Preparation and Characteristics of Starch Esters and Its Effects on Dough Physicochemical Properties

As a recyclable natural material, starch is an important raw material in food and other elds. e native starch by esterication could improve the performance of the original starch and expand its range of application. is article reviews the preparation process of acetylated distarch adipate, starch sodium octenylsuccinate, starch acetate, hydroxypropyl starch, and starch phosphate and research into the inuence of starch esters on dough. At the same time, it forecasts the trend of starch esters and application prospect in the future research.


Introduction
Starch is a natural, renewable, biodegradable polymer and rich in resources that are widely found in a variety of plants.Many of its unique physicochemical properties are extensively applied in food and other industries [1,2], but most of the native starch itself cannot be used directly [3].After modi cation, the starch properties are improved and can meet the requirements of multilevel processing.
Esteri cation is one of the e ective ways of denaturation, and the starch can be modi ed by physical, chemical, or enzymatical methods which are e ectively applied in food, textile, papermaking, petrochemical, and pharmaceutical industries depending on its di erent properties.
e application of starch ester in foreign countries was earlier, and large-scale industrial productions have been achieved.Some starch esters for food applications mainly include starch acetate, acetylated distarch adipate, starch sodium octenylsuccinate, monostarch phosphate, distarch phosphate, phosphated distarch phosphate, acetylated distarch phosphate, hydroxypropyl distarch phosphate, and hydroxypropyl starch in the US and EU countries [4,5].Although the researches are carried out relatively late in China, the researches and development of starch esters has matured gradually in the past two decades.At present, starch esters as food additives mainly include phosphate distarch, acetate starch, sodium starch phosphate, acetylated distarch adipate, phosphorylated distarch phosphate, acetylated distarch phosphate, and hydroxypropyl distarch phosphate in China [6].Since many scholars had already researched the preparation process, the synthesis technology has mainly focused on increasing the degree of substitution (DS) which determined the application direction of esteri ed starch [7,8].
e following is a summary of common organic acid starch esters and inorganic acid starch esters (Table 1).

Preparation of Starch Esters and Properties
2.1.Acetylated Distarch Adipate.Acetylated distarch adipate (ADiSP) is a cross-linked composite modi ed starch obtained by esteri cation of starch with adipic acid and acetic anhydride.e production has the characteristics of crosslinked and esteri ed starch and has thermal stability, high shear resistance, and acid resistance.Acetylated distarch adipate could be used as a thickener, stabilizer, and binder in the food industry [9].Acetylated distarch phosphate is a modi ed starch used in some baby foods.
e bioavailability of ADiSP and a native (unmodi ed) starch was evaluated in 20 normal infants and 21 toddlers aged 8-24 mo with chronic nonspeci c diarrhea [10].
Acetylated, cross-linked, and pregelatinized cassava starches were produced in a single-screw extruder with different moisture contents (180, 220, and 260 g/kg), different adipic acetic mixed anhydride concentrations (4, 11, and 18 g/kg) and screw speeds (100, 130, and 160 rpm).e acetylation, cross-linking, and pregelatinization steps increased the cold viscosity, water absorption index, and gel hardness and reduced the gel cohesiveness, paste clarity, and retrogradation of the starches produced.Products manufactured under less severe operational conditions (260 g/kg moisture and 100 rpm screw speed), and at higher reagent concentration (18 g/kg), had the major group of functional characteristics preferred for puddings, instantaneous desserts, and foods subjected to low-temperature storage.Using 260 g/kg moisture, 11 g/kg reagent concentration, and a screw speed of 160 rpm, the starch products gave high clarity and no syneresis and could be used in fruit pie fillings, soups, and canned foods [11].
Acetylated tapioca distarch adipate was prepared by acetylation and cross-linking reaction using tapioca starch as a raw material and a mixture of acetic anhydride and adipic acid as acetalation and cross-linking agent, respectively, and by a wet approach.e impact of modification factors such as the amount of acetic anhydride and adipic acid, pH value, and reaction time on the esterification reactions was systematically studied.e optimum conditions required for preparation of acetylated tapioca distarch adipate were 0.050% adipic acid, 3% acetic anhydride, pH 8.0, and 90 min.
e peak viscosity and cold viscosity of the acetylated tapioca distarch adipate were 1141 BU and 1695 BU, respectively, which were higher than those of native tapioca starch.e gelatinization temperature of acetylated tapioca distarch adipate decreased, but viscosity stability was enhanced.e shearing resistance and freeze-thaw stability were much improved, but the transparency decreased [12,13].

Starch Sodium Octenylsuccinate.
Starch sodium octenylsuccinate is one of the most widely used starch esters.It was first successfully synthesized by Caldwell and Wurzburg in the United States and was patented in 1953 [14].Starch sodium octenylsuccinate is one of the food additives used earlier and a sort of safe and reliable emulsifier thickener.When the octenylsuccinic anhydride reacts with the starch, the ring of the anhydride is opened under alkaline conditions: one end of which combines with sodium hydroxide to form a sodium salt and the other end reacts with the starch and removes one molecule of water.e entire reaction pH is continuously reduced as the reaction proceeds, so it is continuously neutralized with an alkaline solution to ensure pH Journal of Food Quality of the entire reaction system, so that the reaction proceeds efficiently.Since the esterification reaction and the hydrolysis reaction proceed simultaneously, the esterification reaction predominates at the beginning of the reaction phase, and the reaction proceeds to the esterification reaction; when the reaction reaches a certain time, the hydrolysis reaction will be dominant due to the decrease of the substrate concentration, so the reaction time is not as long as possible, so you must control the reaction time.ere are mainly wet, dry, and physical extrusion methods for preparing starch octenylsuccinate [15].e specific operation of the synthesis is to dispose a certain concentration of suspension in the reaction vessel and use a 2% NaOH solution to adjust the pH of the starch solution.
e treated starch sodium octenylsuccinate was slowly added to the mixed solution in portions while keeping the system pH at 8.0 ± 0.2 during the addition.At the end of the reaction, the pH of the reaction mixture was again adjusted to 6.5 using 2% HCl. e resulting product was washed and centrifuged, and it was dried three times in an oven at 45 °C and dried to obtain starch sodium octenylsuccinate [10].erefore, Yoshimura et al. [16] used the organic phase method to synthesize starch octenylsuccinate using 4-dimethylaminopyridine (DMAP) as an esterification catalyst and dimethyl sulfoxide as a solvent.
e dry method mixes the starch with the alkali, sprays the water to 25% water content of the starch, sprays the anhydride diluted with the organic solvent, reacts after mixing, or the starch is first suspended in a solution with a mass fraction, and then filtered until the starch is dried to the required moisture and sprayed into an anhydride diluted with an organic solvent and heated in dry mixer.is method allows the process to be simple, highly efficient, and low cost but nonuniform and easily leads to local violent reaction [17].
In the conventional wet method (aqueous phase method), the degree of substitution and the efficiency of esterification depend on the type of starch and the reaction parameters, and they are also affected by the surface structure of the starch granules.Due to the low solubility of starch sodium octenylsuccinate in water, the esterification reaction with starch mainly occurs on the surface of the particles, and the problems such as uneven distribution of acid anhydride and poor reaction efficiency occur easily.On the other hand, the use of sodium hydroxide, pyridine, and anhydride at high temperature often leads to the production of other by-products in the process of chemical reaction [18].In recent years, through the improvement of traditional synthetic technology, it has sought to achieve higher efficiency and degree of substitution in a shorter time.e main methods involved mechanical activation, microwaveassisted, and enzymatic methods.
e enzymatic method can realize the reaction under mild conditions and is environmentally friendly.In addition, due to the high efficiency of the enzyme, the reaction rate can be greatly promoted and the product quality can be also improved.e lipase-conjugated esterification can sharply drop the reaction time from several hours to 30 min, and it makes the bioenzymatic method technically feasible in the large-scale production of starch sodium octenylsuccinate [19].Xu et al. [20] researched high-speed shear-assisted OS-starch synthesis and characterized its modified properties.Compared with the control sample, the starch's DS increased from 0.0182 to 0.0202, and thermal stability, transparency, and freeze-thaw stability improved likewise.High-speed shear attenuates the crystalline regions of starch granules without changing the type of crystallization, while the cavitation effect increases the reaction area by destroying the surface of the granules, and also promotes the reduction in droplet size and uniformity of distribution of starch sodium octenylsuccinate, making more OS groups induced into the inner regions of the starches [21].

Starch Acetate.
Starch acetate is obtained by introducing an acetyl group into a hydrogen atom of the hydroxyl group on glucose.Starch acetate could be divided into high (1.5-3),medium (0.2-1.5), and low degree of substitution (0.01-0.2).Low-substituted acetylated starch has been widely used in the food industry as a kind of thickener or stabilizer.However, the acetylated starch with medium and high degree of substitution had high solubility in acetone and chloroform and was mainly used for research and development of thermoplastic materials and biodegradable materials [22].
Preparation of starch acetate esterification agent mainly covered acetic anhydride, vinyl acetate, vinyl chloride, ketene, and so on.Chemical synthesis generally preferred acetic anhydride and vinyl acetate as esterifying agents.In current commercial production, most of the synthesis routes chose NaOH as a catalyst to react starch and anhydride in an alkaline aqueous suspension [23].
e starch suspension was configured and shaken at 1500 rpm for 1 h at 25 °C.e pH of the starch suspension was adjusted to 8.0 with 3% NaOH, and acetic anhydride was slowly added.e pH was always maintained between 8.0 and 8.4 during the addition.After complete addition of acetic anhydride, the reaction was allowed to continue for 15 minutes.e pH was adjusted to 4.5 with a 0.5 mol/L HCl solution, and the suspension after the reaction was stopped, centrifuged for 3 minutes, washed successively with ethanol, and finally dried in an oven at 40 °C to give starch acetate [24].
Tupa et al. [25] used a novel organic acid catalyzed heterogeneous approach to synthesize starch esters, and it features the use of a nontoxic green catalyst tartaric acid in the absence of the solvent.Volkert  e results showed that rice starch with the low amylose content was more easily acetylated, and DS is higher than that of the high and medium amylose under the same circumstances at different reaction times [27].
e physical auxiliary methods for preparing starch acetate mainly include microwave-assisted synthesis and mechanical activation.Microwave processing has achieved comprehensive researches over the past decade.Microwave heating can overcome the limitations of time-consuming and low substitution in single acetylation.Under the condition of keeping starch granules intact, it causes surface roughness and internal destruction of particles promoting the degree of acetylation [28].e pulsed electric field (PEF) that regard as a new technique has been similarly applied to the acetylation process.Hong et al. researched that PEF treatment was able to enhance the esterification rate in a short period of time under appropriate conditions. is was due to the potential difference and the alterant direction of the electric field.e PEF system would accelerate the migration rate and direction of the reaction ions, and the effective collision between ions, which expedited the reaction rate and increased the DS.erefore, moderate starch concentration (35%) and high electric field strength were more conducive to the formation of high DS starch acetate [29].

Hydroxypropyl Starch.
e reaction of starch with the etherifying reagent, propylene oxide, results in the introduction of the hydroxypropyl group onto the polymeric chain of starch.
e alignment of polymers that causes a change in the structure of the food product, leads to an opaque, gelled, and/or chunky texture with "weeping" of liquid from the gel. is is termed as retrogradation and is undesirable in many food applications [30].
e etherification process is mainly done to inhibit retrogradation [31].e reactive nature of propylene oxide is due to its highly strained three-membered epoxide ring.Bond angles in the ring average 60 °C resulting in a very unstable (reactive) molecule.
In substitution reactions by etherification, the starch molecule should first be activated to make the O-H bond nucleophilic and to facilitate the formation of starch-O − .Alkaline reagents in this regard are excellent as catalysts.
is is followed by reaction of starch-O − and propylene oxide which results in bimolecular substitution producing hydroxypropyl starch [32].
e efficiency of hydroxypropylation is greatly influenced by the reagents used.Etherification occurs mainly in the amorphous region of the starch granule.It is reported to affect the conformation of amylose molecules, and holes are known to appear at the surface of the granule [33].e reaction efficiency is defined as the percentage of the reagent reacted or substituted upon starch.
e remaining reagent is consumed to form byproducts.
e efficiency depends upon the diffusion or penetration of alkali catalyst and etherifying agent into starch granules and the chances of collisions of the starch alcoholate nucleophile with the propylene oxide molecule.
e elevated temperature of reaction helps in diffusion of alkaline catalyst and penetration of etherifying reagent more readily into the reaction point inside the starch granule and thus economises the reagent consumption.
Preparation of hydroxypropyl starch from a variety of cereal starch sources such as rice [34], wheat [35,36], corn [37], tuber starch sources like potato [38], and legume starch sources e.g., field pea [39] has been reported.A number of patented processes have been developed for the preparation of low-substituted hydroxyalkyl starch ethers in the aqueous phase.High levels of substitution can be obtained in granular starch by using nonaqueous media or in dry conditions [40].
Kim et al. prepared hydroxypropyl starch and compared the effects of glycerin, sorbitol, and xylitol on the starch film.It was found that 20% glycerol was the best plasticizer.After hydroxypropylation, the brittleness of the starch film decreases [41].Hydroxypropyl gluten corn starch was prepared by using propylene oxide as an etherifying agent, and it was found that the thermal stability, acid resistance, and transparency of the starch were enhanced as the degree of substitution increased.Hydroxypropyl starch has a hydroxypropyl group attached to it, which hinders the hydrogen bond polymerization of starch molecules, which causes the starch gelatinization temperature to decrease, the stability of the paste liquid to be enhanced, the transparency to be improved, the mechanical strength of the starch film to increase, and the barrier property to be enhanced [42].

Starch Phosphate.
Starch phosphate is an esterified starch obtained after phosphorylation.At present, there were mainly dry, wet, and semidry methods for the preparation of starch phosphate at home and abroad.In the dry process, a certain ratio of phosphate and urea solution was adjusted to pH, and then uniformly sprayed into the dry starch to reduce the moisture in the drying oven to heat the reaction to obtain the starch phosphate.
e wet process adopted in traditional industrial production allows phosphorylating agents (orthophosphate, metaphosphate, phosphorus oxychloride, etc.,) to be added to the starch suspension or reacted in organic solvents.Landerito and Wang [43] researched that phosphorylation could increase starch viscosity and water binding capacity.Conventional phosphorylation could produce monosubstituted phosphate monoester starch or cross-linked phosphodiester starch.e type and ratio of the product depended mainly on the phosphorylating agent used, concentration, pH, and reaction conditions.In aqueous media, phosphate monoester starch was easily formed under mild acid conditions and cross-linked phosphodiester starch was formed under alkaline conditions [44,45].
For wet synthesis, sodium phosphate was first dissolved in deionized water, the pH was adjusted to 6 or 8.5 with 10 M NaOH, and water was added to 100 ml.e appropriate amount of starch is added, stirred until it was viscous, and allowed it to equilibrate for 4 hours.e mixture was dried in an oven at 50 °C overnight and then reacted at 140 °C for 4 h.Unreacted sodium phosphate was extracted with a hot aqueous ethanol solution, and the precipitated starch was collected.e distilled water was washed and dried several times to obtain phosphate monoester starch [46].Przetaczek-Roznowska and Fortuna [47] preparated starch phosphates under alkaline conditions with a mixture of sodium tripolyphosphate, sodium trimetaphosphate, sodium sulfate, and pumpkin starch and studied the effect of different esterification temperatures (115 °C and 145 °C) and duration of phosphorylation on starch gelatinization characteristics and rheology.Although the wet process has continued for many years and the technology is mature, it had the disadvantages of wastewater pollution and high energy consumption and high cost in industrial production.
In recent years, semidry preparation has become a research hotspot.Lars Passauer et al. [45] adjusted the pH of sodium dihydrogen phosphate and disodium hydrogen phosphate solution to pH 5 by sodium hydroxide, added starch to the mixture, stirred, and vacuum-filtered.After that, the filter cake was crushed at 55 °C and dried for 24 h.e homogenized mixture was dried again at 65 °C for 90 min and reacted at 150 °C for 3 h.After cooling to room temperature, unreacted phosphate and starch degradation products were removed with 50% methanol solution.e filtered product was dehydrated by washing with absolute ethanol and dried to give starch phosphate.
Furthermore, the use of extrusion can avoid problems such as time-consuming with efficiency and operation steps in the conventional process.At the same time, the high temperature, high pressure, and dry shear force in the extrusion process can also promote the phosphorylation of starch.Manoi and Rizvi [48] developed supercritical fluid extrusion (SCFX) using supercritical CO 2 (SC-CO 2 ) as a foaming agent at a constant screw speed of 120 rpm, a temperature of 60-70 °C, and a pressure of 10-15 MPa.In general, physical extrusion is less expensive and more commercially viable than conventional oven heating.

Effect of Different Starch Esters on Dough Properties
Starch could dilute the gluten in the dough to an appropriate level, interweave with gluten, and absorb the water in the gluten by gelatinization.ere are many deficiencies in the functionality of raw starch, and its quality has a direct impact on the quality of pasta.Starch esters are safe and reliable food additives and also dough quality improvers.e addition of different starch esters could improve the defect properties of the original starch [49].By combining proteins, the gluten process characteristics, the dough processing performance, and gas holdability were heightened, and the improved pasta products were more glossy, elastic, and chewable.Different kinds and different amounts of esterified starch played different roles in improving dough quality.e results showed that adding starch acetate reduced the water absorption of the dough by 4%, making the dough harder.e dough containing 20% starch acetate (DS: 0.03-0.04)lowered the gelatinization peak temperature and changed the endothermic enthalpy compared with the same amount of natural tapioca starch; thus, it could be applied in the preparation of noodles to delay aging [50].Shukri et al. found the rheological difference between pure wheat flour dough and mixed powder dough containing 15% phosphate cross-linked starch ester, the water absorption rate decreased from 64.3% to 62.9%, the dough development time (DDT) was 2 times longer than the original flour, and the mixed tolerance index was positively correlated with the added amount.e wheat dough rich in phosphorylated starch had a significantly reduced ductility and tends to break faster than the control dough.In terms of finished products, steamed buns which are reinforced with cross-linked starch phosphate (15% and 30%) had significantly lower hardness, stickiness, and chewiness, while elasticity was not affected [51].
e quality of the dough during freezing could also be improved by adding starch esters.During the frozen storage of the dough and repeated cycles of freeze-thaw cycles, the surface moisture would be lost due to sublimation and the recrystallization of water and the formation of ice crystals will cause physical damage to the gluten structure, resulting in the weakening of the hydrophobic bonds [52,53].e addition of starch acetate and cross-linked starch phosphate could effectively delay the aging of frozen dough and improve the quality of the dough or bread quality, and the starch ester with high degree of substitution delays the aging phenomenon more clearly [54].Starch octenylsuccinate could also significantly improve the internal structure of frozen dough and alleviate the aging of starch.When the ice crystals in the dough gradually became larger in refrigeration, OSA starch amylopectin molecules could form hydrophilic and hydrophobic bonds with other components in the dough (natural starch, protein, water, and lipids), thereby strengthening the gluten network and avoiding ice crystals that disrupted the structure of the gluten network as well as the possible collapse and skin cracking of the frozen dough during thawing.Similarly, starch octenylsuccinate acted as a protein cryoprotectant to prevent denaturation of the dough protein at low temperatures that extend the shelf life of the dough.
ere is a range of important technological properties of starch which could be esterified by biotechnological, physical, and chemical methods.Esterified starches may be used to replace wheat flour in traditional bakery at the level of 20%, without deterioration of quality of final products.
eir addition influences water absorption and rheological parameters of the dough, pasting characteristics of starch, and texture and staling of the obtained crumb.It allows to formulate recipes for bread with special, strictly controlled properties [50].
e application of esterified starches (acetylated distarch adipate and hydroxypropyl distarch phosphate) caused the increase in volume of the obtained gluten-free loaves, and the observed differences were statistically significant at the levels above 10%.e changes were accompanied by modification of structural properties of bread crumb, e.g., a decrease of average cell size and an increase in their number.However, the addition of modified starch crumb structure became more elastic, which was revealed in the results of stress relaxation.A slight decrease in hardness and chewiness of the crumb was also observed on the day of baking, and its extent depended on the level of modified starch and was a little more pronounced in case of starch adipate [55].
Journal of Food Quality

Expectation
e preparation process and physicochemical properties of various starch esters have been studied in detail, but there are still many drawbacks at present.e esterification efficiency in chemical synthesis was still unsatisfied, and on the other hand, expensive cost and organic solvent which was harmful to environment and human health in the process was expected to be solved.With the rise of enzymatic synthesis last several years, the future process would be more environmentally friendly and efficient.At the same time, except single esterified starch, the composite modified starch has also received extensive attention.With the continuous improvement of the technology, esterified starch would have more development space in the fields of food, biomaterials, and other fields.e production technology would gradually mature and adapt to the trend of modern industrial production.

Table 1 :
Preparation techniques of different starch esters and their properties with applications.
et al. used different synthetic routes to compare the mechanical properties of starch acetate prepared by adding three different activators of acetic acid, sodium hydroxide, and potassium carbonate [26].Colussi et al. made different degrees of acetylation of high, medium, and low amylose rice starch.