Effects of Polypropylene Waste Addition as Coarse Aggregates in Concrete: Experimental Characterization and Statistical Analysis

,


Introduction
In the past decades, the use of plastics has been widely increased in various applications such as automotive, medical, and housing applications [1][2][3][4]. More importantly, their use in packaging and distribution of food for daily usage is high; in that way a large quantity of plastic waste is accumulated all over the world [5,6]. Larger areas of land are required for storing these several million tons of waste plastics. Even though plastic products are lightweight and easy to design and fabricate, they possess low-or nonbiodegradability. As a result, the disposal of plastic waste causes a considerable threat to humans and animals and is one of the major reasons for environmental pollution, [7]. Terefore, it is important to develop biodegradable plastics [8] or reuse plastic waste for the beneft of diferent perspectives. Most countries have already started to utilize plastic waste for various applications [9]. In particular, thermoplastic waste materials have been extensively used in energy applications [10] and the construction industry [11].
In recent years, many researchers studied the mechanical properties of thermoplastic waste materials incorporated in concrete structures [12,13]. Almeshal et al. [14] used polyethylene terephthalate (PET) as a fne aggregate for the partial replacement of sand in concrete. Tey have investigated the compressive, fexural, and split tensile strength values for diferent weight substitution levels (0%, 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, and 50%) of PET-incorporated concrete. A gradual decrease in compressive, fexural, and split tensile strength values with the increase of PET percentage in concrete was found. Ohemang and Ekolu [15] studied the compressive and fexural strength values of diferent volume fractions of low-density polyethylene (LDPE)-embedded cement mortar. Tese strength values were compared for diferent curing ages such as 7, 14, and 28 days. Te decrease in strength values with the increase in various proportions of LDPE in cement mortar was found. Also, the increase in strength values with the increase of curing age was reported. In particular, the increase was reported to be higher from the age interval of 7 days to 14 days, compared to those at age intervals of 14 days to 28 days. Te decrease in compressive strength with the increase in plastic waste contents and the enhancement in compressive strength with the increase of curing age were also found by several researchers [12,16,17].
Several researchers used analytical models to predict the fexural and split tensile strength values using compressive strength values [14,18]. Moreover, many researchers are also used artifcial neural network (ANN) methods to solve complex problems in the area of concrete technology [19][20][21][22]. Onyelow et al. [23] compared the compressive strength values of 28 days of post-cured Fly Ash-embedded concrete specimens using genetic programming (GP), evolutionary polynomial regression (EPR), and three different ANN (backpropagation, gradually reduced gradient, and genetic algorithm) methods. It was found that the compressive strength values of the GP model had the least accuracy of 81%, the EPR model had a moderate accuracy of 90%, and all ANN models had almost the same accuracy of approximately 94%. Rezazadeh Eidgahee et al. [24] employed diferent machine learning methods (ANN, GP, and group method of data handling (GMDH)) in predicting the dynamic modulus of hot mix asphalt. It was reported that the accuracy of the ANN model is higher based on higher correlation coefcient values greater than 0.98, compared with GP and GMDH models.
In general, there is a tendency for strength values to be scattered due to the possibility of operator and instrument errors. In particular, the occurrence of errors during the manufacturing of the component is high. Statistical studies are useful to capture the scatter in strength values [25,26]. However, very limited researchers employed statistical approaches to predict the strength values for diferent weight proportions of plastic waste embedded in concrete or cement mortars [15,27]. In this study, the two-parameter Weibull distribution is used to predict the compressive and split tensile strength values for diferent weight proportions of polypropylene plastic waste-embedded concrete. A good correlation was obtained between the predicted and experimental results. Te ANN strategy is also adopted to predict the compression and split tensile strength values of polypropylene plastic waste embedded in cement concrete specimens.

Materials.
In this study, materials such as cement, sand as fne aggregate, and recycled polypropylene as coarse aggregate are used. Te material specifcations for cement, fne aggregate, coarse aggregate, and admixtures are discussed. Sieve analysis was done for sand and coarse aggregate to test their suitability for use in concrete.

Cement.
In this study, ordinary Portland cement (OPC) of 53 grade was used for casting cubes and cylinders for all concrete mixes. Te cement was of uniform color, i.e., grey with a light greenish shade and was free from any hard lumps. Te specifc gravity (SG) of cement was carried out as per IS 2386 (Part 3)-1963 using equation (1), as given in Table 1. Te summary of the various tests conducted on cement is given in Table 2, and the obtained values are closer to standard values.

Fine
Aggregates. Te sand used for the experimental program was locally procured and conformed to Indian Standard Specifcations IS: 383-1970. Te sand was frst sieved through a 4.75 mm sieve to remove any particles greater than 4.75 mm and then was washed to remove the dust. Te properties of the fne aggregate used in the experimental work are given in Table 3. Te aggregates were sieved through a set of sieves as shown in Figure 1(a) to obtain the sieve analysis and the same is presented in Table 3. Te fne aggregates belonged to grading zone III.

Coarse Aggregates.
Te recycled polypropylene was used as coarse aggregate in this study. Tese aggregates were tested as per Indian Standard specifcations IS: 383-1970. Te results of the sieve analysis of recycled polypropylene are given in Table 4 and Figure 1(b).

Specimen Fabrication.
Before manufacturing the specimens, the mix design was determined for M30 grade concrete based on the degree of workability and quality control, specifc gravity, etc. Te specifc gravity of cement, sand (fne aggregate), and recycled polypropylene (coarse aggregate) was determined as 3.01, 2.61, and 2.65, respectively. Mixture ratios such as cement: fne aggregate: coarse aggregate: water were used for manufacturing the specimens, by weight as 1 : 1.09 : 2.29 : 0.38, respectively. Fabricated cubic and cylindrical specimens for compression and split tensile tests are shown in Figure 2.      . Tree diferent specimens were tested in each combination. Te dimensions of the specimens such as length, width, and thickness used for compression tests were 150 mm × 150 mm × 150 mm, respectively. Te specimens were submerged in clean fresh water for the duration of 3, 14, and 28 days before testing and kept in a dry place so that the water is drained well to get better results. Te compressive load is applied on the specimen using the universal testing machine, as shown in Figure 3(a). Te load is gradually applied until it fails. Te compressive strength of the specimen was calculated using equation (2), it is given by where F c is the compressive strength, P is the ultimate load, and A is the area of the specimen which is 150 mm × 150 mm.

Split Tensile Strength of Concrete.
It is difcult to investigate the direct tensile strength of concrete; however, often, researchers are performed fexural or split tensile tests to estimate the direct tensile strength. A split tensile test for diferent weight proportions of polypropylene-embedded concrete specimens was performed as per IS 516-1999 standard. Tree diferent specimens were tested in each combination. Te dimensions of concrete cylindrical specimens such as a diameter of 150 mm and a length of 300 mm. Te cylindrical specimens were placed horizontally between the loading surfaces of a compression testing machine, as shown in Figure 3(b) and the load is applied until the failure of the cylinder along the vertical diameter. Te splitting tensile strength of specimens is calculated using equation (3), it is given by where l and d are the length and diameter of the specimen, respectively. is relatively less compared to 3 and 28 days. Tis can be attributed to an increase in physical, chemical, and mechanical bonding of the microstructure of concrete specimens, which strengthens the specimen. Terefore, it is essential to postcure the concrete specimen for a minimum of two weeks. An enhancement in compressive strength with the increase in curing age of concrete specimens was also found by numerous researchers [12,16,17]. However, the decrease in strength values is observed with the increase in diferent weight percentages of polypropylene in the concrete. However, the strength values of 20% PP-embedded concrete specimens are closer to 0% PPembedded concrete specimens. Terefore, specimens of 20% PP-embedded concrete specimens are recommended for primary load-bearing applications, whereas 40% and 60% PP-embedded concrete specimens are recommended for secondary load-bearing applications. Te trend of the curves matches well with the literature [28][29][30]; in their studies, they have reported the decrease in compressive strength of concrete with the increase in plastic substitution. Tetwo main factors which restrict the improvement of compressive strength, at higher weight percentages (40% and 60%) of PP embedded in concrete specimens, are (i) poor bonding between PP aggregate and concrete due to the development of agglomerations, (ii) the hydrophobic nature of PP aggregate that decreases the rate of hydration [31]. A similar kind of decrease in strength values with the addition of higher weight percentages of waste materials in the concrete is found in these articles [9,14,32].

Results and Discussion
Te trend of split tensile strength values seen in Figure 4 is similar to compressive strength values. Similar kinds of results are reported elsewhere [33]. As expected, from Figures 4 and 5, the compressive strength values are signifcantly higher in all specimens tested at diferent curing ages compared to split tensile strength values. A similar kind of trend is found elsewhere [34]. From equations (2) and (3), the applied direction of loading is the main reason for the diference between the values in these two tests [24]. Te compressive strength of concrete is always higher for a concrete specimen as it withstands axially directed pushing force until it reaches its maximum force, after that the specimen is crushed, as shown in Figure 3(a). However, the failure response of the specimen subjected to the split tensile test is the transverse shear, as shown in Figure 3(b). Numerous researchers [35][36][37] have reported experimentally and theoretically that the compressive strength value of the cubic concrete specimen is several times higher than that of the split tensile strength.

Prediction of Compressive and Split Tensile Strength
Values Using Two-Parameter Weibull Distribution. In this section, the procedure for predicting the compression and split tensile strength values are discussed using the twoparameter Weibull analysis. Te compressive (σ C ) and split tensile strength (σ ST ) values can be written in terms of scale parameter (α), shape parameter (β), and gamma function (Γ) using equations (4) and (5), respectively [20,38].  Advances in Materials Science and Engineering Te subscript 'C' denotes the compressive strength and 'ST' denotes the split tensile strength. Te scale parameter is the characteristic strength and the shape parameter is the Weibull modulus. Tese parameters can be determined by using equation (6) [39,40].
where F is the cumulative failure probability � (i − 0.3)/n + 0.4 [41,42]; i is the current test number which varies from 1 to 3 as three specimens are tested for   Advances in Materials Science and Engineering each mixture of polypropylene-embedded concrete; n is the total number of specimens tested in each set which is equal to 3. σ is the experimental compressive or split tensile strength. Γ(1 + (1/β)) corresponding to β value is used in the gamma function data sheet.
Te variability of compressive strength values for different curing ages such as 3, 14, and 28 days can be seen in Figures 6(a)-6(c), respectively. Tese are linear regression lines plotted using equation (6). Black, red, blue, and green color lines indicate the strength values for diferent weight contents of polypropylene such as 0, 20, 40, and 60%, respectively, embedded concrete specimens. Similarly, the scatter in split tensile strength values for the same curing ages of specimens are given in Figures 7(a)-7(c). Tables 5 and 6 show the scale parameter, shape parameter, and gamma function values for the compressive and split tensile strength values of PP-embedded concrete specimens for diferent curing ages, respectively. Te comparison of the predicted and experimental compressive and split tensile strength values are given in Table 7. It is clear from the table that the percentage of deviation of the predicted strength values from the experimental results is less than 5%. Te decrease in compressive and split tensile strength values with the increase in PP content in concrete is observed in both predicted and experimental results.

Prediction of Compressive and Split Tensile Strength
Values Using the ANN Model. Te ANN is a family of massively parallel architectures that are capable of learning and predicting the results. Te basic strategy for developing a neural network-based model for material behavior is to train In (In (1/ (1-F)   Advances in Materials Science and Engineering a neural network on the results of a series of experiments using that material [43]. If the experimental results contain relevant information about the material behavior, then the trained neural network will contain sufcient information about the material's behavior to qualify a material for new values. Such a trained neural network not only could reproduce the experimental results but also could approximate the results in other experiments through its generalization capability [37]. Te present study adopts a feed-forward supervised ANN model for the prediction of compression and split tensile strength values of diferent weight contents of PPembedded concrete. Te training parameters are the number of iterations (epoch), learning rate, error goal, and the number of hidden layers. Tese parameters are varied until a good convergence of ANN training is obtained and thereby fxes the optimal training parameters. Tese optimal parameters are used for the testing and validation process. Te general computational ANN model is always represented by the term topology which represents the number of neurons in the input layer, hidden layer, and output layer. However, the number of neurons in the input and output layers is determined based on the problem domain depending upon the number of input variables and the number of output or target variables. Te number of hidden layers and neurons in the hidden layer is fxed during the training process. Advances in Materials Science and Engineering Figure 8 depicts the ANN model adopted in this study to predict the compression and split tensile strength values for diferent weight contents of PP-embedded concrete specimens. Here, the Levenberg-Marquardt (LM) algorithm and the Log-Sigmoid transfer function are adopted for predicting the mechanical properties. Figure 9 shows the graphical representation of ANN predicted and experimental values.
Here, all the data are convergent to the equity line. Te correlation coefcient between the experimental and predicted data is 0.99. Table 8 shows the comparison of experimental and ANN predicted compressive and split tensile strength values and their respective percentage of errors. It is observed Table 8 that the deviation between the experimental and predicted results is less than 10%.

Conclusion
In the present work, mechanical properties for diferent weight percentages of polypropylene plastic wastes embedded in concrete specimens were studied. Te mechanical properties were studied at diferent age intervals such as 3, 14, and 28 days. Te compressive and split tensile strength values were predicted using two diferent theoretical models, the two-parameter Weibull distribution and ANN. Te decrease in compressive and split tensile strengths was found in both predicted and experimental results, with the increase in polypropylene weight contents in the concrete specimens. However, the strength values for the specimens of 20% PPembedded concrete specimens are closer to 0% PP-embedded concrete specimens. Te mechanical properties were found to be increasing with the increase in the age duration from 3 to 28 days. Tis can be attributed to an increase in the bonding of the microstructure of the concrete specimen, which strengthens the specimen. However, the increase in mechanical properties is relatively less between 14 and 28 days compared to between 3 and 28 days, which indicate that the post-cure of the concrete specimen for a minimum of two weeks is essential. An excellent correlation is obtained between the predicted and experimental values. It can be concluded from this study that specimens of 20% PP-embedded concrete specimens can be used for primary loadbearing applications. Tis contributes to reduce the unit weight of the concrete.

Data Availability
Tis manuscript includes raw data recorded from the apparatus and processed data derived from raw data.

Conflicts of Interest
Te authors declare that they have no conficts of interest.