Time-Dependent Vascular Effects of Endocannabinoids Mediated by Peroxisome Proliferator-Activated Receptor Gamma (PPARγ)

The aim of the present study was to examine whether endocannabinoids cause PPARγ-mediated vascular actions. Functional vascular studies were carried out in rat aortae. Anandamide and N-arachidonoyl-dopamine (NADA), but not palmitoylethanolamide, caused significant vasorelaxation over time (2 hours). Vasorelaxation to NADA, but not anandamide, was inhibited by CB1 receptor antagonism (AM251, 1 μM), and vasorelaxation to both anandamide and NADA was inhibited by PPARγ antagonism (GW9662, 1 μM). Pharmacological inhibition of de novo protein synthesis, nitric oxide synthase, and super oxide dismutase abolished the responses to anandamide and NADA. Removal of the endothelium partly inhibited the vasorelaxant responses to anandamide and NADA. Inhibition of fatty acid amide hydrolase (URB597, 1 μM) inhibited the vasorelaxant response to NADA, but not anandamide. These data indicate that endocannabinoids cause time-dependent, PPARγ-mediated vasorelaxation. Activation of PPARγ in the vasculature may represent a novel mechanism by which endocannabinoids are involved in vascular regulation.


Introduction
Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors (PPARs) are nuclear receptors which control the transcription of many families of genes. They have a large ligand binding pocket and are pharmacologically promiscuous, being activated by a number of structurally diverse natural and synthetic ligands including some angiotensin II receptor antagonists [1], statins [2], retinoic receptor antagonists [3], flavinoids [4], and citrus fruit compounds [5]. An increasing body of evidence now also suggests that cannabinoids activate PPARs, and this may mediate some of the biological effects of cannabinoids [6], in addition to activation of two wellestablished 7-transmembrane cannabinoid receptors (CB 1 and CB 2 ).
The first evidence of cannabinoid interactions with PPAR came in 2002 in a study by Kozak and colleagues who showed that lipoxygenase metabolism of the endocannabinoid, 2-arachidonoylglycerol (2-AG), produced a metabolite that increases the transcriptional activity of PPARα [7]. Fu et al. (2003) then showed that the appetite-suppressing and weight-reducing effects of another endocannabinoidrelated agent, oleoylethanolamide (OEA), were absent in PPARα knock-out mice [8]. Guzmán et al. (2004) also showed that the stimulatory effect of OEA on lipolysis in vivo was absent in PPARα knock-out mice [9]. Palmitoylethanolamide (PEA), which is structurally related to OEA, similarly activates PPARα transcriptional activity, causing anti-inflammatory actions that were absent in PPARα knock-out mice [10]. Other endocannabinoids that have been shown to activate PPARα include noladin ether and virodhamine [11].
As well as activating PPARα, it was shown in 2003 [12] that the synthetic cannabinoid, ajulemic acid (an analogue of a tetrahydrocannabinol metabolite) binds to and increases the transcriptional activity of PPARγ. We have since shown that the principal active ingredient of Cannabis sativa, Δ 9tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), activates the transcriptional activity of PPARγ and stimulates adipogenesis, a PPARγ property [13]. The endocannabinoids anandamide and 2-AG have anti-inflammatory effects which are sensitive to PPARγ antagonism [14,15], although it was not clear whether these effects were through activation of PPARγ directly, or via metabolites of the endocannabinoids. Subsequent research has shown that anandamide directly binds to PPARγ [16,17], activates PPARγ transcriptional activity, and stimulates the differentiation of fibroblasts to adipocytes [16]. Other cannabinoids that activate the transcriptional activity of PPARγ include the endocannabinoid/endovanilloid, Narachidonoyl-dopamine (NADA), the synthetic cannabinoids WIN55212-2 and CP55940, and the phytocannabinoid, cannabidiol [18].
We have shown that THC causes time-dependent, endothelium-dependent, PPARγ-mediated vasorelaxation of the rat isolated aorta [13]. This response was dependent on nitric oxide (NO) and superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity [13]. Furthermore, subsequent studies showed that 2-hour incubation with THC (10 μM) in vitro blunts subsequent contractile responses and enhances vasodilator responses in isolated arteries, which was also inhibited by a PPARγ antagonist [19]. These experiments similarly indicated a role for increased SOD activity stimulated by THC. Together, these studies suggest that THC, through activation of PPARγ, leads to increased synthesis of SOD, promoting vasorelaxation by preventing NO being scavenged by endogenous superoxides. This is in agreement with research showing that, in addition to direct effects on NO production, PPARγ ligands enhance NO bioavailability in blood vessels through induction of SOD [20].
There has been much interest surrounding the vascular actions of endocannabinoids. The mechanisms underpinning the acute vasorelaxant response to endocannabinoids include activation of sensory nerves [21][22][23], activation of the CB 1 receptor, and activation of a novel endothelial cannabinoid receptor [23][24][25]. In light of the growing evidence that endocannabinoids activate PPARγ [14][15][16][17][18], the aim of the present study was to investigate whether similar time-dependent, PPARγ-mediated vasorelaxation to endocannabinoids occurs in the rat aorta as observed for THC, and to investigate the underlying mechanisms.

In Vitro Vascular Studies.
Male Wistar rats (250-350 g) were stunned by a blow to the back of the head and killed by cervical dislocation. The aortae were removed rapidly and placed into cold modified Krebs-Henseleit buffer (composition, mM: NaCl 118, KCl 4.7, MgSO 4 1.2, KH 2 PO 4 1.2, NaHCO 3 25, CaCl 2 2, and D-glucose 10). The aortae were dissected free of adherent connective and adipose tissue and cut into rings 3-4 mm long, and mounted on fixed segment support pins using the Multimyograph system (Model 610M, Danish Myo Technology, Denmark) as previously described [13,19,23]. Once mounted, all vessels were kept at 37 • C in modified Krebs-Henseleit buffer and gassed with 5% CO 2 in O 2 . The aortae were stretched to an optimal passive tension of 9.8 mN tension. Vessels were allowed to equilibrate and the contractile integrity of each was tested by its ability to contract to 60 mM KCl by at least 4.9 mN. Vessels were contracted with a combination of U46619 (10-100 nM, a thromboxane prostanoid receptor agonist), and the α-adrenoceptor agonist methoxamine (1-5 μM) to increase tension. When stable contraction was maintained, the vasorelaxant effect of a single concentration of endocannabinoid or vehicle control (0.1% ethanol) on induced tone was assessed as the reduction in tone over time. The endocannabinoids chosen were anandamide (5 μM) and NADA (10 μM), both previously demonstrated to be PPARγ ligands [14,[16][17][18], and PEA (10 μM), which activates PPARα but not PPARγ [10]. For every experimental protocol, vehicle-treated and endocannabinoid-treated experiments were performed in adjacent segments of the same artery.
To assess any possible contribution of vasorelaxation mediated through cannabinoid receptors, some experiments were performed in the presence of the cannabinoid CB 1 receptor antagonist AM251 (1 μM), or the CB 2 receptor antagonist AM630 (1 μM), both added 10 minutes before contracting the vessels.
To assess the contribution of PPARγ activation, some experiments were performed in the presence of the PPARγ antagonist GW9662 (1 μM) added 10 minutes prior to precontraction. To establish whether the time-dependent vasorelaxant effects of endocannabinoids were dependent upon de novo protein synthesis, some experiments were performed in the presence of the protein synthesis inhibitor cycloheximide (10 μM).
To investigate the role of endothelium-derived relaxing factors in the time-dependent vasorelaxation to endocannabinoids, some vessels were denuded of their endothelium by abrasion with a human hair. The role of endothelium-derived nitric oxide (NO) was investigated using the NO synthase inhibitor N G -nitro-L-arginine methyl ester (L-NAME, 300 μM, present throughout). To establish To assess whether the actions of endocannabinoids are due to their breakdown to other biologically active compounds that may act at PPARγ, some vessels were treated with the FAAH inhibitor, URB597 (1 μM, added 10 minutes prior to precontraction).

Statistical Analysis.
In each protocol, the number of animals in each group is represented by n, and values are expressed as mean ± SEM. The difference between endocannabinoid-treated and vehicle-treated vessels (adjacent segments from the same aorta) under each experimental protocol were analysed by paired Student's t-test.

Discussion
In the present study, we have examined whether endocannabinoids cause time-dependent, PPARγ-mediated vascular effects as previously shown for the phytocannabinoid, THC [13,19]. In these studies, we demonstrate for the first time that the endocannabinoids anandamide and NADA cause PPARγ-mediated, time-dependent vasorelaxation of rat aortae, which is dependent on de novo protein synthesis, nitric oxide production and superoxide dismutase activity. These are similar mechanisms to those found to underlie the vasorelaxant effects of the PPARγ agonists, rosiglitazone [26], and THC [13].
On the basis that PPARγ agonists cause time-dependent vasorelaxation of isolated aortae [13,26], and that endocannabinoids activate PPARγ [14][15][16][17][18], we investigated whether endocannabinoids produce time-dependent vasorelaxation. The endocannabinoids chosen were anandamide and NADA, both previously demonstrated to activate PPARγ [14,[16][17][18], and PEA, which activates PPARα but not PPARγ [10]. We found that, like rosiglitazone and THC, anandamide and NADA produced a slowly developing decrease in tone of precontracted aortae that was significantly greater than that seen in vehicle-treated segments of the same artery. The vascular response to anandamide and NADA was inhibited by the PPARγ antagonist, GW9662, and by inhibition of de novo protein synthesis. In contrast, PEA did not cause vasorelaxation of the rat aorta. This is in agreement with our previous finding that the PPARα ligand, bezafibrate, does not cause time-dependent vasorelaxation of isolated aortae [13]. These results demonstrate that PPARγ-, but not PPARα-active endocannabinoids cause time-dependent vascular effects.
Some of the vasorelaxant effects of cannabinoids are due to activation of other target sites such as the CB 1 or CB 2 receptor [27], and we explored whether the vasorelaxant response to endocannabinoids might be partially mediated by any of these. We found that neither the CB 1 nor CB 2 receptor antagonists had any significant effect on vasorelaxation to anandamide. However, vasorelaxation to NADA was inhibited by the CB 1 receptor antagonist, AM251. It is possible, therefore, that NADA may activate cannabinoid receptors at the cell surface, initiating intracellular signalling that may lead to PPARγ activation. For example, it has been shown that statins activate PPARs through activation of extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK)1/2 and p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) [28]. Both of these pathways can be activated by cannabinoid receptor activation [29,30].
Further analysis of the time-dependent vasorelaxant effects of anandamide and NADA showed that these responses are partially endothelium-dependent and NOdependent, as previously demonstrated for rosiglitazone and THC [13,26]. We have also previously demonstrated that the PPARγ-mediated vascular effects of cannabinoids are due to increases in SOD activity [13,19]. Similarly, in the present study, the time-dependent effects of anandamide and NADA were abolished in the presence of a SOD inhibitor, DETCA, suggesting the vasorelaxant effects of anandamide and NADA are mediated by upregulation of SOD, preventing NO of being scavenged by endogenous superoxides. This is in agreement with other work showing PPARγ ligands cause the induction of Cu/Zn-SOD [20], and with numerous studies that have shown that PPARγ ligands increase NO production and bioavailability in vitro and in vivo [31][32][33][34].
There are several potential mechanisms by which cannabinoids can activate PPARγ including direct binding, metabolism to other compounds that activate PPARs, or via intracellular signalling cascades. To establish whether endocannabinoids are metabolised into PPARγ-active compounds, we performed some experiments in the presence of the FAAH inhibitor, URB597. The vasorelaxant effects of anandamide were not affected by URB597, which is consistent with previous studies showing that anandamide directly binds to PPARγ [16,17]. It also suggests that prolonging the effects of anandamide by preventing its breakdown does not enhance the PPARγ-mediated vasorelaxant response. By contrast, the vasorelaxant effects of NADA were inhibited by URB597, suggesting that it is the conversion of this compound to PPARγ-active metabolites that mediate the effects of NADA. There are no data presently available demonstrating a direct interaction between NADA and the PPARγ ligand binding domain.
In summary, these data provide evidence for the first time that the endocannabinoids anandamide and NADA, but not the related acylethanolamide PEA, activate PPARγ in the vasculature, leading to NO-dependent vasorelaxation. PPARγ agonists have a number of positive cardiovascular effects, which include increased availability of NO, in vivo reductions in blood pressure and attenuation of atherosclerosis [35][36][37]. Similarly, endocannabinoids have a number of beneficial effects on the cardiovascular system such as cardiac protection [38][39][40], benefits in hypertension [41,42], and potential benefits in atherosclerosis [43]. PPARγ activation by some endocannabinoids may represent a novel mechanism by which they are involved in the regulation of the cardiovascular system.