Journal of Healthcare Engineering
Volume 2020 (2020), Article ID 2483285, 13 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/2483285

Research Article

Automatic Detection of Brain Tumor on Computed Tomography Images for Patients in the Intensive Care Unit

Fahmi Fahmi,¹ Fitri Apriyulida,¹ Irina Kemala Nasution,² and Sawaluddin³

¹Department of Electrical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Universitas Sumatera Utara, Medan, Indonesia
²Department of Neurology, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Sumatera Utara, Medan, Indonesia
³Faculty of Computer Science and Information Technology, Universitas Sumatera Utara, Medan, Indonesia

Correspondence should be addressed to Fahmi Fahmi; fahmimn@gmail.com

Received 12 September 2019; Revised 1 June 2020; Accepted 24 June 2020; Published 15 July 2020

Academic Editor: Ahmed F. Hussein

Copyright © 2020 Fahmi Fahmi et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Abstract.

Patients in the intensive care unit require fast and efficient handling, including in-diagnosis service. The objectives of this study are to produce a computer-aided system so that it can help radiologists to classify the types of brain tumors suffered by patients quickly and accurately; to build applications that can determine the location of brain tumors from CT scan images; and to get the results of the analysis of the system design. The combination of the zoning algorithm with Learning Vector Quantization can increase the speed of computing and can classify normal and abnormal brains with an average accuracy of 85%.

1. Introduction

Patients in the intensive care unit require fast and efficient handling, including in-diagnosis service. The development of technological systems in the medical world is now proliferating. Many applications have been built that can process medical image results from modalities such as Computed Tomography (CT), Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI), Positron Emission Tomography (PET), and X-ray systems [1]. In the medical world, CT scans are widely used to support the diagnosis of a disease that can display body tissue without the need to go through surgery.

Detection of brain tumors has an essential role in the field of biomedical application in terms of diagnosis of medical image records. The importance of identifying brain tumors has increased in the recent years. The brain tumor classification was developed to help medical staff diagnose the disease. In the classification, there are several processes that need to be performed, e.g., preprocessing, feature extraction, and classification. Preprocessing is part of processing an image before feature extraction is performed to determine an area or object. This process consists of filtering, normalizing, and identifying objects before the extraction stage. Feature extraction is a step to take the core value (feature) on a CT-scan image to get an object that will be recognized or distinguished from other objects [2]. The extraction features include using the Gray Level Co-Occurrence Matrix (GLCM) with a matrix size of 64 × 64 pixels [3], with discrete wavelet transform applying Principal Component Analysis (PCA) [4] or zoning method [5].

Classification is the process of determining functions that can distinguish concepts with the aim of estimating the unknown class of an object [6]. One method that can be used in the classification is Learning Vector Quantization (LVQ). LVQ is a classification method that can conduct training at supervised layers of a version of the Kohonen model that has a simple learning algorithm consisting of one input and output layer [7].

The following are several studies that have been previously conducted in the area of brain tumors, including the classification of soft tissues within brain CT scan based on wavelet-dominant gray level run length texture features [8]. This study obtained standard brain accuracy and brain tumor identification of 98.00%. Classification of brain tumors based on the statistical feature set uses the support vector machine with an accuracy of 68.1% [9].

In this study, we used feature extraction with zoning and classification methods with Learning Vector Quantization (LVQ) techniques. For each sample data that has gone through the image preprocessing process and feature extraction, and tumor location will be determined.

The objectives are to produce a computer-aided system so that it can help radiologists to classify the types of brain tumors suffered by patients quickly and accurately; to build applications that can determine the location of brain tumors from CT scan images, and to get the results of the analysis of the system design. The benefits obtained from this study are to help radiologists to diagnose the types of brain tumors suffered by patients quickly and accurately, especially patients in the intensive care unit, and also, it becomes one of the references for researchers who focus on computer vision technology in the medical field.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Brain Tumors

The brain tumor is tissuemass that grows uncontrollably and is suppressing other healthy tissue. Brain tumors can be classified as benign (soft) brain tumors and malignant (severe) brain tumors. It is clinically challenging to distinguish between benign or malignant brain tumors because the symptoms that arise are also determined by the location of the tumor, the rate of growth, and the effect of the tumor mass on brain tissue [10].

Initial diagnosis is made by obtaining data on the patient’s family health history and physical examination. After that, a neurological examination is performed to determine the mental status, memory, cranial nerve function, muscle strength, and response to pain. The next step is a radiological examination through CT-scan or MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging).

2.2. Computed Tomography

Computed Tomography (CT) scan is a method used to examine patients without direct surgery but uses X-ray and a computer to produce brain images in axial fragments [11]. The number of pieces produced by the CT-scan is determined by the specifications of the CT-scan used. In order to improve the quality of the image in the radiological examination, the patient is sometimes injected with a contrast agent in order to improve the image quality of the desired organ. The size of the images contained on the CT-scan ranges from −1024 to +3071 on the Hounsfield unit scale. Hounsfield itself is a measurement of the density of the tissue, as shown in Figures 1 and 2.

Figure 1: Brain tumor on CT-scan [12].

Figure 2: Normal brain on CT-scan.

Image processing is a method for processing and analyzing images so as to produce images in accordance with image perceptions and needs to be used using computer aids. The image can be interpreted as a function that has two dimensions f (x, y), where x and y are coordinates and f at each point (x, y) expresses the intensity, brightness, and grayscale in the image. The digital image is the study of a matrix in which there are elements of an image that can provide information in a discrete form. Digital images are continuous as in X-ray and television monitors. Thus, the conversion process needs to be performed to get information from the required digital image. To get feature information on images, various applications can be used, one of which is computer vision, which has been developed in the process of taking image information in the form of features that have been extracted automatically from the image itself. This process is often used to combine several technologies such as image and signal processing, pattern recognition and multimedia, and interaction between humans and computers. This process is often referred to as CBIR (Content-Based Image) in the field of image processing [12].

Some stages contained in the CBIR process include the following:

 (1) Preprocessing aims to determine an object that will be used at the extraction stage (2) Feature Extraction is a process for obtaining new features in the form of patterns, shapes, and textures

2.3. Forming a Binary Matrix (Binarization)

At this stage, the image will be formed as black and white by converting a gray-level image to a binary image. This process will take the average value of each RGB value, where the pixel value produced is higher than the threshold value, it will be represented aswhite and if the resulting pixel value is less than the threshold value, it will be represented as black [13]. The thresholding process is used to determine the degree of the gray level in the image and determine the threshold value. The process for determining this threshold value uses the following equation:

where T = threshold value, fmaks = maximum pixel value, and fmin = minimum pixel value.

2.4. Feature Selection

Feature selection is the process of determining patterns by obtaining values on image characters to form feature values. Classification uses feature values to recognize input units from output units so that they can easily distinguish objects.

2.5. Zoning Method

The zoning method is a method of feature extraction that can divide the characters into N × M zones from each zone. The feature value calculation is performed to form the feature values in the M × N zone. In the classification process, the introduction of the zoning method produces proper and efficient feature extraction. Zoning can be used to calculate the number of white pixel values in a particular zone; the value obtained from the zoning process will be used as a value for the vector input. The results of the zoning process are vector features that can be entered into the classification stage, as in Figure 3 [14].

Figure 3: Zoning method.

2.6. Definition of LVQ (Learning Vector Quantization)

LVQ is a classification method that can conduct training at supervised layers at the competitive layer. This layer is able to classify the given vector input automatically. Some input vectors have close weights; therefore, the weights will connect the input layer with the competitive layer. The competitive layer produces a class that is connected to the output layer with an activation function. The architecture of an LVQ network with several input layer units and units at the output layer can be seen in Figure 4 [16].

Figure 4: LVQ network architecture [15].

Figure 4 explains that the values X1 to X2 are input values where this value will be used for the training process and testing process. W1 and W2 as weight vectors that can connect each input layer with the output layer. W1 and Wn are used to get the smallest weight distance from the weight vector obtained from the calculation of input values. E1 and E2 are used as the output layer to represent several classes, while D1 and D2 are used as the output values at the output layer for the testing process.

Some of the advantages of LVQ are as follows [16, 17]:

(1)Able to produce a minimum error value(2)At the classification, the stage can summarize large data sets into small vectors(3)Can do a gradual renewal of the resulting model

The disadvantages of LVQ are as follows:

(1)To determine the distance to all attributes, an accurate calculation must be used.(2)Calculation of initialization and parameters are needed in determining the accuracy of the LVQ model.(3)There is difficulty in determining the number of vectors in new problems before entering into the classification process using the LVQ method, the training process is first carried to simplify the process of class searching so that it can perform an introduction of input patterns based on the output obtained. LVQ can perform input pattern recognition if the distance between the weight vector and the input vector is close together.

2.7. Training and Testing

At LVQ, there are two stages of training and testing as follows: the training algorithm and testing of the LQV artificial neural network used for the training and testing process . The initial weight of the input values X1 to Xn towards the output layer that represents the whole class, maximum epoch (MaxEpoch), learning rate parameters (α), reduction of learning rate (Decα), and minimum error (Eps) is determined.

At the training stage, LVQ calculation results are used to get the weight value that will be stored and used in the testing phase. In the testing phase, new input data is classified by calculating the value of each weight in the input and selecting the smallest distance in the two weights that have been stored. The value at the smallest weight distance will represent the class in the input image.

The data used are 40 data stored in the medical record of H. Adam Malik General Hospital in patients aged 40 to 60 years with male sex 60% and female 40%, all anonymized.

2.8. Input of the Brain Image

The image input process is carried out before the image classification process. The image data used in this study is axial piece brain image data obtained from CT Scan. The image used is a grayscale image measuring 512 × 512.

2.9. Preprocessing

At the preprocessing stage shown in Figure 5, several stages are carried out to facilitate the next process; the preprocessing stage consists of grayscale and binarization processes. At the stage of binarization, the image is converted into a grayscale form, and then, thresholding will be performed where the grayscale image will be converted into a binary form, which has values 1 and 0 (white and black). In this stage, the threshold value is used to determine the binary value in each image. If the resulting value is above the threshold value, the pixel value is changed to white; if the resulting value is less than the threshold, the pixel value will be changed to black. This is shown in Figure 6.

Figure 5: Research flowchart.

(a)

(b)

Figure 6: Binarization, normal (a) and after binarization (b).

2.10. Feature Extraction

In the next process, after going through the preprocessing, the feature extraction step is carried out by the zoning method to get a good feature value on the image of a brain tumor. Furthermore, the feature values obtained from the method will be classified using the LVQ (learning vector quantization) method.

Zoning is one method that can divide several regions, where each region will produce a feature value by counting the highest number of white pixels. At this stage, the image size of 512 × 512 will be divided into 8 columns and 8 rows so that it gets 64 zones, and there are 64 feature values in it. The following process of extraction features can be seen in Figure 7, while the division of zones can be seen in Figure 8.

Figure 7: Feature extraction process.

Figure 8: Result of image zoning.

The process of the zoning method on CT brain image tumors is as follows:

(1)The number of white pixels are counted per zone from Z1 to Z512(2)It is determined which zone has the highest number of white pixels(3)The feature values (Zn) of each zone are calculated from Z1 to Z512

The following formula is used:

where 1 ≤ n ≤ 512.

Feature values (Zn) are obtained by comparing the number of white pixels from one zone with the zones obtained from process no 2. Examples of zoning method calculations are as follows:

(1)The number of white pixels in each zone is

 Z4 = 40, Z12 = 30, Z40 = 70, and Z53 = 50

(2)The zone that has the highest number of white pixels is Z40 = 70(3)Feature values for each zone include

 Z1 = 40/70 = 0.57 Z12 = 30/70 = 0.42 Z40 = 70/70 = 1 Z53 = 50/70 = 0.71 Z60 = 20/70 = 0.28

The feature extraction process by the zoning method will produce 64 features where the feature will be used as an input value at the next stage, which is the classification process using LVQ and can be seen in Figure 9.

Figure 9: Value of feature extraction with zoning.

2.11. Classification

Classification is a process to train and test the value of features produced through the feature extraction process using the zoning method and classified with Learning Vector Quantization (LVQ). At the classification stage, there are two processes, namely, the training process and the testing process, where the training process is used to train memorization on Learning Vector Quantization (LVQ) while the testing process is testing the value of features that have never been trained [15].

2.12. Training Process

At the training stage, the LVQ algorithm will process the input values by receiving 64 input vectors in the feature class, and then, the vector will calculate the distance of all vectors representing the class.

The process of applying the Vector Quantization Learning Algorithm (LVQ) to the training is as follows [18]:

(1)The initial process in the LVQ algorithm is the initialization stage to determine the initial weight, maximum iteration, minimum error, and learning rate.(2)The input and target values ​​of the input are initialized.(3)The next step determines the initial conditions epoch = 0 and error = 1.(4)When the epoch is smaller than the maximum epoch, each weight value is calculated, and then, the shortest distance to the weight is set with the value that has been set.(5)The next step is to update the weight value if the target class and weight are the same as when using the following equation:

(6)The same calculation is repeated for each input using the updated weight.(7)After the calculation of the input is complete, the value of α is reduced and α is iterated until it approaches the maximum. The value is determined so that Error becomes a minimum.

2.13. System Testing and ROC Analysis

The testing process uses LVQ that has been trained to recognize test data that has never been trained. The testing process is the same as the training process, where the classification calculates the value of each weight input and selects the closest distance between the two weights. When LVQ is tested using training data, testing is performed to see how the memorization of LVQ is developed after going through the training process because the cases included have been studied before.

The results of the testing process on the sample will be adjusted in the contingency table to get the sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of the contingency table, as can be seen in Table 1. The probability of success from a calculation has four possibilities. The four possibilities are as follows:

(1)If the doctor diagnoses the brain image as a tumor and the brain image is classified positively identified by the tumor, then true positive (TP) is calculated(2)If the doctor diagnoses the brain image as a tumor and the brain image is classified as negatively identified by the tumor, then false negative (FN) is calculated(3)If the doctor diagnoses a healthy brain and the brain image is classified as negative, true negative (TN) is calculated(4)If the doctor diagnoses a healthy brain image and the brain image is classified as positive, the tumor is calculated as false positive (FP)

Table 1: Contingency table.

P
N

Y
TP (True Positive)
FP (False Positive)

N
FN (False Negative)
TN (True Negative)

Total
P
N

2.14. Image Preparation

This part discusses the process of classifying brain images, amounting to 40 images. In the training process, 10 brain images were identified as tumors, and 10 healthy brains for the training process consisted of 10 brain images that were identified as tumors, and 10 were normal. CT-scan brain image data were obtained from medical records of H. Adam Malik General Hospital in patients aged 40 years to 60 years. At this stage, it aims to display the results of the testing process on learning vector quantization. The author builds this application using programming in java.

The CT image data used to support the findings of this study may be released upon application to the Department of Neurology, Adam Malik Hospital, Medan, Sumatera, Utara, Indonesia, who can be contacted at irina.kemala (at) usu.ac.id.

2.15. Specifications of the CT-Scan Plane Used

The CT-scan aircraft specifications used are as follows:

(1)Brand: GE LightSpeed 16 Slice CT(2)Rotation: 0.5 s(3)Thickness slice: 5 mm(4)Kv: 120 kV

3. Results and Discussion

3.1. Preprocessing

The initial process carried out in the classification of brain tumors through the stages of preprocessing in which the image will be converted into black and white before the globalization process is carried out. In this study, using a threshold value of 128, determining the threshold value is used to obtain gray values in the image of a brain tumor. The results of this process can be seen in Figure 10.

(a)

(b)

Figure 10: Binary image reconstruction.

After the binary image is obtained, the next step is feature extraction using the zoning method. In addition to determining the value of the zoning method, features are also used to determine the location of the tumor. A division of several zones of the same size is performed in order to get the results of the CT scan brain tumor image values. The purpose of this feature extraction stage is to find a collection of features found in the character of the brain image.

3.2. Training Process

The image training process uses data in the form of 20 CT scan brain images consisting of 10 normal images and 10 suspected images. CT scan brain images used are 512 × 512 in size stored on local hard disks, and the classification process uses an artificial neural network LVQ (Learning Vector Quantization). Training can be seen in Figure 11, while the training data from CT brain image can be seen in Table 2.

Figure 11: Training process.

Table 2: Data set training.

No.
Brain image
Weight
Result

1

0.076161
Normal

2

2.304818
Normal

3

2.2668598
Normal

4

1.456988
Normal

5

2.9700592
Normal

6

1.6688762
Normal

7

1.6688761
Normal

8

2.9700592
Normal

9

2.769984
Normal

10

1.6688762
Normal

11

2.9779766
Suspected

12

2.9736168
Suspected

13

2.9230187
Suspected

14

2.800454
Suspected

15

3.2186778
Suspected

16

1.8768171
Suspected

17

2.3506687
Suspected

18

1.9752706
Suspected

19

3.0961044
Suspected

20

2.006145
Suspected

From Table 2, the weight value in each training data has been seen. The weight value is the final value used in the testing process, where the weight value is obtained from the LVQ calculation process. To make an introduction to the image by calculating the value of each weight in the input and choose the smallest distance on both weights. The value at the smallest weight distance will represent the class in the input image.

3.3. Image Testing Process

During the testing phase, 20 imagery input data were used, consisting of 10 normal brain images and 10 suspected brain images. Display application of the classification of brain tumors by zoning using learning vector quantization can be seen in Figure 12, and the results of the test can be seen in Table 3.

Figure 12: Image testing process.

Table 3: Result of testings.

No.
Image
Weight 1
Weight 2
Input∗
Result
Notes
Pos.

1
Data-5.png
3.489579
2.9736168
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Right

2
Data-9.png
3.7573445
3.2186778
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Right

3
Data-2.png
3.4895792
2.9779766
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Right

4
Data-12.png
3.0037804
2.6869104
Normal
Suspected
FN
Normal

5
Data-13.png
2.304818
2.9392818
Normal
Normal
TN
Normal

7
Data-7.png
3.07729601
1.8768171
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Right

9
Data-19.png
2.2668598
2.9678066
Normal
Normal
TN
Normal

10
Data-11.png
2.305248
2.9393818
Normal
Normal
TN
Normal

11
Data-13.png
2.304818
2.93938118
Normal
Normal
TN
Normal

12
Data-8.png
3.4555268
2.9230187
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Left

13
Data-18.png
2.9360542
2.8076556
Normal
Suspected
FN
Normal

14
Data-4.png
3.5838966
2.800454
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Right

15
Data-1.png
3.043977
2.006145
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Right

16
Data-6.png
3.0350804
2.3506687
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Left

17
Data-10.png
2.3829138
3.0961044
Suspected
Normal
FP
Normal

18
Data-3.png
2.8869388
1.9752706
Suspected
Suspected
TP
Right

19
Data-14.png
2.769984
2.9166098
Normal
Normal
TN
Normal

20
Data-15.png
2.2493293
2.9494078
Normal
Normal
TN
Normal

From Table 3, the input value in data-12 shows the condition of the image for the normal category, but the system shows a suspect; this is because the learning vector quantization method has a weakness of being sensitive to changes in weight values. If the position of the input value in the form of a feature value is changed, the weight value will also change.

3.4. Classification Results Using the LVQ Method

The results of the test data on the application of brain tumor classification are obtained with the learning vector quantization method with an average classification result of 85% so that the results of the accuracy using learning vector quantization can be calculated simply by using the following equation:

To get accurate results, it is necessary to perform an ROC analysis of the classification results based on the LVQ method; the results for the LVQ method are shown in Table 4.

Table 4: LVQ result.

Classification
LVQ

TP
9

TN
8

FP
2

FN
1

Sensitivity %
90

Specificity %
80

Accuracy %
85

This study has several limitations. The use of CT imaging in the intensive care unit is very limited nowadays due to the need for a radiographer’s presence to analyze and diagnose the patients, sometimes in a not very regular period of time. The availability of CT data, therefore, was very limited, especially with manual reading as the golden standard, as explained in the research flowchart (Figure 5). In this study, only 20 images from 40 data images are used for training, and the rest 20 images are used for testing purposes. This split portion of training and testing was applied in order to get the proof on a concept and can be extended in the future.

4. Conclusions

The combination of the zoning algorithm with learning vector quantization can increase the speed of computing and can classify normal and abnormal brains with an average accuracy of 85%. Optimal recognition of image data can be achieved with the learning vector as it is suitable for use in the intensive care unit in hospitals.

The quantization method has a fast calculation in the introduction of an appropriate character so that there are no errors when testing data. The suggestions for developing this study are to compare the learning vector quantization method with the support vector machine method so that it can produce the best way for classifying brain images. The use of the zoning method and learning vector quantization can be applied to further research by adding methods to determine the extent of abnormal brain images.

Data Availability

All the brain CT Image data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

Acknowledgments

This research was fully funded by the Ministry of Research, Technology, and Higher Education, Indonesia, through Universitas Sumatera Utara financial year 2019 based on contract no. 11/E1/KP.PTNBH/2019 dated 29 March 2019.

References

P. N. H Tra, N. T. Hai, and T. T. Mai, “Image segmentation for detection of benign and malignant tumors,” in Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Biomedical Engineering (BME-HUST), pp. 51–54, IEEE, Hanoi, Vietnam, October 2016.

A. P. Nanthagopal and R. S. Rajamony, “A region-based segmentation of tumour from brain CT images using nonlinear support vector machine classifier,” Journal of Medical Engineering & Technology, vol. 36, no. 5, pp. 271–277, 2012.

V. Marita, “Identifikasi tumor otak menggunakan jaringan syaraf tiruan propagasi balik pada citra ct-scan otak,” Prisma Fisika, vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 117–121, 2014.

A. Bargaje, A. Kulkarni, and S. Lagad, “Brain tumor detection and classification using adaptive boosting,” International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET), vol. 4, no. 7, pp. 1961–1965, 2017.

K. S. Siddharth, R. Dhir, and R. Rani, “Handwritten gurumukhi character recognition using zoning density and background directional distribution features,” International Journal of Computer Science and Information Technologies, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 1036–1041, 2011.

E. Miranda, M. Aryuni, and E. Irwansyah, “A survey of medical image classification techniques,” in Proceedings of International Conference on Information Management and Technology (ICIMTech), pp. 56–61, IEEE, Bandung, Indonesia, November 2016.

M. Azara, T. Fatayer, and A. E. Halees, “Arabic text classification using learning vector quantization,” in Proceedings of 8th International Conference on Informatics and System (INFOS), pp. 40–44, IEEE, Cairo, Egypt, May 2012.

A. Padma and R. Sukanesh, “SVM based classification of soft tissues in brain CT image using wavelet-based dominant gray level run length texture feature,” Middle-East Jornal of Scientific Research, vol. 13, no. 7, pp. 883–888, 2013.

M. K. M. Priya, S. Kavitha, and B. Bharathi, “Brain tumor types and grades classification based on statistical feature set using support vector machine,” in Proceedings of 10th International Conference on Intelligent Systems and Control (ISCO), pp. 1–8, IEEE, Coimbatore, India, January 2016.

R. Lavanyadevi, M. Machakowsalya, J. Nivethitha, and A. Niranjil Kumar, “Brain tumor classification and segmentation in MRI images using PNN,” in Proceedings of the International Conference on Electrical, Instrumentation, and Communication Engineering (ICEICE), pp. 1–6, IEEE, Karur, India, April 2017.

F. Fahmi, H. Marquering, G. Streekstra et al., “Automatic detection of CT perfusion datasets unsuitable for analysis due to head movement of acute ischemic stroke patients,” Journal of Healthcare Engineering, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 67–78, 2014.

R. S. Choras, “Image feature extraction techniques and their applications for CBIR and biometrics systems,” in Proceedings of International Journal of Biology and Biomedical Engineering, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 6–16, IEEE, Minneapolis, MN, USA, June 2007.

T. Triantoro, F.R. Batubara, and F. Fahmi, “Image Based water gauge reading developed with ANN Kohonen,” in Proceedings of International Conference on Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (ICEECS), pp. 74–78, IEEE, Kuta, Indonesia, November 2014.

B. Gatos, A. L. Kesidis, and A. Papandreou, “Adaptive zoning features for character and word recognition,” in Proceedings of 11th International Conference on Document Analysis and Recognition, pp. 1160–1164, IEEE, Beijing, China, Sepetmber 2011.

N. B. Karayiannis, “A methodology for constructing fuzzy algorithms for learning vector quantization,” in IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks, vol. 8, no. 3, IEEE, New York, NY, USA, May 1997.

S. K. Khatri, “Recognizing images of handwritten digits using learning vector quantization artificial neural network,” in Proceedings of International Conference on Reliability, Infocom Technologies and Optimization, pp. 1–4, IEEE, Uttar Pradesh, India, Sepetmber 2015.

S. Kusumadewi, “Komputasi dan sistem cerdas,” GRAHA ILMU, vol. 1, p. 408, 2004.

F. Fahmi, F. Apriyulida, and S. Suherman, “Brain tumour image classification using learning vector quantization based zoning method,” Journal of Physics: Conference Series, vol. 1235, no. 1, Article ID 012027, 2019.