Study the Effects of Carbon Nanotubes and Graphene Oxide Combinations on the Mechanical Properties and Flame Retardance of Epoxy Nanocomposites

Carbon-based fillers have attracted a lot of interest in polymer composites because of their ability to alter beneficial properties at low filler concentrations, good surface bonding with polymers, availability in different forms, etc. Carbon-based materials (such as fullerene, CNTs, graphene, and graphite) have been studied as fillers with enhanced fire resistance to epoxy resins. In order to reduce the flammability and improve the thermal stability of epoxy resin-based nanocomposite materials, which can be achieved by a simultaneous combination of graphene oxide and multiwall carbon nanotubes, the graphite oxide (GO) epoxy nanomaterial was developed by 1% wt.% GO combined with 0.02 wand 0.04wt.% MWCNT. The homogeneous dispersion of GO and MWCNTs in epoxy resins is supported by ultrasonic vibrations. The results showed that when nanocomposite materials were present at the same time MWCNTs and GO, their mechanical properties and fire resistance were significantly improved. Nanomaterials are characterized by FT-IR spectroscopy and SEM imaging, mechanical strength, and flame retardant properties (LOI, UL94).


Introduction
Graphene oxide (GO) composites are carbon-based materials with excellent performance and low cost. They are applicable in a wide range of civil, mechanical, and aerospace applications. GO material is used in polymer mixture systems as filler to improve mechanical properties of polymer materials. Graphene oxide significantly enhances the durability of composites while it clearly does not decrease the strength of composites [1]. When 0.5 percent by mass or 1.5 percent by mass is added, the mechanical properties of epoxy composite materials improve. GO/epoxy composites will perform very well in applications in the electronics, aerospace, and automotive industries [2,3]. In addition, when a small fraction of graphene oxide (GO) was incorporated into epoxy resin (EP), the results showed that GO increased fire resistance, with a limited oxygen index of 24.5%, and resistance tests fire to other standards. The bar-rier effects of GO and the limited mobility of polymer chains are important factors in increasing thermal stability and reducing dangerous carbon monoxide generation during combustion [4]. Guo et al. were also investigated when adding 2 wt.% GO to epoxy resin, resulting in a 50% and 19.6% increase in the learning mode and regeneration module of GO/ER material synthesis [5]. In order to improve the synergistic effect of GO/MWCNTs in epoxy resin, a number of research projects have been conducted to modify the surface of MWCNTs to increase compatibility. Fabricated materials show a marked improvement in mechanical properties [6,7]. Ultrasound is an appropriate method to disperse GO/MWCNTs into epoxy resins, studies have shown that when adding 0.3 or 0.5 wt.% GO, and the mechanical properties of nanocomposites are significantly enhanced by the addition of GO [8,9]. Bahrami et al. fabricated nanocomposite specimens with 0.02, 0.04, 0.06, 0.08, and 0.1 wt.% MWCNTs combined with 1% mass RGO (oxidized GO). The results showed that the mechanical properties could be significantly changed by adding two different nanoparticles simultaneously [10]. Liu et al. used acetone as a solvent to disperse GO/MWCNTs into epoxy. Carbon nanotubes were first dispersed in a solution of acetone, then the epoxy resin is dissolved in the acetone solution, and the filler is evenly dispersed in epoxy resin. Mechanical properties, thermal properties, and electrical conductivity properties of synthetic materials preparation by this method have greatly improved [11]. The graphite oxide (GO) polymer nanomaterial was developed at 1, 5, and 10% by weight of GO using polycarbonate (PC), acrylonitrile butadiene styrene, and high impact polystyrene for evaluation of fire resistance. This work reveals that GO shows some promise for the fabrication of polymer nanocomposites in which reduced flammability is desired [12]. The phosphaphenanthrene double structure has been successfully grafted onto the surface of graphene oxide (GO), called functionalized graphene oxide (FGO). The introduction of FGO improved poor interface compatibility between the graphene and epoxy matrices. When the FGO content is 3% by weight, the amount of oxygen is limited the index value reached 30.4% [13]. Some other works, without modification of GO or MWCNTs, were applied directly to the epoxy resin substrate. Research results indicate that GO is one of the potential flame retardant additives [14,15]. Epoxy nanocomposites are fabricated with different GO loads by mixing technical solutions. Several other programs have also demonstrated that the incorporation of a small amount of GO into the epoxy matrix significantly enhances the mechanical properties of epoxy [16][17][18][19]. In summary, carbon and its household materials (graphite, MWCNTs, etc.) are potential flame retardant reinforcement in polymer composites, and these reinforcements are attractive alternatives to conventional flame retardants. Carbon-based fillers actively reduce the flammability of polymer composites by (1) protective coal formation layer and (2) absorb free radicals [20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27]. In this work, the combination of MWCNTs and GO affecting the mechanical properties and flame retardation was studied using the high-speed mechanical stirring method combined with the ultrasonic vibration method.

Materials.
Epoxy resin with the trade name epoxy Epikote 240 is supplied from Shell Chemicals (USA). The epoxy group content is 24.6%, and the viscosity is 0.7-1.1 Pa.s (25 degrees Celsius). This epoxy resin was chosen because of its low viscosity, making it suitable for dispersing nanoadmixtures. The curing agent for epoxy resin used was diethylene triamine (DETA), supplied by Sigma-Aldrich with MW: 103 g.mol -1 and specific gravity at 25°C: 0.95 g/cm 3 . Multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) were provided by Showa Denko Japan Co., with a diameter of 40 to 45 nanometers and a length of about 3 μm. Graphene oxide is a gray-brown solid, with a C:O ratio of 2:1 to 2:9, well dispersed in water and many other solvents. GO was synthesized according to Hummers' improved method, and then GO was dispersed in water at a concentration of 5 mg/mL.

Results and Discussion
3.1. Mechanical Properties. Figure 1 shows the mechanical properties of epoxy resin-based composite materials, 1 wt.% GO combined with 0.02 wt.% and 0.04 wt.% MWCNTs, respectively. To study the effect of the combination of GO and MWCNTs on the material's mechanical properties, we compared and discussed materials: neat epoxy, EP-GO, EP-MWCNTs, and EP-GO-MWCNTs. From Figure 1, it is confirmed that GO and MWCNTs can enhance the mechanical properties of nanocomposites based on epoxy resins. From Figure 1, it is confirmed that GO [28]. Good interface bonding facilitates the efficiency of force transfer resulting in increased material resistance [29]. Thus, the aforementioned properties of hybrid nanocomposites with a suitable filler ratio have higher improvements than those made in the individual mode [30]. Hybrid nanocomposites with total content of 1% by weight GO and 0.04% by weight of MWCNTs showed the best results in the study.

Journal of Nanomaterials
When the amount was added to 1 wt. % GO, the oxygen index of the material reached 24.1%. When combining (hybrid between GO and MWCNTs) 1 wt. % with 0.02 wt. % MWCNTs, the oxygen index is 29.3% and when MWCNTs increase to 0.04 wt. %, the oxygen index is 30.4%. It was found that GO could effectively improve the flame retardant performance of epoxy composite materials, and the ability increased further with MWCNTs included.
The UL-94 tests (Table 1) showed material on the basis of combining 1 wt.% GO with 0.02 wt.%, 0.04 wt.% MWCNTs reached at V1, and no minor phenomena drop after the flame is extinguished. With the assessment results of LOI index, UL-94 V, GO is one of the highly effective green flame retardants when combined with nanoadditive MWCNTs. When the GO content was 1% by weight combined with 0.04% by weight of MWCNT, the limiting oxygen index value reached 30.4%. The effectiveness of increased fire resistance and smoke suppression is mainly due to the formation of the physical barrier and the compressibility of the developed GO/MWCNT composite coal layers, which act as an effective barrier layer. The increased fire resistance and thermal stability of the coal layers stems from the effect of the synergistic inclusion between GO and MWCNT.
GO and MWCNts work together to form an excellent carbon layer with high strength and thermal stability. It prevents heat penetration and volatile metamorphic products and further slows down the rate of heat release, thus protecting the underlying matrix from fire during combustion [13].
The significant increase in flame retardants is due to the formation of excellent coal layers with high strength and thermal stability of GO and MWCNTs. The developed coal layers can slow heat penetration and volatile decomposing materials during combustion, thereby limiting ignition and protecting the underlying polymer from flames. Such a result leads to the formation of a denser carbon layer. The reduced EP flammability is related to the development of coal formation and the creation of GO's "winding line" and the effect of the barrier during ignition. This work provides a clean and simple solution for the production of active graphene-based flame retardants to enhance EP resin flame retardants compared to halogenated or nonhalogen composites that release acidic gases at high temperatures or deteriorate the mechanical properties of composites. One of the important novelties achieved in this research is the discovery of flame retardants that retain the mechanical properties of the composite matrix or do not release toxic gases at high temperatures [31].   Journal of Nanomaterials The flame retardant effect between MWCNTs and GO promotes the formation of dense additional layers of coal and improves the thermal oxidation resistance of graphene and MWCNTs. A layer of highly thermally stable coal, consisting of graphene sheets combined with MWCNTs nanoparticle, slows heat penetration and release of volatile metamorphic products [32].
3.3. Morphology. SEM has been used in this study to investigate the morphology of EP-based composites: EP-GO and EP-GO-MWCNTS. Figure 3 shows the fracture surface morphology of the material GO/epoxy resin composite material. Figure 3 shows that the graphene oxide has dispersed into layers and therefore, the substrate is compatible with the epoxy-GO interface. When the system is loaded, GO evenly dispersed within the composite material can bear the load and prevent and stop developing cracks. In the form of fracture, impact and rough fracture surface, and damaged surface, more energy consumption is greater. It proves that the appearance of GO in the material has a great impact on the formation of cracks and the restriction of defects. Materials can extend their resistance to factors such as mechanical forces. Thus, we can see that the addition of structure GO to EP has reduced the number of cracks of the material under the impact (see SEM image, Figure 3). Figure 4 shows that MWCNTs are well dispersed in the epoxy matrix. These SEM images clearly illustrate that the MWCNT particles were well dispersed, and there was no evidence of MWCNT aggregation. These nanotubes also appear to be encapsulated with a polymer epoxy matrix. On the other hand, graphene oxide sheets can be seen in Figure 4 dispersed in the epoxy matrix according to layers. The SEM image also showed the fracture surface of the material revealing that the GO scale did not aggregate into a dense region. The GO fragments, several micrometers in size, were found protruding from the polymer matrix and indicated by the white arrows. The presence of nanofillers (MWCNTs) and GO in the epoxy resin substrate not only improved the mechanical properties but also changed the fracture pattern of the nanocomposites. This can be explained by SEM imaging of the fracture surfaces for pure epoxy and nanomaterials as illustrated in Figure 5. The fracture surface of pure epoxy is shown in Figure 5(c), which has a uniform pattern characterized by smooth and parallel lines exposing cracks in the fracture surface and a brittle fracture mechanism [16,33]. This shows that during the load, cracks develop without obstacles along their direction. As Figures 5(a) and 5(b) shows, the disorder appears more at the fracture surface due to the presence of GO. This is thought to be due to crack development due to the properties of the epoxy resin brittle. Because epoxy resin has a brittle weakness, when the force exerts the epoxy monolithic areas, cracks will appear.
When the crack develops and spreads met with GO and nanoparticles (MWCNTs) (Figure 5(d)), the crack changes its trajectory, and the direction is skewed. Consequently, new lines, new fracture surfaces, and new branch cracks are created on the fracture surface. The fracture surface in this case has irregular faces as illustrated in Figure 5. Obviously, the creation of new branching and fracture surfaces due to the containment of GO and of MWCNTs ( Figure 5(d)) requires additional energy to be able to model the fracture or pull prolongs the application of the force. The   Journal of Nanomaterials uniform distribution of fracture patterns observed in the fracture surface shown in Figure 5 is evidence of the uniform dispersion of the filler in the epoxy resin substrate [16,33]. The improvements are due to the existence of GO nanosheets and their contribution to stiffness enhancement, acting as a barrier to prevent crack growth and deflecting them. As shown, the smooth fracture surface of pure epoxy is transformed into a rough surface. This occurs due to the existence of GO sheets as reinforcing material in epoxy as well as their contribution to hardness enhancement, acting as an obstacle to prevent crack growth [34][35][36][37].
3.4. Results of Infrared Spectroscopy (IR) Measurement. Figure 6 shows the infrared (IR) spectrum of epoxy resin samples with absorption frequencies characteristic for covalent oscillation of the group: OH and CH of the CH 2 group and of the aromatic ring, C = C of the ring aromatic, CO-in ether, and CO-in the oxirane ring are 3507.

Conclusions
The results of this study showed that the combination of 1 wt.% GO and 0.02 wt.% or 0.04 wt.% MWCNTs in the fabrication of epoxy composite materials improved mechanical properties and flame retardation. Obviously, the combination of GO and MWCNTs at the appropriate percentage of mass has brought into play an effective synergy in the fabrication of composite materials with high mechanical properties and good flame retardant properties. This research result opens up many directions for work and study in the future. In addition, SEM showed that GO and MWCNTs were well dispersed throughout the material. This work reveals that GO shows some promise for the fabrication of polymer nanomaterials in which reduced flammability is desired, especially when combined with the nanoadditive MWCNTs.

Data Availability
The experimental data used to support the findings of this study are included within the article.

Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest regarding the publication of this paper.