Stem Cells International
Volume 2020 (2020), Article ID 4242130, 14 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/4242130

Research Article

Human Adipose Derived Cells in Two- and Three-Dimensional Cultures: Functional Validation of an In Vitro Fat Construct

Robert Bender,1,2 Michelle McCarthy,² Theodore Brown,² Joanna Bukowska,2,3 Stanley Smith,¹ Rosalyn D. Abbott,⁴ David L. Kaplan,⁵ Christopher Williams,⁶ James W. Wade,⁷ Andrea Alarcon,¹ Xiying Wu,1,8 Frank Lau,⁹ Jeffrey M. Gimble,1,2,8,10,11,12 and Trivia Frazier1,8,10

¹LaCell LLC, New Orleans LA, USA
²Center for Stem Cell Research and Regenerative Medicine, Tulane University School of Medicine, New Orleans LA, USA
³Polish Academy of Science, Olsztyn, Poland
⁴Department of Biomedical Engineering, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh PA, USA
⁵Departments of Biomedical Engineering and Chemical and Biological Engineering, Bioengineering and Biotechnology Center, Tufts University, Medford MA, USA
⁶Department of Pharmacology, Xavier University of Louisiana, New Orleans LA, USA
⁷Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Baton Rouge LA, USA
⁸Obatala Sciences Inc., New Orleans LA, USA
⁹LSU Department of Plastic Surgery, New Orleans, LA, USA
¹⁰Department of Structural and Cell Biology, Tulane University School of Medicine, New Orleans LA, USA
¹¹Department of Medicine, Tulane University School of Medicine, New Orleans LA, USA
¹²Department of Surgery, Tulane University School of Medicine, New Orleans LA, USA

Correspondence should be addressed to Robert Bender; robertjbender@gmail.com and Michelle McCarthy; mmccart@tulane.edu

Received 19 September 2019; Revised 20 January 2020; Accepted 13 March 2020; Published 10 June 2020

Guest Editor: Ali Mobasheri

Copyright © 2020 Robert Bender et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract.

Obesity, defined as a body mass index of 30 kg/m² or above, has increased considerably in incidence and frequency within the United States and globally. Associated comorbidities including cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes mellitus, metabolic syndrome, and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease have led to a focus on the mechanisms promoting the prevention and treatment of obesity. Commonly utilized in vitro models employ human or mouse preadipocyte cell lines in a 2-dimensional (2D) format. Due to the structural, biochemical, and biological limitations of these models, increased attention has been placed on “organ on a chip” technologies for a 3-dimensional (3D) culture. Herein, we describe a method employing cryopreserved primary human stromal vascular fraction (SVF) cells and a human blood product-derived biological scaffold to create a 3D adipose depot in vitro. The “fat-on-chip” 3D cultures have been validated relative to 2D cultures based on proliferation, flow cytometry, adipogenic differentiation, confocal microscopy/immunofluorescence, and functional assays (adipokine secretion, glucose uptake, and lipolysis). Thus, the in vitro culture system demonstrates the critical characteristics required for a humanized 3D white adipose tissue (WAT) model.

1. Introduction

Obesity is defined as a body mass index (BMI), calculated as (, of 30 or above [1]. This condition can be the consequence of both hyperplasia and hypertrophy of mature adipocytes and their progenitor stromal/stem cells within adipose tissue depots [1]. According to the Centers for Disease Control, the past three decades have witnessed a considerable increase in the incidence and frequency of obesity in the United States where levels of >35% exist in some states (http://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data). While few other countries approach this level of obesity, many are experiencing alarming increases due to changes in diet, exercise, and lifestyle. Since obesity is accompanied by comorbidities including cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes mellitus, metabolic syndrome, and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, the international scientific community has focused its attention on the mechanisms promoting the prevention and treatment of obesity [1]. In vitro models employ preadipocyte cell lines, such as 3T3-L1, or primary adipose-derived stromal/stem cells (ASC) derived from rodent or human adipose tissue [2–4]. Over a one- to two-week period, these cultures undergo robust adipogenesis in response to inductive cocktails containing glucocorticoid and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor γ (PPARγ) ligands, a phosphodiesterase inhibitor to elevate cyclic AMP levels, and insulin. Nevertheless, a recent comprehensive scholarly review has concluded that there is a pressing need to improve preadipocyte models in order to enhance discoveries relating to adipocyte biology and dysfunction in obesity research [5].

While the majority of in vitro studies have employed a 2-dimensional (2D) format, this structural approach fails to mimic the native 3-dimensional (3D) microenvironment. Mature adipocytes in vivo are surrounded on all sides by a biomechanically supportive extracellular matrix (ECM) and display a classical “signet ring” morphology, characterized by a single unilocular lipid vacuole occupying the entire cytoplasmic space with an eccentric nucleus. In contrast, adipocytes in 2D cultures in vitro display multilocular lipid vacuoles scattered throughout the cytoplasm around a centrally located nucleus. Morphological differences appear to correlate with functional differences. For example, when human ASC are maintained in 3D spheroids in vitro, their adipokine secretion is an order of magnitude greater than an equivalent number of ASC in 2D cultures [6].

Increased attention to “organ on a chip” technologies has promoted advances in 3D culture approaches for adipose tissue and cells [7–10]. These approaches combine murine cell lines (3T3-L1) or primary murine or human ASC with biomaterial scaffolds derived from hyaluronic acid or silk to create in vitro or in vivo microphysiological systems that mimic either white or beige/brown adipose tissue [7–10]. In a recent report, Lau et al. described a method for maintenance of human adipose tissue as “SWAT” or “sandwiched white adipose tissue” cultures [11]. Intact fragments of adipose tissue were maintained for up to 8 weeks in vitro as organoid cultures between sheets of primary cultured human ASC [11]. This method has a value for pathophysiological and pharmacological investigation of primary human adipose tissue. Nevertheless, it does require direct collaboration with a research-oriented plastic or general surgeon and an approved Institutional Review Board protocol. For laboratories located on campuses without a medical school or research hospital, these restrictions may make the SWAT approach impractical. Therefore, the current study was undertaken to provide an alternative 3D human adipose model for this segment of the research community.

This manuscript describes a method employing cryopreserved primary human stromal vascular fraction (SVF) cells and a human blood product-derived biological scaffold to create a xenoprotein-free 3D adipose depot in vitro that is suitable for investigating human adipose biology. The construct is established using cryopreserved human SVF cells which contain heterogeneous subpopulations of viable cells that are representative of individual donor demographics. The resulting adipose constructs self-assemble into spheroids within 1 week of culture without the need for laborious or expensive protocols and have been validated relative to 2D cultures based on flow cytometry, confocal and cryogenic electron microscopy/immunofluorescence, in vivo behavior, and functional assays (adipokine secretion, glucose uptake, and lipolysis).

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. General

Unless otherwise noted, all materials were obtained from Thermo Fisher Scientific and its subsidiary companies or from LaCell LLC. Specimens of human lipoaspirate were donated by healthy individuals undergoing elective liposuction with written informed consent under a protocol reviewed and approved by the Western Institutional Review Board (WIRB, Puyallup WA) (IRB Tracking # 20130449).

2.2. Stromal Vascular Fraction (SVF) Cell Isolation

Human SVF cells were isolated from lipoaspirate specimens of subcutaneous adipose tissue by enzymatic digestion using collagenase type 1 (Worthington Biochemical, Lakewood, NJ) according to published protocols [12, 13]. The resulting SVF cell viability and quantification were determined using Live/Dead Solution assay (LaCell Catalog # LaLD-2) and fluorescent microscopy hemocytometer inspection.

2.3. Cell Proliferation Assay

Immediately after thawing, metabolically active SVF cells were quantified with using an ethidium bromide/acridine orange-based Live/Dead Solution (LaCell Catalog # LaLD-2) viability staining protocol. Cells were then plated in triplicate at a concentration of 64,000 cells/well in a 96-well culture plate with 1 mL of culture medium supplemented with the corresponding amount of ObaGel™ (LaCell Catalog # LaObG-10) (0% for cultures and silk scaffolds, 7.5% for gel). Cells were cultured for 3, 5, and 7 days. After culture, cells were incubated with 20 μL Cell Titer Blue working reagent which was added to wells for four hours. Fluorescence was quantified using an excitation wavelength of 560 nm and an emission wavelength of 590 nm. Control scaffolds and wells were analyzed similarly to adjust for background fluorescence.

2.4. Colony-Forming Unit Fibroblast (CFU-F)

Immediately after thawing, metabolically active cells were quantified using an ethidium bromide/acridine orange Live/Dead Solution (LaCell Catalog # LaLD-2) viability staining protocol. Cells were then plated in 100 mm culture dishes at a concentration of 50 or 100 cells/plate in LaCell Stromal Medium (LaCell Catalog # LaSM-500) and fed every 3 days. After 12-14 days, cultures were fixed in formalin and stained using a Toluidine Blue Staining Solution (LaCell Catalog # LaTB-50) protocol.

2.5. Adipogenic Differentiation

For 2-dimensional cultures, immediately after thawing, cells were seeded into 24-well plates at a concentration of cells/cm² for 24 hours to allow for cell attachment. After the overnight incubation, medium was removed, replaced with fresh AdipoQual™ Medium (LaCell Catalog # LaADM-500), and fed with the same medium every 3 days for up to two weeks.

2.6. ObaGel 3D Static Adipogenic Cultures

For 3-dimensional cultures using ObaGel, a summary figure has been provided to represent the overall process for developing static fat-on-a-chip cultures (see ObaGel Figure 1). ObaGel is a thermoresponsive gel that self-assembles into a complex, self-assembling tissue matrix with a structure that is driven by cell-mediated extracellular matrix remodeling. Briefly, ObaGel was thawed overnight on ice (4°C) and diluted with StromaQual (LaCell Catalog # LaSM-500) media to desired concentrations (0% to 25% ()). SVF cells were isolated from digested subcutaneous adipose tissue according to published protocols and as described in Stromal Vascular Fraction (SVF) Cell Isolation above. Cells were mixed with the ObaGel/medium mixture at desired concentrations and immediately seeded into 24-well multidishes in 1 mL volumes, or as indicated for each study. The cell suspension was pipetted directly into the wells according to the desired volume per well. Matrix polymerization occurred immediately after transfer to 37°C cell culture incubators. Cells/ObaGel mixtures, referred to as ObaCell™, were cultured for two weeks to allow cell-mediated matrix remodeling, robust growth, and priming for adipose tissue functionality. Constructs were then induced along the adipogenic lineage with exposure to AdipoQual (LaCell Catalog # LaADM-500) medium supplemented with ObaGel at the same indicated concentrations per study (see Cell Proliferation Assay,, Functional Analytical Assays (Glucose Uptake, Lipolysis, and Adipokine Secretion), and Confocal and Electron Microscopy).

Figure 1: Summary figure representing the overall process for developing static fat-on-a-chip cultures using ObaGel.

2.7. Oil Red O Staining

Intracytoplasmic lipid deposition was assessed using an Oil Red O Staining Solution (LaCell Catalog # LaORO-50) protocol: Cells cultured for 3 days in 24-well plates were first rinsed with PBS thrice and then fixed for 15 minutes with 10% () formalin solution. Monolayers were then washed three times with PBS to remove formalin solution. Fixed monolayers were then incubated for 45 minutes at room temperature with the ORO Staining Solution. After 45 minutes, excess staining solution was aspirated and monolayers were rinsed four times with PBS to remove any remaining staining solution. The ORO-stained monolayers were visualized using phase contrast microscopy (Motic AE2000, Richmond, British Columbia, Canada).

2.8. BODIPY Staining

For ObaCell cultures, accumulated lipid was also visualized using BODIPY lipophilic fluorescent staining. ObaCell cultures were fixed in 10% buffered neutral formalin overnight at 4° Celsius and rinsed with distilled water. BODIPY working solution was added to cultures and incubated for an additional 24 hours. Cultures were rinsed with distilled water and counterstained with Hoechst nuclear dye according to the manufacturer’s protocol. Images were taken using confocal laser microscopy.

2.9. Functional Analytical Assays (Glucose Uptake, Lipolysis, and Adipokine Secretion)

ObaCell cultures were established according to Methods in Cell Culture in 2- and 3-Dimensional Configurations. 100 μL of the conditioned medium from ObaCell cultures was collected at days 7, 14, 21, and 28 ( replicates per sample condition) and transferred to 96-well dishes for assays. Protocols were followed as specified by manufacturers for measuring glucose uptake, lipolysis, adiponectin, or leptin secretion.

2.10. Flow Cytometry: 2D SVF Cultures

Single-cell suspensions were prepared according to a standard protocol for 2D cultures and ObaGel 3D static cultures. For 2D cultures, 10⁶ SVF cells were plated in T-75 flasks and cultured in control or differentiation medium. The SVF were then resuspended using a standard trypsin-EDTA protocol, washed with prechilled phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) supplemented with 1% bovine serum albumin (BSA), distributed into separate Eppendorf tubes, and incubated with an antibody in darkness for 30 minutes. Following the incubation periods, cells were washed with PBS three times and fixed using 10% formalin. Samples were analyzed using a FACSCalibur cytometer (Becton Dickinson Immunocytometry Systems). The following markers were analyzed: CD29+/CD105+/CD45-/CD34+/CD73+/CD90+.

2.11. Flow Cytometry: ObaGel Cultures

ObaGel cultures were established using the methods described in ObaGel 3D Static Adipogenic Cultures above. Cells were cultured and harvested at the time points indicated per study by adding an Obazyme digestion agent (Obatala Sciences Catalog # ObaZYM-15) directly to the wells in a 1 : 1 ratio with ObaCell static culture volumes for 15 minutes for one-day cultures and up to one hour for two-week established cultures. The resulting single-cell suspensions were collected, centrifuged at 300 x g (1200 rpm) for 5 minutes, and resuspended in PBS supplemented with 1% BSA. Cells were then distributed into separate Eppendorf tubes and incubated with the same antibodies and protocol indicated above in Flow Cytometry: 2D SVF Cultures.

2.12. Confocal and Electron Microscopy

Confocal microscopy was performed on ObaGel- and silk-based in vitro adipogenic differentiated constructs (see Adipogenic Differentiation) and explants following 6-week in vivo implantation and staining with BODIPY lipophilic dye. Confocal research was conducted using a Nikon A1 LASER Ti-E microscope system. The tissue was imaged in Nunc 35 mm glass bottom dishes, at 10x and 20x oil-free objectives, using the FITC and DAPI LASERs. Cryoscanning electron microscopy was conducted on ObaGel constructs and silk scaffolds that were seeded with human SVF cells following a 2-week adipogenic differentiation. Cryo-SEM structure research was done with Gatan 2500 alto Cryo-system and Hitachi S-4800 SEM. The tissue was cut to (mm) and laid about 5 mm high above a cryogenic SEM sample holder surface, clamped and glued into the holder, and then frozen in slushed liquid nitrogen at approximately -210°C for about 30 seconds. The frozen tissue was transferred in vacuum to the prechamber attached to the SEM and then fractured and sublimed for 5 minutes at -95°C. After coating for 88 seconds at -130°C with Pt/Pd, the sample was moved to the SEM and observed at 3 kV at -130°C.

2.13. Cell Profiler Image Analysis

Image analysis was performed using CellProfiler v2.2.0. Raw images from all image sets were imported into CellProfiler and then separated into discrete DAPI and FITC channels. For each channel, the total image intensity was measured using the MeasureImageIntensity module. Individual image sets were then run through a series of modules to identify the objects in them.

For the 2D versus 3D culture image set, the DAPI channel was run through the IdentifyPrimaryObjects module using a global threshold strategy and an Otsu three-class thresholding method with pixels from the middle intensity assigned to the background. Intensity was used to distinguish individual objects after thresholding. The FITC channel from the same set was run through the IdentifyPrimaryObjects module with the same settings, except that a Laplacian of Gaussian method was used to distinguish between objects after thresholding and the resulting shapes were used to draw dividing lines.

For the white three-dimensional culture image set, the DAPI and FITC channels were subtracted from each other using the ImageMath module to improve contrast. Both the DAPI minus FITC and the unaltered DAPI channels from this set were then run through the IdentifyPrimaryObjects module using an adaptive threshold strategy and an Otsu three-class thresholding method with pixels from the middle intensity assigned to the background. The FITC minus DAPI image set and the unaltered FITC channels from the white set were run through the IdentifyPrimaryObjects module using a global threshold strategy and an Otsu three-class thresholding method with pixels from the middle intensity assigned to the background. The unaltered DAPI and FITC channels were then averaged using the ImageMath module. The resulting images were then run through the IdentifyPrimaryObjects module using an adaptive threshold strategy and an Otsu three-class thresholding method with pixels from the middle intensity assigned to the foreground. All three sets of modules used for the white image set used intensity to distinguish individual objects after thresholding.

For the silk- versus ObaGel-based fat formation image set, the DAPI channel was run through the IdentifyPrimaryObjects module using an adaptive robust background thresholding strategy. For this set, intensity was used to identify objects after thresholding and their shape was used to draw dividing lines. The FITC channel from this set was run using a global threshold strategy and an Otsu three-class thresholding method with pixels from the middle intensity assigned to the background. For this set, intensity was used to distinguish individual objects after thresholding.

The image area occupied by identified objects in all image sets was measured using the MeasureImageAreaOccupied modules. Objects touching the border of the image from all images were then discarded, and the remaining objects were quantified with the MeasureObjectIntensity and MeasureObjectSizeShape modules. Images were saved after splitting the channels and each object identification module. Results from all modules were exported to Excel.

2.14. In Vivo 3-Dimensional Construct Implants

Implants were performed using ObaGel or hexafluorisopropanol (HFIP) silk scaffolds (Tufts University Tissue Engineering Research Center, Medford, MA) seeded with or without SVF cells in 6-8-week-old C57BL/6 female mice (Charles River Laboratories, Wilmington, MA) in accordance with a Tulane University Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee reviewed and approved protocol (#4302R; March 16, 2016) as previously described [14]. Studies were conducted in the Tulane University vivarium with veterinary care provided daily by the Department of Comparative Medicine.

2.15. Statistical Analyses

Values are presented as the (SD) unless otherwise noted. Statistical significance was determined based on Student -test and 1-way or 2-way ANOVAs with multiple comparisons tests performed. For multiple comparisons using statistical hypothesis testing, Sidak post tests were used with multiplicity-adjusted values reported, for values < 0.05. Calculations were performed using Prism GraphPad software (La Jolla California, USA).

3. Results

3.1. Immunophenotype of Human SVF Cells

Freshly isolated and cryopreserved human SVF cells ( donors) utilized in the study were characterized on the basis of adipogenic and osteogenic differentiation, colony-forming unit fibroblastic (CFU-F) formation, proliferation, and immunophenotype at passage 0 (P0) of the culture (Figure 2). Our labs have worked extensively with SVF cells and developed standard operating procedures to characterize the subpopulations that exist within this heterogeneous fraction (Frazier et al. 2018). The donors had a mean age (± SD) of years and a mean body mass index (± SD) of  kg/m². Donor immunophenotypes consisted of hematopoietic/stromal (CD90: ), cell-cell and cell-surface adhesion (CD29: ; CD44: %), leukocyte common antigen (CLA; CD45: %), and stem/progenitor (CD34: %; CD73: , and CD105: %) markers immediately postthaw.

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

(e)

Figure 2: Demographic characteristics of donors and SVF cells utilized in the study. Human SVF cells were characterized on the basis of (a) adipogenic and osteogenic differentiation, (b) donor demographics, (c) colony formation, (d) proliferation, and (e) cell immunophenotype. Donor demographics are as follows (in ): age (), body mass index (BMI ).

3.2. Polymerization of ObaGel as a Thermoresponsive Gel Is a Cell-Driven Process

Studies investigating the correlation of cell seeding density and ObaGel concentration to gel stability were performed (Figure 3(a)). ObaGel cultures were seeded in increased concentrations, ranging from 500 to 20 k cells per cm² of 24-well multiwells. Gel stability was measured by observing the number of wells with gels maintained at a consistent volume postseeding, divided by the total number of seeded wells, and reported as a percentage (%) total gelling. 100% gel formation was maintained in 7.5% ObaGel-supplemented medium (), in the absence of any additional supplementary growth factors (Figures 3(a) and 3(d)).

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Figure 3: Temporal immunophenotype and gelling behavior of SVF cells cultured in 3 dimensions in human-derived ObaGel. Studies investigating the correlation of cell seeding density and ObaGel concentration to gel stability were performed (a), and whole plate images were taken (b). Gel stability was measured and reported as a percentage (%) total gelling. Investigations into impact on SVF immunophenotype from freshly isolated SVF cells compared to ObaGel cultures at days 1 and 7 (c). 100% gel formation was maintained in 7.5% ObaGel-supplemented medium (), in the absence of any additional supplementary growth factors (d). Values reported as . .

3.3. Immunophenotype of ObaGel-Cultured Human SVF Cells

Flow-based immunophenotyping of SVF cells cultured in 7.5% ObaGel determined that the cells remained viable and continued to display heterogeneity (Figure 3(c)). Compared to the immunophenotype of freshly thawed cells, the expressions of antigens associated with myeloid (CD19), stem/progenitor (CD34), preadipocyte (CD36), hematopoietic (CLA; CD45), pericytic (CD146), and lymphoid (CD3) identity were not significantly different after cryopreservation, thawing, and culturing in ObaGel for one-week postseeding. In contrast, SVF cells significantly upregulated the expression of CD31, a marker of endothelial progenitors (freshly thawed SVF: % vs. day 7 ObaGel culture: %), and significantly downregulated the expression of CD73, a marker of lymphocytic differentiation (freshly thawed SVF: % vs. day 7 ObaGel culture: ).

3.4. 3D Culture in ObaGel Stimulates Robust Human SVF Cell Proliferation and Self-Assembly into Spheroids

Cellular proliferation was substantially higher in ObaGel compared to traditional 2D culture in medium supplemented with fetal bovine serum (Figure 4(a)). Further investigation into the impact of ObaGel on SVF cell behavior revealed a concentration-dependent development of spheroids upon exposure to lower concentrations of ObaGel, as early as 5 to 7 days of culture (Figure 4(c)). Spheroid size and volume were increased as a function of ObaGel concentration between percentages of 0.25% and 0.75%. Adherent cell populations decreased with increasing ObaGel concentrations, reflecting an indirect relationship existing between cell attachment and ObaGel concentration (data not shown). Adipogenic differentiation of the ObaGel cultures revealed an ability to induce a robust intracytoplasmic lipid accumulation within the adipose stromal/stem populations in spheroids at low ObaGel concentrations in cultures (Figure 4(d)).

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Figure 4: Comparison of SVF proliferation, spheroid volume and formation, and adipogenic functionality in 2D culture and ObaGel. (a) Bright field and confocal microscopy images of SVF cell proliferation in 2D culture and ObaGel. Cells were seeded in traditional 2D media or ObaGel, cultured for 5 days, and stained with the Hoechst dye. Robust cell proliferation occurs in ObaGel compared to 2D culture, as indicated by Hoechst positivity. (b, c) report photomicrographs and respective quantification that reflect a positive correlation between ObaGel concentration and SVF spheroid size, density, and volume within 5-7 days of culture. (d) demonstrates that adipogenesis occurs within spheroids as early as day 3 of differentiation. Values reported as . when compared to the freshly thawed cells or silk constructs.

3.5. Compared to 2D Culture and Silk Scaffolds, ObaGel Supports Robust Lipid Accumulation, More Complex Network Formation, and Maintenance of a Cell Surface Antigen Profile Similar to Freshly Isolated SVF Cells

Previous 3D adipose studies conducted by our lab and our collaborators employed hexafluoro-isopropyl- (HFIP-) treated silk porous scaffolds to support the growth and adipogenic differentiation of SVF cells for an in vitro adipose tissue model [14–16]. The present study extended these observations by comparing the behavior of human SVF cells when cultured in 2-dimensional conditions and in 3-dimensions when seeded on either silk scaffolds or cultured in ObaGel for 2 weeks. SVF cell immunophenotype, adipogenic capacity, and adipokine functionality were investigated (Figure 5). At two weeks postseeding, undifferentiated SVF cells demonstrated robust differences in proliferation, similar to observations in Figure 3. Cell-mediated matrix remodeling was supported in ObaGel cultures, where complex networks were formed as early as 8-10 days (Figure 5(a), ObaGel confocal image). Formed networks increased their complexity and size by 14 days of culture (Figure 5(a)). This phenomenon was also noted to be dependent on ObaGel concentration, initially appearing at concentrations as low as 1.5% (; data not shown). Likewise, intracytoplasmic lipid accumulation was significantly higher in ObaGel cultures compared to 2D cultures (Figure 5(a)). Lipid droplets were observed near the top of ObaGel cultures and continuing to accumulate in number, starting from day 5.

(a)

(b)

(c)

Figure 5: A comparison of the in vitro behavior of human SVF cells when cultured in 2-dimensional conditions and in 3 dimensions when seeded on either silk scaffolds or cultured in ObaGel for 2 weeks. (a) Confocal and cryoscanning electron microscopy (cryo-SEM) images of SVF cell seeding, proliferation, and adipogenic differentiation behavior in traditional 2D culture, silk scaffolds, and ObaGel. (b) SVF immunophenotype following 1 week of culture reveals that ObaGel is superior in maintaining a heterogenic immunophenotype similar to freshly isolated cells and supports the expansion of CD44-positive subpopulations (b), and adipokine functionality (c) reports the measure of leptin secretion from adipogenic differentiated cells seeded on silk or with ObaGel are early (day 3) and late (day 28) time points of differentiation. Immunophenotype values reported as (SD). .

Similar to previous characterization studies (Figure 3), ObaGel did not significantly impact SVF heterogeneity. Compared to the immunophenotype of freshly thawed cells, the expression of antigens associated with all of the lineages immunoassayed was significantly decreased in silk after 2 weeks of culture (Figure 5(b)). In comparison, ObaGel a higher degree of SVF heterogeneity, with a significant increase in the expression of the stromal marker CD44 and decreases in the expressions of pericytic (CD146), lymphoid (CD3), and lymphoid differentiation (CD73) markers (Figure 5(b)). Similar to previous reports, adipokine secretion was supported during early adipogenesis in silk. However, ObaGel cultures secreted higher levels of leptin than silk 3D cultures at both early (day 3: silk,  pg/mL; ObaGel,  pg/mL) and late (day 28: silk,  pg/mL; ObaGel,  pg/mL) time points.

3.6. ObaGel Cultures Exhibit Adipose Functionality Relative to Physiologically Relevant Adipose Explants and In Vivo Serum Levels

Adiponectin (AdN) and leptin (Lep) secretions were measured from 2D cell cultures compared to ObaGel cultures after 21 days of culture. ObaGel cultures consistently secreted higher adipokine levels compared to 2D cultures, both in the case of AdN (2D: ; ObaGel: ; Figure 6(a)) and Lep (2D: ; ObaGel: ; Figure 6(a)). AdN serum concentrations in humans are reported in the literature as a median of 41.47 ng/mL (41,470 pg/mL), with a range of 6.01 ng/mL-145.40 ng/mL (6,010 pg/mL–145,400 pg/mL) [17]. Lep serum concentrations in humans are reported in the literature as a median of 221.85 pg/mL, with a range of 45.68 pg/mL–894.5 pg/mL [17]. ObaGel culture functionality was further investigated with measurement of glycerol secretion in the conditioned medium after 14 days of culture. Free glycerol levels were substantially higher in ObaGel cultures compared to 2D cultures (2D: ; ObaGel: ; Figure 5(b)). In comparison, detected glycerol levels from excised murine adipose was averaged at 276 μM.

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Figure 6: ObaGel cultures exhibit physiologically relevant functionality. Adiponectin (AdN) and leptin (Lep) secretions were measured from traditional cell cultures (2D) compared to three-dimensional adipose cultures (ObaCell) after 21 days of culture. Values reported are in pg/mL conditioned medium and are reported as (SD). . Adipose tissue functionality demonstrated with measurement of glycerol secretion in a conditioned medium from cells differentiated in two dimensions (2D) compared to ObaGel after 14 days of culture. ObaGel cultures demonstrated higher sensitivity to AMPK-targeting compounds isoproterenol, metformin, compound C, and IBMX. Values reported are in pg/mL conditioned medium and are reported as (SD). .

3.7. ObaGel Cultures Exhibit Increased Sensitivity to AMPK-Targeting Compounds Prescribed for Regulating Insulin Sensitivity

In the absence of any compounds, ObaGel 3D cultures demonstrated higher functionality as measured by 2-deoxy-D-glucose uptake activity (2D: ; ObaGel: ; Figure 6(c)). Further studies evaluated ObaGel cultures treated with AMPK-activating compounds isoproterenol and metformin, and an AMPK inhibitor, compound C (Dorsomorphin). Exposure to the compounds revealed increased sensitivity in ObaGel cultures compared to 2D (Figure 6(c)), at doses reported to correlate with pharmacologically relevant levels found in the literature. Compound C significantly attenuated 2-DG6P detection by 9% compared to baseline and by 36% compared to metformin-mediated glucose uptake (Figure 6(c)). Likewise, ObaGel cultures demonstrated significantly higher glycerol secretion at both baseline levels (2D: vs. ObaGel: ; Figure 6(d)), and when stimulated by isoproterenol (2D: vs. ObaGel, ; Figure 6(d)).

3.8. ObaGel Demonstrates Robust Vascular Potential In Vivo

We investigated the ability of human SVF cells to form functional fat in nude mice when seeded in ObaGel as compared to silk sponge scaffolds (Figure 7). Negative controls included injections of ObaGel alone or empty silk scaffolds. Scaffolds remained in mice for 6 weeks, similar to previously published silk adipose construct studies [14]. Hematoxylin and eosin staining revealed a dense confinement of proliferating cells within the silk scaffolds. In contrast, ObaGel implants contained larger structures that were clearly integrated functionally within larger, more mature adipocytes (Figure 7).

Figure 7: Implantation of ObaGel for the development of a humanized fat pad in mice. Scaffolds remained in mice for 6 weeks. Hematoxylin and eosin staining revealed a dense confinement of proliferating cells within the silk scaffolds. In contrast, ObaGel implants contained large blood vessels that were clearly integrated functionally within larger, more mature adipocytes.

3.9. In Vivo Analysis of Implants of Human SVF Cell ObaGel Constructs in Immunodeficient Mice

BODIPY lipophilic staining was performed in explants removed from nude mice following 6-week implantation. Images were taken by confocal laser microscopy and quantified using CellProfiler v2.2.0 software. Control implants were ObaGel implants injected in the absence of cells. Quantified results demonstrate the presence of significantly larger adipocytes that contained larger nuclear areas within ObaGel/SVF explants compared to ObaGel control explants (Figure 8).

Figure 8: In vivo analysis of implants of human SVF cell ObaGel constructs in immunodeficient mice. BODIPY lipophilic staining was performed in explants removed from nude mice following 6-week implantation. Images were taken by confocal laser microscopy and quantified using CellProfiler v2.2.0 software. Values reported are in pg/mL conditioned medium and are reported as (SD). .

4. Discussion

International regulatory agencies have begun to advocate for the increased incorporation of 3D human cell-based models as a central screening assay within the pharmaceutical drug discovery process [18]. It is anticipated that such 3D models will reduce the reliance on in vivo animal models while increasing the efficiency for the identification of effective therapeutic target compounds [19]. As a result, investigators have begun to combine natural or synthetic scaffolds with primary human tissue-derived cells to create novel 3D organoids. The current manuscript demonstrates the utility and functionality of a 3D construct containing both primary human adipose-derived cells and a natural scaffold as an in vitro model for adipose tissue depots (Figure 2). Based on morphological criteria, the ObaGel scaffold was superior to a silk scaffold in supporting the adipogenic differentiation of human SVF cells. The ObaGel in the presence of SVF cells promoted the formation of vascular-like structures within the 3D constructs and gelled in a time- and concentration-dependent manner. Throughout a one-week period, adipose-derived SVF cells within the ObaGel constructs continued to express surface antigens associated with stem cell (CD34), endothelial cell (CD31), and ASC (CD73) phenotypes. Relative to 2D cultures, SVF cells in 3D ObaGel constructs displayed increased adipogenesis based on both number and lipid vacuole size, consistent with the differentiation of mature “signet ring” adipocytes. Likewise, the 3D ObaGel constructs were superior to 2D cultures with respect to glucose uptake and adipokine (leptin) secretion as well as lipolytic response to agents such as isoproterenol, metformin, and compound C. In the presence of selective inductive cocktails, the SVF cells in 3D ObaGel constructs expressed biomarkers consistent with white adipose tissue (WAT) depots. Together, this data documents the efficacy and utility of reagents and methods for the reproducible construction of 3D scaffolds displaying features of human adipose depots suitable for pharmaceutical and metabolic in vitro studies.

Prior studies have reported protocols to culture 3D human adipose depots in vitro. Among the most well-established models has been the maintenance of intact adipose tissue fragments by a variety of culture methods as described by Fried, Lau, Miyazaki, and others [11, 20–22]. In these methods, adipose tissue is minced into cubes of 1-2 mm in any dimension and incubated as suspensions forced below the surface of the culture medium by a screen, as explant “ceiling cultures” within flasks completely filled with medium, in the presence of continuous agitation, or sandwiched between layers of culture expanded ASC. These models rely on the investigator’s ready access to freshly isolated adipose tissue specimens from donors of appropriate demographic characteristics (BMI, age, gender, ethnicity, and disease status). While a number of studies have demonstrated the feasibility of cryopreserving intact adipose tissue fragments for extended periods of time, only ~50% of the SVF cell population within these tissues remain viable [23]. This contrasts with cryopreservation of isolated SVF cells and ASC which retain postthaw viability levels of 80% or better, depending on the isolation process and cryopreservation agent [23–27]. It is noteworthy that in the current study, the SVF cell immunophenotype differed between freshly prepared and cryopreserved/thawed cells. While there is clear utility for the cryopreserved SVF cells and tissues, each may face some limitations.

Likewise, multiple independent investigators have employed spheroids as an in vitro 3D culture model [6, 28–31]. While spheroids could be prepared using hanging drop methods and low adhesion tissue culture surfaces, they could also be obtained using polymer microparticles [6, 28, 30, 31]. These studies further demonstrated that 3D spheroids secreted significantly greater quantities of adipokines [28] and wound healing-associated proteins [6] relative to 2D cultures containing comparable total cell numbers. Additionally, the adipose-derived cells in the 3D spheroids displayed superior brown adipogenesis relative to 2D culture models [28]. Alternative 3D culture methods, including bioprinting, have likewise displayed superior brown adipogenesis relative to 2D systems in vitro [32–34]. Several natural and synthetic biomaterials have been used here to support 3D adipogenic constructs in vitro. A growing body of literature has evaluated decellularized adipose tissue extracellular matrix as a biomaterial scaffold to promote 3D models for both brown and white adipogenesis [35–43]. Likewise, 3D silk scaffolds in combination with adipose-derived cells have been demonstrated to support adipogenesis [7, 14–16, 44–47].

While the current study validates the utility of ObaGel and SVF cells as an in vitro human adipose depot model, further studies are needed. In addition to the current work’s examination of the 3D model’s response to metformin and isoproterenol, the system needs to be tested more thoroughly with a wider panel of drugs with established pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic profiles in adipose tissue. While the system has been established firmly using SVF cells isolated from subcutaneous adipose depots, similar analyses should be performed using SVF cells isolated from adipose depots in the viscera, omentum, and around vital organs. Likewise, studies need to be performed evaluating the differentiation of human SVF cells in ObaGel along the beige/brown adipocyte lineage pathway. Moreover, since human ASC and SVF cells can be differentiated along the chondrogenic, endothelial, and osteogenic lineages, it also remains to be determined if the ObaGel/SVF cell scaffolds can be used to model the bone, cartilage, and/or vascular networks or depots in vitro. Finally, while the current model relies on a static culture system, its performance within a perfusion bioreactor is feasible and needs to be evaluated. These issues provide a potential framework for the design of future experiments employing the human SVF cell and ObaGel constructs as an “off the shelf” system with an extended shelf life that is superior to the more laborious and more expensive methods that rely heavily on superimposed cellular dynamics and plasticware with specialized surface coatings.

5. Conclusions

The current study demonstrates that a combination of primary SVF cells and ObaGel scaffolds can be used to create a 3D in vitro construct with functional properties mimicking a humanized adipose depot. The ready availability of a 3D model as opposed to a 2D adipocyte model offers investigators an alternative model that more closely approximates the in vivo white adipose tissue microenvironment. Further studies will be necessary to characterize the SVF cell/ObaGel model with respect to beige/brown adipose tissue differentiation.

Data Availability

The data used to support the findings of this study are included within the article.

Conflicts of Interest

The following authors state the following conflicts of interest: A. Alarcon, T. Frazier, J. M. Gimble, and X. Wu are all employees of LaCell LLC and Obatala Sciences Inc.; T. Frazier, J.M. Gimble, and X. Wu are cofounders and coowners of Obatala Sciences; J.M. Gimble and X. Wu are coowners and cofounders of LaCell. All remaining authors have no conflicts to declare.

Authors’ Contributions

Robert Bender and Michelle McCarthy contributed equally to this work.

Acknowledgments

The authors wish to thank the following: Dr. Wade’s patients for consenting to generously donate their tissues to this project under an Institutional Review Board approved protocol; his office staff for their time and effort; Hugh Alan Tucker of the flow cytometry core facility, Dina Gaupp of the histology core facility; Gina Dobek DVM, Director, Department of Comparative Medicine, Tulane University, for overseeing the veterinary care of animals involved in the study; and Lifeshare (Shreveport and Baton Rouge LA) for providing qualified expired human blood products. Images in this publication were made possible in part with equipment support from Louisiana Board of Regents Enhancement Grant LEQSF(2013-15)-ENH-TR-18 housed in the Coordinated Instrumentation Facility, Tulane University. This study was supported with resources provided by LaCell LLC and Obatala Sciences Inc.

References

G. A. Bray, K. K. Kim, J. P. H. Wilding, and on behalf of the World Obesity Federation, “Obesity: a chronic relapsing progressive disease process. A position statement of the World Obesity Federation,” Obesity Reviews, vol. 18, no. 7, pp. 715–723, 2017.

H. Hauner, G. Entenmann, M. Wabitsch et al., “Promoting effect of glucocorticoids on the differentiation of human adipocyte precursor cells cultured in a chemically defined medium,” The Journal of Clinical Investigation, vol. 84, no. 5, pp. 1663–1670, 1989.

H. Green and O. Kehinde, “An established preadipose cell line and its differentiation in culture II. Factors affecting the adipose conversion,” Cell, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 19–27, 1975.

P. Bourin, B. A. Bunnell, L. Casteilla et al., “Stromal cells from the adipose tissue-derived stromal vascular fraction and culture expanded adipose tissue-derived stromal/stem cells: a joint statement of the International Federation for Adipose Therapeutics and Science (IFATS) and the International Society for Cellular Therapy (ISCT),” Cytotherapy, vol. 15, no. 6, pp. 641–648, 2013.

H. Sadie-Van Gijsen, “Adipocyte biology: it is time to upgrade to a new model,” Journal of Cellular Physiology, vol. 234, no. 3, pp. 2399–2425, 2019.

P. J. Amos, S. K. Kapur, P. C. Stapor et al., “Human adipose-derived stromal cells accelerate diabetic wound Healing: Impact of Cell Formulation and Delivery,” Tissue engineering. Part A, vol. 16, no. 5, pp. 1595–1606, 2010.

E. Bellas, K. G. Marra, and D. L. Kaplan, “Sustainable three-dimensional tissue model of human adipose tissue,” Tissue Eng Part C Methods, vol. 19, no. 10, pp. 745–754, 2013.

J. H. Choi, J. M. Gimble, G. Vunjak-Novakovic, and D. L. Kaplan, “Effects of hyperinsulinemia on lipolytic function of three-dimensional adipocyte/endothelial co-cultures,” Tissue engineering Part C, Methods, vol. 16, no. 5, pp. 1157–1165, 2010.

K. M. Tharp, A. K. Jha, J. Kraiczy et al., “Matrix-assisted transplantation of functional beige adipose tissue,” Diabetes, vol. 64, no. 11, pp. 3713–3724, 2015.

P. Loskill, T. Sezhian, K. M. Tharp et al., “WAT-on-a-chip: a physiologically relevant microfluidic system incorporating white adipose tissue,” Lab on a Chip, vol. 17, no. 9, pp. 1645–1654, 2017.

F. H. Lau, K. Vogel, J. P. Luckett et al., “Sandwiched white adipose tissue: a microphysiological system of primary human adipose tissue,” Tissue engineering Part C, Methods, vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 135–145, 2018.

J. Li, J. L. Curley, Z. E. Floyd, X. Wu, Y. D. C. Halvorsen, and J. M. Gimble, “Isolation of human adipose-derived stem cells from Lipoaspirates,” Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 1773, pp. 155–165, 2018.

G. Yu, X. Wu, M. A. Dietrich et al., “Yield and characterization of subcutaneous human adipose-derived stem cells by flow cytometric and adipogenic mRNA analyzes,” Cytotherapy, vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 538–546, 2010.

T. P. Frazier, A. Bowles, S. Lee et al., “Serially transplanted nonpericytic CD146(-) adipose stromal/stem cells in silk bioscaffolds regenerate adipose tissue in vivo,” Stem Cells, vol. 34, no. 4, pp. 1097–1111, 2016.

R. D. Abbott, W. K. Raja, R. Y. Wang et al., “Long term perfusion system supporting adipogenesis,” Methods, vol. 84, pp. 84–89, 2015.

R. D. Abbott, R. Y. Wang, M. R. Reagan et al., “The use of silk as a scaffold for mature, sustainable unilocular adipose 3D tissue engineered systems,” Advanced Healthcare Materials, vol. 5, no. 13, pp. 1667–1677, 2016.

A. Lubkowska, A. Radecka, I. Bryczkowska, I. Rotter, M. Laszczyńska, and W. Dudzińska, “Serum adiponectin and leptin concentrations in relation to body fat distribution, Hematological indices and lipid profile in humans,” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 12, no. 9, pp. 11528–11548, 2015.

D. R. Jones, “Looking to the future of organ-on-chip and toxicity assessment: a regulator's opinion,” Future Science OA, vol. 2, no. 4, 2016.

R. Prantil-Baun, R. Novak, D. Das, M. R. Somayaji, A. Przekwas, and D. E. Ingber, “Physiologically based pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic analysis enabled by microfluidically linked organs-on-chips,” Annual Review of Pharmacology and Toxicology, vol. 58, pp. 37–64, 2018.

J. Li, H. Li, and W. Tian, “Isolation of murine adipose-derived stromal/stem cells using an explant culture method,” Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 1773, pp. 167–171, 2018.

K. A. Carswell, M. J. Lee, and S. K. Fried, “Culture of isolated human adipocytes and isolated adipose tissue,” Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 806, pp. 203–214, 2012.

T. Miyazaki, Y. Kitagawa, K. Toriyama, M. Kobori, and S. Torii, “Isolation of two human fibroblastic cell populations with multiple but distinct potential of mesenchymal differentiation by ceiling culture of mature fat cells from subcutaneous adipose tissue,” Differentiation, vol. 73, no. 2-3, pp. 69–78, 2005.

F. Zanata, A. Bowles, T. Frazier et al., “Effect of cryopreservation on human adipose tissue and isolated stromal vascular fraction cells: in vitro and in vivo analyses,” Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, vol. 141, no. 2, pp. 232e–243e, 2018.

S. Thirumala, J. M. Gimble, and R. V. Devireddy, “Cryopreservation of stromal vascular fraction of adipose tissue in a serum-free freezing medium,” Journal of Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 224–232, 2010.

S. Thirumala, S. Zvonic, E. Floyd, J. M. Gimble, and R. V. Devireddy, “Effect of various freezing parameters on the immediate post-thaw membrane integrity of adipose tissue derived adult stem cells,” Biotechnology Progress, vol. 21, no. 5, pp. 1511–1524, 2005.

B. C. Goh, S. Thirumala, G. Kilroy, R. V. Devireddy, and J. M. Gimble, “Cryopreservation characteristics of adipose-derived stem cells: maintenance of differentiation potential and viability,” Journal of Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 322–324, 2007.

F. S. Shah, J. Li, F. Zanata et al., “The relative functionality of freshly isolated and cryopreserved human adipose-derived stromal/stem cells,” Cells, Tissues, Organs, vol. 201, no. 6, pp. 436–444, 2016.

A. J. Klingelhutz, F. A. Gourronc, A. Chaly et al., “Scaffold-free generation of uniform adipose spheroids for metabolism research and drug discovery,” Scientific Reports, vol. 8, no. 1, p. 523, 2018.

Y. N. Ma, B. Wang, Z. X. Wang, N. A. Gomez, M. J. Zhu, and M. du, “Three-dimensional spheroid culture of adipose stromal vascular cells for studying adipogenesis in beef cattle,” Animal, vol. 12, no. 10, pp. 2123–2129, 2018.

N. R. Labriola, J. S. Sadick, J. R. Morgan, E. Mathiowitz, and E. M. Darling, “Cell mimicking microparticles influence the organization, growth, and mechanophenotype of stem cell spheroids,” Annals of Biomedical Engineering, vol. 46, no. 8, pp. 1146–1159, 2018.

K. Mineda, J. Feng, H. Ishimine et al., “Therapeutic potential of human adipose-derived stem/stromal cell microspheroids prepared by three-dimensional culture in non-cross-linked hyaluronic acid gel,” Stem Cells Translational Medicine, vol. 4, no. 12, pp. 1511–1522, 2015.

M. Kuss, J. Kim, D. Qi et al., “Effects of tunable, 3D-bioprinted hydrogels on human brown adipocyte behavior and metabolic function,” Acta Biomaterialia, vol. 71, pp. 486–495, 2018.

A. M. Unser, B. Mooney, D. T. Corr, Y. H. Tseng, and Y. Xie, “3D brown adipogenesis to create "Brown-Fat-in-Microstrands",” Biomaterials, vol. 75, pp. 123–134, 2016.

A. M. Unser, Y. Tian, and Y. Xie, “Opportunities and challenges in three-dimensional brown adipogenesis of stem cells,” Biotechnology Advances, vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 962–979, 2015.

C. F. Brown, J. Yan, T. T. Han, D. M. Marecak, B. G. Amsden, and L. E. Flynn, “Effect of decellularized adipose tissue particle size and cell density on adipose-derived stem cell proliferation and adipogenic differentiation in composite methacrylated chondroitin sulphate hydrogels,” Biomedical Materials, vol. 10, no. 4, 2015.

H. K. Cheung, T. T. Han, D. M. Marecak, J. F. Watkins, B. G. Amsden, and L. E. Flynn, “Composite hydrogel scaffolds incorporating decellularized adipose tissue for soft tissue engineering with adipose-derived stem cells,” Biomaterials, vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 1914–1923, 2014.

L. E. Flynn, “The use of decellularized adipose tissue to provide an inductive microenvironment for the adipogenic differentiation of human adipose-derived stem cells,” Biomaterials, vol. 31, no. 17, pp. 4715–4724, 2010.

P. M. Martin, A. Shridhar, C. Yu, C. Brown, and L. E. Flynn, “Decellularized adipose tissue scaffolds for soft tissue regeneration and adipose-derived stem/stromal cell delivery,” Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 1773, pp. 53–71, 2018.

C. Thomas-Porch, J. Li, F. Zanata et al., “Comparative proteomic analyses of human adipose extracellular matrices decellularized using alternative procedures,” Journal of biomedical materials research Part A, vol. 106, no. 9, pp. 2481–2493, 2018.

A. E. Turner, C. Yu, J. Bianco, J. F. Watkins, and L. E. Flynn, “The performance of decellularized adipose tissue microcarriers as an inductive substrate for human adipose-derived stem cells,” Biomaterials, vol. 33, no. 18, pp. 4490–4499, 2012.

J. S. Choi, B. S. Kim, J. Y. Kim et al., “Decellularized extracellular matrix derived from human adipose tissue as a potential scaffold for allograft tissue engineering,” Journal of Biomedical Materials Research Part A, vol. 97A, no. 3, pp. 292–299, 2011.

Y. C. Choi, J. S. Choi, B. S. Kim, J. D. Kim, H. I. Yoon, and Y. W. Cho, “Decellularized extracellular matrix derived from porcine adipose tissue as a xenogeneic biomaterial for tissue engineering,” Tissue engineering Part C, Methods, vol. 18, no. 11, pp. 866–876, 2012.

L. W. Dunne, Z. Huang, W. Meng et al., “Human decellularized adipose tissue scaffold as a model for breast cancer cell growth and drug treatments,” Biomaterials, vol. 35, no. 18, pp. 4940–4949, 2014.

J. H. Choi, E. Bellas, J. M. Gimble, G. Vunjak-Novakovic, and D. L. Kaplan, “Lipolytic function of adipocyte/endothelial cocultures,” Tissue Engineering. Part A, vol. 17, no. 9-10, pp. 1437–1444, 2011.

J. H. Choi, E. Bellas, G. Vunjak-Novakovic, and D. L. Kaplan, “Adipogenic differentiation of human adipose-derived stem cells on 3D silk scaffolds,” Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 702, pp. 319–330, 2011.

J. H. Choi, J. M. Gimble, K. Lee et al., “Adipose tissue engineering for soft tissue regeneration,” Tissue engineering Part B, Reviews, vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 413–426, 2010.

J. H. Kang, J. M. Gimble, and D. L. Kaplan, “In vitro 3D model for human vascularized adipose tissue,” Tissue Engineering. Part A, vol. 15, no. 8, pp. 2227–2236, 2009.