Journal of Environmental and Public Health
Volume 2019 (2019), Article ID 7074959, 6 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2019/7074959

Research Article

Disposal Practice of Unfit Medicines in Nongovernmental Hospitals and Private Medicine Outlets Located in Mwanza, Tanzania

Stanley Mwita,¹ Godfrey Ngonela,² and Deogratias Katabalo¹

¹School of Pharmacy, Catholic University of Health and Allied Sciences (CUHAS), P.O. Box 1464, Mwanza, Tanzania
²Shinyanga Regional Referral Hospital, P.O. Box 17, Shinyanga, Tanzania

Correspondence should be addressed to Stanley Mwita; stanleymwita@gmail.com

Received 10 October 2018; Revised 18 January 2019; Accepted 12 February 2019; Published 3 March 2019

Academic Editor: Stefano Capolongo

Copyright © 2019 Stanley Mwita et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract.

Introduction. For a medicine to qualify as safe and effective and to be of good quality, it should be properly labelled, stored, and transported. If a medicine is not handled properly, it ends up being unfit. Improper disposal of unfit medicines contributes to the appearance of their metabolites in the environment. Methods. A descriptive cross-sectional study was designed to capture quantitative data. The study was conducted in Mwanza region, Tanzania. The study population comprised nongovernmental hospitals and private medicines outlets in the region. The sample size was 111 facilities. This study was conducted between October 2013 and May 2014. The questionnaire was used to assess experience and challenges of dealing with unfit medicines. A review of waste management records was done to capture data of past disposal for unfit medicines. The coded data were analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (Version 20.0) computer analysis software. Comparison of proportions between groups was performed using Pearson’s chi square. Results. The majority of facilities (41.4%) used methods such as the pouring of unfit medicines into the sink and into the dustbin. About 60.4% of facilities were found with unfit medicines at the time of survey. Majority of unfit medicines found were antibiotics (64.1%). Almost 10% of health facilities maintained a register book for recording unfit medicines. Conclusion. There was improper disposal of unfit medicines in health facilities studied, whereby commonly reported methods of disposal were pouring into the sink and putting into the street dustbin. In private medicines outlets, there was poor storage management practice as some of the unfit medicines were left unpacked into boxes or separated from the usable medicines and not properly labelled.

1. Introduction

Medicines are commonly used by the healthcare system to diagnose, treat, or prevent illnesses. Because of their importance in improving public health services, regulatory processes concerning their quality are necessary to ensure that intended treatment outcomes are met. For a medicine to qualify as safe and effective and to be of good quality, it should be properly labelled, stored, and transported. If a medicine is not handled properly, it ends up being unfit. Healthcare activities generate significant amounts of medical wastes such as unfit medicines. The management of medical waste is an integral part of a national healthcare system [1].

According to the Tanzania Food and Drugs Authority (TFDA) Guidelines for safe disposal of unfit medicines and cosmetic products, medicines are considered unfit when they are expired, improperly sealed, damaged, improperly stored, improperly labelled, counterfeit, substandard, adulterated, prohibited, and unauthorized [2].

Improper disposal of unfit medicines contributes to the appearance of their metabolites in the environment [3]. Traces of pharmaceutical residues have consistently been detected in effluents from sewerage facilities, surface water, and drinking water [4–7]. The rate of medical waste generation is high, about 2,250 kg/day to 2,500 kg/day [8]. Controlled high-temperature incineration is the appropriate disposal method process rather than open pit burning or burying [9, 10]; however, the main disposal methods for unfit medicines in health facilities (HF) comprises open pit burning (48%), burying (29%), and incomplete low-temperature incineration (19%) [11, 12]. Open pit burning and uncontrolled incomplete incineration emit toxic air pollutants and toxic ash residues that are the major source of dioxins in the environment [13]. During incineration, if no proper filtering of flue gases is done, air can be polluted causing airborne illnesses to the nearby populations [14]. Dumping of healthcare waste in the uncontrolled areas can have a direct environmental effect by contaminating soils and underground water [15].

The absence of proper management of medical wastes such as unfit medicines and poor control of their disposal is the most critical problems connected with medical wastes [16]. In many countries, medical wastes are still handled and disposed off together with domestic wastes, posing a great health risk to municipal workers, the public, and the environment [17, 18]. Medical waste must be separated from municipal waste [19, 20]. Results from a survey of hospitals in Metropolitan Lagos, Nigeria, to assess medical waste management (MWM) practices and their implications to health and environments revealed a high rate of noncompliance to the Nigerian National Guidelines for MWM, whereby medical waste, including medicines from the surveyed facilities, was disposed off alongside municipal solid waste. The main reason cited was weak regulatory enforcement by the relevant authorities [21].

Studies conducted in Tanzania regarding medical wastes had described MWM in Tanzania as being poor and that the general awareness on issues related to MWM is lacking among the medical waste generators (e.g., health facilities) and handlers (e.g., staff involved in handling wastes) [12]. Due to poor control of wastes, hospital owners do not inspect well how they handle and dispose off the wastes they produce; as a result, hazardous wastes reach the dumpsite without notice [22]. It is estimated that 10–25% of healthcare waste is hazardous [23]. This study intends to assess practices and challenges encountered in managing disposal of unfit medicines in nongovernmental hospitals and private medicines outlets in the Mwanza region. Such assessments endeavour to provide valuable information for local health policy makers, TFDA, health services providers in private sectors, and all other stakeholders involved in disposal of unfit medicines to effectively plan, manage, and supervise their safe disposal.

2. Methods and Materials

2.1. Study Design

A descriptive cross-sectional study was designed to capture quantitative data.

2.2. Study Sites

The study was conducted in the Mwanza region. Mwanza region is among 26 regions in the Tanzania mainland. The entire region has six districts, namely, Nyamagana, Ilemela, Kwimba, Misungwi, Magu, and Ukerewe.

2.3. Sample Size

All five nongovernmental hospitals were included. There were 56 pharmacies in Mwanza region (22 wholesale and 34 retail pharmacies); however, two pharmacies were not willing to participate, so 54 pharmacies were included. For Accredited Drug Dispensing Outlets (ADDO) shops, the sample size was 52, which were calculated using Yamane Taro, 1967. Thus, the study involved 111 health facilities.

2.4. Data Collection

The study was performed using records of all nongovernmental hospitals and private medicines outlet, and the participants were personnel involved directly with medicines. This study was conducted between October 2013 and May 2014. Data were collected by the use of a structured questionnaire (Annex I in Supplementary Materials). The questionnaire was used to assess experience and challenges on dealing with unfit pharmaceuticals. A review of records was done using a checklist (Annex II in Supplementary Materials) to capture data for the past disposal of unfit medicines. The record review collected information from the register book for recording unfit medicines, application form, and type of unfit medicines found in the health facility. This methodology helped to obtain actual information on the practices and procedures of safe disposal of unfit medicines. The method adopted for this study follows the procedure used by Longe and Williams [21].

2.5. Data Management and Analysis

All the collected data were counterchecked for their clarity and validity. The coded data were analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (Version 20.0) computer analysis software. Comparison of proportions between groups was performed using Pearson’s chi square test or Fisher’s exact test where appropriate. A value of less than 0.05 was considered as statistically significant at 95% confidence interval.

2.6. Ethical Consideration

Ethical clearance was obtained from MUHAS Ethical Review Committee of Research and Publication. Permission to conduct study in the selected study sites was granted by owners of nongovernmental hospitals, pharmacy, and ADDO shops.

3. Results

3.1. Frequency of Disposal of Unfit Medicines

Responses with regard to the frequency of disposal of unfit medicines by the health facilities are summarized in Table 1.

Table 1: Frequency of disposal of unfit medicines.

Frequency of disposal
Type of HF

Nongovernmental hospital
Pharmacy
ADDO shops
Total

No.
%
No.
%
No.
%
No.
%

After six months
0
0
1
1.9
1
1.9
2
1.8

After every one year
0
0
9
16.7
5
9.6
14
12.6

After every 2 years
0
0
2
3.7
0
0
2
1.8

When necessary
5
100
42
77.8
46
88.5
93
83.8

Total
5
100
54
100
52
100
111
100

The result shows that majority of facilities (83.8%) undertake the disposal of unfit medicines when necessary. Results show no difference between frequency of disposal with the type of facility ().

3.2. Disposal Methods of Unfit Medicines

In order to ascertain disposal methods that are commonly used by the health facilities, respondents listed the following as the most common methods for unfit medicines disposal (Table 2).

Table 2: Methods of disposal used by the health facility.

Methods of disposal used regularly
Type of HF

Nongovernmental hospital ()
Pharmacy ()
ADDO shops ()
Total ()

No.
%
No.
%
No.
%
No.
%

Landfill of untreated unfit medicines
2
40
8
14.8
13
25
23
20.7

Burning in open spaces
1
20
24
44.4
17
32.7
42
37.8

Others (pour into sink and put into dustbin)
2
40
22
40.7
22
42.3
46
41.4

Majority of facilities (41.4%) use methods like pouring of unfit medicines into the sink and putting into the dustbin. Results show no association between methods of disposal with the type of facility ().

3.3. Storage Practices of Unfit Medicines Prior to Disposal

In order to ascertain the disposal practices of a particular health facility, the checklist was used to determine the procedures for handling unfit medicines prior to terminal disposal. The results of the checklist questions are shown in Table 3.

Table 3: Storage practices of unfit medicines prior to disposal.

Storage practices of unfit medicines
Type of HF

Nongovernmental hospitals ()
Pharmacy ()
ADDO shops ()
Total ()

No.
%
No.
%
No.
%
No.
%

Maintained register
3
60
8
14.8
1
1.9
12
10.8
0.001

Segregated from usable medicines
4
80
28
51.9
13
25
45
40.5
0.002

Presence of separate area/box
4
80
14
25.9
4
7.7
22
19.8
<0.0001

Labelled properly
4
80
10
18.5
2
3.8
16
14.4
<0.0001

Only around 10% (10.8%) of health facilities surveyed maintained the register book for recording unfit medicines.

3.4. Type of Unfit Medicines Found in the Health Facility

About 60.4% of health facilities were found with unfit medicines at the time of survey, and majority of unfit medicines found were antibiotics (64.1%).

3.5. Barriers to Proper Disposal of Unfit Medicines

About 2% mentioned lack of areas for disposal as the barrier to proper disposal of unfit medicines.

About 40% of pharmacies mention long procedures for disposal of unfit medicines as the barrier.

4. Discussion

Medicines are vital for saving life in conditions of morbidity, but yet these medicines might become unfit before reaching the consumer. When medicines become unfit, they need more special care and handling than before and hence need special protocols to attend them. In most cases, authorities are failing to install appropriate systems for a variety of reasons, such as nonavailability of appropriate technologies, inadequate financial resources, and absence of professional training on waste management [24].

This study revealed that more than eighty percent of health facilities undertake disposal of unfit medicines when necessary, while almost ten percent dispose off unfit medicines annually (Table 1). This entails that many facilities have had no standard protocols to guide them on the timing and frequency with which disposal should be conducted. As a consequence, some of the facility owners decide to dispose off unfit medicines conveniently by pouring into sewerage system, burying at their homes, or burning in open spaces. Indeed, most of the health facilities do not have separate collection and disposal programmes for pharmaceutical waste [25].

The disposal methods most commonly used by nongovernmental hospitals and private medicine outlets were putting into the street dustbin or pouring into the sink (41.4%), (Table 2). No significant differences in disposal practice occurred between the types of health facility. A similar study in New Zealand revealed that 44.7% of private medicines outlets poured liquid medicines into the sink [26]. These practices increase potential danger for environmental pollution [27]. Improper disposal can contaminate the environment and pose significant risks to water, air, agricultural products, and food chain, even harm animals and livestock [4, 28]. Indeed, the majority of hospitals do not have incineration facility or access to other essential healthcare waste management equipment [6, 7]. Peer-reviewed literature on attitudes and practices to medicine disposal methods revealed that the most popular methods for medication disposal were in the garbage, toilet, or sink. Liquid medications were more likely to be rinsed down the sink, as opposed to solid tablets and capsules, which were more likely deposited in the rubbish bin [29].

The current study attempted to examine handling procedures of unfit medicines prior to terminal disposal. Most medicines’ storekeepers and dispensers were interviewed on procedures prior to terminal disposal, and they mentioned the follows: isolation of unfit medicines from usable medicines, recording the medicines in a register, packing into boxes/keeping them in separate area, and labelling them. Results revealed poor storage management practices as some of the unfit medicines were left unpacked into boxes or separated from the usable medicines and not properly labelled, less than half of facilities are segregated unfit from usable medicines (Table 3).

About 60.4% of health facilities were found with unfit medicines at the time of survey, and more than half of unfit medicines were in the group of antibiotics (Figure 1). Evidence shows that the presence of antibiotics in water may lead to antibiotic resistance [5]. Studies on antibiotics have shown that up to 95% of antibiotic compounds can be released unaltered into the sewage system, and higher concentrations of antibiotics can lead to change in the microbial community structure and ultimately affect food chains [30]. Moreover, almost 30% of unfit medicines were analgesics (Figure 1). Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), like ibuprofen, naproxen, and aspirin, are the most commonly used drugs, which are usually found in effective quantities in municipal effluents [5, 31].

Figure 1: Types of unfit medicines found in the health facility.

Almost half of health facilities (Figure 2) reported no barriers to disposal, and this might be due to the common practice used (pouring into the sink and putting into the street dustbin) does not need long procedures and extra resources. About 40% of pharmacies mentioned long procedures for disposal of unfit medicines as the barrier (Figure 3). The regulatory bodies need to do a better job at minimizing long disposal procedures and monitoring disposal practices for unfit medicines. Inadequacy in the MWM practices is mainly related to unsafe storage, lack of priority to the proper disposal, and poor control of waste disposal [32, 33]. Accumulation of unfit medicines poses three major concerns: (i) active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) disposed off into sewage or trash comprise a diverse source of potential chemical stressors in the environment. (ii) Accumulated medicines represent an increased potential for medicines diversion, with its attendant risks of unintentional poisonings and abuse. (iii) Leftover medicines represent wasted healthcare resources and lost opportunities for medical treatment [34]. The use of contractors in disposal of unfit medicines has shown to be the best way to minimize barriers in disposal of unfit medicines. Community pharmacists in New Zealand reported that 80.4% solid medications were removed by contractors [26]. However, this study was limited by the inability of the collected data to report on a detailed plethora of disposal methods which may have been used for the disposal of unfit medication rather than those commonly assumed by the authors.

Figure 2: Barriers to proper disposal of unfit medicines.

Figure 3: Barriers to proper disposal of unfit medicines according to health facility.

Also, the research instrument was not able to collect, analyze, and report data on the percentage of participants who disposed off unfit medicines through the dustbin and sink separately. Further research to investigate other methods used apart from those reported in this study is a priority.

5. Conclusion

There was improper disposal of unfit medicines in health facilities studied whereby commonly reported methods of disposal were pouring into the sink and putting into the street dustbin. In private medicines outlets, there were poor storage management practices as some of the unfit medicines were left unpacked into boxes or separated from the usable medicines and not properly labelled. Medicines storekeepers and dispensers have a significant role in ensuring proper disposal and reducing the generation of unfit medicines. Doctors have a role for ensuring proper prescribing practices which do not result in an excess of unfit medicines. TFDA should enhance and strengthen its enforcement on nongovernmental hospitals and private medicine outlets through inspections and distribution of relevant guidelines. TFDA should register private companies in every region of the country on safe disposal of unfit medicines.

Data Availability

The data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.

Authors’ Contributions

GN, SM, and DK designed the study. GN collected the data. DK and SM analyzed the data. SM and DK drafted the first manuscript. GN and SM critically reviewed the manuscript.

Acknowledgments

The financial support from Tanzanian Ministry of Health is gratefully acknowledged.

Supplementary Materials

(i) Annex I: study questionnaire. (ii) Annex II: checklist on procedures of unfit medicines disposal. (Supplementary Materials)

References

O. Awodele, A. A. Adewoye, and A. C. Oparah, “Assessment of medical waste management in seven hospitals in Lagos, Nigeria,” BMC Public Health, vol. 16, no. 1, p. 269, 2016.

Tanzania Food and Drugs Authority (TFDA), Guidelines for Safe Disposal of Unfit Medicines and Cosmetic Products, Tanzania Food and Drugs Authority (TFDA), Dares Salaam, Tanzania, 2009.

S. A. Tamplin, D. Davidson, B. Powis, and Z. O’Leary, “Issues and options for the safe destruction and disposal of used injection materials,” Waste Management, vol. 25, no. 6, pp. 655–665, 2005.

N. Nakada, T. Tanishima, H. Shinohara, K. Kiri, and H. Takada, “Pharmaceutical chemicals and endocrine disrupters in municipal wastewater in Tokyo and their removal during activated sludge treatment,” Water Research, vol. 40, no. 17, pp. 3297–3303, 2006.

C. Tixier, H. P. Singer, S. Oellers, and S. R. Müller, “Occurrence and fate of carbamazepine, clofibric acid, diclofenac, ibuprofen, ketoprofen, and naproxen in surface waters,” Environmental Science & Technology, vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 1061–1068, 2003.

S. L. Bartlett-Hunt, D. D. Snow, T. Damon, J. Shockley, and K. Hoagland, “The occurrence of illicit and therapeutic pharmaceuticals in wastewater effluent and surface waters in Nebraska,” Environmental Pollution, vol. 157, no. 3, pp. 786–791, 2009.

M. J. Benotti, R. A. Trenholm, B. J. Vanderford, J. C. Holady, B. D. Stanford, and S. A. Snyder, “Pharmaceuticals and endocrine disrupting compounds in U.S. drinking water,” Environmental Science & Technology, vol. 43, no. 3, pp. 597–603, 2009.

I. S. Kagonji and S. V. Manyele, “Analysis of the measured medical waste generation rate in Tanzanian district hospitals using statistical methods,” African Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, vol. 5, no. 10, pp. 815–833, 2011.

Z. Singh, R. Bhalwar, J. Jayaram, and V. W. Tilak, “An introduction to essentials of bio-medical waste management,” Medical Journal Armed Forces India, vol. 57, no. 2, pp. 144–147, 2001.

C. A. Smith, “Managing pharmaceutical waste,” Journal of the Pharmacy Society of Wisconsin, vol. 5, pp. 17–22, 2002.

W. S. Pray and J. J. Pray, “Childhood poisoning. What should be done?” U.S. Pharmacist, vol. 29, p. 3, 2004.

S. V. Manyele and H. Anicetus, “Management of medical waste in Tanzanian hospitals,” Tanzania Health Research Bulletin, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 177–182, 2006.

V. Gautam, R. Thapar, and M. Sharma, “Biomedical waste management: incineration vs. environmental safety,” Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology, vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 191-192, 2010.

C. E. Da Silva, A. E. Hoppe, M. M. Ravanello, and N. Mello, “Medical wastes management in the south of Brazil,” Waste Management, vol. 25, no. 6, pp. 600–605, 2005.

A. Prem Ananth, V. Prashanthini, and C. Visvanathan, “Healthcare waste management in Asia,” Waste Management, vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 154–161, 2010.

V. Mathur, M. A. Hassan, S. Dwivedi, and R. P. Misra, “Knowledge, attitude, and practices about biomedical waste management among healthcare personnel: a cross-sectional study,” Indian Journal of Community Medicine, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 143–145, 2011.

A. Z. Alagöz and G. Kocasoy, “Determination of the best appropriate management methods for the health-care wastes in Istanbul,” Waste Management, vol. 28, no. 7, pp. 1227–1235, 2008.

A. Bdour, B. Altrabsheh, N. Hadadin, and M. Al-Shareif, “Assessment of medical wastes management practice: a case study of the northern part of Jordan,” Waste Management, vol. 27, no. 6, pp. 746–759, 2007.

D. L. Kgathi and B. Bolaane, “Instruments for sustainable solid waste management in Botswana,” Waste Management & Research, vol. 19, no. 4, pp. 342–353, 2001.

P. Taru and A. T. Kuvarega, “Manejo de los desechos sólidos médicos. El caso del Hospital de Parirenyatwa, Zimbabwe,” Revista Biomédica, vol. 16, no. 3, pp. 153–158, 2005.

E. O. Longe and A. Williams, “A preliminary study of medical waste management in Lagos metropolis, Nigeria,” Iranian Journal of Environmental Health, Science and Engineering, vol. 3, no. 2, pp. 133–139, 2006.

S. V. Manyele and T. J. Lyasenga, “Factors affecting medical waste management in low-level health facilities in Tanzania,” African Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, vol. 4, no. 5, pp. 304–318, 2010.

World Health Organization, Safe Management of Waste from Health Care Activities, WHO, Geneva, Switzerland, 1999.

A. D. Patil and A. V. Shekdar, “Health-care waste management in India,” Journal of Environmental Management, vol. 63, no. 2, pp. 211–220, 2001.

S. Sasu, K. Kümmerer, and M. Kranert, “Assessment of pharmaceutical waste management at selected hospitals and homes in Ghana,” Waste Management & Research, vol. 30, no. 6, pp. 625–630, 2012.

A. Tong, B. Peake, and R. Braund, “Disposal practices for unused medications in New Zealand community pharmacies,” Journal of Primary Health Care, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 197–203, 2011.

M. S. Hossain, A. Santhanam, N. A. Nik Norulaini, and A. K. M. Omar, “Clinical solid waste management practices and its impact on human health and environment–a review,” Waste Management, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 754–766, 2011.

M. A. Patwary, W. T. O’Hare, G. Street, K. Maudood Elahi, S. S. Hossain, and M. H. Sarker, “Quantitative assessment of medical waste generation in the capital city of Bangladesh,” Waste Management, vol. 29, no. 8, pp. 2392–2397, 2009.

A. Y. C. Tong, B. M. Peake, and R. Braund, “Disposal practices for unused medications around the world,” Environment International, vol. 37, no. 1, pp. 292–298, 2011.

C. B. Patneedi and K. D. Prasadu, “Impact of pharmaceutical wastes on human life and environment,” Rasayan Journal of Chemistry, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 67–70, 2015.

D. Ashton, M. Hilton, and K. V. Thomas, “Investigating the environmental transport of human pharmaceuticals to streams in the United Kingdom,” Science of the Total Environment, vol. 333, no. 1–3, pp. 167–184, 2004.

M. M. Abd El-Salam, “Hospital waste management in El-Beheira Governorate, Egypt,” Journal of Environmental Management, vol. 91, no. 3, pp. 618–629, 2010.

I. Alam, G. Alam, S. Ayub, and A. A. Siddiqui, “Assessment of bio-medical waste management in different hospitals in Aligarh city,” Advances in Waste Management, pp. 501–510, 2019.

I. S. Ruhoy and C. G. Daughton, “Beyond the medicine cabinet: an analysis of where and why medications accumulate,” Environment International, vol. 34, no. 8, pp. 1157–1169, 2008.