Creep Rupture Behavior in Dissimilar Weldment between FB2 and 30Cr1Mo1V Heat-Resistant Steel

School of Mechanical Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China State Key Laboratory of Long-Life High Temperature Materials, Dongfang Turbine Co., Ltd, Deyang 618000, China Manufacturing Technology Department, Dongfang Turbine Co., Ltd, Deyang 618000, China School of Mechanical Engineering, Chengdu University, Chengdu 610106, China Institute of Light Alloy Materials, Leshan Normal University, Leshan 614000, China


Introduction
With the purpose of reducing carbon dioxide emissions which cause increasingly serious environmental pollution and meeting increasing demand on energy, research on renewable green energy is needed on the one hand; traditional ultrasupercritical (USC) generation technology with improved steam parameters like higher temperature and pressure has developed rapidly in recent decades on the other hand [1][2][3]. Dissimilar metal welding techniques have been gradually utilized to manufacture many important mechanical parts in industry, such as thermal power rotors in USC unit or large petrochemical pressure vessels like reactor and separator in petrochemical industry, since dissimilar welding applications have the advantages like unique property combinations, weight reductions, lower costs, and improved energy efficiency [4]. However, as known, it is challenging to produce excellent dissimilar welds due to different chemical and physical properties (melting point and coefficient of linear expansion, thermal conductivity, etc.) between different base metals [5,6]. Generally, the properties of dissimilar weld depend on the properties of the base materials, the selection of the welding methods and parameters, and the postweld heat treatment process; and the welds exhibit different mechanical property irregularities due to uneven changes in the microstructure [4].
A great amount of researches [6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13] have been implemented to assess the creep deformation and fracture behavior of dissimilar weld joints of creep-resistant steels. For instance, Dagmar [12] researched the precipitates quantitatively in weld joints of COST F and FB2 creep-resistant steels with conventional and accelerated creep tests, and the fracturing was located in HAZ of the F steel. Creep resistance of similar and dissimilar weld joints of P91 steel (a similar weld joint of 9Cr1Mo steel and a dissimilar weld joint of 9Cr1Mo and 2.25Cr1Mo steels) was studied in Ref. [8] with two experimental weld joints, finding out that for high temperature, the similar weldment ruptured in the HAZ of the parent material while the dissimilar weldment's rupture position was in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of the weld metal. Evaluation of the creep behavior of 2.25Cr-1Mo/ 9Cr-1Mo dissimilar weld joint with its base and weld metals was performed by Ref. [10]. In this research, dissimilar weld joint of FB2 (13Cr9Mo1Co1NiVNbNB) and 30Cr1Mo1V heat-resistant steel was produced. Compared with other metals which may perform as functional material [14,15], heat-resistant steels have been commonly used as structure material in ultrasupercritical (USC) power plants owing to their creep and oxidation resistance and great hightemperature strength. Ferritic (9-12 wt.%) Cr steels [16] are recognized as the key materials for producing casings and forgings for turbines of USC units, and FB2 steels were developed under the European Cooperation in Science and Technology (COST) program [17] for large-scale forging production applying under creep temperature 620°C. 30Cr1Mo1V [18][19][20][21][22][23] is a type of turbine-rotor steel, which was designed in the 1990s to manufacture the highpressure or intermediate-pressure rotors in USC units, serving at a pressure between 23.5 and 25 MPa and a temperature range of 538 and 540°C. Though studies have been carried out to research long-term creep behavior of the heat-resistant steels and their weldments, the creep behavior of the dissimilar FB2 and 30Cr1Mo1V weldment still needs detailed research.
Herein, in this paper, dissimilar welded pipe with FB2 and 30Cr1Mo1V forging pieces for the steam turbine rotor were manufactured in Dongfang Turbine Company in China, which satisfied all requirements set by technical standards. Creep testing at 783 K (510°C) under different stresses was carried out. Microhardness values were obtained along the crept welded joint. Optical microscopy (OM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) were applied to explore microstructure, fracture morphology, and precipitates in crept specimens. The main goal of this work is to investigate the creep stress sates under 783 K (510°C) on the creep rupture behavior of the dissimilar weld joint of FB2 and 30Cr1Mo1V.

Materials and Methods
The chemical compositions of the two base metals are displayed in Table 1. The heat treatment of forged FB2 consisted of one-time quenching and tempering twice, forming full lath martensite microstructure. The 30Cr1Mo1V forging first experienced a preheat treatment process including normalizing and the following tempering and then was quenched and tempered, to form bainite along with ferrite structure. The multilayer welding was carried out employing   International Journal of Photoenergy tungsten inert gas arc welding (TIG-W) for backing weld and submerged arc welding (SA-W) for the subsequent multipass welding. Welding wire TG-S2CMH and US-521H were adopted for TIG and SA welding, respectively. After the welded circular pipe was produced, the postweld heat treatment (PWHT) was conducted to stabilize microstructure and relieve internal stress. Round tensile creep specimens were machined parallel to the axial direction of the welded pipe with two types of parent materials, and the welded fusion zone occupied a center position, and the design and dimensions of the creep specimens are shown in Figure 1. The uniaxial tensile creep tests were carried out employing a leveraged creep machine (CRIMS RD2-3) in the atmosphere, with high-temperature furnace to keep a high temperature of 783 K (510°C), under seven applied stress levels, 420, 400, 350, 320, 300, 270, or 260 MPa. In order to monitor and regulate the test temperature, two NiCr-NiSi thermocouples were attached to the specimen. Gage length displacement and cumulative creep strain were measured with double linear variable displacement transducer (LVDT) extensometers, whose resolution was 0.001 mm. The gage length and cross-sectional area of each specimen were measured before and after creep testing to calculate the percent elongation and the percent reduction in area. Microhardness values were obtained along the crept welded joint. Optical microscopy (OM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) equipped with energydispersive spectrometer (EDS) were applied to explore microstructure, fracture morphology, and precipitates in crept specimens.

Results and Discussion
3.1. Fractured Specimens. Photos of welded specimens between FB2 and 30Cr1Mo1V after creep tests at 783 K under different stresses from 420 to 260 MPa are displayed in Figure 2(a). All of the investigated samples fractured in the weld fusion zone. The location of fracture of dissimilar weldments depends not only on the parent material but also on the creep test conditions. For example, the fracture of the weldment of FB2 and COST F creep-resistant steels was in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of the F steel in Ref. [12]. Moreover, according to Ref. [8] which studied the P91/P22 weld joint, the fracture was initiated in P22 parent material at relatively low temperatures and high stresses while fracture occurred in the weld metal at higher temperatures and lower stresses. Based on the research of Ref. [24] on dissimilar steel welded joints between ferritic steel and austenitic stainless steel (T92/HR3C), the rupture positions vary with change in stresses, from T92 base material to HAZ of T92 and to weld seam with decreasing stress. A certain amount of localized plastic deformation, i.e., the necking, after various creep damages can be observed in samples under stresses no less than 270 MPa, with the measured percentage elongation ranging from 5.52% to 7.19% and the percentage reduction of area from 55.73 to 73.19%. The detailed percentage elongation and reduction of area values under various creep conditions are displayed in Figure 2(b). The 3 International Journal of Photoenergy creep ductility exhibits little change between 420 and 300 MPa, and it drops dramatically at 270 MPa. The rupture time exhibits an increasing trend with the drop of applied stress, and the welded specimen does not break till the target time of 10,000 hours for the lowest stress of 260 MPa. Roomtemperature and high-temperature tensile testing has been implemented on welded joints, and just like creep testing, all specimens ruptured in the weld metal, and the strength decreases significantly while the ductility values increase slightly with testing temperature. Under room temperature, the yield strength, tensile strength, elongation, and reduction of the area are 692 MPa, 617 MPa, 13%, and 72%, and they change to 463 MPa, 430 MPa, 14%, and 78% for 823 K (550°C), respectively.
It is worth noting that the specimens under 400 and 320 MPa deviate from the above rupture time increasing with the drop of the stress trend, which is probably as a result of the welding defects. Figure 3 displays the SEM fractograph of the specimen at 320 MPa, and secondary cracks and inclusions can be observed. Besides, small local ductile fracture regions which show dimpled fracture surfaces spread out across the fracture surface, implying that the fraction in this specimen is not pure ductile fraction.

Creep Rupture Exponent and Life Assessment.
Variations between applied stress (σ) and creep rupture life (t r ) of the welded joint are logarithmically plotted in Figure 4 according to the equation t r = A•σ −n , where A is a coefficient and n is creep rupture exponent. The fitted creep rupture exponent is 14.53, with a coefficient of determination, R 2 , of 0.93477. Zhang et al. [25] have successfully utilized this law to predict the creep life of weldments between an austenite heat-resistant steel and a nickel base weld metal at a specified temperature. The extrapolating strength of rupture time at 10,000 h at 783 K (510°C) can be obtained as 261.67 MPa, which agrees with our experimental data (see Figure 2). In order to evaluate the combined influence of the exposed temperature and applied stress on the creep rupture of the weldment, the Larson-Miller parameter (LMP) with a form of P = TðC + lg t r Þ where C is the material constant, which is one of the three versions of time-temperature parametric (TTP) methods with a relative rate of success [26], is utilized to analyze the creep data. The calculated results are displayed in Figure 4. The extrapolating strength of rupture time at 783 K for 10,000 h is 259.02 MPa, with a LMP value of approximately 2:16 × 10 4 . Therefore, the 10,000 h extrapolating strength values predicted by the power law and LMP methods show good agreement.   Figures 5 and 6, before and after creep testing. The OM image of parent material FB2 shows a typical microstructure of high Cr (9-12 wt.% Cr) ferritic steel; that is, prior austenite grains are divided into packets and further into blocks, and many elongated subgrains which contain a high density of free density can be observed in the blocks [27]. As for the 30Cr1Mo1V, it has a much smaller prior austenite grains compared to FB2, and a bainite and ferrite structure can be observed, agreeing with previous studies [21][22][23]. The heat-affected zone exhibits different microstructures including coarse-grain zone and fine-grain zone, whose evolution is mainly influenced by weld thermal cycle (the heating and cooling rate), peak temperature experienced, dwelling time, number of welding passes, and postweld heat treatment. As displayed in Figure 2, the fracture site is located at the weld fusion zone, and accordingly, the weld seam ( Figure 6) shows a complex microstructure of bainite, martensite, and coarse primary ferrite. Various crystallizing morphologies including fine equiaxed grains and coarse columnar crystals and dendrites can be observed in Figure 1(b) even with the unaided eyes. Such microstructure variation can be attributed to the effect of each pass on previous welding pass. The temperature gradient between weld and base metal leads to rapid solidification that results in the formation of columnar austenite grains. For multipass welding, the subsequent passes might cause autotempering of previously deposited metal, leading into the formation of fine former austenite grain structures in previously near deposited metal. It can be found in the weld seam of ruptured dissimilar weldment at 783 K (510°C) under 300 MPa ( Figure 6) that the equiaxed grain zone is increased while the columnar crystals and dendrites are decreased, perhaps because previously formed martensitic structure in the weld seam is not stable and has a tendency to degenerate into ferritic equiaxed crystals with low density of dislocation as a result of recovery and recrystallization during high-temperature creep.

Creep Resistance Analysis in Weld
Metal. Weldments have a highly heterogeneous microstructure; thus, the microhardness can vary considerably over relatively short distance. Figure 7 displays the hardness profile across the original weldment before creep testing and the specimens after testing at 783 K at an applied stress of 400, 300, or 270 MPa. Please note that the width of the weld fusion zone for crept specimens in the figure is smaller than its real dimension, because a section of the fractured specimen, approximately 10 mm, was cut off to observe the fracture surface. The practical widths of the weld metal for the crept specimen should be greater than those of the original weld joint, as a result of the plastic deformation in creep testing. It can be seen clearly that the base metal of FB2 exhibits greater microhardness values than 30Cr1Mo1V, whether before creep tests or after. The hardness in weld metal exhibits a decline trend with decreasing stress and increasing creep time while the hardness in other microzones of the weldment does not show such a sharp decline. Therefore, the weld fusion zone changes from the maximum hardness region to the minimum during creep testing, which is more obvious for the regions on the side near the fusion boundary, indicating that a softening phenomenon occurs in weld metal. This result is different from the results from previous   [25,[28][29][30], where hardness of the FGHAZ/IC-HAZ is the lowest, and soft FGHAZ/IC-HAZ shows higher susceptibility to type IV cracking.
There are mainly three strengthening mechanisms: solution strengthening, precipitation strengthening, and dislocation substructure for high Cr ferritic steel [27]. It is known that martensitic and bainitic transformation in the weld seam can introduce an extremely high density of dislocation, and these dislocations decrease rapidly with respect to the microstructural change during creep testing, resulting in the decrease in creep strength and microhardness. The evolution of dislocation density in X20 and P91 (two martensite ferritic steels), during heat treatment and creep, was analyzed using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) in Ref. [31], and according to their results on P91, the dislocation density is 4:20 × 10 14 m -2 after quenching and drops to 0:60 × 10 14 m -2 after one hour tempering, to 0:06 × 10 14 m -2 in crept specimen. Figures 8(a)  and 8(b) show the TEM micrographs of elongated martens-itic lath structure in weld metal which does not experience stress; there exists a high density of dislocations within the laths and subgrains, which is mainly attributed to the formation of martensite during welding and subsequent heat treatment. The microstructural studies of specimen crept at 270 MPa, as shown in Figures 8(c) and 8(d), exhibit a decrease in the dislocation and precipitate density and an increase of the size of precipitates. Besides deterioration of the abovementioned strengthening mechanisms, Laves phase precipitation, (Fe, Cr) 2 (W, Mo), weakens the creep strength by removing Mo from solid solution. Accordingly, Laves precipitates along with Mn-and Cu-rich precipitates can be observed along grain boundaries based on Figure 9, which will be further discussed in the following section.
Moreover, previous studies demonstrated that the hardness is affected not only by the dislocation structure but also by other microstructures such as substructures like microvoids and precipitates [29]. Figure 10 displays the evolution of microvoids with respect to creep stress. It can be found out that a great amount of microvoids form in  3.5. Fractography and Precipitate Analysis. Figure 11 displays creep microvoids and precipitates near the fracture surface.
As displayed above, all of the investigated samples exhibit necking after various creep damages, which is a ductile fracture character. A tearing region can be clearly observed on each fracture surface, which is considered an eventual plastic deformation (tearing) of the fracture procedure. The SEM morphologies at the smooth region of the ruptured specimens exhibit transgranular fracture features which are characterized by dimples as a result of microvoid coalescence 7 International Journal of Photoenergy [32]. Equiaxed dimpled fracture surfaces can be observed in micrographs at high magnification, and with the drop of the applied stress, i.e., with the increase in creep time, large dimples emerge and thus, the dimples' average size increases. Creep cavities are found to be surrounded by the ductile dimples, and a large amount of the observed dimples are centered around near-spherical particles. In general, the nucleation of microvoids preferentially takes place at precipitates or inclusions, acting as a stress concentrator; then, the voids grow together to form a macroscopic flaw, resulting  International Journal of Photoenergy into fracture. Herein, the fracture mechanism is the microvoid coalescence fracture, and the precipitates will create a stress concentration that can cause transgranular fracture initiation. EDS analysis of the precipitates in Figure 12 shows that the precipitate contains metal elements like Fe, Cr, and Mo. According to previous studies [12,33,34], the precipitates can be recognized as the Laves phase precipitates, which is an intermetallic phase of W and Mo recognized as (Fe, Cr) 2 (W, Mo). And W is not obvious in the above precipitate since no W is added into 30Cr1Mo1V and only 0.01 wt.% W is added to the FB2. About the formation mechanism of the Laves phase, some researchers believe that it swallows the M 23 C 6 carbides by nucleating and growing on it and forms a cluster around prior grain boundaries [35]. After long-term creep, with the nucleation and growth of the Laves phase, the Mo and W contents are decreased; meanwhile, the pinning effect of the M 23 C 6 is weakened, leading into the decrease in solid solution strengthening and creep strength, which will limit the life of component under high-temperature service condition; in addition, it is known that Laves precipitation can enhance the creep resistance by inhibiting the subgrain structure recovery and providing the pining effect to boundaries for short time creep, and such positive effect declines with creep time due to high coarsening rate [36]. Big-size Laves precipitates can act as cavity trigger, and precipitates larger than 130 nm changed the fracture mode from ductile to brittle according to the research of Panait et al. [37]. Besides the Laves phase, copper-rich precipitates containing Fe, Cu, Cr, and C can be observed in the vicinity of the fracture surface. Xiao et al. [38] discussed solute-dislocation interactions and creep-enhanced Cu-rich precipitate (CRPs) evolution in a novel ferritic-martensitic steel G115 during creep. And the large precipitates may nucleate microvoids which results into final fracture.

Conclusions
Dissimilar weldments between FB2 and 30Cr1Mo1V were obtained employing multipass submerged arc welding (SA-W) with backing weld being performed by tungsten inert gas arc welding (TIG-W). High-temperature creep tests at 783 K (510°C) were carried out for various applied stresses from 420 to 260 MPa. The creep rupture behavior of the dissimilar weldments are studied and summarized.
All creep samples fractured with a certain amount of localized plastic deformation in the weld fusion zone, which exhibits a heterogeneous microstructure as a result of multipass welding. The specimen does not break for the target time of 10,000 h under the lowest stress of 260 MPa, and the extrapolating strength of rupture time at 10,000 h with power law is 262 MPa, and the value predicted by Larson-Miller parameter is 259 MPa, which agree well with the experimental result. The base metal of FB2 exhibits greater microhardness values than 30Cr1Mo1V, whether before creep tests or after. The hardness in weld metal shows a decline trend with decreasing stress and increasing creep time, so the weld fusion zone changes from the maximum hardness region to the minimum as a result of creep, indicating that a softening phenomenon occurs in weld metal. The rupture occurs in the weld metal, probably as a result of the decreased dislocation density, the appearance of the  Figure 12: EDS spectrum of precipitates in the vicinity of the fracture surface in the specimen after 7386.5-hour creep testing. 9 International Journal of Photoenergy microvoids, and precipitates during creep. The SEM morphologies at the smooth region of the ruptured specimens exhibit transgranular fracture features, and equiaxed dimpled fracture surfaces can be observed. With the increase in creep time, large dimples emerge and thus, the dimples' average size grows. Creep cavities are found to be surrounded by the ductile dimples, and a large amount of the observed dimples are centered around near-spherical particles. The particles are recognized as the Laves phase and Cu-rich precipitates based on the EDS analysis. Microvoids preferentially nucleate at precipitates; then, the voids grow together to form a macroscopic flaw, which leads into eventual fracture.

Data Availability
The microstructure, hardness, and creep data used to support the findings of this study are included within the article.

Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest regarding the publication of this paper.