How Do Climate and Nonclimatic Variables Influence the Production of Agricultural Staple Crops in Vulnerable Rural Communities in the Bawku Municipality of Northern Ghana?

We examined the influence of climate (temperature and rainfall) and nonclimatic variables (soil fertility using soil pH and organic matter) on the production of agricultural staple crops (maize [Zea mays L.], millet [Pennisetum glaucum L.], and rice [Oryza sativa L.]) in vulnerable communities in the Bawku Municipality of northern Ghana. Using five selected farming communities as study sites, multiple datasets were obtained from primary and secondary sources. Participatory approaches together with questionnaires were used as data collection tools to quantify and qualify climate (temperature and rainfall) and nonclimatic variables (soil fertility using soil pH and organic matter) and crop production. )e Mann–Kendall trend test results indicate a significant variation in annual rainfall for the 15-year period (1999 to 2013) with a relatively stable mean temperature variation in the Municipality. )e results of the multiple regression indicate that climatic and nonclimatic factors, particularly rainfall, soil pH, and organic matter have a significant positive effect on maize, millet, and rice when other factors are held constant. We conclude that to ease the burden of climate on production, better irrigation facilities be provided for the Municipality and weather forecasting information on the pending growing season be made available to farmers to enable them take informed decision. Also, policy on climate adaptation should take into account the interaction of external drivers of climate and nonclimatic variables to better build farmers’ resilience for food security at the local level.


Introduction
e dynamic oscillation of the Earth's climate is a reality. e variation in the climate system across spatial scales is what is termed as climate variability (henceforth CV) [1]. Under global warming, it is projected that climate variables including temperature and rainfall will vary with disproportional effects on agriculture [2][3][4]. e complexity of CV remains a cardinal challenge for sustainable agriculture and food security [4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11]. Regionally, Sub-Saharan Africa illuminates high level of vulnerability to food insecurity due to the considerable impacts CV has on agricultural systems which remain the "oxygen" that supports the economies.
Low precipitation considerably affects agricultural systems of many SSA countries [12]. Many staple crops have suffered drastic declines which consequently affected the livelihood of smallholder farmers in many parts of SSA including Ghana [13]. e big question is how susceptible food crop production might be to the interaction of climate and nonclimatic variables? Scholarship on how specific crops are adversely influenced by CV is abound in many parts of the world. For instance, Osbourne and Wheeler [9] indicate that, globally, between the years 1960 and 2009, rice yields declined considerably due to low rainfall. Scientific evidence suggests that, in many agricultural landscapes, crop yields are expected to fall between 10% and 20% because of increased CV risks [14]. In a related analysis, the IPCC estimated that 34 million to over 600 million are likely to suffer from starvation by 2080 [15]. us, it is increasingly relevant to ascertain the dynamics of how climate variables interact to influence crop production in order to develop strategic policies that will be sustainable for food security [16]. Apart from rainfall, high temperature is another climate determinant of many agricultural crops [4]. It is estimated that for each 1°C rise in average temperature, the income of farmers will potentially reduce by about 10% [5].
is may likely be intensified in many ird World countries due to their limited ability to adapt. Consequently, the economic hardship of farmers could intensify as a result of the impacts on livelihoods [17]. e myriad of impacts according to the IPCC [1] would be experienced differently across the continent due to other socioeconomic challenges.
Nonclimatic factors are also recognized as important factors that influence crop yield [18,19]. Technological and management factors such as irrigation, crop varieties, and fertilizer application are suggested as important nonclimatic factors that can directly or indirectly influence crop production, particularly maize [20]. Soil fertility is argued as an important nonclimatic driver that can considerably affect crop productivity, especially grains [19]. However, the consideration for nonclimatic variables and their concomitant risks on agricultural systems, particularly crop production is largely given little attention [21]. It is suggested that the interface of climate and nonclimatic factors are disproportional in terms of their impacts on crop production [22]. us, exploring how these variables influence different staple crops is important, particularly in SSA and Ghana where many people depend on agricultural crop production for their livelihood.
Ghana has not been exempted from the phenomenon of CV. is is because of the level of exposure and sensitivity of agricultural systems to CV in the country. Rainfall patterns have shifted, coupled with protracted drought spells and increased temperature conditions [23]. ese manifestations are considerably conspicuous in the northern sector with more expected future variations [6]. is situation will significantly constrain agricultural systems in many parts of Ghana, particularly the northern sector [8,24]. Since the agricultural sector employs a large proportion of the people of Ghana, any uncertainties due to CV could, therefore, cause great devastation to the economy of the country. e inadequate rainfall in 1982-1983 is a testament to how drought destroyed most crops and negatively affected more than 12 million people in the country [25]. Furthermore, in 2007, northern Ghana was wrecked by marauding flood waters that affected three hundred and seventeen thousand (317,000) people with the Central Gonja District being described as an environmental calamity; because, about twenty-six thousand eight hundred and twenty-two (26,822) acres of farmlands were destroyed [26]. Crop production data for staples such as maize (Zea mays L.), millet (Pennisetum glaucum L.), and rice (Oryza sativa L.) in Northern Ghana have been declining since the year 2010/2011 due to low rainfall [27].
Extensive research on CV risks on crops in Ghana has indicated the threats CV poses to agricultural crops [23,24,28]. However, little information is available in the literature on how climate and nonclimatic predictors, particularly temperature, rainfall, soil pH, and organic matter interact to dynamically influence the production of agricultural staple crops in vulnerable rural communities in northern Ghana. e challenge is, therefore, to investigate and fill this knowledge gap for a good policy link aimed at effective adaptative capacity building to mitigate the influence of climatic and nonclimatic risks on staple crop production. Specifically, this paper aims to quantify and qualify how climate and nonclimatic variables influence the production of agricultural staple crops with emphasis on maize (Zea mays L.), millet (Pennisetum glaucum L.), and rice (Oryza sativa L.) cultivated in many vulnerable rural communities in the Bawku Municipality of northern Ghana.

Study Site.
e Bawku Municipality is located in the extreme north-eastern part of Ghana and is one of the two Municipalities in the Upper East Region of Ghana ( Figure 1). It lies between latitudes 10°40 1 and 11°11 1 north of the Equator and longitudes 0°18 1 west and 0°6 1 east of the Greenwich Meridian. e Bawku municipality has a total land size of about 247.23720 km 2 . e municipality is bounded to the north by Burkina Faso, to the south by the Garu-Tempane District, to the west by Binduri District, and to the east by Pusiga District [29]. e Municipality is located within the Sudan Savanna zone with variable rainfall pattern and unfavourable soil characteristics to support agriculture. e research covered five communities in the Bawku Municipality.
ese are Mognori, Kuka, Gosezi, Zabugu, and Gentiga communities. e choice on the study sites was informed by the vulnerability of the Municipality to CV and staple insecurity.

Data Collection.
We employed both qualitative and quantitative data in the study for a comprehensive understanding of the issues. e two datasets were obtained from primary and secondary sources using questionnaires, focus group discussions (FGDs), and structured interview protocols. Questionnaires were administered in a face-to-face manner to food crop farmers. Focus Group Discussions were carried out in each community to generate conversations that uncover individual opinions regarding the effects of CV on food crop. Structured interviews were employed to obtain additional information from officials of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture (MoFA), Savanna Agriculture Research Institute (SARI), for their direct contact with farmers in the Municipality and the Ghana Meteorological Agency (GMA). e purpose was to explain and verify the findings from the questionnaires. e study relied on documented records of monthly observations of climate variables compiled by the GMA for a period of 15 years. e use of a 15-year data was considered as adequate because consistent collation of data over periods of 15 years or more according to Hochman et al. [30] provides a good basis for crop yield analysis in relation to CV. e climate variables used for the study were temperature and rainfall [1,5]. Production data on key food crops; maize (Zea mays L.), millet (Pennisetum glaucum L.), and rice (Oryza sativa L.) in the study area from 1999 to 2013 were also obtained from MoFA in Bawku for analysis. In addition, data on soil fertility in the Bawku Municipality over the period under investigation were obtained from the Soil Research Institute (SRI) in Kumasi. To assess which soil fertility variables are important in explaining the variations on crop yield, a correlation analysis was performed on staple crops and soil fertility variables (soil pH, organic matter, nitrogen, and phosphorus). Organic matter was found to be correlated with maize and millet while soil pH was correlated with rice. Soil pH was therefore used as a proxy for soil fertility in rice production and organic matter as a proxy for soil fertility in millet and maize production. e study participants were sampled simple randomly and purposively. e random sample of the survey participants were based on the model proposed by Kasiulevičius et al. [31]: where e � deviation of sampling, N � population size and n � sample size. e model has a confidence level of 95% and a 5% error margin [31]. e sample frame of the study consisted of a master list of household farmers of the five communities obtained from the Planning Department of the Bawku Municipal Assembly. A total of 214 household farmers were randomly sampled for the survey across the study communities (Table 1).

Data Analysis.
e quantitative data obtained from the farmers were processed and analysed using descriptive statistics. Frequency tables, cross-tabulations, bar graphs, and pie charts were used as tools for representing the survey data. Also, time series analysis was used to examine the trend in annual maximum and minimum temperatures as well as rainfall over the 15-year period (1999 to 2013) with the help of MAKESENS Excel Software. e magnitude of the trends of the climate variables was tested by the Mann-Kendall trend test. e trend was quantified using Sen's slope formula:  Advances in Agriculture where x j and x k values are time j and k, respectively. e median of these N values of Q i is Sen's estimator of the slope. Also, the variability of rainfall, temperature, and food crop production was analysed using the coefficient of variation. is was determined by dividing the standard deviation by the mean. A multiple regression model (Ordinary Least Square procedure) was used to analyse the influence of climatic (temperature and rainfall) and nonclimatic (soil pH and organic matter) factors on three major food crops, maize e multiple regression model was used due to the fact that it has been widely used in analyzing the effects/impacts of climate variability/change on food crop production [7,32]. To ensure the robustness and validity of the estimates of the multiple regression model, the underpinning assumption of normal distributions, homoscedasticity, and serially uncorrelated errors were tested using Jacque-Bera, Breusch-Pagan-Godfrey test, and Breusch-Godfrey Serial Correlation LM Test (Antonakis and Deitz, 2011 cited in Ballance) [33]. e level of significance for the study was set at 0.05. e linear regression model used is similar to the model used by Onoja and Ajie [34] to analyse how food crops respond to climate variability and microeconomic policies reform in Nigeria. e model is presented as where Y is the dependent variable; X is the independent variable while µ is the stochastic error term, and βo is the intercept of the model. Natural logarithms of the variables were taken to strengthen out exponential growth pattern and reduce the potential heterogeneity of variance of error terms; that is, to stabilize variance [35].
where RA � annual rainfall in millimeters in the Bawku Municipality; TE � mean annual temperature in°C in the Bawku Municipality; SPH � soil pH; ORG � organic matter; µ � stochastic error term; and βo � intercept of the model. e qualitative data recorded from the focus group discussions and structured interviews were analysed thematically based on different responses and used as vital elements of written text to better understand how farmers perceived the effect of climate variability on food crop production.

Rainfall Variation and Trend.
Rainfall amount and timing influence the yield of crops. Low rainfall amounts can be detrimental to crop yield, particularly if dry periods occur during the critical stages of development of the crop [8]. e total annual amount of rainfall and the trend over the 15year period in the Bawku Municipality are displayed in Figure 2. e mean annual total rainfall from 1999-2013 is 901.9 mm. e total annual rainfall for the period ranged from a low of 217.9 mm in 2008 to a high of almost 1376 mm in 2007. Generally, the Mann-Kendall trend test of the rainfall dataset from 1999 to 2013 shows that at 5% significance level, the trend is not statistically significant. Sen's estimate (−26.567) indicates a decreasing trend ( Figure 2). is is congruent to the findings of Asante and Amuakwa-Mensah [36] whose study of climate change and variability in Ghana reported decreasing trends of total rainfall amounts in northern Ghana. e variability in the year to year rainfall particularly towards the decreasing trend is a cautioning sign to the farming communities in the Municipality as this may adversely affect their livelihoods.
From Figure 3, the years 2005, 2008, 2010, and 2011 had a negative deviation signifying meteorological drought (period of below average precipitation) periods with the worst drought occurring in 2008. Global record of rainfall indicates a substantially high rainfall in 2005 and 2010 that resulted in severe floods in many parts of the world [37]. e positive deviation in 1999 and 2007 according to Paeth et al. [38] is attributable to the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) effects which caused much rainfall in Sub Sahara Africa. is implies that severe floods might have occurred in 1999 and 2007 in the Bawku Municipality. Report by the Daily Graphic online [39] that floods occurred in the Upper West, Upper East, and the Northern Regions of Ghana confirms possibility of such earlier events. is may have affected agricultural activities in the Municipality. e estimated annual anomaly of rainfall ( Figure 3) indicates that the total amount of annual rainfall varied substantially from year to year. is confirms the findings of Amikuzuno and Donkoh [23] that the prevailing evidence in the rainfall pattern observed in the semiarid regions of Africa is highly variable.
With regard to farmers' observations, all the respondents claim to have observed rainfall variation in the 15 years spanning 1999 to 2013. Approximately, 37% of farmers were of the view that the amount of rainfall has reduced. irtyfive of the respondents representing 16.4% reported that the length of the rainy season had reduced. Interestingly, 28.5% and 18.2% noticed an irregularity in the amount of rainfall  Advances in Agriculture and a reduction in how long the rainy season lasts respectively (Table 2). Similarly, key informants from SARI, MoFA, and GMA had also noted some pronounced variations in the rainfall pattern. According to the key informants, the rains either come earlier or later than expected. is was supported by a male farmer in Gentiga who pointed out in a focus group discussion that (i) "When we were young, our wells and rivers were full in the rainy season which enabled us to get water in the dry season, drawing water from wells was not difficult but nowadays our wells and rivers have little water even in the rainy season... e rains do not fall as they used to. My biggest worry is its unpredictable nature" (FGD, 2014) Generally, it was observed that respondents were much perturbed by the abnormality of the rainfall pattern in the Municipality which sometimes made it difficult to accurately predict when to start planting. e results presented show farmers observations are in line with the historical rainfall data for the 15-year period.  However, the Mann-Kendall trend statistics for mean annual minimum temperature at 5% significance level was not statistically significant. e mean minimum temperature for 1999 (22.7°C) was found to be the same as the mean value (22.7°C) for the 15-year period, showing no change for 1999. However, the years 2002 to 2006 and 2010 illustrate a significant increase in the minimum temperature with a positive deviation of between 0.2°C and 0.9°C above the baseline average ( Figure 5). e rest of the years recorded negative deviations with the highest decrease of 1.53°C observed in 2012. is significant interannual variation in minimum temperature may have affected crop production in the Municipality. is is because a decrease in minimum temperatures affects night time plant respiration rate and possibly reduces crop yield [40]; meanwhile, when plants are exposed to higher minimum temperatures, it decreases their ability to grow and also reduces crop yield [41].

Mean Annual Maximum Temperature.
e mean annual maximum temperature varied between 33.6°C and 35.8°C for the 15-year period. e total mean maximum temperature from 1999-2013 was 35.05°C. e trend statistics of the Mann-Kendall test at 5% significance level for the mean annual maximum temperature is not statistically significant. However, the observed trend of Sen's estimate (−0.017) of the Mann-Kendall test for the mean annual maximum temperature over the 15-year period portrays a decreasing trend (Figure 6).
Notwithstanding the above information, the mean maximum temperatures from 1999 to 2013 show distinctive interannual variation ( Figure 6). In general, the maximum temperature decreased below the mean for     is has the tendency to cause fluctuations in crop output in the Municipality.
ough, there are significant discrepancies in the interannual minimum and maximum temperature in the Municipality, the coefficient of variation (0.0155) for the mean annual temperature shows slight variation. is confirms the findings of Amikuzuno and Donkoh [23] that Northern Ghana has not significantly experienced notable temperature variation.
Superimposing the annual mean maximum temperature on the annual rainfall deviation for the 15-year period shows that effective rainfall for food crop production in 2005, 2010, and 2011 was very low. is is because total annual rainfall for these years was below the baseline average while the temperature was high. Low annual rainfall coupled with high temperature on one hand results in poor organic matter content, making soil suitability for cropping one of the major problems in crop production [42]. is is likely to have had negative consequences on food crop production. On the other hand, the high rainfall coupled with low maximum temperature in 2007 and 2012 suggests that effective rainfall for these years were high.
is may have benefited some crops. High temperature and high rainfall were recorded in 1999 and 2003. According to Shakoor et al. [43], high temperature and high rainfall are beneficial for all tropical crops but will produce negative effects if these climatic variables are increased too much in the future.
With respect to respondents' observations, the results indicate that most farmers (86.4%) had observed temperature variation in the last 15 years. Majority of the farmers (76.1%) who observed temperature variation believed that temperature has been increasing for the past 15 years (Figure 8), whereas 10.3% observed irregularities in temperature.
ough most farmers asserted that temperatures have increased, the observed mean annual temperature for the Municipality showed a decreasing trend. Farmers' observations are therefore at variance with the observed trend. Perhaps, the daily and monthly temperatures observed by the farmers were significant enough for them to notice some increase in temperature. It is clear from the results that farmers are aware of the temperature variation of the Municipality through their own experiences of the past. (1999)(2000)(2001)(2002)(2003)(2004)(2005)(2006)(2007)(2008)(2009)(2010)(2011)(2012)(2013). Figure 9 shows variation in the output figures of the three major food crops grown in the Municipality from 1999 to 2013. e first five years of the study period depict high production for the major food crops as compared to the second five years of the study period. Even though production was high for the first five years, there was a significant variation in the output of the food crops. e low level of production in 2013, according to the Municipal Director of MoFA, was as a result of the carving out of a new district (Binduri District) from the Municipality. He explained that the splitting of the Bawku Municipality has reduced the production level of food crop since most food crop farmers are now part of the Binduri District. However, the year 2010 marked the worst season for maize and rice farmers when output levels fell tremendously. is is most likely due to the high maximum temperature and a low amount of rainfall recorded in 2010 [8,44,45]. Notwithstanding, the output of millet increased in 2010. Given that millet is drought-tolerant and grown as a famine crop [8,45], most farmers may have shifted to the cultivation of millet when rainfall was expected to be below average in 2010. is reflects the assertion by a key informant from SARI that millet production has almost replaced maize in the Municipality due to the observed short and erratic rainfall pattern. is may have contributed to the increased millet production in 2010. e variation in maize (CV � 0.4598), millet (CV � 0.5653), and rice (CV � 0.3860) for the 15-year period could have implications for food security and livelihoods of farmers.

Effect of Climate Variability on Food Crop Production.
We assessed and quantified the effects of climate variability on food crop production using a multiple regression model. e multiple regression results of the residual diagnostic test of assumptions are presented in Table 3. e residual diagnosis for the test for heteroscedasticity for rice, maize, and millet using the Breusch-Pagan-Godfrey test did not show any heteroscedasticity at 5% significance level; thus, the variance of the error term is constant. e result of the serial correlation in determining the autocorrelation shows that there is no correlation among the residuals in the regression model for maize (Zea mays L.), millet (Pennisetum glaucum L.), and rice (Oryza sativa L.). e test for normality using Jarque-Bera statistics also  Advances in Agriculture 7 indicates that the residuals are normally distributed. e results of the diagnostic test for rice, maize, and millet production, therefore, satisfied the assumptions of the multiple regression model. is implies that there are no problems that will significantly affect the regression results for rice, maize, and millet production.

Effect of Climate Variability on Rice (Oryza sativa L.)
Production.
e results of the log-linear regression model used for estimating the influence of climatic (mean annual temperature and annual rainfall) and nonclimatic (soil pH) variables on rice production is presented in Table 4. e coefficient of determination (R 2 � 0.5838) of the results shows that approximately 58.4% of the variation in the log of rice is explained by the log of average temperature, annual rainfall, and soil fertility. e remaining percentage (41.6%) could be attributed to other factors such as seed varieties, method of cultivation, etc. e insignificant levels of temperature and rainfall could be attributed to the low variation in average temperature (Table 5) during the study period (1999-2013) and use of irrigation for rice production in the Sudan Savanna Zone [24,46]. However, the result indicates that soil pH is statistically significant at 5% (p < 0.0251) and positively influences rice production. is may be due to the desirable soil pH (5.5 to 6.5) for rice production in the Bawku Municipality. e result, therefore, implies that a 1% increase in soil pH potentially leads to a 6.6% increase in rice yield holding other variables constant.
e estimation, therefore, shows that rice production in the Municipality for the 15-year period was largely dependent on soil pH. is result is similar to the findings of Azman et al. [47] who observed in their study that relative rice yield is affected by soil pH. is suggests that growing rice in an area with low soil pH could have adverse effects on the output of rice. From the regression results, it could be confirmed that soil pH rather than rainfall and temperature was an influential factor determining the variation in rice yield in the Municipality from 1999 to 2013.

Effect of Climate Variability on Maize (Zea mays L.)
Production. Table 6 presents the results of the multiple regression used for estimating the influence of annual rainfall, average temperature, and soil organic matter on maize yield. From the results, the F-statistic is statistically    Advances in Agriculture significant at the 5% level (p < 0.0131). is means that the explanatory variables specified in the maize production model are jointly significant. e results show that about 60.9% (R 2 � 0.6091) of the variation in the log of maize is explained by the log of average temperature, annual rainfall, and organic matter. e remaining percentage (39.1%) could be attributed to other factors such as seed varieties, method of cultivation, etc.
e annual rainfall (p < 0.0319) and organic matter (p < 0.347) at 5% significance level are statistically significant and positively contribute to maize production. e result, therefore, implies that a 1% increase in soil organic matter results in a 1.9% increase in maize yield holding other variables constant. is means that maize production in the Municipality would be partly influenced by nonclimatic variables. e result also shows that every 1% increase in rainfall potentially leads to a 0.7% increase in maize production holding other variables constant. is also means that as rainfall increases, maize yield also increases. ese validate the study objective on the influence of observed climatic trends on food crop production. However, the average temperature is not statistically significant at 5% significance level.
us, the estimation shows that maize production in the Municipality is principally dependent on rainfall and organic matter. Table 7 shows the results of the loglinear regression model used for estimating the influence of climatic (temperature and rainfall) and nonclimatic (organic matter) on millet production. e F-statistics is statistically significant at 5% significance level (p < 0.0444). is implies that the explanatory variables specified in the millet production model, namely, annual rainfall, average temperature, and organic matter are jointly significant. From Table 7, about 50.6% (R 2 � 0.5060) of the variation in the log of millet is explained by the log of average temperature, annual rainfall, and organic matter. e remaining percentage (49.4%) could be attributed to other factors such as seed varieties, method of cultivation, etc. e results further reveal that organic matter is statistically significant with a p-value of 0.0128 (Table 7). e implication is that, holding other variables constant, a 1% increase in organic matter potentially leads to a 2.6% increase in millet yield. e result corroborates the findings of Tunde et al. [45] and Amikuzuno and Donkoh [23] who noted that millet production in the Kwara State in Northern Nigeria and Northern Ghana appear to be insensitive to low rainfall, respectively. us, a low level of rainfall does not necessarily reduce millet production.

Effect of Climate Variability on Millet (Pennisetum glaucum L.) Production.
e estimation, therefore, shows that in the Municipality, millet production is highly dependent on organic matter and not rainfall and temperature which were found to be statistically insignificant in explaining the variation in millet output during the 15-year period.

Effects of Rainfall Variability on Food Crop Production as Perceived by the Farmers.
To triangulate the secondary data results with primary data, farmers' experiences were also obtained ( Figure 10). e results show that all the farmers perceived rainfall variability to adversely affect the production of their main staple crops. A 57 years old male respondent explained that Statistically, all the respondents (100%) indicated that the manifestations of rainfall variability have affected the growing season in the past 15 years. Also, nearly all the respondents (93%) were of the view that the variable nature of rainfall in the Municipality has reduced the length of the growing season while the remaining respondents (7%) observed irregularities in how long the growing season lasts. All the respondents (7%) who observed irregularities in the length of the growing season reported that crop yield had moderately reduced. More than 76% and 16% of those who reported of a reduction in the length of the growing season also reported that crop yields have severely and moderately reduced, respectively. e responses differed among the study communities. For instance, all the respondents in Gozesi and Gentiga pointed out that the shortened length of the growing season has severely reduced crop yields, whereas   Figure 10). Although most respondents attributed the reduction in crop yield to a shorter growing season, discussants of focus groups from the selected communities acknowledged factors such as pests and diseases, wrong use of fertilizer, outmoded farm practices, inadequate funds, and intertribal conflicts as some of the major factors affecting crop production. e above nonclimatic factors coupled with low rainfall amounts and frequent droughts have the propensity to worsen food insecurity among the most vulnerable households in the Municipality [8,45]. From the results, respondents' observations of the effect of rainfall variability on food crop production are in line with the regression results for maize production but inconsistent with rice and millet production. e inconsistency may be due to the influence of nonclimatic factors on food crop production as outlined by the farmers. Drawing on the results of the regression analysis and respondents' observations, it can be argued that rainfall variability for the 15-year period had a significant influence on the variation of food crop production in the Municipality.

Perceived Effects of Temperature Variability on Food
Crop Production. Also, we assessed farmers' perceived effects of temperature variability on food crop production. e results show that majority of the respondents (86.4%) were of the view that temperature variability negatively affects crop production especially maize. Out of the 86.4% respondents who claimed that temperature variability had badly affected crop production, 23.4%, 22.9%, 15.9%, 11.7%, and 12.6% were from Mognori, Zabugu, Gozesi, Kuka, and Gentiga respectively (Figure 11). ese farmers asserted that there was a reduction in maize yield. Several studies have demonstrated similar results. Previous studies have observed that temperature increase above the requirement of between 30°C-34°C for maize production would reduce maize yield significantly [48][49][50][51].
In support of the above findings, interviews with officials of MoFA and SARI revealed that high temperatures during the main cropping season and dry season gardening lead to stunted growth and low yields of crops like maize, sorghum, onions, groundnut, and other vegetables. e official from SARI explained that high temperatures during the growing season negatively affects the respiration and transpiration of plants and in turn affects plant development and yield. is assertion is also buttressed by McCarl [52] and Fosu-Mensah [8] whose findings revealed that high temperatures influence the respiration needs and raises water demand for plant growth. Consequently, these factors will affect crop development and reduce crop yield [53].
Probing further to ascertain other possible factors responsible for low yield or crop failure, discussants of focus groups from the selected communities outlined poor farm practices, poor seeds, and misapplication of fertilizers as the key factors that may affect crop production. Despite the adverse effects of temperature variability on food crop production revealed by the survey, discussants of a focus group at Zabugu explained that millet thrives well under high temperatures with little amount of water. As a result, more millet is being produced in recent times. is finding supports previous studies on how millet and other droughttolerant crops are well adapted to high temperatures [8,46,54].
Similarly, some discussants at Gentiga and Gozesi also argued that increased temperature during the harvest time helps reduce postharvest losses in cereals, particularly maize, and rice. e results revealed by the respondents on the effects of temperature variability on food crop production supports the idea that climatic variables may have both negative and positive implications on food crop production.
In general, the respondents in the Municipality seem to have noticed that temperature variability negatively affects maize production. However, the regression results indicated otherwise. e discrepancy between farmers' observations and the regression results may be due to the use of the mean annual temperature that mostly conceals daily extremes. In addition, the disparity may also be due to the influence of nonclimatic factors on food crop production as outlined by the farmers.

Conclusion and Policy Implications
is paper analysed how climate (rainfall and temperature) and nonclimatic variables (soil fertility using soil pH and organic matter) influence the production of agricultural staple crops of maize (Zea mays L.), millet (Pennisetum glaucum L.), and rice (Oryza sativa L.) in vulnerable rural communities in the Bawku Municipality of northern Ghana.
e study revealed a decreasing trend with significant variation in the rainfall pattern while mean temperature showed a marginal decreasing trend with less variation over the 15-year period. e multiple regression model revealed that rainfall and organic matter had a significant positive influence on maize production. us, maize production in the Municipality is mainly dependent on rainfall and organic matter. Similar to previous reports, mean temperature, and rainfall had no significant influence on millet and rice production in the Municipality. Nonetheless, organic matter and soil pH had a significant positive influence on millet and rice production, respectively. e prevailing evidence from the regression results suggests that temperature variation within the 15-year period had no significant influence on food crop production in the Municipality.
e results point to the need for effective ways to be adapted to a more uncertain rainfall pattern in the Municipality.
e results provide an opportunity to ensure sustainable crop production in the Municipality through a concerted effort between the Municipal Assembly, civil societies, NGOs, and farmers to negotiate and reach an agreement on pragmatic and effective adaptation measures. Not only will this option seek the concerns of farmers, it will also build the adaptive capacity of farmers in the Municipality. Provision of agricultural infrastructure such as irrigation facilities in the Bawku Municipality as well as improvement of existing ones could go a long way to address this critical challenge. is would encourage more farmers to farm during the long dry season. e provision of weather forecasts to farmers is central to farmers' adaptation because weather information has the tendency to influence farmers' decision on their farm operations. Finally, there is also the need for policy link by the government to promote the integration of indigenous knowledge and technologies with scientific knowledge to enable farmers adapt and develop agricultural resilience in the rapid climatic changes in Ghana.

Data Availability
Climate data used may be accessed from the Regional Meteorological Office, Bawku. Crop production figures may be accessed from the Municipal Directorate of the Ministry of Food and Agriculture, Bawku.

Conflicts of Interest
ere are no conflicts of interest for this paper.