We report on high frequency (HF) and noise performances of AlSb/InAs high electron mobility transistor (HEMT) with 100 nm gate length at room temperature in low-power regime. Extrinsic cut-off frequencies fT/fmax of 100/125 GHz together with minimum noise figure NFmin=0.5 dB and associated gain Gass=12 dB at 12 GHz have been obtained at drain bias of only 80 mV, corresponding to 4 mW/mm DC power dissipation. This demonstrates the great ability of AlSb/InAs HEMT for high-frequency operation combined with low-noise performances in ultra-low-power regime.
1. Introduction
Though the best high frequency performances are obtained for InAlAs/InGaAs HEMT technology which is more mature [1], AlSb/InAs HEMTs are potentially excellent candidates for low-voltage, low-power consumption operation in the case of high-speed analog and digital applications [2]. AlSb/InAs heterostructures are grown since the 1980s [3, 4], but AlSb/InAs HEMT with noticeable RF figures-of-merit and amplifiers with interesting low-noise performances have only been obtained since the last ten years [5, 6].
The best extrinsic fT of 303 GHz has been reached for a transistor with 120 nm gate length at drain bias of 0.44 V [7]. The main modifications regarding our previous work [7, 8] lie in an optimization of heterostructure growth conditions [9], no ohmic cap layer [10], and the use of alternative metallic gate stack [11]. With this technology, the highest combination of cut-off frequencies obtained simultaneously for AlSb/InAs HEMTs has recently been shown at Vds=360 mV [10], beyond previous fT/fmax record of 260/280 GHz reported for 100 nm HEMT at Vds=400 mV [12]. Cut-off frequencies fT/fmax of 290/335 GHz were obtained for a 120 nm HEMT. We presently focus on HEMT operation in mobility regime (Vds=80 mV) in which we will demonstrate that no impact ionization occurs. In these low drain bias conditions, corresponding to ultra-low-power dissipation, previous works report fT/fmax of 112/107 GHz for (Vds=0.1 V; PDC=4.3 mW/mm) [5] and fT/fmax of 143/115 GHz at (Vds=0.1 V; PDC=9.9 mW/mm) [7]. In this study, we present a full set of characteristics at Vds=80 mV regarding DC, HF, and noise performances, extracting RF figures-of-merit, extrinsic and intrinsic parameters, and noise parameters obtained from small-signal equivalent circuit with noise sources.
2. Heterostructure and Device Fabrication2.1. Heterostructure
The AlSb/InAs heterostructure was grown by molecular beam epitaxy on 3-inche semi-insulating GaAs substrate. A thick AlSb buffer is used to accommodate the large lattice mismatched between 6.1 Å materials and GaAs substrate. Then, the structure consists of a 120 Å InAs channel, a 65 Å AlSb spacer, a Te δ-doping plane, and a composite Schottky barrier with a 25 Å Al0.8Ga0.2Sb layer and a 50 Å Al0.5In0.5As layer (Figure 1). The Al0.5In0.5As layer in the composite Schottky barrier avoids oxidation of Al0.8Ga0.2Sb with air exposure and acts as a hole barrier [13]. Hall measurements at room temperature exhibit a sheet carrier density of 1.5 × 1012 cm−2 and electron mobility of 26000 cm²/(Vs), giving sheet resistance of 160 Ω/□.
AlSb/InAs heterostructure.
2.2. Device Fabrication
HEMTs fabrication starts with ohmic contact evaporation of Pd/Pt/Au after e-beam lithography, followed by rapid thermal annealing at 275°C. Despite the absence of highly doped cap layer in the heterostructure, contact resistance, obtained by transmission-line model measurements, is still below 0.05 Ω·mm. Schottky T-gate is realized using bilayer resist e-beam lithography process and Mo/Pt/Au metallization. Then, Ti/Au bonding pads are evaporated. Finally, the active area is defined by chemical deep mesa isolation using HF/H2O2 solution to completely remove the AlSb buffer, leading to air-bridge gate. Device features are a two-finger 100 nm long gate with 2 × 25 μm transistor width (Figure 2). Source-drain spacing is 1.2 μm.
100 nm AlSb/InAs HEMT.
3. Static and Dynamic Measurements
Drain current-voltage characteristics are plotted in Figure 3. Pinch-off voltage is −1.0 V. Maximum drain currents are 220 mA/mm and 620 mA/mm for drain bias of 80 mV and 240 mV, respectively. These are similar to our previous results [7, 8] despite the higher sheet resistance of the heterostructure and the higher source-drain spacing in the present device.
Drain current-voltage characteristic of 100 nm AlSb/InAs HEMT. Vgs is varying from 0 V to −1.4 V with −0.2 V step. (Crosses are polarisation conditions for measurements at peak fT).
HF measurement setup consists in a 67 GHz Agilent PNA for S-parameters on-wafer measurements and an Agilent HP4142 generator for DC biasing. Extrinsic current gain |H21|2 and unilateral power gain U for Vds=80 mV and Vds=240 mV at peak fT are presented in Figure 4. Cut-off frequencies (fT, fmax) obtained simultaneously at Vds=80 mV are (108 GHz, 129 GHz) for power dissipation PDC=5 mW/mm and (232 GHz, 250 GHz) at Vds=240 mV for PDC=60 mW/mm. PDC is calculated as Vds×Ids, with power consumption in the gate being negligible.
fmax and fT extrapolated from Mason’s unilateral gain U and current gain |H21|2 for Vds=80 mV and Vds=240 mV.
In Figure 5, the evolution of extrinsic cut-off frequencies is plotted as a function of PDC for Vds=80 mV and Vds=240 mV. This evidences the ability of AlSb/InAs HEMT for RF performances in low drain bias regime. In fact, (fT, fmax) are (100 GHz, 125 GHz) for PDC=4 mW/mm at Vds=80 mV. The DC power consumption at Vds=240 mV for reaching the same cut-off frequencies is, respectively, 30 mW/mm and 22 mW/mm. Consequently, to get the same RF performances in more standard drain bias conditions, power consumption must be at least 5 times higher.
Extrapolated (fT, fmax) plotted as a function of DC power consumption calculated as Vds×Ids.
Finally, intrinsic and extrinsic parameters have been extracted from the small-signal equivalent circuit (SSEC) presented in Figure 6.
Small-signal equivalent circuit tacking into account gate leakage current (Rgg) and impact ionisation (gm2).
Resistance Rgg parallel to Cgs and current source gm2 parallel to output conductance gd to account, respectively, for gate leakage current and impact ionization have been added to the classical model. Indeed, there is impact ionization in AlSb/InAs HEMT at high drain bias with an increase of gate current and a typical bell-shape of the Igs-Vgs characteristic [14], which is a signature of impact ionization in DC measurements. With RF characterization, impact ionization results in S22 parameter evolving from inductive to capacitive behaviour with increasing frequency as can be seen for Vds=240 mV in Figure 7. In the literature, this phenomenon in HEMTs has been modelised with a low-pass filter [15]. We prefer to introduce an additional current source gm2 controlled by gate-drain voltage as realized by Isler [16] to account for impact ionization effects. This model allows to perfectly fit scattering parameters at Vds=80 mV and Vds=240 mV as shown in Figure 7.
S-parameters measured (blue dots) and simulated (red curves) at Vds=80 mV and Vds=240 mV.
Parameters extracted from the SSEC at peak fT are presented in Table 1. Rgg is much higher at Vds=80 mV compared to Vds=240 mV, which is relevant of much lower gate leakage current, and gm2 is negligible at Vds=80 mV, which stresses that there is no impact ionization at this drain voltage.
Small-signal equivalent circuit parameters for Vds = 80 mV and Vds = 240 mv at peak fT.
Vds (mV)
RG (Ω/mm)
RD (Ω·mm)
RS (Ω·mm)
gm (S/mm)
gd (S/mm)
Cgs (fF/mm)
Cgd (fF/mm)
gm2 (S/mm)
Rgg (k Ω)
80
74
0.11
0.11
0.75
0.73
468
327
0.007
80
240
74
0.11
0.11
1.36
0.72
584
259
1.47
12
4. Noise Measurements
Regarding low impact ionization occurring at Vds=80 mV as shown above with RF wideband measurements, SSEC with noise sources as presented in Figure 8 is used. For the sake of simplicity, there is no current source accounting for impact ionization since extracted value of gm2 at Vds=80 mV is negligible. As a consequence, no additional noise source, which should probably be correlated with output noise current or even input noise voltage, is required for extraction of accurate parameters values. We extracted the following noise parameters using F50 method [17]: minimum noise figure NFmin, associated gain Gass, noise equivalent resistance Rn, and output noise temperature Tout at 12 GHz (Figures 9 and 10). NFmin is 0.5 dB and Gass is 12 dB for 4 mW/mm power dissipation. As a comparison, we should quote results obtained by Ma et al. [5] for 2 × 20 μm HEMT with NFmin above 0.5 dB at 12 GHz in the “best bias conditions for minimum noise figure.” The present results should also be compared with similar NFmin and Gass reported in literature for AlSb/InAs HEMTs but with 50% higher DC power consumption of 6 mW/mm at Vds=200 mV [6, 18]. In the present case, at Vds=80 mV, NFmin, and Gass are optima for PDC=4 mW/mm and it is important to underline that it would be impossible to reach these noise performances at Vds=240 mV with such low-power consumption. Despite an accurate extraction of noise parameters under high drain bias is not done here, the element values would obviously be degraded due to the higher gate voltage required to operate in low-power regime, which would increase shot noise. Then, drain polarization of transistor at Vds=80 mV allows an excellent compromise between noise performances and power dissipation.
Small-signal equivalent circuit with noise sources for AlSb/InAs HEMT at Vds=80 mV.
Minimum noise figure NFmin and associated gain Gass as a function of power consumption at 12 GHz for Vds=80 mV.
Noise equivalent resistance Rn and output noise temperature Tout as a function of power consumption at 12 GHz for Vds=80 mV.
5. Conclusion
In this study, we reported on microwave and noise performances in low-power regime of AlSb/InAs HEMTs with optimized heterostructure. Combined (fT, fmax) of (100 GHz, 125 GHz) have been obtained at Vds=80 mV and DC power consumption of 4 mW/mm, performances that cannot be reached at Vds=240 mV for such a low power dissipation. A small-signal equivalent circuit was established and demonstrated that impact ionization effects at Vds=80 mV are negligible, which is not the case for Vds=240 mV. This allowed an accurate extraction of noise parameters thanks to SSEC with noise sources fully reliable in mobility regime. NFmin=0.5 dB and Gass=12 dB have been obtained at 12 GHz for (Vds=80 mV; PDC=4 mW/mm). These results exhibit the high suitability of AlSb/InAs HEMTs for combined RF and low-noise performances in ultra-low-power dissipation regime.
Conflict of Interests
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.
Acknowledgments
This work is supported by the National Research Agency under Projects Low IQ (no. ANR-08-NANO-022) and SMIC (no. ANR-11-ASTR-031-03).
DealW.MeiX. B.LeongK. M. K. H.RadisicV.SarkozyS.LaiR.THz monolithic integrated circuits using InP high electron mobility transistors20111125322-s2.0-8005248554110.1109/TTHZ.2011.2159539BennettB. R.MagnoR.BoosJ. B.KruppaW.AnconaM. G.Antimonide-based compound semiconductors for electronic devices: a review20054912187518952-s2.0-2804444296710.1016/j.sse.2005.09.008ChangC.-A.ChangL. L.MendezE. E.ChristieM. S.EsakiL.Electron densities in InAs-AlSb quantum wells1984222142162-s2.0-002140429310.1116/1.582786TuttleG.KroemerH.An AlSb/InAs/AlSb quantum well HFT198734112358MaB. Y.BergmanJ.ChenP.HackerJ. B.SullivanG.NagyG.BrarB.InAs/AlSb HEMT and its application to ultra-low-power wideband high-gain low-noise amplifiers20065412444844542-s2.0-3384772477410.1109/TMTT.2006.883604DealW. R.TsaiR.LangeM. D.Brad BoosJ.BennettB. R.GutierrezA.A low power/low noise MMIC amplifier for phased-array applications using InAs/AlSb HEMTProceedings of the IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium DigestJune 2006205120542-s2.0-3425033932110.1109/MWSYM.2006.249858RoelensY.OlivierA.DesplanqueL.NoudeviwaA.DannevilleF.WichmannN.WallartX.BollaertS.Tellurium δ-doped 120 nm AlSb/InAs HEMTs: towards sub-100 mV electronicsProceedings of the 68th Device Research Conference (DRC '10)June 201053542-s2.0-7795760659610.1109/DRC.2010.5551945OlivierA.NoudeviwaA.WichmannN.RoelensY.DesplanqueL.DannevilleF.DambrineG.WallartX.BollaertS.High frequency performance of tellurium δ-doped AlSb/InAs HEMTs at low power supplyProceedings of the 5th Microwave Integrated Circuits Conference (EuMIC '10)October 2010Paris, France1621652-s2.0-78649554552DesplanqueL.El KazziS.Codron -LJ.WangY.RuteranaP.MoschettiG.GrahnJ.WallartX.AlSb nucleation induced anisotropic electron mobility in AlSb/InAs HEMTs heterostructures on GaAs20121002626210326210410.1063/1.4730958GardèsC.BagumakoS. M.DesplanqueL.120 nm AlSb/InAs HEMT without gate recess: 290 GHz fT and 335 GHz fmaxProceedings of the International Conference on Indium Phosphide and Related Materials (IPRM '13)2013Kobe, Japan1210.1109/ICIPRM.2013.6562604ChouY. C.LeeL. J.YangJ. M.The effect of gate metals on manufacturability of 0.1 µm metamorphic AlSb/InAs HEMTs for ultra low-power applicationsProceedings of the 20th International Conference on Indium Phosphide and Related Materials (IPRM '08)May 200811410.1109/ICIPRM.2008.4702994TsaiR.LangeM.LeeL. J.NamP.NambaC.LiuP. H.SandhuR.GrundbacherR.DealW.GutierrezA.260 GHz fT, 280 GHz fmax AlSb/InAs HEMT technologyProceedings of the 63rd Device Research Conference (DRC '05)June 20052572582-s2.0-3375133565510.1109/DRC.2005.1553146Brad BoosJ.KruppaW.BennettB. R.ParkD.KirchoeferS. W.BassR.DietrichH. B.AlSb/InAs HEMT's for low-voltage, high-speed applications1998459186918752-s2.0-003216336110.1109/16.711349MoschettiG.AbbasiM.Per-Ake NilssonTrue planar InAs/AlSb HEMTs with ion-implantation technique for low-power cryogenic applications20137926827310.1016/j.sse.2012.06.013TeyssandierC.de GrooteF.SommetR.Characterization and modeling of impact ionization effects on small and large signal characteristics of AlGaAs/GaInAs/GaAs PHEMTsProceedings of the 3rd European Microwave Integrated Circuit Conference (EuMIC '08)October 2008Amsterdam, The Netherlands11912210.1109/EMICC.2008.4772243IslerM.Investigation and modeling of impact ionization in HEMTs for DC and RF operating conditions20024610158715932-s2.0-003677914010.1016/S0038-1101(02)00110-7DambrineG.HappyH.DannevilleF.CappyA.New method for on wafer noise measurement19934133753812-s2.0-002756030610.1109/22.223734TsaiR.GrundbacherR.LangeM.Manufacturable AlSb/InAs HEMT technology for ultra-low power millimeter-wave integrated circuitsProceedings of the Mantech Conference20046972