/nbt892SwansonE. A.HuangD.HeeM. R.FujimotoJ. G.LinC. P.PuliafitoC. A.High-speed optical coherence domain reflectometry199217151153WelzelJ.Optical coherence tomography in dermatology: a review200171192-s2.0-003518838110.1034/j.1600-0846.2001.007001001.xParkB. H.SaxerC.SrinivasS. M.NelsonJ. S.De BoerJ. F.In vivo burn depth determination by high-speed fiber-based polarization sensitive optical coherence tomography2001644744792-s2.0-003547099110.1117/1.1413208PierceM. C.SheridanR. L.Hyle ParkB.CenseB.De BoerJ. F.Collagen denaturation can be quantified in burned human skin using polarization-sensitive optical coherence tomography20043065115172-s2.0-414308065710.1016/j.burns.2004.02.004SivakM. V.KobayashiK.IzattJ. A.RollinsA. M.Ung-runyaweeR.ChakA.WongR. C. K.IsenbergG. A.WillisJ.High-resolution endoscopic imaging of the GI tract using optical coherence tomography20005144744792-s2.0-0034032747JackleS.GladkovaN.FeldchteinF.TerentievaA.BrandB.GelikonovG.GelikonovV.SergeevA.Fritscher-RavensA.FreundJ.SeitzU.SchroderS.SoehendraN.In vivo endoscopic optical coherence tomography of esophagitis, Barrett's esophagus, and adenocarcinoma of the esophagus200032107507552-s2.0-003381909410.1055/s-2000-7705LiX. D.BoppartS. A.Van DamJ.MashimoH.MutingaM.DrexlerW.KleinM.PitrisC.KrinskyM. L.BrezinskiM. E.FujimotoJ. G.Optical coherence tomography: advanced technology for the endoscopic imaging of Barrett's esophagus200032129219302-s2.0-003367457410.1055/s-2000-9626PonerosJ. M.BrandS.BoumaB. E.TearneyG. J.ComptonC. C.NishiokaN. S.Diagnosis of specialized intestinal metaplasia by optical coherence tomography200112017122-s2.0-0035173098TearneyG. J.BrezinskiM. E.BoumaB. E.BoppartS. A.PitrisC.SouthernJ. F.FujimotoJ. G.In vivo endoscopic optical biopsy with optical coherence tomography19972765321203720392-s2.0-003076030910.1126/science.276.5321.2037WuJ.ConryM.GuC.WangF.YaqoobZ.YangC.Paired-angle-rotation scanning optical coherence tomography forward-imaging probe2006319126512672-s2.0-3374515613210.1364/OL.31.001265WuT.DingZ.WangK.ChenM.WangC.Two-dimensional scanning realized by an asymmetry fiber cantilever driven by single piezo bender actuator for optical coherence tomography2009171613819138292-s2.0-6834913344310.1364/OE.17.013819SergeevA. M.GelikonovV. M.GelikonovG. V.FeldchteinF. I.KuranovR. V.GladkovaN. D.ShakhovaN. M.SnopovaL. B.ShakhovA. V.KuznetzovaI. A.DenisenkoA. N.PochinkoV. V.ChumakovY. P.StreltzovaO. S.In vivo endoscopic OCT imaging of precancer and cancer states of human mucosa19971134324402-s2.0-0000632632WangY.BachmanM.LiG. P.GuoS.WongB. J. F.ChenZ.Low-voltage polymer-based scanning cantilever for in vivo optical coherence tomography200530153552-s2.0-1234426887810.1364/OL.30.000053LiuX.CobbM. J.ChenY.KimmeyM. B.LiX.Rapid-scanning forward-imaging miniature endoscope for real-time optical coherence tomography20042915176317652-s2.0-394311362410.1364/OL.29.001763FuH. L.LengY.CobbM. J.HsuK.HwangJ. H.LiX.Flexible miniature compound lens design for high-resolution optical coherence tomography balloon imaging catheter20081360605022-s2.0-6244915093510.1117/1.3037340XieT.MukaiD.GuoS.BrennerM.ChenZ.Fiber-optic-bundle-based optical coherence tomography20053014180318052-s2.0-23144433829BoppartS. A.BoumaB. E.PitrisC.TearneyG. J.FujimotoJ. G.BrezinskiM. E.Forward-imaging instruments for optical coherence tomography19972221161816202-s2.0-0000063299BustjlloJ. M.HoweR. T.MullerR. S.Surface micromachining for microelectromechanical systems1998868155215732-s2.0-0032138470KovacsG. T. A.MalufN. I.PetersenK. E.Bulk micromachining of silicon1998868153615512-s2.0-0032139387PanY.XieH.FedderG. K.Endoscopic optical coherence tomography based on a microelectromechanical mirror20012624196619682-s2.0-0001352717PetersenK. E.Silicon torsional scanning mirror19802456316372-s2.0-0019063742FanL.WuM. C.Two-dimensional optical scanner with large angular rotation realized by self-assembled micro-elevatorProceedings of the IEEE/LEOS Summer Topical MeetingJuly 19981071082-s2.0-0031629145SuG. D. J.ToshiyoshiH.WuM. C.Surface-micromachined 2-D optical scanners with high-performance single-crystalline silicon micromirrors20011366066082-s2.0-003536273810.1109/68.924038GreywallD. S.PaiC. S.OhS. H.ChangC. P.MaromD. M.BuschP. A.CirelliR. A.TaylorJ. A.KlemensF. P.SorschT. W.BowerJ. E.LaiW. Y. C.SohH. T.Monolithic fringe-field-activated crystalline silicon tilting-mirror devices20031257027072-s2.0-024272076910.1109/JMEMS.2003.818068GreywallD. S.BuschP. A.PardoF.CarrD. W.BogartG.SohH. T.Crystalline silicon tilting mirrors for optical cross-connect switches20031257087122-s2.0-024265939610.1109/JMEMS.2003.818067HaoZ.WingfieldB.WhitleyM.BrooksJ.HammerJ. A.A design methodology for a bulk-micromachined two-dimensional electrostatic torsion micromirror20031256927012-s2.0-024240614810.1109/JMEMS.2003.817888ChiouJ. C.LinY. C.A multiple electrostatic electrodes torsion micromirror device with linear stepping angle effect20031269139202-s2.0-074228671210.1109/JMEMS.2003.820287DokmeciM. R.PareekA.BakshiS.WaeltiM.FungC. D.HengK. H.MastrangeloC. H.Two-axis single-crystal silicon micromirror arrays2004136100610172-s2.0-1094423392710.1109/JMEMS.2004.839812JoudreyK.AdamsG. G.McGruerN. E.Design, modeling, fabrication and testing of a high aspect ratio electrostatic torsional MEMS micromirror20061610214721562-s2.0-3374876470010.1088/0960-1317/16/10/031ConantR. A.NeeJ. T.LauK. Y.MullerR. S.A flat high-frequency scanning micromirrorProceedings of the Hilton Head Solid-State Sensor and Actuator Workshop200069SchenkH.DunP.KunzeD.LaherH.KiickH.An electrostatically excited 2D micro-scanning-mirror with an in-plane configuration of the driving electrodesProceedings of the 13th IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS '00)January 2000Miyazaki, JapanPiyawattanamethaW.PattersonP. R.HahD.ToshiyoshiH.WuM. C.Surface- and bulk-micromachined two-dimensional scanner driven by angular vertical comb actuators2005146132913382-s2.0-2924448875310.1109/JMEMS.2005.859073MilanovićV.MatusG. A.McCormickD. T.Gimbal-less monolithic silicon actuators for tip-tilt-piston micromirror applications20041034624712-s2.0-434471848510.1109/JSTQE.2004.829205XieH.PanY.FedderG. K.A CMOS-MEMS mirror with curled-hinge comb drives20031244504572-s2.0-004138610910.1109/JMEMS.2003.815839PattersonP. R.HahD.NguyenH.ToshiyoshiH.ChaoR. M.WuM. C.A scanning micromirror with angular comb drive actuationProceedings of the 15th IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS '02)January 2002Las Vegas, Nev, USA5445472-s2.0-0036118040JungW.McCormickD. T.ZhangJ.WangL.TienN. C.ChenZ.Three-dimensional endoscopic optical coherence tomography by use of a two-axis microelectromechanical scanning mirror2006881632-s2.0-3364620489810.1063/1.2195092163901McCormickD. T.JungW.AhnY. C.ChenZ.TienN. C.A three dimensional real-time MEMS based optical biopsy system for in-vivo clinical imagingProceedings of the 4th International Conference on Solid-State Sensors, Actuators and Microsystems (TRANSDUCERS '07)June 20072032082-s2.0-5004911302810.1109/SENSOR.2007.4300106AguirreA. D.HerzP. R.ChenY.FujimotoJ. G.PiyawattanamethaW.FanL.WuM. C.Two-axis MEMS scanning catheter for ultrahigh resolution three-dimensional and En Face imaging2007155244524532-s2.0-3384774379710.1364/OE.15.002445MillerR. A.TaiY. C.Micromachined electromagnetic scanning mirrors1997365139914072-s2.0-0001272349YalcinkayaA. D.arda.yalcinkaya@boun.edu.trUreyH.hurey@ku.edu.trHolmstromS.NiFe plated biaxial magnetostatic MEMS scannerProceedings of the 14th IEEE International Conference on Solid-State Sensors, Actuators and Microsystems (Transducers '07)June 2007Lyon, France1517152010.1109/SENSOR.2007.4300433JudyJ. W.MullerR. S.Magnetically actuated, addressable microstructures1997632492552-s2.0-0031237318ChoI. J.YunK. S.LeeH. K.YoonJ. B.YoonE.A low-voltage two-axis electromagnetically actuated micromirror with bulk silicon mirror plates and torsion barsProceedings of the 15th IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS '02)January 2002Las Vegas, Nev, USA5405432-s2.0-0036118156BernsteinJ. J.TaylorW. P.BrazzleJ. D.CorcoranC. J.KirkosG.OdhnerJ. E.PareekA.WaeltiM.ZaiM.Electromagnetically actuated mirror arrays for use in 3-D optical switching applications20041335265352-s2.0-314273576210.1109/JMEMS.2004.828705AhnSI. H.KimY. K.Silicon scanning mirror of two DOF with compensation current routing20041411145514612-s2.0-964428927710.1088/0960-1317/14/11/004YangH. A.TangT. L.LeeS. T.FangW.A novel coilless scanning mirror using Eddy current Lorentz force and magnetostatic force20071635115202-s2.0-3454777276710.1109/JMEMS.2007.896708KimK. H.ParkB. H.MaguluriG. N.LeeT. W.RogomentichF. J.BancuM. G.BoumaB. E.De BoerJ. F.BernsteinJ. J.Two-axis magnetically-driven MEMS scanning catheter for endoscopic high-speed optical coherence tomography2007152618130181402-s2.0-3754899983910.1364/OE.15.018130WatanabeY.watanabeyoshiy@pref.yamagata.jpAbeY.IwamatsuS.KobayashiS.TakahashiY.SatoT.Electromagnetically driven 2-axis optical beam steering MEMS mirror and its dependence of actuation on magnetic field20101304107112KawabataT.IkedaM.GotoH.MatsumotoM.YadaT.2-dimensional micro scanner integrated with PZT thin film actuatorProceedings of the International Conference on Solid-State Sensors and Actuators (Transducers '97)June 1997Chicago,Ill, USA3393422-s2.0-0030691573NamH.-J.KimY.-S.ChoS.-M.YeeY.BuJ.-U.Low voltage PZT actuated tilting micromirror with hinge structureProceedings of the IEEE/LEOS International Conference on Optical MEMSAugust 2002Lugano, SwitzerlandKikuchiN.HagaY.MaedaM.MakishiW.EsashiM.Piezoelectric 2-D micro scanner for minimally invasive therapy fabricated using femtosecond laser ablationProceedings of the 12th International Conference on Solid State Sensors, Actuators and Microsystems (Transducersv '03)June 2003Boston, Mass, USAYeeY.BuJ. U.HaM.Fabrication and characterization of a PZT actuated micromirror with two-axis rotational motion for free space opticsProceedings of the 14th IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS '01)January 2001Interlaken, SwitzerlandTsaurJ.ZhangL.MaedaR.MatsumotoS.2D micro scanner actuated by sol-gel derived double layered PZTProceedings of the 15th IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS '02)January 2002Las Vegas, Nev, USA5485512-s2.0-0036124177SmitsJ. G.FujimotoK.KleptsynV. F.Microelectromechanical flexure PZT actuated optical scanner: static and resonance behavior2005156128512932-s2.0-1874438581710.1088/0960-1317/15/6/021GilchristK. H.McNabbR. P.IzattJ. A.GregoS.Piezoelectric scanning mirrors for endoscopic optical coherence tomography20091992-s2.0-7035063935010.1088/0960-1317/19/9/095012095012BuserR. A.de RooijN. F.TischhauserH.DommannA.StaufertG.Biaxial scanning mirror activated by bimorph structures for medical applications1992311–329342-s2.0-0026839301BühlerJ.FunkJ.PaulO.SteinerF. P.BaltesH.Thermally actuated CMOS micromirrors1995471–35725752-s2.0-0029272594MotamediM. E.ParkS.WangA.DadkhahM. S.AndrewsA. P.MarcyH. O.KhoshnevisanM.ChiouA. E.HuhnR. J.SellC. F.SmitsJ. G.Development of micro-electro-mechanical optical scanner1997365134613532-s2.0-6944238574AtakaM.OmodakaA.TakeshimaN.FujitaH.Fabrication and operation of polyimide bimorph actuators for a ciliary motion system1993241461502-s2.0-002787624810.1109/84.273089LinG.KimC.-J.KonishiS.FujitaH.Design, fabrication, and testing of A C shape actuatorProceedings of the 8th International Conference on Solid-State Sensors and Actuators (Transducers '95 and Eurosensors)June 1995Stockholm, SwedenSchweizerS.CalmesS.LaudonM.RenaudPH.Thermally actuated optical microscanner with large angle and low consumption1999761–34704772-s2.0-034302240510.1016/S0924-4247(99)00012-6LiuQ.HuangQ. A.Micro-electro-mechanical digital-to-analog converter based on a novel bimorph thermal actuatorProceedings of the 1st IEEE International Conference on SensorsJune 2002Orlando, Fla, USA103610412-s2.0-1542331484SinclairM.A high frequency resonant scanner using thermal actuatorProceedings of the 15th IEEE International Conference on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEMS '02)January 2002Las Vegas, Nev, USAJainA.KopaA.PanY.FeederG. K.XieH.A two-axis electrothermal micromirror for endoscopic optical coherence tomography20041036366422-s2.0-434456579010.1109/JSTQE.2004.829194XieH.hkxie@ece.ufl.eduPanY.FedderG. K.fedder@ece.cmu.eduEndoscopic optical coherence tomographic imaging with a CMOS-MEMS micromirror20031031-223724110.1016/S0924-4247(02)00347-3XieT.XieH.FedderG. K.PanY.Endoscopic optical coherence tomography with new MEMS mirror20033921153515362-s2.0-014224759610.1049/el:20030998XuY.SinghJ.PremachandranC. S.KhairyantoA.ChenK. W. S.ChenN.SheppardC. J. R.OlivoM.Design and development of a 3D scanning MEMS OCT probe using a novel SiOB package assembly200818122-s2.0-5814935228710.1088/0960-1317/18/12/125005125005SinghJ.TeoJ. H. S.XuY.PremachandranC. S.ChenN.KotlankaR.OlivoM.SheppardC. J. R.A two axes scanning SOI MEMS micromirror for endoscopic bioimaging20081822-s2.0-4254914389910.1088/0960-1317/18/2/025001025001MuX. J.ZhouG. Y.FengH. H.A 3mm endoscopic probe with integrated MEMS micromirror for optical coherence tomography bioimaging, Procedia Engineering5Proceedings of the 24th Eurosensor Conference2010681684WangM.XuY.PremC. S.Microfabricated endoscopic probe integrated MEMS micromirror for optical coherence tomography bioimagingProceedings of the IEEE Annual International Conference on Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC '10)August-September 20105760SunJ.GuoS.WuL.LiuL.ChoeSE. W.SorgB. S.XieH.3D in vivo optical coherence tomography based on a low-voltage, large-scan-range 2D MEMS mirror2010181212065120752-s2.0-7795354860610.1364/OE.18.012065XieH.SunJ.WuL.Optical micro-endoscopes for 3D in-vivo imagingProceedings of the Electrothermal Micromirrors and a Flexible Printed Circuit Board Permit Fast, Small Optical Coherence Tomography of Internal OrgansFebruary 2010SPIE Newsroom10.1117/2.1201002.002555LiuL.linliu86@ufl.eduWuL.SunJ.LinE.XieH.Miniature endoscopic optical coherence tomography probe employing a two-axis microelectromechanical scanning mirror with through-silicon vias201116210.1117/1.3533323