Insights into the Synergistic Effect of Fungi and Bacteria for Reactive Red Decolorization

Bacterial contamination is a prevalent problem in fungal dye wastewater decolorization that prevents the development of this technology in practical engineering. New insight into the relationship between fungi and bacteria is given in terms of settleability, bioadsorption, and biodegradation, which all confirm their synergistic effect. Sterilization is implied to be not the only mechanism for fungi decolorization.When the fungi and bacteria isolated from the activated sludge were cocultured, fungi removedmore than 70% of the reactive red through sole bioadsorption in 5min and enhanced the settleability of the bacteria group from 7.7 to 18.4 in the aggregation index. Subsequently, the bacteria played a more significant role in dye biodegradation according to the ultravioletvisible spectrum analysis. They further enhanced the decolorization efficiency to over 80% when cocultured with fungi. Therefore, the advanced bioadsorption and settleability of fungi, combined with the good dye biodegradation ability of bacteria, results in the synergistic effect of the coculture microorganisms.


Introduction
Effluents from textile industries that contain dyes are highly colored and visually identifiable [1].The complex aromatic structure of dyes is resistant to light, biological activity, ozone, and other degrading environmental conditions [2].Fungi have attracted much attention because of their ability to decolorize dyes compared to simple single cell organisms as their increased cell-to-surface ratio provides a greater physical and enzymatic contact condition [3].They produce ligninmodifying enzymes, such as laccase, manganese peroxidase, and lignin peroxidase, to tolerate the toxicity of dyes and mineralize them [4].
Bacterial contamination is a prevalent problem in fungal dye wastewater decolorization.Critical operational and environmental conditions, including temperature, pH, hydraulic residence time, and sludge residence time [5], are usually controlled to maintain the dominance of fungal biomass [6].Fulfilling the above control conditions is extremely expensive and unrealistic for practical wastewater treatment.
The present work gives new insight into the synergistic relationship between fungi and bacteria.Fungi and bacteria were cultured together in flasks containing typical reactive dye, and no extra operational and environmental conditions that favor the dominance of fungi were set during the whole experiment.The roles of fungi and bacteria in bioadsorption, biodegradation, total biomass concentration, and settleability were evaluated, and they were significant to the decolorization efficiency of industrial wastewater plant operation.The synergistic effect of fungi and bacteria enhanced their decolorization and settleability, and it gives a novel view on using fungi for textile wastewater treatment.Preventing bacterial contamination or controlling fungi dominance is not the best way to treat textile wastewater.

Medium.
Basal salts medium (BSM) with additional 120 mg/L of reactive red X-3B (BSM-dye medium) was used.The composition of the BSM media was as described by Juhasz et al. [7].The reactive red X-3B was purchased from the Dye Synthesis Laboratory of China.The pH of the medium was adjusted to 7.0, and the temperature was set to 25 ∘ C during cultivation.

Enrichment, Isolation, and Identification.
A 100 mL portion of activated sludge sampled from a bioreactor in Jilin 2 Journal of Spectroscopy University was shaken overnight in 100 mL of Ringer's solution (Dingguo, China) at 30 ∘ C and 110 rpm in an incubation shaker.BSM (95 mL) containing 120 mg/L red reactive X-3B was inoculated with 5 mL of the supernatant.When the growth of the microorganisms was observed, enrichment was continued by serially subculturing the sample several times in the same medium using a 10% inoculum from the previous culture.
Initial attempts to separate the resulting fungal-bacterial consortium involved subculturing it into the fresh BSM medium containing 0.1 g/L cycloheximide.The absence of fungi was confirmed by plating the subculture onto PDA after each transfer.The resulting bacterial consortium is referred to as the bacteria group hereinafter.To isolate the fungi, the enriched culture was diluted 10-fold, and 0.1 mL of the samples was spread onto PDA plates supplemented with 0.06 g/L penicillin G and 0.1 g/L streptomycin sulfate.Fungal colonies were selected and replated on the same medium until pure colonies were obtained.The pure colonies were subcultivated on PDA and were identified.A 500 L portion of each colony spore suspension (with 0.2 OD 600 ) was inoculated into the BSM-dye medium for the subsequent subculturing.This fungal consortium is referred to as the fungi group hereinafter.
The bacterial and fungal samples were obtained through centrifugation (8000 rpm) and washed twice with PBS buffer.Then, DNA extraction, polymerase chain reaction amplification, and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) analysis of the bacteria/fungi group were consigned to a professional biological engineering company (Sangon Company, Shanghai, China).

Analysis.
Absorbance measurements of the original dye and the decolorized dye by spectrophotometer were performed at 538 nm to estimate biodegradation occurrence using an ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) spectrophotometer.Bioadsorption was evaluated using the decolorization efficiencies of the biomass after inactivation by supplementing 0.7 mg/L HgSO 4 in the BSM-dye medium.The decolorization efficiency of the X-3B was calculated by (1 − / 0 ) × 100%, where  0 and  represent the initial and the residual concentrations of X-3B, respectively.
The biomass suspension was collected, and the aggregation index was measured by monitoring the changes in absorbance at 600 nm using a UV-vis spectrophotometer.The aggregation index (I%) was calculated using [8] (%) = ((OD 0 −OD 30 )/OD 0 )×100%, where OD 0 and OD 30 represent the initial absorbance and the absorbance after 30 min of deposition, respectively.
All experiments were performed in duplicate, and the average values were used in the calculations.

Isolation and Identification.
Fungi and bacteria groups were obtained after separation.Two fungi were isolated from the fungi group.The 18S rRNA sequences revealed that the sequences were 99% homologous to those of Geotrichum Figure 1: UV-vis spectra of the original reactive red X-3B and the residuals after culturing the bacteria and fungi groups in the BSMdye medium for 3 days, respectively; X-3B adsorption efficiencies of bacteria and fungi groups, respectively (inset).candidum (Genbank accession number: KJ543497) and Candida pseudolambica (Genbank accession number: KJ543498), respectively.Geotrichum candidum was filamentous under the microscope (Olympus, BX40, Japan) with a Pro-Micro Scan system and the size of the granules was determined using the Scopephoto software.For bacteria identification, the sequences of the 15 dominant bands that appeared in the DGGE profiles were identified and compared with those available in the GenBank library.The majority of the bacterial 16S rDNA sequences were grouped with the members of proteobacteria (9 in total), six of which were in the  subdivision.The other bacterial species in the bacteria group were Sphingobacteriia, Flavobacteriia, Bacteroidia, Nitrospirales, and Phycisphaerae.

Decolorization Mechanisms of the Two Groups.
The reactive red X-3B decolorization mechanisms of the fungi group and bacteria group were attributed to both bioadsorption and biodegradation functions, as shown in Figure 1.However, the contributions of bioadsorption and biodegradation in the X-3B decolorization for the microbial groups were quite different.Bioadsorption, instead of biodegradation, plays a more significant role in fungi group decolorization as it achieved more than 70% decolorization in 5 min.Such great adsorption capability of fungi is due to their wide range of binding sites for azo dyes [9], that is, amino, carboxyl, phosphate, and hydroxyl functional groups located on the surface of fungi [10].Using fungi as adsorbing agents has received much attention [11].However, the removal efficiency of X-3B reached only 44% when absorption achieved equilibrium at 15 min.
The bacteria group seemed to have complementary advantages over fungi group in terms of bioadsorption and biodegradation.The living bacteria group had stronger  biodegradation ability than that of the fungi group (Figure 1).Reactive red X-3B has a maximum absorption peak at 538 nm, and this peak almost disappeared after the bacteria group biodegradation.The new products are found at wavelengths of 210 nm and 248 nm.The chromogenic group of X-3B was broken, and it generated other chromogenic groups.The biodegradation ability of fungus was not as strong as that of bacteria because the peak at the wavelength of 538 nm was still apparent.The products of the fungus group were different from those of the bacteria group, as confirmed by the shifting of the maximum absorption wavelength from 538 nm to 220 nm and 270 nm.
In brief, both bioadsorption and biodegradation decolorized reactive red X-3B for both the bacteria group and the fungi group.Fungi showed a much better bioadsorption capability and reached equilibrium in 5 min, whereas the bacteria group had a more radical biodegradation for decolorization.

Settleability Enhancement of the Fungus Group.
The aggregation index was used to evaluate the aggregation capability of the microorganisms.At the stationary phase of the microbial groups (the 6th day of culture), the bacteria group had the poorest self-aggregation ability, with an aggregation index of 7.7.The aggregation index of the fungi group was 68.5, with a very clear boundary between the settled biomass and the supernatant (see Figure 2).Thus, the settleability of the mixed group reached an acceptable degree, with an aggregation index of 18.4.The biomass concentrations of these microbial groups were close.This finding indicates that the aggregation indexes of the groups are comparable and that the competition between bacteria and fungus in the cocultured group does not affect the total biomass.As expected, the fungus enhanced the settleability in the synergistic fungibacteria cocultured group and had no significant influence on the total biomass production.

Decolorization Enhancement of the Bacteria Group.
The reactive red X-3B decolorization efficiencies with different kinds of nutrient (i.e., (NH 4 ) 2 SO 4 , KH 2 PO 4 , and K 2 HPO 4 ) at different levels were determined to identify the decolorization abilities of the individuals and the cocultured bacteria and fungi group (see Figure 3).The influence of nutrient feed levels on decolorization seemed to be generally consistent for the three groups, and the decolorization efficiencies tended to be higher when the nutrient supplications were more abundant.The efficiencies of the three groups with different kinds of nutrient at the same level were very close, and the bacteria group seemed to have a positive effect on the decolorization ability of the cocultured group because of its advanced biodegradation performance (see the UV-vis spectra results in Figure 1).

Discussion
Traditionally, bacterial proliferation is a problem in nonaseptic fungal decolorization.Bacteria compete with fungi for substrates, and they also deteriorate the dewatering ability [6].An insight into the synergistic relationship between the fungi group and the bacteria group for azo dye wastewater treatment was given without artificial modification of any operational, environmental, and physiological conditions.These synergistic effects were expressed as both the enhanced settleability of the fungi group and the enhanced biodegradation ability of the bacteria group when the two groups were cocultured.The former is the main contributor to the separation of biomass and effluent, and the latter plays a more important role in the improvement of the quality of the effluent (Figure 4).The fungus in the cocultured group adsorbed the azo dye in several minutes.This adsorption is attributed to the many binding functional groups in their cell walls, such as amino, carboxyl, thiol, and phosphate [2].Then, the azo molecule dye closed around the fungal and bacterial cells that were wrapped together.The dye was easier to transfer into their cells for further biodegradation.
The enzyme-mediated activity of fungi enabled the treatment of wastewater containing hazardous or xenobiotic organic pollutants [12].Thus, the toxicity of the dye dramatically decreased when the bacteria, which presented a much greater growth speed, were added [13].
As discussed above, the synergistic effect of the fungi group and the bacteria group shows that they promoted their own bioaccumulation, bioadsorption, and biodegradation.The relationship between the fungi group and the bacteria group is implied to be not limited to completion, but it could also be a synergistic effect.Therefore, sterilization is not the only way to use fungi for wastewater treatment.The bacteria and fungi groups used in this work were isolated from the same source.The synergistic effect between them was stronger than that from different sources.This process may be an effective way to strengthen the synergistic effect rather than the competition between the two groups.

Conclusions
Two fungi and 15 bacteria were isolated from activated sludge and were identified and classified into the fungi group and the bacteria group, respectively.Fungi played a more significant role in bioadsorption and settleability, and bacteria were more efficient in reactive red X-3B decolorization when cocultured.The synergistic relationship was implied between the fungi group and the bacteria group for the azo dye wastewater treatment.Therefore, the expensive artificial modification of operational, environmental, and physiological conditions to prevent bacterial contamination is not necessary.The bacteria group and the fungi group used in this work were isolated from the same source.Using cocultured microorganisms from the same source is an effective way to strengthen the synergistic effect.

Figure 2 :
Figure 2: Aggregation indexes and biomass concentrations of the bacteria group, fungi group, and bacteria-fungi coculture at the stationary phase.

FungiFigure 4 :
Figure 4: Insight into the synergistic effect of fungi and bacteria for reactive red X-3B decolorization.