Planar MIMO Antenna with Slits for WBAN Applications

A planar MIMO antenna with slits for WBAN applications is proposed. The antenna consists of two PIFAs, ground pads, and two slits. By adding ground pads, the antenna size is reduced with improved impedance matching.Through two slits in a ground plane, the isolation characteristic is improved and the resonant frequency can be controlled. To analyze the antenna performance on a human body, the proposed antenna on a human equivalent flat phantom is investigated through simulations. Regardless of the existence of the phantom, the antenna operates in 2.4GHz ISM band with the isolation higher than 18 dB.


Introduction
Recently, wireless body area network (WBAN) systems for medical devices, police and military agencies, sports training, entertainment, and wearable computing have received great attention in conjunction with the rapid development of wireless communication technology [1,2].The antennas for WBAN system should satisfy certain requirements such as small size, low profile, low human body effects, and low specific absorption rate (SAR) [3].Since the antennas for WBAN system are located on or in the human body, the performance of the antenna is affected by the human body's high dielectric constant and conductivity at the microwave frequency band.Therefore, the gain and radiation efficiency of the antenna can deteriorate [4][5][6][7].
A lot of research for the on-body communication channel of WBAN system in the industrial scientific medical (ISM) band has been conducted [8][9][10].In on-body communication, a multipath fading occurs due to reflections from the surrounding environment and the body parts, large relative movement of the body parts, shadowing, and scattering from the moving of the body and the surrounding environment [8].The multipath fading distorts communication signals and reduces the efficiency of WBAN system [11].Since a diversity technique forces signals to be independently processed, stable communication performance of an antenna system can be achieved in multipath fading environment.Multiple-input and multiple-output (MIMO) antennas have received much attention as one of promising diversity techniques.A high isolation characteristic is essential for MIMO antenna system in order to achieve independency of multiple signals [12].
In the paper, a planar MIMO antenna with slits for on-body WBAN applications in 2.4 GHz ISM band (2.4∼ 2.485 GHz) is proposed.A planar inverted-F antenna (PIFA) operating with a resonant length of /4 is used to achieve compact size [13].Ground pads are added to reduce the size of the antenna with improved impedance matching.By using two slits in a ground plane, the isolation characteristic increases over 18 dB in 2.4 GHz ISM band.The performance of the proposed antenna on the human equivalent flat phantom such as -parameter characteristics, radiation characteristics, SAR, and an envelope correlation coefficient (ECC) is analyzed.PIFAs have a dimension of 11.5 × 16 × 1 mm 3 .A distance between the two PIFAs is 8 mm and  1 denotes the length of the radiator of PIFAs.Addition of ground pads at a ground plane increases the electrical length and bandwidth of PIFAs without changing the size of PIFAs. 2 and , respectively, denote the length and the width of the ground pads.Although an isolator does not exist between the two PIFAs, the isolation characteristic is improved by adding two slits with the length of  3 in the ground plane.

Antenna Geometry
Figure 2 shows the proposed antenna on the human equivalent flat phantom.The dimension of the human equivalent flat phantom is 200 × 270 × 60 mm 3 .The proposed antenna for possible applications (portable devices such as Bluetooth headset and wearable smart watch) has the maximum allowed separation distance of 10 mm from the phantom in order to provide the clearance of cover assembly [4].To account for this situation, the separation distance  between the antenna and the phantom is chosen as 10 mm.In order to analyze the antenna performance on a human body, simulations were conducted using the human equivalent flat phantom having the equivalent electrical properties (  = 52.7 and  = 1.95 S/m) of human tissue [14].The simulation results were obtained using HFSS based on the finite-element method [15].

Simulated Results
Figure 3 shows the simulated -parameter results for the proposed antenna with and without the phantom.The design Figure 4 shows the simulated -parameter results for the proposed antenna on the phantom with slit and without slit.By adding a slit at the ground plane, the isolation at 2.44 GHz is improved from 15 dB to 20 dB.The isolation characteristic over the entire 2.4 GHz ISM band is higher than 18 dB.
Figure 5 shows the simulated surface current distributions for the proposed antenna at 2.44 GHz.The slit operates at the electrical length of /4.Because the minimum current of the slit implies high impedance by /4 slit, the slit blocks current flowing from PIFA 1 to PIFA 2 through the ground plane [16,17].For the antenna without slit, when PIFA 1 is excited by port 1, a strong current excites on PIFA 2 as shown in Figure 5(a).For the antenna with slit, a weak current excites on PIFA 2 as depicted in Figure 5(b).
Figure 6 shows the simulated -parameter results for various values of length  1 .Other parameters, excluding  1 , are the same as described above.A resonance frequency is formed by the length of radiator (/4).As  1 increases, the radiator approaches the ground pad.Therefore, the resonance frequency decreases with a deteriorated impedance matching.However, the isolation characteristic is maintained above 18 dB.Because the distance between the PIFA and the slit is far enough as shown in Figure 5(b), the change of the radiator's length hardly affects the isolation characteristic.When  1 is 28 mm, 10 dB return loss bandwidth of the antenna fully covers 2.4 GHz ISM band.
Figure 7 shows the simulated -parameter results for various values of length  2 .As  2 increases, the resonance frequency decreases because the coupling between the ground pad and the part of PIFA near feeding port becomes stronger in Figure 5  18 dB.Because  2 is the length of the ground pad, the addition of ground pad contributes to the size reduction of the PIFA.When  2 is 10.5 mm, the best isolation performance in 2.4 GHz ISM band is achieved.Figure 8 shows the simulated -parameter results for various values of width .As  decreases, the resonance frequency increases because the coupling between the ground pad and the tip of PIFA becomes weaker in Figure 5(b).The 10 dB return loss bandwidth increases with an improved impedance matching.The isolation characteristic remains nearly constant above 18 dB regardless of the change in .To cover 2.4 GHz ISM band,  is chosen as 3 mm.Figure 9 shows the simulated -parameter results for various values of length  3 .As  3 increases, the isolation characteristic is improved, while the  11 characteristic is retained.Because  3 is the length of the slit, the change of  3 mainly affects the isolation characteristic.When  3 is chosen as 24 mm, the isolation characteristic is higher than 18 dB in 2.4 GHz ISM band.
Figure 10 shows the simulated SAR distribution of the proposed antenna on the phantom at 2.44 GHz.According to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the SAR values for a partial body should be below 1.6 W/kg over a volume of 1 g of tissue [18].When the maximum input power is 100 mW, the SAR of the proposed antenna is 1.42 W/kg which satisfies the FCC SAR limitation of 1.6 W/kg.Therefore, the proposed antenna can be used for a low power wireless terminal operating below 100 mW such as Bluetooth system [19].
International Journal of Antennas and Propagation  Table 1 shows the simulated total efficiency at 2.44 GHz.The total efficiency of the proposed antenna is higher than that of the antenna without the slits due to the improvement of isolation between the two antenna elements by inserting the slits.

Measured Results
Figure 11 shows the fabricated antenna and phantom for measurement setup.The measured electrical properties of the fabricated human equivalent semisolid flat phantom are   = 52.7 and  = 1.95 S/m [20].The human equivalent semisolid flat phantom is used to measure the antenna performance.
Figure 12 shows the simulated and measured -parameter results for the proposed antenna.The simulated results are virtually identical to the measured results.The discrepancy between the simulated and the measured results may have been due to a manufacturing error (long coaxial feed cable) of the fabricated antenna [21].The proposed antenna has the 10 dB return loss bandwidth of 210 MHz (2.34∼2.55GHz).This is wide enough to fully cover 2.4 GHz ISM band.The isolation characteristic is higher than 20 dB over 2.4 GHz ISM band.
Figure 13 shows the simulated and measured radiation patterns of the proposed antenna at 2.44 GHz.The measured radiation patterns agree well with the simulated ones.The radiation patterns of the PIFA 1 and PIFA 2 are similar to each other.In Figure 13(a), nearly omnidirectional radiation patterns are observed.In Figure 13(b), radiation patterns directed toward the outside of phantom are observed.Table 2 shows the measured peak gain and radiation efficiency of the proposed antenna at 2.44 GHz.The peak gain is 1.61 dBi for the PIFA 1 and 1.6 dBi for the PIFA 2.   The diversity performance of a MIMO antenna could be evaluated by the envelope correlation coefficient (ECC).The ECC should be calculated from 3D radiation patterns [22].Figure 14 shows the calculated ECC from simulated and measured radiation patterns of the proposed antenna.The simulated ECC agrees well with the measured ECC.The ECC values are maintained below 0.5 over 2.4 GHz ISM band.The simulated ECC of the proposed antenna is lower than that of the antenna without slits due to the improvement of isolation between the two antenna elements by inserting the slits.

Conclusion
In this paper, the planar MIMO antenna with slits in 2.4 GHz ISM band for WBAN applications is proposed.The 10 dB return loss bandwidth of the antenna on the human equivalent flat phantom is wide enough to cover 2.45 GHz ISM band.The addition of ground pads contributes to the size reduction and the improvement of the impedance matching of the PIFA.
The isolation characteristic is improved by adding two slits.The isolation is higher than 18 dB over the ISM band.The resonant frequency can be controlled by the PIFA, the ground pad, and the slit.The performance of proposed antenna is insensitive to the existence of the phantom.Consequently, the above advantages make the proposed antenna a good candidate for WBAN applications.

Figure 1 2 International 3 Figure 1 :(
Figure1shows the geometry of the proposed antenna.The antenna consists of two identical PIFAs, two identical ground pads, and two identical slits.The proposed planar antenna is designed on a FR4 substrate (  = 4.4) with a 1 mm thickness.The total size of the substrate is 40 × 40 mm 2 .

Figure 2 :
Figure 2: Proposed antenna on the human equivalent flat phantom.

Figure 3 :
Figure 3: Simulated S-parameter results for the proposed antenna with phantom and without phantom.

Figure 4 :
Figure 4: Simulated S-parameter results for the proposed antenna on the phantom with slit and without slit.

Figure 5 :
Figure 5: Simulated surface current distributions for the proposed antenna at 2.44 GHz (port 1: on, port 2: off) (a) without slit and (b) with slit.

Figure 11 :
Figure 11: Fabricated antenna and phantom for measurement setup.(a) Fabricated antenna and (b) the antenna on the phantom for measurement setup.

Figure 12 :
Figure 12: Simulated and measured -parameter results for the proposed antenna.

Figure 13 :
Figure 13: Simulated and measured radiation patterns of the proposed antenna at 2.44 GHz (a)  plane and (b)  plane.

Figure 14 :
Figure 14: Simulated and measured envelope correlation coefficient of the proposed antenna and the antenna without slits.

Table 1 :
Simulated total efficiency at 2.44 GHz.

Table 2 :
Measured peak gain and radiation efficiency.