Opportunities and Challenges for Pastoral Beef Cattle Production in Ethiopia

)e beef cattle production sector plays a crucial role in the livelihoods of pastoral farmers in Ethiopia, and it is the main source of beef animals for domestic and foreignmarkets. As compared to other African countries, Ethiopia has a huge beef cattle population (65.35 million heads). However, the quality and quantity of beef, as well as per capita meat consumption of Ethiopians, are very low (8.4 kg/individual/year). In this sense, the goal of this review was to provide and synthesize the most validated scientific information on the opportunities and challenges for pastoral beef cattle production in Ethiopia. )e potential for pastoral beef cattle producers in Ethiopia included population growth, urbanization, literacy, and family income, as well as high demand for beef animals in domestic and foreign markets. In contrast, problems with beef cattle production systems, diseases, shortages of feed and water, lack of veterinary services, droughts, lack of market access and infrastructure, illegal animal trades, and poor genetic potential of indigenous cattle are among the limiting factors that hamper efficient beef production in the country. In Ethiopia, the yield and compositional quality of beef are very low compared to other African countries and the global market in general. )erefore, empowering pastoral beef cattle producers will help us to supply high quality and quantity of beef and will ensure sustainable beef cattle production with an identified market destination and access.


Introduction
Livestock production has a considerable contribution to the economy of Ethiopia and plays a vital role in providing export commodities like meat and meat products, live animals, hides and skins, and leather products to earn foreign currency [1]. Although the country is gifted with a very high potential for livestock resources, the sector's contribution to the national economy is much lower than its production potential [2]. e beef cattle production sector is critical to the livelihoods of pastoral farmers in Ethiopia, providing income, food, draught power, and a common asset for households [3,4]. e total number of cattle in the country is estimated to be 65.35 million heads, which is the highest in Africa [1]. Among these, 99.4% of the total cattle in the country are local breeds. e proportion of hybrid and exotic breeds is too small, at only 0.58% and 0.07%, respectively. One-fourth of cattle aged between 3 and 10 years are used for draught purposes, while the percentage of beef cattle (i.e., cattle reared exclusively for meat) is about 0.72% [5,6]. Despite the fact that there are a huge number of cattle in Ethiopia, the contribution of the sector to earning foreign currency and total gross domestic product (GDP) is still very low [7].
On the other hand, since there are no or little improved beef cattle breeds and production systems in Ethiopia, the yield and compositional quality of beef are very low compared to other African countries [8].
e cattle breeds in the country are multipurpose types, with the majority found in the traditional highland practices [9]. e current or existing beef cattle production systems in Ethiopia are traditional highland practices (mixed crop-livestock production system), by-product fattening, and Hararghe fattening systems [10,11]. Despite the fact that Ethiopia has a large beef cattle population compared to other African countries, the average per capita meat consumption of Ethiopians is very low (8.4 kg/individual/year), and the beef produced in the country is not of high quality [10]. In this regard, numerous pastoral beef cattle producers sell their animals when they need money or a drought hits [12][13][14].
Consequently, the majority of pastorals do not consider the live beef animal trade as a profitable enterprise or a small business segment, and they do not pay attention to beef cattle husbandry practices that could increase their animal market value. In general, pastoral beef cattle producers in Ethiopia do not consider beef cattle production as their primary objective, but dairy production [15].
As a result, Ethiopia's beef productivity is 110 kg/head, which is around 25-30% lower than other East African countries (143 kg/head) or the continental average (156 kg/head), whereas the global average is 212 kg/head [16]. Furthermore, in many sections of the country, pastoral cattle producers constitute the primary supply of beef animals for domestic and international markets. Several studies on the productivity of beef cattle have been undertaken in the past in various parts of the country [16]. However, in Ethiopia, the limiting reasons and potential for a sustainable beef export marketing system, as well as the degree of competitiveness with domestic and worldwide demand, have not been well investigated and gathered [17]. In this regard, multiple researches have been undertaken in various parts of the country in order to identify the potentials and limitations of farmers' beef cattle fattening operations. However, the opportunities and challenges for pastoral beef cattle production have not been thoroughly investigated or collated. erefore, the goal of this review was to provide and synthesize scientifically validated and up-to-date information on the potentials and challenges for pastoral beef cattle production in Ethiopia with the following specific objectives: (i) To outline the opportunities for pastoral beef cattle production (ii) To identify the challenges for pastoral beef cattle production

Review Method
is review is based on theories and empirical findings, with saturated information extracted. Experiments and scientific findings were utilized to filter data and focus on recent publications. e period of search for this script is from January 10, 2021, to March 30, 2021. e script's literature search focused primarily on the challenges and opportunities for pastoral beef cattle production in Ethiopia. e information provided by Google Scholar, as well as peer-reviewed major indexers such as Web of Science, PubMed, and Scopus, was used to extract useful information during this review script. us, keywords such as "opportunities and challenges for pastoral beef cattle production" were used to find journal articles, papers, books, and symposia. e next section of this script will go through some concepts and experimental settings from the perspectives of pastoral beef cattle production opportunities and pastoral beef cattle production challenges in Ethiopia.

Domestic and Foreign Demand for Beef Cattle.
According to several studies, Ethiopians' demand for beef is increasing over time due to population growth, urbanization, literacy, and family income [9,[18][19][20]. Meat consumption is an excellent indicator of a person's economic position, and people in higher social classes have a stronger demand for high-quality meat products [21]. is might be a huge win for small-scale beef cattle producers across the country. Furthermore, local butchers and abattoirs in Ethiopia have a significant demand for beef animals in order to maintain a steady supply of high-quality live animals and to meet the needs of their customers, among other things, in order to improve their efficiency and competitiveness. In addition, the government earns foreign currency through exporting live cattle animals, particularly red meat, to the Middle East and other African countries [22,23]. According to FAO [24], meat demand in low-and middle-income countries will rise by 80 percent by 2030 and more than 200 percent by 2050. is is owing to the high population growth rate [25]. According to ornton [26], the demand for livestock goods such as milk, meat, and eggs is fast increasing in Ethiopia because the majority of livestock products are derived from pastoral farmers [3]. According to Ameha's [27] research, the export sector has a significant influence over the meat and live animal industries.
e number of contemporary livestock product sector firms developed in the country, particularly meat export firms, has been expanding, as has the capacity of domestic abattoirs, the amount of meat exported, and the hard currency earned from this industry (meat) [28].
Furthermore, the country's enormous cattle population of various breeds, as well as the country's few legal live animal and meat exporters, provides further chances for beef cattle fattening enterprises, which mostly acquire beef cattle from pastoralists and pastoral farmers [3]. According to the Ethiopian tax and customs administration, live animal exports accounted for 70% of revenues in 2010, while meat exports accounted for 30%. Cattle accounted for 46% of the total exported live animals and contributed to 67 percent of the cash earned. ere is also the chance of expanding to Asian countries like Malaysia, where hall-slaughtered, frozen, skin-off corpses are required, and hygiene laws are less rigorous [29]. e volume of meat and meat products exported by Ethiopia during the last five years was varied from 2014 to 2018. ese variations might be due to drought, diseases, and illegal trade. Even though there were occasional variations, the volume of meat and meat products exported increased from 2013/14 to 2017/18, according to the data given in Figure 1.

Socioeconomic Importance of Beef Cattle.
Animal husbandry practices make a substantial contribution to improving pastoral food security, particularly for pastoralists who rely entirely on their livestock [4]. Beef cattle farming employs 12.5 million people (70 percent of the total population) [24]. e sector also provides social and cultural value, adds to environmental values, and supports the rural community's livelihood by providing jobs, maintaining food security, and generating revenue [31]. Even if the industry's contribution falls short of its potential, the livestock sector accounts for 15% of export revenues, 16.5 percent of national GDP, 30% of agricultural employment, and 35.6 percent of agricultural GDP in Ethiopia's economy [5]. Ethiopians rely on beef cattle for revenue, food security, manure, investment, and foreign currency profits, as well as social and cultural identity.
In most agropastoral communities, livestock serves as the best asset for social activities. Cattle are utilized for dowering price, pride, and sacrifices for social events in the peripheral highlands and pastoral and agropastoral districts. Although most agricultural strategies are skewed towards crops for food security reasons, livestock is also an anchor for economic diversification and sustainable rural development. In Ethiopia, livestock is a primary source of income and food for the majority of rural people in pastoral and agropastoral farming systems due to the poor potential for crop development, particularly the lack of and/or restricted irrigation methods. Because of its various social, economic, and cultural applications, livestock ownership, in terms of both number and quality, is a valuable asset in this regard [32].

Challenges for Pastoral Beef Cattle Production.
Pastoral beef cattle production in Ethiopia was severely limited by disease outbreaks, a lack of both quality and quantity of feed and water, a lack of veterinary services, the occurrence of droughts, a lack of market access and infrastructure, illegal live animal trades, and the genetic potential of indigenous cattle breeds.

Feed Shortage in Both Quality and Quantity.
Natural grasses and agricultural leftovers, which have poor nutritional content and are not consistently supplied owing to seasonal fluctuations and drought, are the main feed resources for pastoral beef cattle farmers in Ethiopia [33,34]. ey may also differ among Ethiopia's various beef cattle production systems [35]. is could have a negative impact on the carcass production and beef quality of beef animals. In contrast, Dinku [18] stated that, during dry seasons, feed shortages and nutrient deficiencies are more severe.
According to Matawork [36], communal, uncontrolled, free, and private grazing grounds are the most available feed supply for pastoral beef cattle producers in many parts of the country. During the summer, however, these grazing fields turn muddy and are no longer suitable for grazing cattle. Crop wastes are also an important source of feed for pastoral farmers in the country during the dry season.
Similarly, Agegnehu et al. [22] found that feed scarcity for beef cattle is severe, in terms of both quality and quantity, notably in pastoral areas of Ethiopia, particularly in January and February. is could cause cattle cows' growth patterns to fluctuate and become erratic. Furthermore, both pastoral and agropastoral pastoral beef animal farmers use natural pasture grazing as their primary method of production. Due to overgrazing, this grazing ground is insufficient for beef cattle production, and it has seriously deteriorated and diminished from year to year [37]. Figure 2 depicts Ethiopia's key livestock feed resources and their proportions. According to the statistics, green fodder (grazing), agricultural leftovers, and hay are the main feed sources for pastoral farmers' cattle in Ethiopia. According to the statistics, the quality and supply of these resources vary periodically.
is may have an impact on the country's beef production.

Water Shortage.
During the dry season, water shortages, even if of low quality, are a major issue in many regions of the country, and the situation is exacerbated in pastoral areas where pastoral beef cattle producers have few wells, resulting in a variety of waterborne diseases in beef animals [34]. It is only available from wells and a few lakes and streams [38]. Similarly, pastoral beef animal producers walk with their cattle for more than 6-8 hours every day during dry seasons to find a source of water [39]. Animals' body weight, carcass yield, and quality decline as a result of this. Tolera and Abebe [38] and Kedija et al. [40] also showed that as the watering interval increases, the feed conversion efficiency of animals decreases. Similarly, Andualem et al. [34] found that poor water quality in cattle animals is linked to infections and helminth infestation, resulting in a lower carcass yield. Advances in Agriculture

Diseases of Beef Cattle.
Diseases have a variety of detrimental effects on herd productivity, such as animal death, weight loss, slowed growth, poor fertility performance, and physical weakness. Diseases have been combated in a variety of ways, including immunizations (preventive measures) and therapies (curative measures). Even though many experts throughout the world recommend proper preventive and curative approaches, there is a paucity of scientific data on illness prevalence, immunizations, and therapies in Ethiopia, which makes fundamental disease prevention and control difficult [1]. Anthrax, foot and mouth disease (FMD), blackleg, lumpy skin disease (LSD), pasteurellosis, and parasites (both ecto and endo) were all major challenges in the beef cattle production sector and could be the cause of poor beef animal performance at any stage of pastoral production systems. Poorly fed beef animals, for example, have low disease resistance and fertility issues, resulting in low beef/meat production [41][42][43]. Physical contact between cattle animals brought from diverse locations via common pastures and watering as well as market areas, on the other hand, plays an essential role in the transmission of economically relevant infectious illnesses and parasites [44].
is may result in a reduction in animal tissue (muscle, fat, bone, and related tissues), resulting in poor quality and quantity of beef. Furthermore, according to Desta [45], beef animal diseases are the leading cause of economic and social losses among Ethiopian beef cow owners. is might have a significant detrimental impact on pastoral people, whose livelihood is entirely dependent on their livestock.

Lack of Market Access, Infrastructure, and Illegal Trade.
Other important limiting constraints for the pastoral beef cattle production sector in Ethiopia include a lack of market access and infrastructure, as well as illicit trade or contraband live beef animal trades, which are not conducive to efficient cattle marketing. is could make it difficult for small-scale beef cattle farmers to remain profitable and active in the industry. Similarly, Tewodros and Mebrate [35] stated that, due to the lack of a nearby market, beef cattle producers are forced to travel long distances to sell their animals, resulting in significant body weight loss and animals being exposed to physical injuries and illness, resulting in a reduction in money available to cattle producers in particular and the country in general. is scenario is exacerbated in pastoral area communities where beef animal farmers lack access to current market information. As a result, producers may be vulnerable to market uncertainty, which could stymie the country's livestock industry. Ethiopia's legal system is dominated by illegal beef animal marketing methods [46]. is may reduce the country's export abattoirs' capacity to export high-quality beef animals or meat to neighboring nations, making them less competitive in the regional or global meat/beef market [47]. Furthermore, despite the fact that beef cattle production contributes to the county's economy and pastoral livelihood, the production system is not sufficiently market-oriented [23]. e annual migration of beef cattle from Ethiopia to other adjacent countries via the illegal market is substantial, as shown in Figure 3. Brokers, according to the graph, purchase directly from producers or fattening cooperatives. Small-and medium-scale exporters ship those animals legally, whereas small-scale exporters and farmers export them illegally, resulting in a shortfall of both live beef animals and beef for the country's legal exporters. is could have ramifications for small-scale beef cattle farmers as well as the country's livestock economy.

Lack of Veterinary Service.
In many sections of the country, veterinary services are insufficient or unsatisfactory due to the lack of infrastructure and limited resources such as pharmaceuticals and veterinarians (people) [45,48]. Because pastoral and low-land-area community beef cattle producers in the country are mobile, this may be overlooked. e lack of veterinarians (people), as well as a lack of inputs such as medications, vaccines, and equipment, was the key impediment to providing successful veterinary services to pastoral farmers [49]. e vast majority of Ethiopian beef cattle owners do not have access to curative and preventive services. Only a few public clinics with a small number of veterinarians are accessible in major cities, and they mostly serve cattle owners. ese towns may completely overlook low-land and pastoral settlements. In general, animal health services are provided to only a few cattle farmers in and near towns in the country. is is mostly affecting the country's pastoral beef cattle output.

Lack of Improved Beef Cattle
Breeds. According to CSA [50], Ethiopian indigenous beef cow breeds are suited to feed and water limitations, disease resistance, and hard temperatures.
e output and productivity of indigenous beef animals, on the other hand, are quite low. Furthermore, Aynalem et al. [51] found that enhancing beef/meat output  in the country has been unsuccessful due to little or no genetic improvement in recent decades. As a result, an effective and long-term beef animal genetic development plan for Ethiopia's indigenous beef cow breeds is required. Ethiopian cattle breeds are divided into five categories: Humpless Brachyceros, Hamitic Longhorn, Zebu, Sanga, and intermediate between Sanga and Zebu, totaling 28 indigenous varieties. Although indigenous cattle can withstand hard weather, have strong disease resistance, and can adapt to a limited feed supply, their output per animal is poor [6]. e performance of cattle in terms of production and reproduction is a significant determinant factor in ensuring long-term livelihood improvement for individuals involved in the system. e Ethiopian livestock sector rarely employs technological adaptation since practically all livestock species are indigenous, and the fraction of hybrid livestock is too small, limiting average yields [52]. Improving the livestock industry in terms of quality and quantity is necessary in order to boost the export of leather and leather products, live animals, and livestock products such as leather and leather products, meat, and milk products. is can be aided by the production and use of genetically engineered plants and animals [53].
According to studies conducted by [54,55], Ethiopia introduced exotic cattle breeds several decades ago (since the 1950s), mostly the Holstein Friesian breed, when the United Nations donated 300 Friesian and Brown Swiss dairy cattle to Ethiopia, which were also crossbred with the indigenous once. Several cattle productivity development projects have been conducted in Ethiopia for various reasons. In 1963, the first cow genetic improvement program was established with the goal of developing commercial dairy farms [54]. According to the CSA study, the majority of cattle reared by the agrarian community in Ethiopia are local breeds and ecotypes, accounting for 98.2 percent of total cattle in the country, with 1.62 percent being crossbred and 0.18 percent being exotic cattle breeds [31].

Incidence of Drought.
Drought is one of the most significant limiting factors, particularly in the pastoral/lowland-area community beef animal production sector, as it causes a feed shortage and a water shortage, resulting in lower productivity and reduction in beef animal mature weight or longer time to reach mature weight [11]. According to the same authors, infestation of invasive species due to local weather change has limited the availability of herbaceous species, resulting in a necessary feed scarcity. According to ornton et al. [38], drought has a negative impact on the results or availability of animal feed resources, which could have a significant impact on cattle animal productivity, feeding choices, and grazing management. e situation for pastoral beef cattle producers in arid and semiarid areas is dire.
Pastoral beef cattle production in Ethiopia was severely limited by disease outbreaks, a lack of both quality and quantity of feed and water, a lack of veterinary services, the occurrence of droughts, a lack of market access and infrastructure, illegal live animal trades, and the genetic potential of indigenous cattle breeds. In general, shortages of feed, diseases and parasites, lack of veterinary services, drought, lack of market access and infrastructure, and poor genetic potential of indigenous cattle breeds are the most recent major identified constraints of beef cattle production and fattening practice as expressed by farmers in various parts of the country, as shown in Table 1.  Advances in Agriculture 5

Conclusions
e purpose of this review was to collate the opportunities and challenges for pastoral beef cattle production in Ethiopia.
e rapid growth of the Ethiopian population, urbanization, literacy, and family income, as well as the high demand for live beef animals and red meat by domestic abattoirs and other countries, were among the prospects or potentials for pastoral beef cattle producers. Traditional beef cattle production systems, diseases, lack of feed and water, lack of veterinary services, drought, lack of market and infrastructure, illegal trades, and the genetic potential of indigenous cattle breeds were among the main hindrances to Ethiopian beef cattle production being sustainable and successful. Furthermore, while pastoral beef cattle producers in Ethiopia were not considered a small business segment, and the majority of beef came from old oxen kept for draft purposes, culled cows, and surplus young bulls, the level or quality of beef produced in Ethiopia is lower than that in the market of other East African countries and the global market in general. e following suggestions are made based on the aforesaid conclusion: (i) To alleviate the serious shortage of animal feed in Ethiopia, the government should pay special attention to pastoral farmers' cattle production and establish a framework for introducing, adapting, and growing improved or drought-resistant forages or grass species (ii) e responsible body should provide knowledge and skill-based training for pastoral beef cattle producers and create awareness for them to engage in different beef cattle fattening operations that may improve their production systems in collaboration with all the agricultural sectors of the country (iii) Sustainable pastoral beef cattle production with a defined market destination or a strong market linkage with other market chain sectors should be established by the government of Ethiopia in order to reduce the amount of money lost to the country illicit or contraband live beef cattle merchants (iv) e genetic makeup of country beef cattle breeds should be improved by crossbreeding with exotic cattle breeds, as well as pastoral beef cattle production systems (v) Affordable community-based animal health service delivery, encompassing pastoral and rural populations, should be implemented, as this may increase Ethiopia's beef production competitiveness in contrast to other East African countries Data Availability e document used to support the review of this paper is available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Conflicts of Interest
ere are no conflicts of interest related to the publication of this review manuscript. Shortage of feed and water; limited knowledge; poor genetic potential of cattle 123 [62] 6 Advances in Agriculture