Recent Trends in the Microwave-Assisted Synthesis of Metal Oxide Nanoparticles Supported on Carbon Nanotubes and Their Applications

The study of coating carbon nanotubes with metal/oxides nanoparticles is now becoming a promising and challenging area of research. To optimize the use of carbon nanotubes in various applications, it is necessary to attach functional groups or other nanostructures to their surface. The combination of the distinctive properties of carbon nanotubes and metal/oxides is expected to be applied in field emission displays, nanoelectronic devices, novel catalysts, and polymer or ceramic reinforcement. The synthesis of these composites is still largely based on conventional techniques, such as wet impregnation followed by chemical reduction of the metal nanoparticle precursors. These techniques based on thermal heating can be time consuming and often lack control of particle size and morphology. Hence, there is interest in microwave technology recently, where using microwaves represents an alternative way of power input into chemical reactions through dielectric heating. This paper covers the synthesis and applications of carbon-nanotube-coated metal/oxides nanoparticles prepared by a microwave-assisted method. The reviewed studies show that the microwave-assisted synthesis of the composites allows processes to be completed within a shorter reaction time with uniform and well-dispersed nanoparticle formation.


Introduction
The extraordinary mechanical properties and unique electrical properties of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have stimulated extensive research in almost every research institution and industry worldwide [1].CNTs exhibit superior thermal [2,3], mechanical [4], and electrical properties [5][6][7][8] and are considered the most promising building block for manufacturing low-cost, high-performance nanostructured composite materials.Over the last few years increasing attention has been given to the preparation of various kinds of CNT-based composite materials to enhance the inherent properties of the matrix and optimize the use of CNTs by means of coating or filling with some foreign inorganic materials including metal/oxides [9][10][11].The resultant composite materials have been envisioned to be useful for nanoscale sensors [12][13][14], field emitters [15,16], nanoelectronics [15,17], nanotweezers [18], batteries for electrode materials [15], supercapacitors [19], hydrogen storage [20,21], and many other unique applications.
Composites of metal/oxide nanoparticles and CNTs can be prepared by various strategies, and their preparation is still largely based on conventional techniques.Thus far, coating or deposition of CNTs with various metal nanoparticles has been developed and different methods have been used, such as solid-state reactions, capillary action, radiolysis, physical evaporation, electroless deposition, physisorption, self-assembly, and colloidal chemistry combined with electrostatic interactions or with sonication in aqueous solution [22][23][24][25][26].Many of these methods typically entail multiple steps involving reflux with strong acids combined with ultrasonication that take long hours or even days followed by chemical reduction of the precursor metal salts.Moreover, these methods often lack good control of particle size and morphology and large amounts of materials and energy are used.Only a few reports provide simple, efficient routes for uniform dispersion and strong attachment of nanoparticles to CNT surfaces.Therefore, any new synthesis technique that helps to save time would be extremely beneficial because it would allow scientists to perform more experiments within a shorter time and testing new theories and processes could be done much faster allowing more time to expand scientific creativity [27].
Recently, a microwave-assisted method has been widely applied in chemical reactions and synthesis of nanomaterials [11,28].Research has shown the method to be an attractive choice to promote reactions and is energy effective heating compared to conventional heat conduction methods (such as an oil bath) due to the direct heating of the reaction mixture [29].By conventional methods, the vessel is heated and this then transfers the heat by convection.Microwave heating is more efficient in terms of the energy used, produces higher temperature homogeneity, and is considerably more rapid than conventional heat sources.
Microwave heating is a transfer of electromagnetic energy to thermal energy, and is an energy conversion phenomenon rather than the heat transfer.The electric component [30] of an electromagnetic field causes heating by two main mechanisms, dipolar polarization mechanism and conduction mechanism.In polarization mechanism; for a substance to generate heat when irradiated with microwaves it must possess a dipole moment, as in water molecule.A dipole is sensitive to external electric fields and will attempt to align itself with the field by rotation.The applied field provides the energy for this rotation [31].As molecules vainly attempt to follow the field, they collide with one another and heating in the sample is observed.High-and low-frequency radiation does not give rise to efficient heating: in the first case, the field oscillates too quickly for the molecules to respond; in the second case, the molecules follow the field so well that there is no random motion generated [32].
If two samples containing distilled water and tap water, respectively, are heated in a single mode microwave cavity at a fixed radiation power and for a fixed time, the final temperature will be higher in the tap water sample.This phenomenon is due to the second major interactions of the electric field component with the sample, the conduction mechanism.The conduction mechanism is a much stronger interaction than the dipolar mechanism with regard to the heat-generating capacity [31].In this case, any mobile charge carriers (electrons, ions, etc.) move relatively easily through the material under the influence of the microwave's electric field.These induced currents will cause heating in the sample due to any electrical resistance.If the sample is a metallic conductor, most of the microwave energy is reflected with relatively little energy penetrating beyond a few microns into the surface.However, the surface electrons respond to the field in less than 10 −12 s, and colossal surface potentials (of the order of hundreds of kV m −1 ) may be induced.Conduction heating itself can be demonstrated quite easily in a domestic microwave oven using materials such as copper oxide or carbon.Alternatively, if pure water is heated in a microwave oven, where the polarisation mechanism dominates, the heating rate is significantly lower than that observed when the same volume of a dilute salt solution is heated.In the latter case, both dipolar polarisation and conductive mechanisms contribute to the heating effect [32].
Microwave energy is a spectrum in the same way as visible light, infrared irradiation, and UV irradiation and is delivered directly to the material through molecular interaction with the electromagnetic field.Since microwaves can penetrate the material and supply energy, heat can be generated throughout the volume of the material resulting in volumetric heating [33].Additionally, the method shows acceleration in reaction rate, yield improvement, short reaction time, small particle size, narrow particle size distribution, high purity materials, and enhanced physicochemical properties [34][35][36].The results obtained cannot be explained by the effect of the rapid heating alone, and this has led various authors to postulate the existence of "microwave effect."Historically, "specific microwave effects" have been claimed, when the outcome of a synthesis performed using microwave heating differs from the conventionally heated counterpart carried out at the same apparent temperature [33].
Microwave effects result from material-wave interactions and due to the dipolar polarization phenomenon, the greater the polarity of a molecule (such as the solvent), the more pronounced the microwave effect when the rise in temperature [37] is considered.In terms of reactivity and kinetics, the specific effect has therefore to be considered according to the reaction mechanism and particularly with regard to how the polarity of the system is altered during the progress of the reaction.The origin of specific microwave effects can be rationalized under the Arrhenius law (1) and can result from modifications in each of the terms in this equation [38]: (i) Thus, the increase in the preexponential factor A, which is representative of the probability of molecular impacts.The collision efficiency can be effectively influenced by mutual orientation of polar molecules involved in the reaction.As the factor is dependent on the vibration frequency of the atoms at the reaction interface, it could be postulated that the microwave field might affect this.Calculations have also shown that the faster diffusion rates might be explained by an increase in factor A with no change in activation energy [38].
(ii) Decrease in activation energy ΔG is certainly a main effect.When considering the contribution of enthalpy and entropy to the value of ΔG [ΔG = ΔH − TΔS], it may be predicted that the magnitude of the −TΔS term would increase in a microwave-induced reaction this being more organized when compared to classical heating as a consequence of dipolar polarization [38].Lewis et al. [39] presented experimental evidence for such an assumption after measurements of rate constants according to temperature for the unimolecular imidization of a polyamic acid ((1), Figure 1, and Table 1), where the plot demonstrates the differences between the microwave solution imidization processes and those obtained from conventional treatments.The activation energy (ΔH) determined from this treatment was 105 kJ/moL for thermal imidization and 57 kJ/moL for microwave imidization.The apparent activation energy is largely reduced.The same explanation, that is, a decrease in ΔG, was also proposed for the decomposition reaction of sodium hydrogen carbonate in aqueous solution [40].The physical phenomenon that provides the acceleration of the reaction rates is unclear.To support their results, the authors concluded that the microwave irradiation is not sufficiently energetic to cause either ionization or electronically excited state chemistry to occur, so the overall reaction stoichiometry is the same as that for the thermal reaction.The large difference observed in the kinetic parameters might be due to intermediate products being formed (which is discounted by the coincidence of the formation and disappearance rates for the products and reactants) or from the way in which the microwave radiation interacts with the reactants, the solvent, or the complexes between the solvent and reactants.And this would suggest that the acceleration is not due to the environment around the reactants, and therefore, must be due directly to the interaction of the microwave energy with the reactants, although the presence of solvent, and so forth, may have a secondary effect on the kinetic parameters [39].This paper entails a critical review of microwave-assisted synthesis of CNTs supported with metal/oxide nanoparticles.Due to the extraordinary properties of CNTs, the resulting composites were closely investigated.Various applications of the CNT supported metal/oxide nanoparticle composites are also discussed.

Synthesis of Metal and Metal Oxide Nanoparticles Supported on CNT by Conventional Methods
The first demonstration of a metal nanoparticle-CNT hybrid, also known as metal nanoparticle decorated CNTs, was reported over a decade ago by Planeix et al. [41] via the hydrogen reduction of an organic ruthenium salt in the presence of SWCNTs.For example, when the light nanoparticles (NPs), such as TiO 2 , ZnO, CdS, and CdSe, were attached on CNTs with high conductivity, the photocatalytic properties increased dramatically [42][43][44].Later, Kishi et al. [45] prepared a gas sensor for nitrogen dioxide (NO 2 ) using tungsten oxide (WO 3 ) nanoparticles fabricated on multiwalled CNTs (MWCNTs).The response of the gas sensor was found to be 4 times higher than that of MWCNTs-based gas sensor.
Although the attachment of NPs on CNTs has been extensively studied, most of the methods involve a tedious process and usually require multistep reactions.Moreover, the amount of NPs loaded on CNTs is greatly limited, and this fact limits many practical applications [55].For example, gold NPs were self-assembled onto the surface of solubilized CNTs through an interlinker of bifunctionalized molecule (17-1-pyrenyl)-13-oxo-heptadecanethiol (PHT) [56].The MWCNTs were heated under reflux with concentrated nitric acid and were converted to acylchloride in SOCl 2 and reacted for 96 h.The interlinker PHT was mixed with the MWCNTs and sonicated for 30 min and stood for 8 h.The precipitate was washed several times with ethanol under vacuum evaporator to remove the PHT and then the gold colloid was added.This was followed by stirring for 8 h at room temperature.The resulting solution was centrifuged and a dark brown solid was obtained.The transmission electron microscopy (TEM) image (refer to Figure 2) showed densely coated MWCNTs with gold nanoparticles with a narrow size distribution and an average size of ∼5 nm.
The method took days to prepare one batch of CNT composites with proper dispersion of the NPs.It is reported that the pristine CNTs were heated under reflux using concentrated nitric acid before using them to remove the impurities and to introduce the carboxylic groups on the inherently inert CNTs, which in turn creates active sites to which the metal NP precursors can bind.The oxidation of CNTs in a concentrated acid has been actively reported, but the disadvantage is that long hours of treatment using high concentrated acid creates defects on the CNTs' sidewalls, which often results in damaging the CNTs, rendering them useless for their intended purpose.In this article [56], though it is reported that concentrated nitric acid was used, the reaction time for the oxidation process was not stated, which might have contributed to the long mixing of the CNTs and the NPs to get a strong attachment because the CNTs were severely damaged which results in the degradation of the composites.This method is able to synthesize CNTs coated with gold NPs, but the TEM result shows lack of control on uniform dispersion of the NPs.It is also observed that not all the NPs are on the CNTs which means that there is no strong attachment of the NPs on the surface of the CNTs.A thick layer of NPs is observed on one side of the CNT whereas fewer particles on the other side.This observation shows that the NPs are on top of each other rather than being on the CNTs, which may result in fewer NPs in effect if the composites were to undergo heat treatment or alternatively be used for other applications.
Another multistep process was used by Smorodin et al. [57] to coat single-walled CNTs (SWCNTs) with gold NPs.In their study, SWCNTs were first sonicated in a mixture of H 2 SO 4 :HNO 3 for 90 min to modify the walls of the CNTs.The nanotubes were then suspended in anhydrous dimethylformamide and refluxed in thionyl chloride for 24 h.The precipitate was washed and rinsed to remove excess SOCl 2 , and this was followed by the immersion in ethylene diamine for five days.The nanotubes were rinsed again with THF and resuspended in H 2 O and reacted overnight with N-hydroxy succinimidyl biotin.After the final rinsing step, the biotin-terminated SWCNTs were suspended in H 2 O and a surfactant was added.Finally, gold colloids were added to the SWCNT suspension forming an extremely strong binding between the gold NPs and the SWCNTs.From the AFM image (refer to Figure 3), the authors concluded that a large fraction of SWCNTs has at least one NP attached, in most cases to one of the ends of the tube.
In this article [54] the authors reported the self-assembly method of preparing SWCNTs-coated gold NP composites.They reported a good dispersion of the NPs along the CNT with AFM results.Using this characterization equipment alone is not good enough to prove the success of the method in dispersion.It would have been better if they had used TEM images to confirm their results.On the same grounds, another method of preparation of highly uniform and nicely dispersed gold NPs deposited on the CNTs was reported by Zhang et al. [58].They reported reduced steps to synthesize the composites and also reduced the reaction time to less than 1 h using ultrasonic treatment.Figure 4 shows a high-magnification TEM image of a welldispersed and homogeneous coverage of the NPs on the nanotubes.This image demonstrates that the gold NPs are uniformly decorated on the walls of the CNTs with NP sizes of 8 ± 3 nm and 20 ± 2 nm, which they report they were able to control.
The reported method appears to be a simpler and more efficient way of depositing the NPs of controllable sizes on the CNTs.The density of the NPs on the CNTs was controlled by changing the precursor salt, and the composites were prepared in less than an hour.

Synthesis of Metal and Metal Oxide Nanoparticles Supported on CNT by Microwave Method
Although the above methods were very successful and useful in coating CNTs outer surfaces with NPs, one important aspect is that simpler methods are desired in some cases, without the use of a long reaction time.In this instance, bulk production of composites will benefit from simple and faster methods, hence, the need for a microwave-assisted method for the synthesis of NPs on the CNTs.An impressive example was reported by Loupy et al. [59], who observed an increase in yield from 2% to 95% under microwave conditions, in the Leuckart reductive amination.These rate and yield enhancements have been suggested by some to be caused by specific, nonthermal microwave effects [59,60].Kim et al. [61] successfully dispersed ruthenium oxide NPs on MWCNTs using the microwave-polyol process.In this process, the CNTs were initially treated with nitric acid to introduce functional groups on the surface of the CNTs and followed by sonication of the treated CNTs in diethylene glycol solvent.Ruthenium salt, RuCl 3 •nH 2 O, and sodium acetate (NaAc) were dispersed in the CNTs and synthesized in a microwave digestion system.The reaction mixture was heated to 200 • C for 2 min with microwave power of 1600 W. They used HRTEM, Raman spectra, and TGA to characterize their materials, which indicated that CNTs were uniformly coated with crystalline and partially hydrous RuO 2 •0.64H 2 O NPs of 2 nm diameter, and the loading amount of ruthenium oxide in the composite could be controlled up to 70 wt.%.
Parts (a) and (b) of Figure 5 respectively show typical HRTEM images of the 70% and 20% ruthenium oxide/CNT nanocomposites showing remarkably uniform and high surface coverage.From these two TEM images, it is observed that the ruthenium oxide is selectively nucleated and uniformly deposited on the surface of the CNTs. Figure 5(b) gives evidence to the size and morphology control of the NPs when using the microwave method.The image (refer to Figure 5(b)) shows that the decrease of the precursor salt concentration still gives a uniform dispersion of the NPs, which means that the amount of the NPs on the CNTs can be controlled, which is not always possible when using a conventional method.Besides the good interaction between the CNTs and the microwaves, one possible explanation for the sidewall coating is that the CNTs were chemically pretreated with acid to functionalize them and remove the metal impurities formed during their manufacture and that introduces defects into the tube walls which act as active sites for binding with NPs.But in this instance, the oxidation process could have been done using the microwave in less time than in a conventional method that took 4 h.CNTs have been found to display strong microwave absorption especially for functionalized CNTs; therefore using microwave could have saved more time.The overall results are good, and it is evident that the microwave method can synthesize composites of CNT supported NPs.
Chuncheng et al. [62] reported using the microwaveassisted method to coat the CNTs with zinc sulphide NPs.For the best anchoring of the ZnS NPs, the CNTs were first oxidized under reflux in concentrated nitric acid.In the first step, Zn(Ac) 2 •2H 2 O and CNTs were added into a glycol solvent and ultrasonically treated to ensure uniform dispersion of the glycol solution.In the second step, NaS•9H 2 O was also dissolved in a glycol solution and then added to the CNT mixture.The new mixture was placed in a microwave oven and operated for 10 min with a power setting of 700 W. The sample was characterized by TEM and XRD.
The TEM image (refer to Figure 6(a)) shows a welldispersed ZnS on the CNTs surface.From this image, it was concluded that the key factor in forming the well-dispersed composites was to ultrasonically treat the composition with a glycol solution.This was validated by the composites with no agglomerations as compared to the ones that were not treated ultrasonically with glycol solution and showed agglomerations.But looking at the TEM image (Figure 6(a)) some agglomerations exist in some parts of the composites but not as much as is reported on the image (image not shown here) where glycol was not used.It is evident that glycol reduces agglomerations; therefore, the agglomerations here may have been caused by the operating conditions of the microwave such as the high power, residence time, or temperature, though the temperature was not mentioned.The XRD pattern (refer to Figure 6(b)) further confirmed the presence of ZnS-coated MWCNTs composites with the mean size diameter calculated by the Debye-Scherrer equation to be 1 nm.The diffraction peaks identified the sample as a mixture of sphalerite crystal ZnS and MWCNTs.The TEM image and XRD spectra confirmed the formation of NPs on the CNTs, and it can be concluded that the synthesis of the CNTs coated with NPs does not merely depend on the precursor salt, but also has a strong correlation with the synthesis conditions and the method used.
Ghosh et al. [63] reported the coating of platinum NPs on carbon-nitride nanotubes prepared by a microwaveassisted method compared to the NaBH 4 chemical reduction method.In this study, N-doped MWCNTs were dispersed in 2-(2-methoxyethoxy)-ethanol solvent under mild sonication for the ease of Pt coating.H 2 PtCl 6 •H 2 O was added to the above solution and stirred for 10 min.The resultant solution was divided into six parts; one part underwent the NaBH 4 route and the other five parts were subjected to microwave irradiation for 30, 50, 70, 90, and 110 s.Finally, the solid was washed and dried.These samples were labelled depending on the MW-irradiation times, for example, MW50, MW110, and so forth.According to the TEM characterization performed on the samples, the platinum NPs were nicely distributed on the CNTs in both methods as presented (parts (a), (b), and (c) of Figure 7).The Pt NPs grown by NaBH 4 treatment (Figure 7(a)) were observed to be small (average diameter 3 nm) and have a low density.However, those grown by microwave irradiation (refer to Figures 7(b) and 7(c)) were found to be larger and the population gradually increased with irradiation time.Microwave irradiation for 50 and 110 s resulted in 10.2 and 19.8 nm Pt particles, respectively.In this paper, the NaBH 4 -mediated chemical reduction process resulted in small size Pt NPs coated on the carbonnitride nanotubes with low density while the microwaveassisted method gave larger NPs with high population density.In the XPS spectrum (not shown here), the peak intensities showed that NaBH 4 treatment led to the incomplete reduction of Pt ions; meanwhile, the microwave irradiation not only offered complete Pt reduction, but also enabled control of the particle size and density as a function of the irradiation time.The complete reduction of the Pt ions shows the uniform heating of the material to completion when using the microwave method and how comparative the method can be in synthesizing CNT composites in fewer steps.It is also useful that the authors have included the reaction mechanisms of both methods in the paper.
A comparative study was done in our earlier work [65] for the synthesis of SnO 2 /CNTs composites.A microwaveassisted method was used to synthesize MWCNT-coated SnO 2 and then compared to the conventional wet impregnation method.In both methods, the CNTs were first treated by oxidation to introduce the oxygen-containing functionalities to which the metal NP precursors can bind: 2 h for the conventional and 5 min for microwave method.On the second step, tin chloride was dissolved in distilled water and hydrochloric acid was added.The acid-treated CNTs were added to the above solution and magnetically stirred for an hour for the conventional method and heated under reflux for 5 min in the microwave reactor.It was found that SnO 2 NPs were distributed on the CNT surface in both conventional wet impregnation and microwave-assisted method, and a better dispersion was found with the microwave method (refer to Figures 7(b) and 7(c)), which was also able to reduce the total reaction time of the synthesis from 4 h to 10 min.
As shown in the TEM image (Figure 8(a)), the SnO 2 NPs were found to be distributed around and inside the CNTs.An average particle size of 3-5 nm was reported, which is in agreement with the XRD and SEM images.The XRD spectra (Figure 8(b)) also confirmed the presence of the SnO 2 in the composites prepared by both methods.A small variation in these conditions can lead to the production of SnO nanoparticles which were not desired in this case.The study illustrates the efficiency of the microwave method to form SnO 2 NPs on CNT surface with good dispersion.
Using a microwave polyol method, Gan et al. [66] synthesized platinum (Pt) NPs on CNTs.In this method, chloroplatinic acid (H 2 PtCl 2 ) and ethylene glycol were used as the platinum precursor and reducing agent, respectively.Sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) was added to the reaction system to prevent the colloids from aggregating into larger particles.The CNTs and SDS were dispersed into EG under ultrasonic treatment for 60 min.Then H 2 PtCl 2 solution was added into the solution under magnetic stirring.The resulting solution was treated at 150 • C for 20 min in a focused single-mode microwave synthesis system.The products were centrifuged and washed with deionized water and absolute ethanol to remove any loose NPs and EG.Finally, the products were dried in vacuum at room temperature.
The authors reported a uniform coverage of the Pt NPs on CNTs that indicated that the functional groups were created throughout the surface of the CNTs (refer to Figure 9).The average NP size was calculated by the Debye-Scherrer formula and found to be 4.6 nm.From these results it was proposed that the successful synthesis of Pt NPs with small size and good dispersion were attributed to the rapid microwave heating.Some degree of agglomerations was observed along the surface of the CNT in the TEM image at low magnification (image not shown here).This result indicates that though the microwave method is efficient in reducing the reaction time, process optimization must be done for each composite system to improve the composite properties.
Wu et al. [67] reported the synthesis of CoNi/MWCNTs nanocomposites using microwave-assisted method.Acidtreated MWCNTs were mixed with Co(Ac) 2 •4H 2 O and Ni(Ac) 2 •4H 2 O in ethylene glycol and stirred for 24 h and then added NaOH to adjust the pH.Several drops of hydrazine hydrate were added as a reducing agent, and the mixture was heated under microwave refluxing system for 2 min and 600 W. In this case, the sizes of the CoNi alloy NPs were controlled through adjusting atomic ratios of the metals to the CNTs.Experimental results have demonstrated that CoNi alloy NPs were attached on the MWCNTs with an average size of 15-48 nm which is consistent with the trend of the crystallite size calculated from the Debye-Scherrer formula.As can be observed from the images (refer to Figure 10), the number of CoNi alloy NPs attached on the CNTs increases with increasing the atomic ratios of metals to CNTs and this also goes for the particle size.The paper demonstrates clearly the controllable size and density population of the NPs when using the method.Changing the parameters of the synthesis allows uniform dispersion to heavily coated CNTs.Like many others [61,62,68], the authors preferred to oxidize the CNTs under reflux and not use the advantage of microwave, but the nanocomposites were prepared in 2 min, which dramatically reduced the total reaction time.
Pt NPs with different sizes supported on CNTs were prepared by microwave rapidly heating the EG solution of platinum salt with different pH [68].For better anchoring the metal NPs, the CNTs were first oxidized by refluxing in concentrated HNO 3 at 413 K for 4 h.The preparation of Pt/CNTs was carried out in EG solutions of H 2 PtCl 6 precursor salts with different pH by microwave heating.The pH value was adjusted by dropping 0.8 moL/L KOH.The mixture was ultrasonically treated to ensure CNTs were uniformly dispersed in EG solution.The beaker was then placed in the centre of a household microwave oven (National, 2450 MHz, 800 W) and heated for 60 s.The product was collected by filter and washed with absolute acetone and deionized water, then dried in a vacuum oven at 373 K for 12 h.TEM examinations (refer to Figure 11) showed that Pt particles become smaller and more uniform when the synthesis pH increased from 3.4 to 9.2.It was found that pH was an important factor that influenced the particle size.Therefore, Pt particles size could be selected by adjusting the solution pH for preparing high-performance Pt/CNTs catalyst for fuel cell application.Electrochemical measurements showed that the Pt/CNTs catalyst prepared from the synthesis  solution (pH 7.4) exhibited better performance for methanol electrooxidization than other samples.
The paper highlights the important role of pH of the reaction medium on the particle size along the CNTs.The authors suggest that, in addition to pH and good microwave absorption of reactants, other operating parameters are critical in improving the material properties.
Nanostructured Mo 2 C/CNTs composites have been synthesized by using a methodology of microwave-assisted thermolytic molecular precursor with Mo(CO) 6 as single source precursor.Typically, CNTs and molybdenum hexacarbonyl were put in an agate mortar and mixed for 15 min.The completely homogeneous precursor mixture was put in a quartztube reactor with an inner diameter of about 10 mm and fluidized with a flow rate of 30 mL/min argon for 2 h at room temperature to remove oxygen in the reactor and keep the reaction under the inert atmosphere.Next, the reactor was placed in a domestic microwave oven operating at 2.45 GHz with a power of 800 W. Finally, the resulting products were cooled to room temperature under argon.The microwave irradiation time varied from 1 to 15 min to investigate the formation mechanism.TEM images (Figure 12) show the well-distributed nanostructured Mo 2 C particles on the outer surface of CNTs and no agglomerations were observed.The mean size of Mo 2 C particles was reported to be about 5 nm, which was in good agreement with the value from XRD.The reported results were compared with the results found by Liang et al. [69] who used the carbothermal hydrogen reduction method, in which the particle size of β-Mo 2 C also increased with increasing Mo loading.This shows and confirms the efficiency of the microwave-assisted method to get results comparable to other methods but in a faster and more economical way [70].

Applications of Metal Oxides Nanoparticle-CNT Composites
The possible applications of CNTs range from electronics, sensors, water purification, energy-storage devices, to functional fillers in composites.These have attracted both industrial and academic interest.Therefore, it is important that some of the basic knowledge is transferred to industry so that real and novel technologies appear commercially.Some of the applications are listed in the following (refer to Table 2 for summary).

Hydrogen Storage.
In energy storage applications, materials with hydrogen storage capacity are very attractive.
CNTs have been explored for many years for liquid and gas storage or gas filtration applications due to their cylindrical geometry and their nanoscale dimensions [71,72].Dillon et al. [73] were the first to propose that CNTs can be used as a hydrogen storage medium due to their lightweight and high hydrogen storage capacity.Because of the weak van der Waals interaction between CNTs and hydrogen molecules, the pure CNTs cannot store the required amount of hydrogen, but when functionalized with metal atoms, they are the most efficient hydrogen storage medium.Dillon et al. [73] studied the hydrogen adsorption properties of as-prepared soot containing 0.1-0.2wt.% SWCNTs and they estimated a hydrogen storage capacity of 5-10 wt.% for pure SWCNTs.Park and Lee [74] showed that the hydrogen storage capacity of Pt/MWCNTs at 298 K and 100 bar is higher than that of MWCNTs.From the experimental results, it was found that Pt particles were homogeneously distributed on the MWCNTs surfaces.The amount of hydrogen storage capacity increased in proportion to the Pt content, with Pt-5/MWCNTs (3.72 wt.%) exhibiting the largest hydrogen storage capacity.The superior amount of hydrogen storage was linked to an increase in the number of active sites and the optimum-controlled micropore volume for hydrogen adsorption due to the well-dispersed Pt particles.Therefore, it can be concluded that Pt particles play an important role in hydrogen storage characteristics due to the hydrogen Journal of Nanomaterials spillover effect [74].Yang et al. [75] reported the electrochemical hydrogen storage properties of Ni NP-coated SWCNT electrodes.The characteristic properties of the SWCNT samples coated with 4-12 wt.% Ni NPs were examined.According to the electrochemical test results, the highest electrochemical discharge capacity of 1404 mAh/g was obtained for the SWCNT electrode coated with 8 wt.% Ni NPs, which corresponded to 5.27 wt.% hydrogen storage.This enhancement of electrochemical hydrogen storage capacity was ascribed to the fact that the Ni NPs act as a redox site, thus leading to an improved electrochemical hydrogen storage capacity.The results indicated that the SWCNTs coated with Ni NPs are a potential material for hydrogen storage [75].

Energy Storage and Related
Applications.Xu et al. [76] prepared MWCNTs filled and coated with SnO 2 NPs using a simple one-step chemical solution method at 50 Though the capacity retained only 20% of the first cycle, it was still larger than the theoretical capacity of graphite (372 mAh/g).Therefore, the results demonstrated that they had a better cycling performance at large discharge/charge current densities [76].
Another SnO 2 coated on CNTs study was reported by Wang et al. [77] who used a novel thioglycolic acid assisted one-step wet chemical method.The coatings were characterized by XRD and TEM.The composites showed a good lithium intercalation/deintercalation performance when used as anode materials for lithium-ion batteries.Their high charge capacities and durability against decay are ascribed to the good dispersion of SnO 2 on MWCNTs and small particle size, which is a benefit of using SnO 2, and to the release of the stress caused by the drastic volume variation during the lithium intercalation/deintercalation process [77].Zhao et al. [78] investigated Pt-Sn NPs on MWCNTs and explored their use as an anode catalyst for a direct ethanol fuel cell, which may find use as a potential mobile power source.They compared the functionalization of the CNTs with that of carbon black and observed a better performance in the former, which they attributed to the structural difference of CNTs over carbon black, higher electric properties, and lower organic impurities of CNTs as compared to their carbon black sample [78].Matsumoto et al. [82] reported that 12 wt.%Pt deposited onto CNTs results in 10% higher voltages than 29 wt.%Pt deposited on carbon black; this ultimately reduces the Pt wastage by 60% in polymer-electrolyte fuel cells.The higher performance of the Pt-decorated CNTs was attributed to (i) well-dispersed platinum NPs on the CNTs allowing more triple-phase boundaries, (ii) high electric conductivity, and (iii) networks and interiors of the CNTs, which might consist of spaces for gas diffusion.Sakthivel et al. [83] reported the deposition of platinum electrocatalysts on MWCNTs with high loading prepared using a microwaveassisted polyol reduction method and employed for direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs).Single cell DMFC measurements were performed in a membrane-electrode assembly (MEA) with 5 cm 2 active area and very low catalyst loading (0.25 mg•cm −2 of noble metal on both anode and cathode).The DMFC performance of the surfactant stabilized cathode catalyst obtained by the new method described here revealed that the power density was three times higher than for a commercial catalyst used for comparison and two times higher than for an unstabilized CNT-supported catalyst.Much higher power densities were observed for the two samples with CNT as support compared with the Vulcan carbonsupported catalyst.The maximum power density of the DMFC with the surfactant stabilized Pt/CNT catalyst was 74 mWcm −2 , while only 30 mWcm −2 could be achieved with the commercial catalyst [83].Kim et al. [61] investigated the dispersion of ruthenium oxide NPs on MWCNTs  [94], Au [95], Pt-catalyzed hydrogen peroxide oxidation [96], gold-thiol monocapped NPs [10], and Pd, Pt, Au, and Ag for environmental catalysis [23].Dechakiatkrai et al. [90] prepared and characterized TiO 2 /SWCNT composites for photocatalytic applications.The photocatalytic activity of TiO 2 and the TiO 2 /SWCNT composite was investigated using the photooxidation of methanol in sulphuric acid as supporting electrolyte.The results indicated that the TiO 2 /SWCNTs composite enhances the photocatalytic activity compared to TiO 2 alone.Electrochemical studies of the TiO 2 /SWCNT composite were also carried out in various supporting electrolytes, and the presence of SWCNTs in the TiO 2 film was found to be able to photocatalyze the oxidation of methanol, 10 times higher than a pure TiO 2 electrode.This is an attractive way for further application in the field of photocatalytic decomposition of organic compounds in aqueous media under UV irradiation and a potential material for applications involving photocatalyzed fuel cells [90].

Sensors.
CNTs have been effective as sensing elements utilizing their electrical, electrochemical, and optical properties.Detecting a low concentration of toxic gas is important for environmental purposes and chemical safety.CNTs have been highlighted as promising gas-sensing elements due to the 1-dimensional electronic structure with all the atoms residing only on the surface.CNTs have advantages over conventional metal-oxide-based sensors in terms of power consumption, sensitivity, miniaturization, and reliable mass production [97].Espinosa et al. [84] have shown that the addition of a small quantity of O 2 -functionalized MWCNTs to metal oxides can significantly improve the detection capability of metal oxide-based sensors at low operating temperatures.In particular, microsensors based on SnO 2 / MWCNTs hybrid films operated at room temperature showed the higher sensitivity towards NO 2 in the ppb range among the different materials studied.Additionally, the sensors showed a total recovery of their baseline resistance and reasonable response and recovery times.The results suggested that there is an optimum amount of CNTs to be added to each particular metal oxide in order to enhance responsiveness [84].Liu et al. [85] reported the gas sensing properties of MWCNTs coated with SnO 2 .It was found that the sensor exhibited good sensing responses to liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) and ethanol gas (C 2 H 5 OH).Furthermore, the gas sensor responses increased linearly with the increment of the gas concentrations of LPG and ethanol and the sensor exhibits a fast response and a good recovery.The fabrication of hydrogen gas sensors based on undoped and 1 wt.%MWCNT-doped tungsten oxide (WO 3 ) thin films by means of the powder mixing and electron beam (E-beam) evaporation technique were reported by Kerdcharoen et al. [97].Hydrogen sensing properties of the thin films have been investigated at different operating temperatures and gas concentrations ranging from 100 ppm to 50,000 ppm.The results indicated that the MWCNT-doped WO 3 thin film exhibits high sensitivity and selectivity to hydrogen.Thus, MWCNT doping based on E-beam coevaporation was shown to be an effective means of preparing hydrogen gas sensors with enhanced sensing and reduced operating temperatures.At any operating temperature, the sensor response of the MWCNT-doped WO 3 thin film is higher than that of the undoped WO 3 thin film.Specifically, at the optimum operating temperature (350 • C), MWCNT-doped WO 3 thin film yields a 26.9% higher response than the undoped one.This should prove to be useful for developing high-performance H 2 gas sensors [86].Lu et al. [87] have immobilized palladium NPs on SWCNTs and applied this in the detection of methane.The methodology showed advantages over conventional catalytic beads and metal oxide sensors with a tenfold increase in sensitivity and reduced power consumption by a factor of 100.Both Shi et al. [88] and Qiaocui et al. [89] used CNT-supported Pt NPs to fabricate a cholesterol biosensor involving the immobilization of the Pt-modified CNTs and the cholesterase enzyme in a solgel matrix on an electrode.The detection of cholesterol occurred indirectly using the hydrogen peroxide produced by the action of the enzyme and allowed the sensor to have a low detection limit (1.4 mm) over a good linear range (4-100 mm).The Pt-CNTs also limited the effect of interferents compared to bulk materials or CNTs alone [88].Also of note is the Pt-CNT-supported catalysis of both hydrogen peroxide and cysteine for the bioanalytical sensing of both species [90].

Conclusions
In this paper, the challenges of the preparation of metal and metal-oxide-nanoparticle-coated CNTs have been addressed using the microwave-assisted method.The quality and rapid formation of uniform small-sized nanomaterials under microwave conditions have demonstrated to be an effective and alternative way of synthesizing nanoparticle-coated CNTs.As summarized here, the method has shown that it can be used for any metal oxide and CNTs, and by varying the deposition material and deposition time, one can control the size and distribution of metal nanoparticles on CNTs surfaces.The published results have shown that microwave synthesis is a user-friendly method rarely damaging the materials.As the method is being used for various reasons (end-product), different routes and strategies should be applied depending on the final product to be achieved.The existence of a specific microwave effect is still a debate.

Figure 2 :
Figure 2: TEM image of gold nanoparticles self-assembled on the surface of s-MWCNTs through PHT [56].

Figure 4 :
Figure4: TEM image of synthesized MWCNT/Au nanocomposites with higher magnification (the black dot in the centre of the images is an imaging artifact)[58].

Figure 8 :
Figure 8: (a) HRTEM image of SnO 2 /CNT composite prepared by microwave (the inset shows a corresponding low-magnification image).(b) XRD patterns of pure CNTs and SnO 2 /CNT composite samples prepared by conventional and microwave wet impregnation methods [65].

Figure 12 :
Figure 12: TEM images of the Mo 2 C/CNTs with the 16.7 wt% Mo calculated loading at two different magnifications [70].

Table 1 :
Results from the Arrhenius plots in Figure1.

Table 2 :
[81,92,93] CNT-supported metal/oxide applications.Characterization of the samples confirmed the uniform coating with crystalline and partially hydrous RuO 2 •0.64H 2 O NPs of 2 nm diameter and the loading amount of ruthenium oxide in the composite could be controlled up to 70 wt.%.The specific capacitance was 450 Fg −1 of ruthenium oxide/CNT composite electrode with 70 wt.%rutheniumoxideat the potential scan rate of 10 mVs −1 , and it decreased to 362 Fg −1 by 18% at 500 mVs −1 .Ye et al.[81,92,93]also demonstrated in their work on the deposition of Pd NPs on MWCNTs in supercritical CO 2 that the Pd-MWCNTs composites were excellent catalysts for the hydrogenation of olefins, including the conversion of stilbene into 1,2-diphenylethane, with conversions of 96% after 10 min exposure.Other metal NPs used for catalysis include Ru-Sn and Ru-Pt alloys for heterogeneous catalysis [79]Catalysis.Selective hydrogenation catalysts are crucial in the petrochemical and fine chemical industries for the synthesis of a wide variety of chemicals[80].Zhang et al.[79]found that CNTs coated with Co NPs were catalytic for the formulation of 1-octene with a high activity and excellent region selectivity.