A Review of CO2 Sequestration Projects and Application in China

In 2008, the top CO2 emitters were China, United States, and European Union. The rapid growing economy and the heavy reliance on coal in China give rise to the continued growth of CO2 emission, deterioration of anthropogenic climate change, and urgent need of new technologies. Carbon Capture and sequestration is one of the effective ways to provide reduction of CO2 emission and mitigation of pollution. Coal-fired power plants are the focus of CO2 source supply due to their excessive emission and the energy structure in China. And over 80% of the large CO2 sources are located nearby storage reservoirs. In China, the CO2 storage potential capacity is of about 3.6 × 109 t for all onshore oilfields; 30.483 × 109 t for major gas fields between 900 m and 3500 m of depth; 143.505 × 109 t for saline aquifers; and 142.67 × 109 t for coal beds. On the other hand, planation, soil carbon sequestration, and CH4–CO2 reforming also contribute a lot to carbon sequestration. This paper illustrates some main situations about CO2 sequestration applications in China with the demonstration of several projects regarding different ways of storage. It is concluded that China possesses immense potential and promising future of CO2 sequestration.


Introduction
The enormous emission from greenhouse gas, predominated by CO 2 , has caused increasing threat to human environment and the ecological system. The current global annual carbon emission reaches up to more than 30 billion tons. In China, fossil fuel takes up 92.6% of the total energy; 67.1% of CO 2 is generated from coal and petroleum. Moreover, China is the biggest CO 2 emitter by now. According to International Environment Agency, emission from China would overpass the whole world's CO 2 emission by 2020 [1]. Therefore, it is an urgent requirement for China to transform from high-carbon to low-carbon society.
According to "Report on the Development of Low Carbon Economy of China (2012), " China is the largest country for carbon emission reduction. The world's largest carbon emission reduction project started in China in 2005, which is expected to reduce about 19 million tons of CO 2 equivalent emission every year [2]. 1.5 billion tons of CO 2 emission has been reduced during "11th five-year plan" in China, and it is likely to cut 7 billion tons of CO 2 in 2020.
Various ways of reducing carbon emission have already been applied in China. And, among them, a major mitigation method is carbon capture and sequestration (CCS).
It is believed that CCS is the long-term isolation of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere through physical, chemical, biological, or engineered process. It includes carbon sequestration through forestation, soil carbon sequestration, direct ocean injection of CO 2 either into the deep seafloor or into the intermediate depths, and the deep geological sequestration, or even direct conversion of CO 2 to carbonate minerals [3], of which geological sequestration is a major component. CCS is an effective way for China to alleviate pollution and enhance the oil recovery, and most underground spaces in China are good for CO 2 geological storage [4]. However, CCS has just started in China, and there is a certain gap between China and abroad. But there are still some technical foundations in China, especially in the area of CO 2 recycling and injection [5].
Several main types of geological storage media for carbon sequestration are mostly considered in China: depleted or active oil and natural gas field, coal layers, and deep saline
Zhang et al. [18] developed the formula which considers the different storage mechanisms: where 1 is the storage capacity of CO 2 taking the volume previously occupied by produced oil; 2 is the storage capacity of CO 2 dissolved in residual oil; 3 is the storage capacity of CO 2 dissolved in water contained in reservoir; and 4 is the storage capacity of CO 2 reacting with reservoir rock. Sun and Chen [19] proposed the study to calculate increased oil production and the CO 2 storage capacity in oil reservoir and depleted oil reservoir.
Proportion of increased oil by CO 2 -EOR is as follows: where OOIP is the original oil in place, Mt; is the contact ratio between oil and CO 2 . OOIP is the amount of oil that can contact with CO 2 , Mt. The increased oil production and storage capacity are as follows: where EOR is the increased oil production, Mt; CO 2 is the storage capacity, t or Mt; CO 2 is the ratio between the amount of injected CO 2 and the amount of increased oil, t/bbl or t/t. However, for the CO 2 storage capacity in depleted oil reservoir, The Scientific World Journal 3 where RF O is the oil recovery when depleted; FVF O is the formation volume factor; CO 2 is the density of SCCO 2 under the reservoir temperature and pressure, Mt/m 3 . Tanaka and coworkers [20,21] set up two models based on underground structures: model (5) is suitable for aquifers that are well sealed by cap rocks and model (6) for aquifers in monoclonal structures and there may be problem of CO 2 leakage into the upper portion. Consider where is the sweep efficiency (fraction, dimensionless), is storage area (m 2 ), ℎ is effective formation thickness (m), Φ is effective reservoir porosity (fraction, dimensionless), is saturation of supercritical CO 2 (fraction, dimensionless), (CO 2 ) is CO 2 formation volume factor (m 2 /m 3 , reservoir volume/standard volume), (CO 2 ) is CO 2 solubility in formation water (m 3 /m 2 ), is density of CO 2 at standard condition (kg/m 3 ), and is the storage factor (fraction, dimensionless).

Geological
Sequestration. CO 2 can be more effectively sequestrated at pressure higher than 7.38 MPa (equivalent depth of about 800 m), and at temperature above 31.1 ∘ C, where CO 2 will stay in a supercritical state with an elevated density up to 600 kg/m 3 , 400 times more condensed compared to that at atmospheric conditions. SCCO 2 (supercritical CO 2 ) is characterized by stable and inert chemical property. Consequently, at pressures and temperatures typically encountered in the field, CO 2 will behave as a supercritical fluid [28].
CO 2 geosequestration has been implemented successfully around the world like CO 2 -EOR and storage in Weyburn project of Canada in 2000 [29,30]; CO 2 storage in K12-B gas field of The Netherlands in 2004 [31]; the upcoming ROAD project in 2015 with CO 2 storage in P18-4 depleted gas field of The Netherlands [32]; associated CO 2 separation and injection into the saline aquifer in Sleipner project of Norway in 1996 [33]; CO 2 storage in In Salah aquifer of Algeria in 2004 and Snohvit aquifer of Norway in 2008 [34,35]; CO 2enhanced coal bed methane (CO 2 -ECBM) and storage in San Juan Basin of New Mexico in 1995 [36], and other CO 2 -ECBM projects in USA [37,38].
Research results suggest that CCS can provide a valuable greenhouse gas mitigation option for most regions and industrial sectors in China and can be able to store more than 80% of emissions from these large CO 2 sources (2900 million tons of CO 2 annually) at costs less than $70/t CO 2 for perhaps a century or more [10]. Similarly, various geosequestration projects have been in progress in China, regarding the storage in oil and gas fields, in saline aquifer and in coal seams.

CO 2 Sequestration in Oil and Gas
Field. Carbon sequestration with enhanced oil recovery (CSEOR) is a kind of win-win process to increase oil production and store CO 2 . Moreover, the revenue created could be able to offset the storage cost and bring valuable profit. CO 2 has been widely used for EOR around the world. CO 2 -EOR projects now produce about 0.35 × 10 6 bbls/day in USA, accounting for 5.6% of total USA oil and gas production, compared to just 0.19 × 10 6 bbls/day in 2000. And approximately 50 million metric tons of CO 2 is used each year for EOR in USA [39,40].
CSEOR or CSEGR has been assessed and applied for several oil and gas fields across China. When the buried depth is more than 800 m (guarantee the supercritical state of CO 2 ); the CO 2 storage potential capacity is of about 3.6 × 10 9 t, assuming that all onshore oilfields in China are used for CO 2 -EOR, and it can reach up to 4.6 × 10 9 t while considering all onshore oilfields as depleted reservoirs. Therein, reservoirs in northeast and north China have tremendous sequestration potential, accounting for more than 60% of the total capacity [24].
Considering the depth between 900 m and 3500 m, China's major gas fields are able to provide storage capacity of about 30.483 × 10 9 t of CO 2 , and the proven natural gas resources correspond to storage capacity of 4.103 × 10 9 t CO 2 . However, gas industry has been started late in China, and there will be no large-scale depleted gas field for a long time. In this way, gas fields should not be used to store CO 2 in the near future but should serve as the strategic energy reserves due to the good sealing property of depleted gas fields [25].
Oil reservoirs are screened on the basis of oil gravity, reservoir temperature and pressure, MMP, and remaining oil saturation, to determine their suitability for CO 2 flooding [17]. And several different types of screening criteria have been proposed at home and abroad for CO 2 -EOR and storage [17,[41][42][43][44], regarding crude oil properties, reservoir characters, cap formation characters, and economic and environmental issues.
Jilin oilfield, located in northeast of China, is conducting the first large-scale demonstration project on CO 2 -EOR and storage. The oil-bearing formations are characterized by good development of sandbody, good connectivity, and welldefined cap rocks [45]. Natural source of CO 2 is mainly from natural gas. And miscible flooding can be achieved in block Hei-59 and Hei-79; well location is indicated in Figure 2.
In 2008, Jilin oilfield built a pilot demonstration area of CO 2 flooding and storage in the Daqingzi oilfield. And in 2009, a demonstration area with its annual CO 2 storage of 0.2 × 10 6 t and annual oil displacement of 0.1 × 10 6 t was established, which indicated realization of commercial application of such technology. Good production response has been observed after about 6 months of CO 2 injection since April 2008, as shown in Figure 3. Oil production in the whole pilot area has rapidly increased from 20 t/d to around 100 t/d and has been maintained at 60 t/d in 2011. By the end of May 8, 2011, about 0.167 × 10 6 t of CO 2 was stored without obvious CO 2 leakage; and 0.119 × 10 6 t of oil was produced by CO 2 -EOR. At the same time, a plant was built in the Jilin oilfield to separate and capture 0.2 × 10 6 t of CO 2 annually [46,47]. 0.27 × 10 6 t of CO 2 has been safely stored until  August 2012 with remarkable economic benefit, with 1 : 1.37 as the input and output ratio [48]. It is expected that, by 2015, the first production area will be built in China, with an annual CO 2 displacement amount reaching 0.5 × 10 6 t and an annual CO 2 storage over 0.7 × 10 6 t, all of which are equivalent to the total amount of CO 2 released from burning of 0.3 × 10 6 t of coal [46]. And the further work will be focused on optimizing EOR performance, verifying of the geocapacity storage in the targeted zones and carrying forward the monitoring programs [45].
Caoshe oilfield is located in Subei Basin and has been selected to implement CO 2 -EOR and storage demonstration project. The geological map is shown in Figure 4. Taizhou formation is the main oil-bearing formation in Caoshe oilfield. And during the development periods, the oilfield has developed a complete well pattern of injectors and producers with good well connection, the water cut at the producer has been relatively low, and the reservoir pressure has been well maintained [23,49].
Taizhou formation is geologically suitable for CSEOR. Taizhou formation has carried out the CO 2 -EOR pilot test in July 2005, and 5.842 × 10 7 m 3 CO 2 has been injected from July 2005 to December 2009 with increased oil production of 0.03 × 10 6 t [49,50]. CO 2 can achieve a miscible displacement process and be stored safely in the stratigraphic and structure traps of Taizhou formation reservoir [51]. Besides, Nanjing Chemical plant, a synthetic ammonia plant 120 km away from the Caoshe oilfield, would provide a low-cost CO 2 source for the CCS demonstration project. The detailed numerical reservoir model indicates that the maximum CO 2 storage capacity at standard condition is estimated to be 0.309 × 10 9 m 3 . Figure 5 shows the simulation result of CO 2 miscible flooding. Furthermore, the revenue from incremental oil production is significant, which cannot only offset the cost of the CO 2 storage, but also can generate certain economic benefit to Caoshe oilfield [23], while Zhang indicated that the storage cost of CO 2 -EOR process is $25.78/t, based on the economic evaluation model established [52].
The Ordos Basin is the second largest sedimentary basin in China, which takes account for 43% of resources of the whole country. In 2011, the oil and gas production exceeded 0.052 × 10 9 t of oil equivalents [53]. Ordos Basin is able to provide a huge potential capacity for CO 2 storage.
Jingbian field is located in central Ordos Basin in northern Shaanxi slope and has been screened out to conduct the CO 2 sequestration. CO 2 will be captured from the energy and chemical engineering industrial zone in Jingbian City which is 30 km away from the operation site. And it is estimated to inject CO 2 of 0.04 × 10 6 t/yr and increase oil production of 0.05 × 10 6 t/yr from CO 2 -EOR [53].
Furthermore, various feasibility studies of geological CO 2 sequestration have been implemented for wide areas of Ordos The Scientific World Journal Basin [54][55][56]. For example, research indicates that, for 261 production layers of Changqing oilfield, total oil production increment and CO 2 sequestration amount can reach about 0.098 × 10 9 t and about 0.239 × 10 9 t, respectively [54]. Results from the 50-year injection simulation indicate that a total of 450 Mt of CO 2 can be injected into the targeted reservoir of Majiagou formation (northern Ordos Basin), while 166 Mt of original pore fluids will be displaced by CO 2 [55].
Additionally, other fields around the country also show good results for CO 2 application. Xinjiang oilfield, a vital oilfield in western China, is located in Junggar Basin. Around 0.181 × 10 9 t additional oil could be produced for the total screened out 275 production units, which could provide about 0.495 × 10 9 t for CO 2 sequestration capacity [57]. Many mature oil reservoirs in Shengli oilfield (north China) are close to the main CO 2 sources and have good geographical and geological conditions for CO 2 storage. The total EOR potential can be 9.997 × 10 6 t, and the CO 2 storage capacity can reach 95.539 × 10 6 t [44]. Zhongyuan oilfield (central China) and Daqing oilfield (northeast China) get obvious recovery increment after CO 2 flooding.
The associated CO 2 from natural gas is another major carbon emission. IPCC estimated that about 50 million tons of reservoir-CO 2 is liberated into the atmosphere every year, from natural gas production [11]. Projecting this to year 2030, and assuming sourness does not increase, the emissions figure could be 150 Mt/yr [58]. And in South China Sea, the geological reserve of CO 2 is huge [59]. DF1-1 gas field is located in the west of the South China Sea, which is associated with a high concentration of CO 2 . A demonstrative project of CO 2 sequestration is considered for nearly abandoned southeast block of the lower Group II formation in the DF1-1 gas field, which was reassessed for the safety of CO 2 storage [58]. The separated CO 2 would be injected back into the original gas reservoir, similar to the demonstration projects carried out in K12-B (Netherlands).
The feasibility studies showed that the faults in gas field are characteristic of good sealing property for the targeted block. The injected CO 2 of the southeast block will be effectively trapped in the reservoir because of its good sealing mechanism and poor connectivity with other blocks [60]. Simulation results indicate that CO 2 can be injected steadily at a rate of 0.140 × 10 6 Sm 3 /d over 10 years, and the cumulative CO 2 gas injection can be 0.511 × 10 9 Sm 3 for the pressure control required. Zhang et al. [60] showed that unit storage of CO 2 is approximately $20/t at the current economic situation, while there will be no extra finial returns for this demonstration CO 2 sequestration project.
On the other hand, CO 2 injection into oil and gas reservoirs associated with large aquifers takes advantages of lower geological leakage risk from oil and gas traps and large storage capacity from the connected aquifers [61]. Results of cases studies of five oil reservoirs selected from Shengli and Jiangsu oilfields in China demonstrate that CO 2 storage capacity can be greatly increased if the lateral and underlying aquifers are included.

CO 2 Sequestration in Saline Aquifer.
Deep saline aquifers have proven to be the promising geological media for CO 2 sequestration due to the large storage capacity and wide availability. The injected CO 2 can be sequestrated in deep saline aquifers through a combination of physical and chemical trapping mechanisms, which include stratigraphic or structure trapping, residual trapping, solubility trapping, mineral trapping and hydrodynamic trapping [27,[62][63][64].
143.505 × 10 9 t CO 2 can be stored in saline aquifers of China [65]. Most of the north China plain; northern, eastern, and southern Sichuan Basin; southeast of Junggar Basin are the priority for CO 2 aquifer storage in the future, like the deep saline aquifers in Songliao Basin (northeast China) can contribute about 8.96 × 10 9 t of CO 2 sequestration capacity [66].
Saline aquifer trap LT13-1, located in the east of DF1-1 gas field, 60 km away from the Dongfang gas terminal, has been selected as the target CO 2 storage site to sequestrate the CO 2 discharged from the DF1-1 gas terminal [67]. The reservoir is relatively good in homogeneousness and high in salinity, indicating a good trap feature. The injected CO 2 will be trapped both in a supercritical state and in dissolved state in formation water. Sandbodies A and C of LT13-1 structure can provide a CO 2 storage capacity of approximately 0.1 × 10 9 t [67], as shown in Figures 6 and 7. Zhang et al. pointed out that the storage cost is about $33-37/t, slightly higher than abroad due to the high cost of offshore pipeline [68].
Being one of the most typical sedimentary basins in eastern coastal of China, the Bohai Bay Basin is a potential candidate for CO 2 sequestration. CO 2 storage in deep saline aquifers is considered as a viable option because of the widedistribution with a high CO 2 storage capacity. The CO 2 storage capacity within the assessing range is 3.9 × 10 9 t in saline aquifers of Bohai Bay Basin, and storage capacity in Neogene Guantao formation lower than 3500 m is 3.3 × 10 9 t, accounting for 84.4% of the total potential [70].
Section 3 in the lower part of the Neogene Guantao formation of Beitang Sag, Huanghua depression, near the center of the Bohai Bay Basin, has been chosen as the test site for CO 2 injection [71]. Due to the good cap-rock layers, CO 2 can be stored safely in Section 3 in supercritical state.  Figure 7: CO 2 gas distribution radius in sandbodies A and C during and after injection (from Zhang [52]). Based on the model (6) proposed by Tanaka, the CO 2 storage capacity of the Beitang Sag is estimated to be 17.03 Mt.

CO 2 Sequestration in Coal Seam.
China has abundant coal bed methane (CBM) resources. CBM reserves buried lower than 2000 m are estimated to be 36.8 Tm 3 , accounting for 13% of the world's resources and ranking third in the world [72].
Coal seams provide one of the most attractive sites for CO 2 geological sequestration in China as a result of the huge resources and the high and stable adsorption of CO 2 , particularly in combination with ECBM [26,73,74]. Adsorption is the main trapping mechanism for CO 2 storage in coal seams, which accounts for approximately 90% of the total storage. The ECBM potential associated with CO 2 sequestration is estimated to be over 3.751 × 10 12 m 3 . And the CO 2 sequestration capacity of China coal beds is estimated to be about 142.67 × 10 9 t [75]. Based on the assessment for coal beds of China in depth between 300 m and 1500 m, 1.632 × 10 12 m 3 methane can be increased from CO 2 -ECBM, and about 12.078 × 10 9 t of CO 2 can be stored [26].
The Yaojie coalfield is located in the western margin of Minhe and extends across the Gansu and Qinghai provinces of China. The Haishiwan coalfield is located in the deep part of the Yaojie coalfield. High concentrations of CO 2 (34.1-98.64%) have been observed in the number 2 coal seam of Haishiwan coalfield [69].
And the temperature-pressure conditions in Haishiwan coalfield indicate that supercritical CO 2 may occur in the eastern half of the coalfield. Moreover, the Haishiwan coalfield is an ideal storage area because of the good sealing features and the presence of large volumes of juvenile CO 2 that have been naturally sequestered over 15 million years. The pure CO 2 storage capacity of the Haishiwan coal seam is 44.7 m 3 /t at 7.5 MPa and 313. 15 K [69], as shown in Figure 8.

Other Ways of Sequestration.
Plantation forests are the most effective and ecofriendly way of absorbing CO 2 and increasing carbon sinks in terrestrial ecosystems, mitigating global warming and promoting ecological restoration. China's forestation rate is the highest in the world, contributing significantly to the nation's carbon sequestration [76]. Cost of carbon mitigation through plantation is relatively low, generally under $10/t, compared with $25-120/t for cost limitation of energy industry [77].
China currently has one of the world's most ambitious reforestation and afforestation programs, known as grain for green, which has been in place since 1999. It gives grain payouts to farmers who convert fields to forests. It is operating in many different regions across China. Although not one of its goals, carbon sequestration is a cobenefit of the program [78].
From 1950 to the present, plantations in China sequestered 1.686 PgC by net uptake into biomass and emission of soil organic carbon. Huang et al. [76] projected that China's forestation activities will continue to net sequester carbon to a level of 3.169 PgC by 2050.
On the other hand, China's rice paddies, accounting for 19% of the world's total, play an important role in soil carbon sequestration. The simulations demonstrated that all the recommended management practices could result in an increase in carbon sequestration potential, varying greatly from 29.2 to 847.7 TgC by 2050 [79].
Additionally, CH 4 -CO 2 reforming can effectively convert CO 2 and CH 4 into synthesis gas. Interests regarding the CO 2 reforming of CH 4 have been rising due to the feasible approach for resource utilization and greenhouse gas emission reduction and the generated raw materials needed by many manufacturing process. Many efforts have been carried to devote and investigate various types of catalysts to promote the conversion process [80][81][82][83][84].
Overall, Table 1 summarizes the main comparative information of the above CO 2 sequestration projects regarding different storage ways.

Challenge for Future
CCS is somehow a quite new technology in China. Even though a lot of assessments and potential analysis have been  Figure 8: High-pressure CO 2 adsorption on the dry Haishiwan coals at 40 ∘ C with respect to density (a); CO 2 excess sorption isotherms and free CO 2 content versus pressure (b); SC is the critical pressure of CO 2 (from Li et al. [69]). International engagement is critical in developing and enlarging CO 2 sequestration. China has already cooperated with other countries to start up a number of projects regarding CCS in many fields. However, more combined efforts are needed to move forward.
Technology is the priority determinant in CCS operation, including the technique from capture, transportation, assessment, and storage. The main oilfields in China are manifested in complex formation structure with strong heterogeneity, low or ultralow permeability, low porosity, and poor oil property [1]. CO 2 -EOR techniques would be challenged by high miscible pressure, severe gas channeling, heavy solid deposition, and development of complex reservoir [85]. 8 The Scientific World Journal On the other hand, effective policies are suggested to encourage and boost the CCS industry in China. Alternative ways should be developed to capture CO 2 and reduce CO 2 emission for different emitters. Carbon emission trading system is forming in China. Market mechanism is important to reduce carbon emissions for China's low-carbon future [86].

Conclusion
The demand for clean energy and low-carbon technologies is enormous in China, where the rapid growth and heavy reliance on coal provide a mass of opportunities for application of new techniques. A great amount of CO 2 can be sequestered by geological media, forestation, soil, and reforming. As a result, CCS is the most attractive way for reducing CO 2 emission in China. CO 2 sequestration in depleted oil and gas reservoirs, saline aquifers, and coal beds is promising in China. A great number of projects have been implemented to testify the feasibility of CCS, examine the potential for commercial-scale CCS, and assess the storage capacity and possibility of CSEOR in large parts of China like Jilin oilfield, the first large-scale demonstration project on CSEOR.
Forestation, soil, and CO 2 reform could provide alternative ways for CO 2 sequestration. Combination of variety of methods can deeply promote the emission-reducing work.
There is a gap in carbon sequestration between China and other countries. Besides, most of the CO 2 storage projects in China are still in the evaluation and assessment stage. Further efforts are needed to move forward, involving international cooperation, advanced technology, positive policy, and society mechanism.