Advances in Agriculture
Volume 2014 (2014), Article ID 726313, 6 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/726313

Research Article

Comparative Effects of Different Fertilizer Sources on the Growth and Nutrient Content of Moringa (Moringa oleifera) Seedling in a Greenhouse Trial

S. O. Dania, P. Akpansubi, and O. O. Eghagara

Department of Soil Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Ambrose Alli University, Nigeria

Received 30 May 2014; Revised 4 November 2014; Accepted 6 November 2014; Published 30 November 2014

Academic Editor: Innocenzo Muzzalupo

Copyright © 2014 S. O. Dania et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract.

A greenhouse experiment was conducted to investigate the effects of NPK, poultry manure, and organomineral fertilizer on the growth and nutrient concentration of Moringa oleifera leaves. The experimental design was completely randomized design (CRD) with four treatments replicated three times. Data collected were analysed using descriptive statistics and ANOVA at . Growth parameters measured include number of leaves per plant, plant height (cm), and stem girth (mm). The application of poultry manure increased the height, number of leaves, and stem girth of moringa compared to the application of NPK and organomineral fertilizer while the control had the least growth. Poultry manure, NPK, and organomineral fertilizer were 66%, 62%, and 39% higher in number of leaves than the control at eight weeks after planting. The application of poultry manure significantly increased the nutrient content of moringa leaves compared to other sources of fertilizer applied. The results shows that the application of poultry manure significantly improved the growth and nutrient content of moringa; however, further field trial is suggested.

1. Introduction

Moringa oleifera originated from the foothills of the Himalayas in Northwestern India and is cultivated throughout the tropics [1]. Moringa can be cultivated in a wide range of soil types but grow best in well-drained loam to clay loam soil with slightly acidic to neutral pH however, it cannot withstand prolonged water logging. Moringa is very useful in the following areas; as alley cropping, animal forage, biogas, domestic cleaning agent, green manure, gum, medicine, ornamental plants, and water purification. Moringa leaves, seeds, and roots are also use in treating diseases like lung diseases, hypertension and skin infection [2, 3].

Moringa is nutritional and rich in vitamins and minerals. Moringa leaves are the most nutritious part of the plant, being a significant source of vitamin B₆ vitamin C, and provitamin A as beta carotene, magnesium, and calcium [4]. However, Moringa still remains unpopular in Nigeria despite its acclaimed economic values and importance; very little research has been done on this plant, although it is widely used by the rural poor as a food resource [5].

Land degrading is one of the major impediments to agricultural productivity. This is manifested in the loss of soil fertility, desertification, and destruction of the soil structure [6]. Due to the implication of land degradation on agronomic productivity and the environment, it becomes necessary to proffer means to minimize it effects. Ultisols of tropical and subtropical regions occur in old landscapes that have a monsoon climate and are extremely weathered and leached. They have a red, brown, or yellow argillic B horizon with a base saturation of less than 50%. The soils have a low content of organic matter with ferric and hydromorphic properties. These soils are generally of low fertility and are susceptible to erosion [7]. One way to improve soil fertility is the application of fertilizer which obviously is a means required for optimum crop yield.

The use of poultry dungs has been documented to give a better result on soil amendment in degraded ultisols [8]. It has been reported that organic manure can serve as soil amendment to improve soil nutrient status and the growth of crops [9]. Organic base fertilizer such as organomineral fertilizer improves soil structure, reduces erosion, lowers the temperature at the soil surface, and increases soil water holding capacity [10]. The use of NPK fertilizer has resulted in the improvement of the growth and yield of crops. Due to increasing demand of moringa for biofuel and medicinal uses, it is therefore necessary to investigate ways to improve its growth in degraded soil. This study aimed at the responses of moringa seedling to soil amendment in degraded ultisols of Edo state under a greenhouse condition.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Description of Experimental Site

The experiment was conducted at the Teaching and Research Farm of Ambrose Alli University, Emaudo Annex, Ekpoma, in 2012 under greenhouse condition. The area lies between latitude North 6 degrees, 45 minutes, 34 seconds (6° 45′ 34′′) and longitude East 6 degrees, 8 minutes, 27 seconds (6° 8′ 27′′ East) with average amount of rainfall 1750 mm.

2.2. Collection of Soil for Analysis

Top soils (0–15 cm) were collected from the farm site; the soils were sieved with a 2 mm mesh to remove gravel and plant roots. The 5 kg polythene bags used for the experiment were filled with the sieved soil.

2.3. Soil Physical and Chemical Analysis

Particle size analysis was carried out using hydrometer method [11]. The pH was determined in water (ratio 1 : 1, soil : water). Organic carbon was determined by wet dichromate method [12] and available phosphorus by Bray extraction method [13]. Total nitrogen was determined by Kjeldahl method. Exchangeable cations (potassium, calcium, and magnesium) were extracted with ammonium acetate. Potassium was determined by flame photometer while calcium and magnesium were determined by atomic absorption spectrophotometer. Copper, zinc, manganese, and iron were also determined [14].

2.4. Experimental Design

The experimental design was a completely randomized design (CRD) with four treatments replicated three times. The treatments were NKP, organomineral fertilizer (OMF), poultry manure, and control.

2.5. Planting Operation

Moringa (Moringa Oleifera) seeds were first soaked in water for 24 hours to allow the seeds to absorb the moisture required for sprouting. The seeds were removed from the water, wrapped in a wet towel, and stored in a warm dark place. The towel was kept damp to allow maximum germination and prevent drought. The sprouted seeds were planted two per pot and later thinned to one stand per pot.

2.6. Fertilizer Application

Poultry manure (PM) was applied four weeks before planting at the rate of 100 g per pot; organomineral fertilizer (OMF) was applied two weeks before planting at the rate of 5 g per pot. NPK fertilizer was applied two weeks after planting at the rate of 2 g per pot. Ring application method was used for NPK and OMF while poultry manure was mixed with the soil.

2.7. Spacing

The pots were arranged at a distance of 60 cm × 60 cm between and within rows. A total number of 12 pots were used for the experiment.

2.8. Collection of Data

Growth parameters such as plant height, number of leaves, and stem girth were measured at 4, 6, and 8 weeks after planting the sprouted seeds. Moringa leaves were collected for plant nutrient analysis at eight weeks after planting.

3. Results

The soil was moderately acidic with sandy loam texture. The values of the nutrient element were as follows: nitrogen: 0.40 g/kg; phosphorus: 14.15 mg/kg; calcium: 0.88 cmol/kg; magnesium: 0.97 cmol/kg; potassium: 0.17 cmol/kg; sodium: 0.73 cmol/kg. The value of ECEC was 3.39, Mn 63.58 mg/g, Fe 93.34 mg/g, Cu 0.57 mg/g, and Zn 4.77 mg/g (Table 1).

Table 1: Physicochemical properties of soil before planting.

Properties
Results

pH (1 : 1) H₂O
6.20

N (g/kg)
0.40

OC (g/kg)
3.50

P (mg/kg)
14.15

Ca (cmol/kg)
0.88

Mg (cmol/kg)
0.97

K (cmol/kg)
0.17

Na (cmol/kg)
0.73

Mn (mg/g)
63.58

Fe (mg/g)
93.34

Cu (mg/g)
0.57

Zn (mg/g)
4.77

ECEC
3.39

H⁺
0.64

Sand
852

Silt
34

Clay
114

Textural class

Sandy loam.

3.1. The Chemical Properties of the Poultry Manure Used for the Experiment

The poultry manure was alkaline with pH of 9.60, high in organic matter and other nutrient elements. The nitrogen (N) value was 3.4 g/kg, available phosphorus (P) was 59.53 mg/kg, calcium was 19.84 cmol/kg., Mg was 1.64 cmol/kg, Na was 14.32 cmol/kg, K was 7.25 cmol/kg, and H⁺ which was 0.10 cmol/kg (Table 2).

Table 2: Nutrient content of poultry manure.

Parameters
Units
Values

pH

9.60

Organic matter
g/kg
31.2

Total nitrogen
g/kg
3.4

Available phosphorus
mg/kg
59.53

Ca
cmol/kg
19.84

Mg
cmol/kg
1.64

Na
cmol/kg
14.32

K
cmol/kg
7.25

H⁺
cmo/kg
0.10

3.2. Organomineral Fertilizer Analysis

Total nitrogen value was 44.0 g/kg, available phosphorus was 11.0 cmol/kg, and K and Ca were 6.8 cmol/kg and 6.8 cmol/kg, respectively. The value of Na was 0.8 cmol/kg and Mg was 10.8 cmol/kg. Fe value was 8,153.0 mg/kg, Zn was 712.7 mg/kg, Mn was 558.3 mg/kg, and Cu was 247.4 mg/kg (Table 3).

Table 3: Nutrient content of organomineral fertilizer grade A.

Elements
Values

Total nitrogen (g/kg)
44.00

Available phosphorus (mg/kg)
11.00

Exchangeable bases (cmol/kg)

    K
6.80

    Na
0.80

    Mg
10.80

    Ca
6.80

Extractable micronutrients (mg/kg)

    Mn
558.30

    Fe
8153.40

    Cu
247.40

    Zn
712.70

Source: pace setter organomineral fertilizer plant, Ibadan.

3.3. Growth Parameter of Moringa

3.3.1. Plant Height (cm)

Poultry manure consistently and significantly increased the height of moringa compared to other treatments. At six weeks after planting, the height of moringa was significantly () increased with the application of poultry manure (52.8 cm) compared to the application of NPK, organomineral fertilizer. Also at eight weeks after planting, application of poultry manure significantly () increased the height of moringa (65.47 cm) compared to other treatments (Table 4).

Table 4: Responses of moringa height (cm) to different fertilizer applications.

Treatment
Week after sprouting

4
6
8

Control
14.50b
25.00b
27.50b

OMF
22.40a
22.70b
27.95b

NPK
22.53a
48.47a
59.00a

Poultry manure
28.10a
52.80a
65.47a

Values followed by different letters under the same column are significantly different using Duncan’s multiple range test ().

3.3.2. Stem Girth (mm)

The stem girth of moringa was not significantly different among treatments at four weeks after planting. However, the application of poultry manure and NPK significantly () increased the stem girth of moringa (7.22 mm and 6.90 mm) compared to the application of OMF and control. At eight weeks after planting, the stem girth of moringa was significantly () higher when poultry manure and NPK were applied (8.83 mm and 8.16 mm) compared to OMF application and control (Table 5).

Table 5: Responses of moringa stem girth (mm) to different fertilizer applications.

Treatment
Week after sprouting

4
6
8

Control
2.93a
4.76b
5.04b

OMF
3.20a
3.88b
4.62b

NPK
3.16a
6.90a
8.16a

Poultry manure
3.46a
7.22a
8.83a

Values followed by different letters under the same column are significantly different using Duncan’s multiple range test ().

3.3.3. Number of Leaves

Application of fertilizer did not significantly () increase the number of leaves of moringa at four weeks after planting. However, at six weeks after planting, the application of poultry manure and NPK significantly () increased the number of leaves of moringa (334.33 and 307.007) compared to OMF and the control. It was observed that, at eight weeks after planting, poultry manure significantly () increased the number of leaves of moringa (378.33) compared to other treatments (Table 6).

Table 6: Responses of number of leaves of moringa to different fertilizer applications.

Treatment
Week after sprouting

4
6
8

Control
81.00a
119.00b
127.00c

OMF
64.50a
135.00b
209.50b

NPK
99.00a
307.00a
336.00b

Poultry manure
102.66a
334.33a
378.33a

Values followed by different letters under the same column are significantly different using Duncan’s multiple range test ().

3.3.4. Nutrient Content of Moringa Oleifera Leaves

Nutrient content of Moringa oleifera leaves was significantly () influenced by fertilizer application. Poultry manure and NPK significantly () increased the nitrogen content of moringa leaves. Phosphorus, potassium, sodium, and manganese content in moringa leaves were significantly () higher with the application of poultry manure compared to other treatments. OMF application had the highest calcium content with value 2.46 cmol/kg. NPK application increased the values of Cu and Fe content in the leaves of moringa while the control has higher magnesium and zinc (Zn) content compared to other treatments (Table 7).

Table 7: Comparative effect of PM, OMF, and NPK on the nutrient content of moringa.

Treatments
%N (g/kg)
P (mg/kg)
Ca (cmol/kg)
Mg (cmol/kg)
K (cmol/kg)
Na (mg/g)
Mn (mg/g)
Fe (mg/g)
Cu (mg/g)
Zn (mg/g)

Control
2.11b
0.15b
0.87b
0.70a
2.28c
401.08c
100.20c
189.02a
6.61b
36.14a

OMF
2.01b
0.19b
2.46a
0.42a
3.21b
492.14b
115.43c
158.43a
6.04b
10.43b

NPK
3.28a
0.12b
0.94b
0.46a
2.66c
392.18c
392.34b
198.08a
8.31a
17.23b

PM
4.13a
0.26a
0.94b
0.53a
4.78a
563.05a
563.00a
142.17a
8.22a
19.78b

SE
1.70
0.42
1.14
0.73
1.80
21.50
17.11
13.11
2.70
4.57

Values with different letters (a, b, c) are significantly () different using Duncan’s multiple range test.

3.3.5. Correlation Analysis

Positive correlation exists between phosphorus and potassium content at 0.07% and phosphorus and sodium at 0.01%. The result showed that as phosphorus increases potassium and sodium increases as well. It was also observed that there was positive correlation between the following nutrient elements: nitrogen and iron, calcium and iron, and nitrogen and copper, and between magnesium and zinc at 0.01%. The result shows that as nitrogen and calcium increased, iron content increased correspondingly (Table 8).

Table 8: Correlation Analysis.

Nitrogen
Phos
Ca
Mg
K
Na
Mn
Fe
Cu
Zn

Nitrogen
1.00000

Phos
0.46888
1.00000

0.5311

Ca
−0.54252
0.14043
1.00000

0.4575
0.8596

Mg
−0.16828
−0.08404
−0.61241
1.00000

0.8317
0.9160
0.3876

K
0.73612
0.92446
0.01274
−0.29252
1.00000

0.2639
0.0755
0.9873
0.7075

Na
0.38993
0.98775
0.28985
−0.20127
0.90684
1.00000

0.6101
0.0123
0.7101
0.7987
0.0932

Mn
0.99709
0.45822
−0.49191
−0.24219
−0.73970
0.38919
1.00000

0.0029
0.5418
0.5081
0.7578
0.2603
0.6108

Fe
0.91941
0.52196
−0.72280
0.21886
0.68080
0.40206
0.88698
1.00000

0.0806
0.4780
0.0772
0.7811
0.3192
0.5979
0.1130

Cu
0.9560
0.07557
−0.70120
−0.11646
0.40534
−0.01268
0.91445
0.81420
1.00000

0.0844
0.9244
0.2988
0.8835
0.5947
0.9873
0.0856
0.1858

Zn
−0.16598
−0.21472
−0.67190
0.98880
−0.38668
−0.33474
−0.23744
0.20113
−0.05504
1.00000

0.8340
0.7853
0.3281
0.0112
0.6133
0.6653
0.7626
0.7989
0.9450

Significant at 0.001, 0.01, and 0.05.

4. Discussion

The major limiting factor of crop production in the tropics is the deficiency of soil nutrient resulting from land degradation which affects the growth, nutrient content, and uptake of the plant. Low levels of nitrogen, phosphorus, and organic carbon were observed in the soil used for the experiment and the finding corroborates with the earlier results [15]; they reported that most of Nigerian soil is deficient in nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium even organic matter. Therefore, a sustainable method of improving the nutritional status of the soil should be employed to enhance the growth and nutrient content of the plant.

The application of NPK (15 : 15 : 15) fertilizer significantly increased the vegetative growth of moringa plant and this finding agreed with earlier work done [16]. It was reported that the application of NPK fertilizer significantly () increased the vegetative growth of moringa which was also observed from the experiment [17].

The application of poultry manure significantly () increased the height, stem girth, and number of leaves (vegetative growth) of moringa. This result corresponded to the earlier finding [18]. It was reported that the application of poultry manure significantly () increased vegetative growth of moringa. This could result from the nutritional benefits of poultry manure which include improvement of soil fertility, structure, water holding capacity, and organic matter. This will reduce the amount of inorganic fertilizers needed for the growth of moringa plant [19]. The effect of compost and other organic amendment on the growth of moringa plant may be the result of the interaction between the nutrient present and growth of moringa, as organic manure has been found to contain auxins, gibberellins, and cytokines [20].

The application of fertilizer significantly () increased the nutrient content of moringa. Poultry manure application increased the P, K, Na, and Mn content of moringa and this result corresponded to earlier work done [21]. It has been reported that the application of organic manure increased the nutrient concentration of arable and other crops [22]. Similarly, NPK application also improved the nutrient content of moringa which has earlier been reported [23]. The improvement of calcium, potassium, and sodium content of moringa by the application of OMF agreed with the work earlier done [24]. It was reported that organic base fertilizer (OMF) improved the nutrient content of arable crops.

5. Conclusion

The comparative effects of NPK, poultry manure, and OMF on growth of moringa seedling and nutrient concentration was investigated. The results of this study show that the application of poultry manure significantly increased the vegetative growth of moringa. Also the nutrient concentration on the leaves of moringa was significantly improved by amending degraded soil with poultry manure. These results can be investigated further on a field trial.

Conflict of Interests

The authors declared no conflicting interests regarding the publication of this paper.

References

M. A. Nagao, “Macadamia integrifolia: macadamia nut,” in The Encyclopedia of Fruit and Nuts, J. Janick and R. Paull, Eds., pp. 600–610, CABI, Wallingford, UK, 2008.

L. J. Fuglier, The Miracle Tree: Moringa oleifera, Natural Nutrition for the Tropics, Church World Service, Dakar, Senegal, 1999.

Miracle Tree Foundation WHO, 2012, http://miracletrees.org/

R. Bharali, J. Tabassum, and M. R. H. Azad, “Chemomodulatory effect of moringa oleifera, lam, on hepatic carcinogen metabolising enzymes, antioxidant parameters and skin papillomagenesis in mice,” Asian Pacific Journal of Cancer Prevention, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 131–139, 2003.

S. M. Odeyinka, D. O. Torimiro, J. O. Oyedele, and V. O. Asaolu, “Farmers' awareness and knowledge of Moringa oleifera in Southwestern Nigeria: a perceptional analysis,” Asian Journal of Plant Sciences, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 320–325, 2007.

H. Eswaran, R. Lal, and P. F. Reich, “Land degradation: an overview. In responses to land degradation,” in Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference of Land Degradation and Desertification, Oxford Press, Khon Kaen, Thailand, 2001.

E. A. Fitzpatrick, An Introduction to Soil Science, Longman Singapore Publishers, Singapore, 1986.

http://en.Wikipedia.org/wiki/ultisols

P. Y. Stoffella, M. Roe, Ozeres-Hampton, and D. A. Greatz, Utilization of Organic Waste Compost in Vegetable Production System in Asia, edited by R. A. Moris, Asian Vegetable Research and Development Centre, Shanhua, Taiwan, 1997.

N. E. Roe, P. J. Stoffella, and D. Graetz, “Composts from various municipal solid waste feedstocks affect vegetable crops. II. Growth, yields, and fruit quality,” Journal of the American Society for Horticultural Science, vol. 122, no. 3, pp. 433–437, 1997.

G. J. Bouyoucos, “Hydrometer method improved for making particle size analyses of soil,” Agronomy Journal, vol. 53, pp. 464–465, 1962.

D. W. Nelson and L. E. Sommers, “A rapid and accurate method of estimating organic carbon in soil,” Proceeding of Indiana Academics of Science, vol. 84, pp. 456–462, 1975.

J. M. Anderson and J. S. Ingram, Tropical Soil Biology and Fertility. A Handbook of Methods, Information Press, Eynsham, UK, 1993.

IITA, Selected Methods for Soil and Plant Analysis, Manual Series 1, International Institute for Tropical Agriculture Ibadan, 1979.

E. A. Aduayi, V. O. Chude, L. O. Adehusuji, and S. Olayiwola, Fertilizer Use and Management Practices for Crops in Nigeria, Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Abuja, Nigeria, 2002.

A. I. Makinde, “Effects of inorganic fertilizer on the growth and nutrient composition of Moringa (Moringa oleifera),” Journal of Emerging Trends in Engineering and Applied Sciences, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 341–343, 2013.

I. N. Abdullahi, K. Ochi, and A. B. Gwaram, “Plant population and fertilizer application effects on biomass productivity of Moringa oleifera in North-Central Nigeria,” Peak Journal of Agricultural Sciences, vol. 1, no. 6, pp. 94–100, 2013.

W. M. Imoro, I. Sackey, and A.-H. Abubakari, “Preliminary study on the effects of two different sources of organic manure on the growth performance of Moringa oleifera seedlings,” Journal of Biology Agriculture and Healthcare, vol. 2, no. 10, 2012.

J. M. Wapa, S. O. Ojeniyi, and J. D. OKwari, “Response of extra-early maize variety to different organic manure in the drier sub region of Northern Nigeria,” Nigeria Journal of Soil Science, vol. 23, no. 2, pp. 52–59, 2013.

K. Miezah, J. Ofosu-Anim, G. K. O. Budu, L. Enu-Kwesi, and O. Cofie, “Isolation and identification of some plant growth promoting substances in compost and co-compost,” International Journal of Virology, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 30–40, 2008.

K. E. Law-Ogbomo, S. O. Ojeniyi, and F. E. OMazi, “Combined and sole application of compost and NPK effect on Okra yield, soil and nutrient content,” Nigeria Journal of Soil Science, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 130–135, 2013.

C. T. Atere and A. Olayinka, “Soil chemical properties and growth of maize as affected by cocoa pod compost base N and P fertilizer,” Nigeria Journal of Soil Science, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 83–93, 2013.

K. S. Chukwuka and O. E. Omotayo, “Soil fertility restoration potentials of tithonia green manure and water hyacinth compost on nutrient depleted soil in south western Nigeria using maize as test crop,” Research Journal of Biology, vol. 1, pp. 20–30, 2009.

F. A. Olowokere, J. K. Adesodun, C. O. Adejuyigbe et al., “Soil chemical properties, yield and nutrient uptake and animal based organic amendments,” Nigeria Journal of Soil Science, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 197–206, 2013.