Advances in Civil Engineering
Volume 2020 (2020), Article ID 1426485, 16 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/1426485

Research Article

Experimental Study on the Saturated Compacted Loess Permeability under K₀ Consolidation

Yan-zhou Hao,¹ Tie-hang Wang,¹ Xin Jin,¹ Lei Cheng,² and Jiang-le Li¹

¹College of Civil Engineering, Xi’ an University of Architecture and Technology, Xi’an, Shaanxi 710055, China
²College of Engineering Management and Real Estate, Henan University of Economics and Law, Zhengzhou, Henan 450046, China

Correspondence should be addressed to Yan-zhou Hao; 30010508@hncj.edu.cn

Received 16 September 2019; Revised 11 December 2019; Accepted 12 December 2019; Published 29 February 2020

Academic Editor: Robert Černý

Copyright © 2020 Yan-zhou Hao et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract.

This paper investigates the permeability characteristics of compacted loess by focusing on the anisotropy parallel and perpendicular to the compaction. Three tests are conducted on compacted loess: triaxial permeability test under confining pressure consolidation, triaxial permeability test under K₀ consolidation, and SEM test. Samples are maintained and tested at different dry densities under saturated conditions. The test results show that the saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess is exponentially related to the initial dry density under both confining pressure consolidation and K₀ consolidation. The fitting equation can estimate the saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess at different depths. The horizontal saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess is larger than that in the vertical direction, showing obvious anisotropy. The saturated permeability anisotropy ratio is linearly related to the initial dry density. Comparing and analysing the saturated permeability coefficient, the saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess under the K₀ consolidation condition is smaller than that under the confining pressure consolidation condition. Under the condition of K₀ consolidation, the connectivity of vertical and horizontal pores of compacted loess is weakened, the tortuosity is strengthened, and the void ratio is decreased. K₀ consolidation makes the flake-, plate-, and needle-like particles in compacted loess rotate continuously parallel to the compaction surface, which enhances the orientation of particles and leads to the saturated permeability anisotropy increase. The research results provide the basis for water field analysis in loess filling engineering.

1. Introduction

Large-scale hill-cutting and gully-filling and artificial land-building projects have been carried out successively in the loess area in China. In addition, highway, railway, and airport construction in loess areas requires filling to make up for the shortage of the construction land. Compaction is the primary method employed to improve the mechanical properties of compacted loess and prepare loess-filled construction sites. Permeability is an important property of loess. Water infiltration weakens compacted loess; therefore, examining the permeability of compacted loess is of great significance to large-scale filling foundations, roadbeds, and slopes in loess areas in China.

Consolidation under confining pressure simplifies the stress state of the soil sample in situ to three-dimensional equal stress action, which simplifies the operation of the test, but the stress state of the soil sample does not conform to the actual situation, which will cause errors in the analysis of the water field in soil. K₀ consolidation is a consolidation process in which only axial strain occurs and no radial strain occurs under confining pressure and axial deviator stress, which is in accordance with the actual stress state of soil samples in the soil layer. At present, the study of soil permeability is mainly based on the triaxial permeability test. The soil samples of the triaxial permeability test are consolidated under isobaric conditions in all directions, which is inconsistent with the actual initial stress state of natural soil layer K₀ consolidation.

There are few studies on soil triaxial permeability and a lack of systematization under K₀ consolidation. Most studies focus on the permeability of sand and other soils under confining pressure consolidation. The hydraulic conductivity and the coefficient of consolidation of sands with 25% silt content are approximately two orders of magnitude smaller than those of clean sands at effective confining stresses of 50–300 kPa [1]. The saturated soil hydraulic conductivity is predicted from models by triaxial permeability test data under confining pressure consolidation [2, 3]. The saturated hydraulic conductivity of poorly graded sands with nonplastic silt was obtained by using a flexible wall permeameter [4]. The particle shape and packing density characteristics of sand or sand-silt mixtures affected the hydraulic conductivity during in situ testing and in estimating soil behavior in a number of other capacities [5, 6]. The saturated hydraulic conductivity of the sand-silt mixtures was obtained by triaxial tests at an effective confining pressure of 100 kPa to establish the relationship between the undrained shear strength and the saturated hydraulic conductivity and discussed the effect of the percentage of low plastic fines and void ratio of the soil [7]. Li [8] studied the relationship between permeability and porosity in loess. The permeability coefficient is affected by dry density [9, 10], dry-wet cycle [11], permeability time, confining pressure, structure [12], and osmotic pressure [13]. The permeability coefficient function of remolded unsaturated loess was established under varying humidity and density [14]. The above studies were conducted using conventional permeability tests.

Natural soils are generally considered to be in the state of K₀ consolidation [15, 16]. K₀ is defined as the ratio of the lateral effective stress to the vertical effective stress under the condition that no deformation occurs in the lateral direction of the soil. The study of the permeability of soil is generally carried out under the condition of triaxial confining pressure consolidation, after that the pore structure of soil is different from that under the condition of K₀ consolidation, which inevitably leads to the difference of permeability of soil. The permeability of soil under the in situ stress state (K₀ state) can better reflect the actual situation of water seepage in soil. Under the condition of triaxial equal confining pressure consolidation, the study of the permeability of soil is not consistent with the actual stress state of soil, which will inevitably produce some errors in the study of the distribution of the water field in soil. Therefore, it is of great practical significance to study the permeability of soil under the triaxial stress state under K₀ consolidation.

The tests of soil samples under K₀ consolidation are mostly focused on the effects of K₀ consolidation on the mechanical properties and deformation properties of different types of soils [17–31]. There are few reports on triaxial permeability of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation. Therefore, in this paper, the saturated triaxial permeability tests under confining pressure and K₀ consolidation are carried out for compacted loess samples with different dry densities and different consolidation confining pressure to obtain the permeability coefficients. Through comparative analysis of the permeability coefficient, the difference of saturated permeability of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation and confining pressure consolidation is obtained. The research contents are of great significance to the analysis of the water field in compacted loess.

2. Test Scheme

2.1. Samples

Soil samples used in this study were Q₃ Malan loess collected from a foundation pit in Xi’an, China. Malan loess is yellowish brown, relatively weak, and wet. The physical properties of loess samples were determined following the Chinese National Standards GB/T50123-1999 [32]. The grain size distribution curve is shown in Figure 1. The soil sample is silty clay, in which the content of silt particles reaches 63.8% (Table 1 and Figure 1).

Figure 1: Grain size distribution curve.

Table 1: Physical properties of loess.

Relative density GS
Liquid limit WL (%)
Plastic limit WP (%)
Plasticity index Ip
Particle composition (%)

>0.075 mm
0.075–0.01 mm
0.01–0.005 mm
<0.005 mm

2.72
30.8
18.6
12.2
3.72
52.18
15.44
28.66

According to laboratory compaction tests following the Chinese National Standards GB/T50123-1999 [32], the optimal soil sample moisture content was 18.9% and the maximum dry density was 1.73 g/cm³. Soil samples from the soil layer were naturally air-dried and then pulverized using a rubber hammer, which separated the cemented particles only but did not damage the loess particles. The pulverized loess was sieved through a 2 mm mesh in order to prepare soil samples with a moisture content of 18.9%, which were sealed for more than 48 hours to produce the desired water distribution. Samples were prepared using a specifically designed sample press. Wet soil was weighed based on the dry density and moisture content and was compacted vertically into five layers. Samples were 150 mm in diameter and 112 mm in height (Figure 2). The dry density was 1.40 g/cm³, 1.50 g/cm³, 1.60 g/cm³, and 1.70 g/cm³. The error was controlled to be ≤0.02 g/cm³.

Figure 2: Sample of compacted loess and sampling direction.

Soil samples were collected in the direction of vertical compaction (called vertical samples) and parallel to the compaction surface (called horizontal samples) (Figure 2). The first group of samples: triaxial permeability test samples under confining pressure consolidation, was cut out using a soil cutting plate, and the samples were 39.1 mm in diameter and 80 mm in height (Figure 2). The number of samples is four vertical and four horizontal samples. The second group of samples: triaxial permeability test samples under K₀ consolidation, was cut out using a soil cutting plate, and the samples were 39.1 mm in diameter and 80 mm in height (Figure 2). The number of samples is four vertical samples. The third group of samples: the compacted loess sample, was first consolidated by the K₀ state and then cut into 39.1 mm in diameter and 80 mm in height along the horizontal direction on the cutting plate. The number of samples is horizontal samples. All samples were put into a vacuum saturation device for saturation treatment until the saturation was greater than 95%.

2.2. Testing Techniques

2.2.1. Triaxial Permeability Test

The triaxial permeability test for saturated compacted loess was done using an SLB-1 triaxial permeameter (Figure 3). The first group of samples was consolidated under the confining pressure σ₃ of 100 kPa, 200 kPa, 300 kPa, and 400 kPa and kept confining pressure unchanged to determine the saturated permeability coefficient k of compacted loess. The second group of samples was consolidated at the K₀ state under the confining pressure σ₃ of 100 kPa, 200 kPa, 300 kPa, and 400 kPa and kept the K₀ state unchanged to determine the saturated permeability coefficient ks of compacted loess. Because the triaxial permeameter could not realize the stress state of the soil sample taken in the horizontal direction (Figure 4), the compacted soil sample with a diameter of 150 mm and height of 112 mm was consolidated with the K₀ state under the confining pressure of 100 kPa, 200 kPa, 300 kPa, and 400 kPa. After consolidation, the specimen was cut into 39.1 mm in diameter and 80 mm in height parallel to the compacted surface. The sample as the third group was put into the triaxial permeameter to determine the saturated permeability coefficient ks. Consolidation ended when the pore water pressure dissipated more than 95% [32].

Figure 3: SLB-1 triaxial permeameter test apparatus.

Figure 4: Stress state of compacted loess.

2.2.2. SEM Test

The SEM test was done using a scanning electron microscope (Figure 5) to collect microimages of soil samples. The samples for the scanning electron microscope (SEM) test were cut along the direction of the vertical compaction surface and horizontal compaction surface into 5 mm in length, 5 mm in width, and 10 mm in height with the dry densities of 1.40 g/cm³, 1.50 g/cm³, 1.60 g/cm³, and 1.70 g/cm³. Four vertical and horizontal samples were used in the scanning electron microscope test. The samples were broken to be in 5 mm height and formed a relatively flat and fresh section. The loose particles were blown off the surface. The surface was coated with a metal film. Then, the sample was put into the SEM to take 500-fold magnification SEM images.

(a)

(b)

Figure 5: Scanning electron microscope and samples.

3. Analysis of Test Results

3.1. Saturated Permeability of Compacted Loess under Confining Pressure Consolidation

The saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess decreased with the increasing initial dry density under the same consolidation confining pressure and decreased with the increasing consolidation confining pressure under the same initial dry density (Table 2). The saturated compacted loess horizontal saturated permeability coefficient (ksh) and vertical permeability coefficient (ksv) varied significantly for different initial dry densities. The horizontal permeability coefficient was larger than the vertical permeability coefficient, showing obvious anisotropy. During vertical compaction, macropores were destroyed and filled with soil particles, producing numerous small pores. The permeability of compacted loess in different compaction directions was mainly affected by its porosity and pore connectivity. The porosity was larger, the pore connectivity was better, and the permeability coefficient was greater, and it was smaller conversely. Flake and needle particles rotated to be parallel to the compaction surface after vertical compaction. The directionality of the particles, such as flakes and needles, weakened the porosity and connectivity of the pores perpendicular to the compaction surface. On the contrary, the porosity and connectivity of pores parallel to the compaction surface were improved. In addition, there were flaky clay minerals in the compacted loess. During the compaction process, the flaky clay minerals rotated continuously and finally parallel to the compacted surface. The increasing area of clay mineral particles blocked the connectivity of vertical pores which ultimately led to a reduction in the vertical permeability coefficient.

Table 2: Permeability coefficient of saturated compacted loess under confining pressure.

Initial dry density ρd (g/cm³)
Saturated permeability coefficient ks (10−6 cm/s)

100 kPa
200 kPa
300 kPa
400 kPa

ksh
ksv
ksh
ksv
ksh
ksv
ksh
ksv

1.70
3.503
1.873
1.203
0.726
0.506
0.329
0.247
0.167

1.60
5.076
3.808
1.739
1.196
0.707
0.520
0.333
0.264

1.50
6.403
4.580
2.150
1.631
0.969
0.794
0.428
0.374

1.40
8.170
6.997
3.727
3.434
1.304
1.251
0.626
0.614

The relationship between the saturated permeability coefficient and the initial dry density follows the exponential equation (1) and the relationship between the saturated permeability coefficient and the consolidation confining pressure follows the exponential equation (2), which were determined using nonlinear regression analysis and the least-squares method in MATLAB software. The exponential functions were

where ks represents the saturated permeability coefficient (cm/s); a, b, c, a′, b′, and c′ represent fitting parameters; ρd represents the initial dry density (g/cm³); and σ₃ represents the consolidation confining pressure (kPa).

Experimental data (Table 2) were fitted according to equations (1) and (2). Fitting parameters are shown in Tables 3 and 4, and the fitting curves are shown in Figures 6 and 7.

Table 3: Fitting parameters of the saturated permeability coefficient and initial dry density.

Consolidation confining pressure σ³ (kPa)
Fitting parameters

Equation
a
b
c
R²

100

–0.4455
–1.3003
–9.0284
0.9605

–2.1050
2.4899
–11.2385
0.9452

200

6.8075
–24.6774
8.6995
0.9646

9.9169
–35.6333
17.8634
0.9772

300

–0.9346
–0.2577
–11.3574
0.9999

0.3495
–5.4986
–6.5793
0.9995

400

2.7874
–11.6690
–3.4136
0.9922

2.4810
–11.8993
–2.5098
0.9924

Table 4: Fitting parameters of the saturated permeability coefficient and consolidation confining pressure.

Initial dry density ρd (g/cm³)
Fitting parameters

Equation
a′
b′
c′
R²

1.70

–0.0000162
–0.0044
–11.9806
0.9945

–0.0000116
–0.0045
–12.6477
0.9940

1.60

0.00000554
–0.0121
–11.0376
0.9999

–0.00000391
–0.0091
–11.550
20.9984

1.50

0.0000253
–0.0201
–10.2365
0.9995

0.0000229
–0.0187
–10.6291
0.9996

1.40

0.0000467
–0.0299
–9.1241
0.9990

0.0000457
–0.0291
–9.3410
0.9986

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Figure 6: Relationship between the saturated permeability coefficient and the initial dry density under confining pressure consolidation. (a) σ₃ = 100 kPa. (b) σ₃ = 200 kPa. (c) σ₃ = 300 kPa. (d) σ₃ = 400 kPa.

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Figure 7: Relationship between the saturated permeability coefficient and the consolidation confining pressure. (a) Initial dry density ρd = 1.40 g/cm³. (b) Initial dry density ρd = 1.50 g/cm³. (c) Initial dry density ρd = 1.60 g/cm³. (d) Initial dry density ρd = 1.70 g/cm³.

(1)The saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess was exponentially related to its initial dry density and consolidation confining pressure (Figures 6 and 7). Equations (1) and (2) were highly correlated with the fitting of the test data. The fitting equation (Tables 3 and 4) could be used to estimate saturated permeability coefficients of compacted loess with different initial dry densities and different depths (0∼20.2 m, determined by the maximum confining pressure consolidation 400 kPa and the density 2.0213 g/cm³ of the compacted loess in this paper), providing a basis for the analysis of the water field in loess filling engineering.(2)Under the same consolidation confining pressure, the saturated permeability coefficient in both vertical and horizontal directions decreased with the increasing initial dry density. When the initial dry density was close to the maximum dry density (1.73 g/cm³), the saturated permeability coefficient was the smallest. The difference of permeability coefficient in the direction of the vertical compaction surface and horizontal compaction surface was obvious, and the difference increased with the increasing dry density (Figure 6).(3)When the initial dry density of soil was small, pores between soil particles were composed of primarily large and medium trellis pores between aggregates in point-to-surface contact and line-to-surface contact, the pore connectivity was better, and the soil permeability coefficient was larger. With the increasing initial dry density, trellis pores were gradually compacted to form medium and small pores in line-surface contact and surface-surface contact. Pore connectivity and soil permeability coefficient decreased. When ρd = 1.70 g/cm³ (compaction degree: 98%), pores were dominated by micropores, particles were primarily in surface-to-surface contact, and pore connectivity and soil permeability coefficient were minimized.(4)Under the same initial dry density, the saturated permeability coefficient decreased with the increasing consolidation confining pressure. When the consolidation confining pressure was high (σ₃ = 400 kPa), the saturated permeability coefficient was relatively small and had little variation (Figure 7). The difference of the permeability coefficient between the direction of the vertical compaction surface and that of the horizontal compaction surface decreased with the increasing confining pressure.(5)With the increasing consolidation confining pressure, porosity and pore connectivity decreased gradually, the loess became more compact, and the saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess decreased gradually.

The ratio of the permeability coefficient ksh to ksv was defined as the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio rks, which was used to characterize saturated permeability anisotropy of soils [33–36]:

where rks represents the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio; ksh represents the horizontal saturated permeability coefficient (cm/s); and ksv represents the vertical saturated permeability coefficient (cm/s).

The permeability coefficients (Table 2) of saturated compacted loess obtained from the triaxial permeability test were calculated by equation (3), and the permeability anisotropy ratios are shown in Table 5.

Table 5: Permeability anisotropy ratio of saturated compacted loess under confining pressure consolidation.

Initial dry density ρd(g/cm³)
Permeability anisotropy ratio rks

100 kPa
200 kPa
300 kPa
400 kPa

1.70
1.871
1.657
1.538
1.484

1.60
1.569
1.453
1.359
1.263

1.50
1.398
1.318
1.220
1.146

1.40
1.168
1.085
1.043
1.021

The permeability anisotropy ratio of compacted loess increased with the increasing initial dry density under the same consolidation confining pressure and decreased with the increasing consolidation confining pressure under the same initial dry density (Table 5). When the initial dry density was smaller, the permeability anisotropy was less pronounced and was less influenced by confining pressure. On the contrary, when the initial dry density was greater, the permeability anisotropy was more pronounced and confining pressure had a greater influence.

In order to examine the influence of the initial dry density on permeability anisotropy of saturated compacted loess, the relationship between the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio rks (Table 5) and the initial dry density ρd was linearly fitted according to the following equation:

where rks represents the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio; a′ and b′ represent linear fitting parameters (Table 6); and ρd represents the initial dry density (g/cm³).

Table 6: Linear fitting parameters under confining pressure consolidation.

Consolidation confining pressure σ₃ (kPa)
Fitting parameters

a′
b′
Equation
R²

100
−2.0325
2.280
rks = −2.0325 + 2.280ρd
0.982

200
−1.4908
1.851
rks = −1.4908 + 1.851ρd
0.986

300
−1.2272
1.624
rks = −1.2272 + 1.624ρd
0.997

400
−1.1058
1.506
rks = −1.1058 + 1.506ρd
0.962

Figure 8: Relationship between the permeability anisotropy ratio and the initial dry density under confining pressure consolidation.

(1)Under the same consolidation confining pressure, the permeability anisotropy ratio increased with the increasing initial dry density, and the linear slope decreased with the increasing consolidation confining pressure (Figure 8). When the initial dry density was near the maximum dry density (1.73 g/cm³), the permeability anisotropy ratio was the largest. Under the same initial dry density, the permeability anisotropy ratio decreased with the increasing consolidation confining pressure. The permeability anisotropy ratio was relatively small at high consolidation confining pressure (σ₃ = 400 kPa).(2)During compaction, compaction energy eventually transformed into potential energy within soil particles, self-inversion, and mutual imbedding. The flake-, needle-, and plate-like particles were constantly adjusted to be nearly perpendicular to the compaction direction, which led to low pore connectivity in the direction perpendicular to the compaction plane, resulting in obvious differences between the pore structure parallel and perpendicular to the compaction plane. Under the same hydraulic gradient, the circuitous path of water seepage in the direction perpendicular to the compaction surface was longer than that parallel to the compaction surface. Thus, the permeability coefficient perpendicular to the compaction surface was smaller than the permeability coefficient parallel to the compaction surface. The circuitous path was greatly affected by the soil initial dry density and consolidation confining pressure.(3)When σc = 0 kPa and ρd = 1.70 g/cm³, the ratio of the horizontal permeability coefficient to the vertical permeability coefficient was the largest, reaching 1.951. When the soil initial dry density was larger, small pores were the main type and the orientation of particles was more remarkable. The main contact types between particles were surface-to-surface and line-to-surface. The permeability of compacted loess decreased significantly, and although the permeability coefficient was minimized, the ratio of the horizontal to the vertical permeability coefficient was maximized. On the contrary, when the initial dry density of soil was small, primarily large pores were present and the particles did not have a uniform orientation. The main contact types between particles were primarily point-to-surface and line-to-surface. The permeability coefficient was large, and the ratio of the horizontal to the vertical permeability coefficient was small.(4)During consolidation of compacted loess under a confining pressure, the orientation of soil particles became more and more disordered, which led to a decrease in horizontal and vertical permeability anisotropy. The ratio of permeability anisotropy decreased with the increasing confining pressure.

Figure 9: Relationship between the K₀ coefficient and the initial dry density.

3.2. Saturated Permeability of Compacted Loess under K₀ Consolidation

The value of K₀ tended to be constant with the increasing lateral stress and axial stress during the consolidation of K₀. K₀ consolidation tests were carried out on soil samples with the initial dry density of 1.40 g/cm³, 1.50 g/cm³, 1.60 g/cm³, and 1.70 g/cm³. The average value of K₀ corresponding to each initial dry density was taken, and the curve between K₀ and dry density was established, as shown in Figure 9.

K₀ was obviously affected by the initial dry density. With the increasing dry density, the value of K₀ decreased gradually. The relationship between K₀ and the initial dry density was approximately linear (Figure 9).

The triaxial permeability test results of vertical and horizontal specimens of compacted loess consolidated by K₀ are shown in Table 7.

Table 7: Permeability coefficient of saturated compacted loess under K₀ consolidation.

Initial dry density ρd (g/cm³)
Saturated permeability coefficient ks (10−6 cm/s)

100 kPa
200 kPa
300 kPa
400 kPa

ksh
ksv
ksh
ksv
ksh
ksv
ksh
ksv

1.70
2.980
1.516
0.932
0.520
0.359
0.219
0.161
0.104

1.60
4.026
2.478
1.210
0.799
0.436
0.316
0.189
0.146

1.50
4.449
2.954
1.402
1.038
0.595
0.477
0.258
0.214

1.40
5.684
4.534
2.518
2.113
0.814
0.727
0.365
0.337

The saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess decreased with the increasing initial dry density under K₀ consolidation (Table 7). Compacted loess at different depths was in the K₀ state after filling works were completed. K₀ consolidation evolved macropores to uniform small pores, and the flake- and needle-like particles continuously rotated parallel to the compaction surface. Particle orientation enhanced the connectivity of vertical pores, which eventually led to the horizontal permeability coefficient of compacted loess significantly larger than the vertical permeability coefficient.

The saturated permeability coefficient (Table 7) of compacted loess under the K₀ consolidation condition was analyzed by nonlinear regression according to equation (1). Fitting parameters are shown in Table 8, and the fitting curves are shown in Figure 10.

Table 8: Fitting parameters under K₀ consolidation.

Consolidation confining pressure σ³ (kPa)
Fitting parameters

Equation
a
b
c
R²

100

0.3301
–3.0165
5.3029
0.884

1.1713
–7.0138
9.0261
0.933

200

10.1579
–34.6249
29.4816
0.949

10.3482
–36.4984
31.5583
0.971

300

2.5188
–10.5811
9.6730
0.996

1.1606
–7.6152
8.0681
0.999

400

4.2149
–15.8362
12.9037
0.996

3.0295
–13.2970
11.5901
0.999

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Figure 10: Relationship between the saturated permeability coefficient and the dry density under K₀ consolidation. (a) σ₃ = 100 kPa. (b) σ₃ = 200 kPa. (c) σ₃ = 300 kPa. (d) σ₃ = 400 kPa.

The relationship between the saturated permeability coefficient and the dry density of compacted loess under the K₀ consolidation condition was still an exponential function (Table 8) (Figure 10). According to the fitting equation (Table 8), the saturated permeability coefficients of compacted loess with different dry densities and different depths could be estimated, providing a basis for the analysis of the water field in loess filling engineering. Under the condition of K₀ consolidation, the void ratio of soil was further reduced, the connectivity of voids became worse, and the permeability coefficient of soil decreased. The change rule of the saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation was similar to that under confining pressure consolidation.

The permeability coefficients (Table 7) of saturated compacted loess were calculated by formula (3), and the permeability anisotropy ratios are shown in Table 9. The relationship between the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio rks (Table 9) under K₀ consolidation and the initial dry density ρd was linearly fitted according to equation (4). Fitting parameters are shown in Table 10, and the fitting curves are shown in Figure 11.

Table 9: Permeability anisotropy ratio of saturated compacted loess under K₀ consolidation.

Initial dry density ρd(g/cm³)
Permeability anisotropy ratio rks

100 kPa
200 kPa
300 kPa
400 kPa

1.70
1.965
1.793
1.640
1.548

1.60
1.625
1.515
1.376
1.295

1.50
1.472
1.350
1.248
1.206

1.40
1.254
1.192
1.119
1.085

Table 10: Linear fitting parameters under K₀ consolidation.

Consolidation confining pressure σ₃ (kPa)
Fitting parameters

a′
b′
Equation
R²

100
−1.9658
2.287
rks = −1.9658 + 2.287ρd
0.961

200
−1.5909
1.970
rks = −1.5909 + 1.970ρd
0.969

300
−1.2767
1.692
rks = −1.2767 + 1.692ρd
0.945

400
−1.0096
1.479
rks = −1.0096 + 1.479ρd
0.918

Figure 11: Relationship between the permeability anisotropy ratio and the initial dry density under K₀ consolidation.

The saturated permeability anisotropy ratio of compacted loess increased with the increasing dry density under the K₀ consolidation condition. The anisotropy ratio of saturated permeability was linear with the initial dry density (Figure 11). The change rule of the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation was similar to that under confining pressure consolidation.

The linear equation of K₀ and dry density fitted in Figure 9 was substituted into equations (1) and (4) to obtain the following equations, respectively:

where represents the saturated permeability coefficient, cm/s; represents the saturated permeability anisotropic ratio; K₀ represents the coefficient of earth pressure at rest; and a, b, c, d, a′, and b′ represent fitting parameters.

With the decreasing K₀ value, the saturated permeability coefficient and permeability anisotropy of compacted loess increased gradually. In compacted loess engineering, the saturated permeability coefficient and anisotropic ratio of compacted loess could be calculated according to equations (5) and (6) by the value of K₀ and the experimental fitting parameters a, b, c, a′, and b′, which had certain application value in analysing the distribution of the water field of compacted loess.

3.3. Comparative Analysis of Permeability Characteristics of Compacted Loess under Confining Pressure Consolidation and K₀ Consolidation

The saturated permeability of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation and confining pressure consolidation was obviously different. The saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation was smaller than that under confining consolidation. With the increasing initial dry density, the saturated permeability coefficient and the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio increased gradually. In order to quantitatively describe and analyze the saturated permeability difference of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation and confining pressure consolidation, the permeability coefficient ratio Rk was defined (equation (7)). When Rk < 1, the permeability coefficient of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation was less than that under confining pressure consolidation, and when Rk ≈ 1, the permeability coefficient was approximately equal.

The saturated permeability test data in Tables 2 and 7 were calculated according to equation (7). The results are shown in Figure 12.

where represents the saturated permeability coefficient ratio of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation and confining pressure consolidation; represents the saturated permeability coefficient under K₀ consolidation, cm/s; and represents the saturated permeability coefficient under confining pressure consolidation, cm/s.

(a)

(b)

Figure 12: Saturated permeability ratio of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation and confining pressure consolidation. (a) in the horizontal direction. (b) in the vertical direction.

The saturated permeability coefficient ratio of vertical and horizontal compacted loess was between 0.5 and 0.9, which indicated that the saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation decreased in both vertical and horizontal directions compared with that under confining pressure consolidation (Figure 12). The ratio of the horizontal permeability coefficient in the same dry density was smaller than that in the vertical direction, which was due to the decrease of vertical and horizontal void ratios caused by K₀ consolidation, the weakening of connectivity pores, and the enhancement of tortuosity, which had a greater impact in the horizontal direction. With the increasing confining pressure, the saturated permeability coefficient ratio of vertical and horizontal compacted loess decreased gradually. The saturated permeability coefficient ratio of compacted loess decreased with the decreasing dry density. K₀ consolidation reduced the void ratio of soil samples with a small dry density by a large margin.

In order to analyze the relationship between the saturated permeability coefficient ratio and K₀ of compacted loess, the relationship curves were established by Figures 9 and 12 and equation (7). The curves are shown in Figure 13.

(a)

(b)

Figure 13: Relationship curves between the saturated permeability ratio and K₀. (a) in the horizontal direction. (b) in the vertical direction.

The saturated permeability coefficient ratio Rk was obviously affected by the K₀ coefficient. The saturated permeability coefficient ratio decreased with the increasing K₀ (Figure 13). When the confining pressure was smaller, the saturated permeability coefficient ratio was larger and the curve was located at the top of Figure 13. The curve gradually moved down with the increasing confining pressure. The Rk − K₀ curve further proved that the permeability coefficient measured by the triaxial permeability test under the condition of constant confining pressure was larger than that measured by the triaxial permeability test under the condition of K₀ consolidation which was close to the in situ stress state of soil, and when ρd = 1.7 g/cm³, the deviation even reached about 20%. Therefore, it was recommended to adopt the triaxial permeability test under the K₀ consolidation condition to reduce the error of the saturated permeability coefficient caused by the triaxial permeability test under the condition of constant confining pressure. When studying the permeability of compacted loess, the permeability coefficient under the K₀ consolidation condition could also be obtained by modifying the permeability coefficient with the Rk value provided in Figure 13 under the condition of constant confining pressure consolidation.

In order to analyze the difference of saturated permeability anisotropy between compacted loess under K₀ consolidation and confining pressure consolidation, the relationship between the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio and the confining pressure is drawn in Figure 14.

Figure 14: Saturated permeability anisotropy ratio of compacted loess under K₀ consolidation and confining pressure consolidation.

The saturated permeability anisotropy ratio of compacted loess increased significantly under K₀ consolidation, which indicated that K₀ consolidation made the flake- and needle-like particles in compacted loess rotate continuously parallel to the compaction plane, which enhanced the orientation of particles and ultimately led to the increase of saturated permeability anisotropy of compacted loess (Figure 14).

4. Microscopic Mechanism of Permeability Anisotropy of Compacted Loess

The macroporous structure of undisturbed loess is commonly destroyed by vertical rolling or tamping. Pores changed from macropores to medium and small pores. The soil particles take on a preferred orientation when under vertical load. Pore structures and particle arrangements determine the permeability characteristics of compacted loess. In order to reveal the permeability anisotropy of compacted loess, SEM tests were carried out on loess samples with different compacted dry densities to obtain images of the compacted surface and region perpendicular to the compacted surface (Figure 15).

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Figure 15: SEM images with different dry densities (500 times). (a) ρd = 1.70 g/cm³. (b) ρd = 1.60 g/cm³. (c) ρd = 1.50 g/cm³. (d) ρd = 1.40 g/cm³.

(1)The micropore structure of the compacted surface and vertical compacted surface was significantly different (Figure 15). The number of pores perpendicular to the compacted surface was greater than that on the compacted surface, and pore connectivity was better. This was the primary reason why the permeability coefficient of compacted loess parallel to the compacted surface was larger compared to the permeability perpendicular to the compacted surface.(2)When ρd = 1.70 g/cm³ (approaching the maximum dry density of 1.73 g/cm³), the SEM images of the compacted surface showed that the soil particles were flaky and in face-to-face contact. Pores were mainly small pores and micropores between and in aggregates. Soil particles perpendicular to the compacted surface were primarily linear and in face-to-face contact. Pores were primarily composed of small pores between the aggregates. With the decreasing dry density, pore diameter between soil grains increased gradually, and pores were primarily composed of large and medium pores between aggregates (ρd = 1.5 g/cm³ and ρd = 1.4 g/cm³).(3)The number of pores on the compacted surface and perpendicular to the compacted surface increased gradually with the decreasing dry density. However, the difference of pore diameter and number on the compacted surface and perpendicular to the compacted surface decreased with the decreasing dry density, which revealed the reason why smaller dry densities correlate with smaller permeability anisotropy. On the contrary, when the dry density was higher, the permeability anisotropy was greater.

5. Conclusions

(1)The saturated permeability coefficient under confining pressure consolidation and K₀ consolidation of compacted loess was significantly affected by the initial dry density. With the increasing initial dry density, the saturated permeability coefficient decreased gradually, and with the increasing consolidation confining pressure, the saturated permeability coefficient decreased gradually. Through nonlinear regression analysis, the saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess was determined to follow an exponential function related to the initial dry density. The fitting equation could be used to estimate the saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess at different depths, providing a basis for water field analysis in loess filling engineering.(2)The saturated permeability anisotropy under confining pressure consolidation and K₀ consolidation of compacted loess was quantitatively analyzed using the saturated permeability anisotropy ratio, which was linearly related to the initial dry density.(3)The saturated permeability coefficient of compacted loess under the K₀ consolidation condition was smaller than that under the confining pressure consolidation condition. Under the condition of K₀ consolidation, the connectivity of vertical and horizontal pores of compacted loess was weakened, the tortuosity was strengthened, and the void ratio was decreased. The saturated permeability coefficient ratio of compacted loess decreased with the decreasing dry density, and when the dry density was smaller, the permeability coefficient ratio was smaller under the same confining pressure.(4)K₀ consolidation made the flake-, plate-, and needle-like particles in compacted loess rotate continuously parallel to the compaction surface, which enhanced the orientation of particles and led to the saturated permeability anisotropy increase. The research provides the basis for water field analysis in loess filling engineering.(5)The microtest showed that the permeability anisotropy of compacted loess with different dry densities was mainly caused by the different pore structures in the direction of the vertical compaction surface and horizontal compaction surface.

Abbreviations

K₀: | Coefficient of earth pressure at rest
Q₃: | Late Pleistocene epoch
GS: | Specific gravity of the soil particle
ρd: | Dry density
WL: | Liquid limit
WP: | Plastic limit
Ip: | Plasticity index
SEM: | Scanning electron microscope
σ₁: | Axial stress (major principal stress)
σ₃: | Confining pressure (minor principal stress)
ks: | Saturated permeability coefficient
ksh: | Horizontal saturated permeability coefficient
ksh: | Vertical permeability coefficient
: | Saturated permeability coefficient under K₀ consolidation
: | Saturated permeability coefficient under confining pressure consolidation
rks: | Saturated permeability anisotropy ratio
: | Saturated permeability coefficient ratio.

Data Availability

All data and models generated or used during this study are included within the article. All data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank the team members of the key discipline of geotechnical engineering and the workers of the Geotechnical Engineering Laboratory. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 51078309) and Foundation of Science and Technology Department of Henan Province of China (No. 172102310459).

References

P. Bandini and S. Sathiskumar, “Effects of silt content and void ratio on the saturated hydraulic conductivity and compressibility of sand-silt mixtures,” Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, vol. 135, no. 12, pp. 1976–1980, 2009.

R. D’Andrea and F. K. Boadu, “Hydraulic conductivity of soils from grain-size distribution:new models,” Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, vol. 127, no. 10, pp. 899-900, 2001.

H. Han, D. Giménez, and A. Lilly, “Textural averages of saturated soil hydraulic conductivity predicted from water retention data,” Geoderma, vol. 146, no. 1-2, pp. 121–128, 2008.

T. Sathees, “Saturated hydraulic conductivity of poorly graded sands with nonplastic silt using a flexible wall permeameter,” New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, NM, USA, 2006, MS Thesis.

A. Cherif Taiba, Y. Mahmoudi, L. Hazout et al., “Evaluation of hydraulic conductivity through particle shape and packing density characteristics of sand–silt mixtures,” Marine Georesources & Geotechnology, vol. 37, no. 10, pp. 1175–1187, 2019.

M. R. Muszynski and S. J. Vitton, “Particle shape estimates of uniform sands: visual and automated methods comparison,” Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 194–206, 2012.

M. Belkhatir, T. Schanz, and A. Arab, “Effect of fines content and void ratio on the saturated hydraulic conductivity and undrained shear strength of sand-silt mixtures,” Environmental Earth Sciences, vol. 70, no. 6, pp. 2469–2479, 2013.

Y. F. Li, “Relationship between the permeability and the porosity of Luochuan loess layer,” Chinese Journal of Xi’an College of Geology, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 60–64, 1991.

L. Z. Wang, S. H. Ye, K. L. Shen et al., “Undrained shear strength of K₀ consolidated soft clays,” Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, vol. 28, no. 8, pp. 970–977, 2006a.

H. Wang, Z. R. Yue, and C. L. Ye, “Experimental investigation of permeability characteristics of intact and reshaped loess,” Chinese Journal of Shijiazhuang Railway Institute (Natural Science), vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 20–22, 2009.

F. Y. Liu, Z. Zhang, and D. Zhou, “Density saturation dependent air water permeability function of unsaturated loess,” Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 29, no. 9, pp. 1907–1914, 2010.

Y. Z. Hao, T. H. Wang, and J. J. Wang, “Structural properties of unsaturated compacted loess for various sample moisture contents,” Arabian Journal of Geosciences, vol. 12, no. 8, pp. 258–268, 2019.

T. Y. Zhao, H. Y. Zhang, G. S. Yan et al., “Influence of penetrative conditions on permeability of modified loess soil by betonies,” Chinese Hydrogeology and Engineering Geology, vol. 37, no. 5, pp. 108–112, 2010.

H. T. Liu, A. J. Zhang, T. Duan et al., “The influence of alternate dry-wet on the strength and permeability of remolded loess,” Hydro-science and Engineering, vol. 2010, no. 4, pp. 38–42, 2010.

G. X. Zeng, X. N. Gong, and J. Y. Sheng, “Research on normally consolidated clay by K₀ consolidated shear test,” Journal of Zhejiang University, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 1–9, 1987.

M. H. Zhao and X. Yu, Soil Mechanics and Foundations, Wuhan University of Technology Press, Wuhan, China, 2009.

J. H. Atkinson, D. Richardson, and P. J. Robinson, “Compression and extension of K₀ normally consolidated Kaolin clay,” Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, vol. 113, no. 12, pp. 1468–1481, 1986.

H. T. Cheng, B. J. Liu, Y. L. Xie et al., “K₀ consolidation characteristics of compacted loess under continuous loading,” Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 26, no. S, pp. 3203–3208, 2007.

F. Y. Chu, J. G. Zhu, P. Wang et al., “Study of deformation and strength characteristics of coarse grained soil under K₀-consolidation condition,” Rock and Soil Mechanics, vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 1625–1630, 2012.

M. S. Huang, X. Y. Song, and H. L. Qin, “Basal stability of braced excavations in K₀-consolidated soft clay by upper bound method,” Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, vol. 30, no. 2, pp. 250–255, 2008.

Y. Z. Jiu and M. S. Huang, “Coefficient of earth pressure at rest and undrained shear strength of K₀ over consolidated soft clays,” Rock and Soil Mechanics, vol. 38, no. 4, pp. 954–957, 2017.

X. L. Lu, J. G. Qian, and M. S. Huang, “Prediction of instability of K₀-consolidated saturated sands under undrained loading conditions,” Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, vol. 37, no. 6, pp. 1010–1015, 2015.

M. T. Luan, Z. D. Zhang, C. S. Xu et al., “Experimental studies of cyclic shear characteristic of sand under K₀ consolidation condition,” Rock and Soil Mechanics, vol. 29, no. 9, pp. 2323–2328, 2008.

P. W. Mayne and F. H. Kulhawy, “K₀-OCR relationship in soil,” Journal of Geotechnical Engineering Division, ASCE, vol. 108, no. 6, pp. 851–872, 1982.

M. S. Qi, C. X. Feng, Y. L. Xie et al., “Research of intact loess through continuous loading K₀ consolidation tests,” Chinese Journal of Underground Space and Engineering, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 370–373, 2005.

Y. S. Leroueil, G. X. Cui, and W. H. Yang, “Prospect of experimental studies of height-pressure consolidation tests of soils in thick alluvium,” Rock and Soil Mechanics, vol. 24, no. S, pp. 687–690, 2003.

D. Y. Wang, W. Ma, and X. X. Chang, “Study on behavior of stress-strain for frozen soils subjected to K₀ consolidation by unloading triaxial shear tests,” Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanical and Engineering, vol. 23, no. 8, pp. 1252–1256, 2004.

T. H. Wang, J. Lu, and J. F. Zhang, “Experimental study of permeability coefficient of artificially compacted unsaturated loess considering influence of density,” Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 25, no. 11, pp. 2364–2368, 2006b.

J. Y. Yuan, X. B. Wang, J. G. Dong et al., “Research on the strength and deformation of Shanghai clay soils under K₀ consolidation condition,” Dam Observation and Geotechnical Tests, vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 29–32, 1999.

C. L. Zhang, G. L. Jiang, Z. H. Dong et al., “Deformation response characteristics of undisturbed silty clay in K₀ consolidation state,” Journal of Central South University (Science and Technology), vol. 45, no. 7, pp. 2378–2386, 2014.

J. G. Zhu, E. Y. Ji, Z. R. Fang et al., “Comparison of triaxial text with K₀-consolidated and isotropically consolidated specimens of coarse grained soil,” Journal of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation Engineering, vol. 33, no. 4, pp. 394–398, 2013.

Standardization Administration of China (SAC, ), Ministry of Water Resources (1999) China National Standards GB/T50123–1999, Standard for Soil Test Method, Beijing, China, 1999.

P. Basak, “Soil structure and its effects on hydraulic conductivity,” Soil Science, vol. 114, no. 6, pp. 417–422, 1972.

S. Leroueil, G. Bouclin, F. Tavenas, L. Bergeron, and P. L. Bergeron, “Permeability anisotropy of natural clays as a function of strain,” Canadian Geotechnical Journal, vol. 27, no. 5, pp. 568–579, 1990.

R. J. Millington and J. P. Quirk, “Permeability of porous media,” Nature, vol. 183, no. 2, pp. 387-388, 1959.

F. Tavenas, P. Jean, P. Leblond, and S. Leroueil, “The permeability of natural soft clays. Part II: permeability characteristics,” Canadian Geotechnical Journal, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 645–660, 1983.