Hybrid Synchronization of General T-S Fuzzy Complex Dynamical Networks with Time-Varying Delay

We propose and investigate a new general model of fuzzy complex network systems described by Takagi-Sugeno (T-S) fuzzy model with time-varying delays. Hybrid synchronization problem is discussed for this general T-S fuzzy complex dynamical network with nondelayed and delayed coupling between nodes. Utilizing Lyapunov-Krasovskii functional method, synchronization stability criteria for the networks are established in terms of linear matrix inequalities (LMIs).These criteria reveal the relationship between coupling matrices with time-varying delays and synchronization stability of the dynamical network. Numerical simulation is provided to illustrate the effectiveness and advantage of derived theoretical results.


Introduction
In recent years, complex dynamical networked agent systems have attracted a great deal of attention in various engineering fields from physics to biology, chemistry, and computer science [1][2][3].The reason can be attributed to their flexibility and generality for representing virtually any natural and manmade systems.Such systems in the real world usually consist of a large number of highly interconnected dynamical units.Transportation networks, coupled biological and chemical engineering systems, neural networks in human brains, and the Internet are only a few of such examples [4].
Synchronization is one of the most significant and interesting collective behaviors in complex networked agent systems due to its potential applications in many fields including secure communization, parallel image processing, and information science [5][6][7].On the other hand, time delays occur commonly in complex networks because of the finite speed of signal transmission over the links [8].Since the time delay often causes undesirable performance and instability of the network, various approaches to synchronization analysis for complex dynamical networks with time delay have been investigated in the literature [9][10][11][12].Therefore, synchronization criteria of complex networks with delays have become a topic of practical importance.The stability criteria for time delay systems include two categories: delay-dependent ones and delay-independent ones.Since delay-dependent stability criteria include the information on the size of delay, delay-dependent stability criteria are generally less conservative than delay-independent ones [10].Moreover, many real-world networks are not static but more likely to be time-varying evolving, particularly in biological and physical networks.Commonly, time-varying delays are general form of time delays.There are a few research works [13][14][15] considering the time-varying coupling for complex agent systems of dynamical networks.
Furthermore, the uncertainty or vagueness is unavoidable in real modeling problems of agent systems.Fuzzy theory as an efficient tool in approximating a complex nonlinear system is a feasible method to take vagueness into consideration [16].There are some research works investigating the problem of delay-dependent robust controllers and filtering design for a class of uncertain state-delayed Takagi-Sugeno (T-S) fuzzy systems [17][18][19][20].Recently, the problems of stability analysis, approximation, and stabilization for Takagi-Sugeno fuzzy systems with time-varying state delay are investigated [21][22][23][24].So, fuzzy complex networks have advantages over pure complex networks since they incorporate the capability of fuzzy reasoning in handling uncertain information.In this regard, the fuzzy models to describe complex dynamical networks which are subjected to nonlinearity and have timevarying delays are introduced.The synchronization problem for T-S fuzzy stochastic discrete-time complex networks with mixed time-varying delays is discussed in a recent work [25].By employing the information of probability distribution of time delays, the original system is transformed into a T-S fuzzy model with stochastic parameter [26,27].But how to solve the synchronization problem for general fuzzy complex networks still remains largely unsolved and challenging.To the best of our knowledge, time-varying delay [28,29] synchronization analysis of general fuzzy complex dynamical networks has not been reported in the literature.
Besides, it is noticed that most of the studies on synchronization of dynamical networks have been performed under some implicit assumptions that there exists the information communication of nodes via the edges only at time  or at time   [30].However, in many circumstances, this simplification does not match satisfactorily the peculiarities of real networks; there exists the information communication of nodes not only at time  but also at time  .More recently, coexistence of the hybrid synchronization in chaotic systems was investigated intensively [31].However, our generalized dynamical network model has different coupling strengths for different connections.So it is complex and extended comparing with the simplified network model in [32].So our conclusion is more compact and more meaningful for the generalized network models.To the best of our knowledge, there are very few studies on the hybrid synchronization of general coupled complex dynamical networks with nondelayed and delayed coupling in the literature.
Motivated by the previous discussions, in this paper, we attempt to introduce some more general time-varying dynamical network models based on the T-S fuzzy model and investigate the synchronization properties of this model.Based on the Lyapunov-Krasovskii functional method, we use a linearized method to solve the problem of synchronization for fuzzy complex networks with time-varying coupling delay and derive hybrid synchronization conditions for delaydependent stabilities in terms of LMIs, the time-varying network model.A numerical example is given to demonstrate the effectiveness and the advantage of the proposed method.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows.In Section 2, we present some preliminaries for proving the proof and the fuzzy time-varying coupled dynamical network model.Hybrid synchronization criterions are derived in Section 3. In Section 4, we provide a numerical simulation to verify the correctness and effectiveness of the derived results.Conclusions are presented in Section 5.

Problem Formulation
Consider the following model of general continuous-time complex networks with time-varying coupling delays which can be represented by a T-S fuzzy model.
where   ( = 1, . . ., ;  = 1, . . ., ) are the fuzzy sets;  is the number of rules and   ( = 1, . . ., ) are the premise variables;  is the number of agent nodes, where each agent node is an -dimensional dynamical system with node dynamics ẋ = (,);   = ( 1 ,  2 , . . .,   )  ∈   are the state variables of node ;  :   →   is continuously differentiable; Γ  and Γ are the constant innercoupling matrices of the nodes; the constant  > 0 is the coupling strength;  = (  ) × and C = (c  ) × are the outer-coupling matrices of the network, in which   is defined, as follows: if there is a connection between node  and node  ( ̸ = ), then   =   = 1; otherwise,   =   = 0, c is similar defined and the diagonal elements of matrices  and C are defined by Suppose that C and C are irreducible matrices.Time-varying delay () satisfies in which ℎ and  are constants.The initial function () is a continuous and differentiable vector-valued function.By using the standard fuzzy inference method, the T-S fuzzy network (1) can be expressed by the following model: where () = [ In the following, some elementary situations are introduced, which play an important role in proving the main result.
Definition 1.The dynamical networked agent system (1) is said to achieve asymptotic synchronization if where () is a solution of an isolate node, satisfying ṡ () = (()).

Main Results
In this section, we focus on investigating the hybrid synchronization problem of fuzzy complex dynamical networks with nondelayed and delayed coupling.Before deriving our main results, the following lemma will be utilized.(4).Let 0 =  1 >  2 ≥ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ≥   and 0 = λ1 > λ2 ≥ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ≥ λ , respectively, be the eigenvalues of outer coupling matrix C and C. If the following  − 1 time-varying delayed differential equations are asymptotically stable about their zero solution:

Lemma 4. Consider the T-S fuzzy dynamical network
where () is the Jacobin of (()) at (), then synchronized states in fuzzy complex networks (1) are asymptotically stable.
Substituting ( 9) into (4), we obtain Considering that (()) is continuous differentiable, it is easy to know that the origin of the complex networks ( 8) is an asymptotically stable equilibrium point for the following linear time delay systems: According to Lemma 2, there exist nonsingular matrices, are asymptotically stable, then () will tend to the origin asymptotically, which implies that synchronized states of complex networks (8) are asymptotically stable.
The proof is thus completed.
Remark 5. We use Lemma 4 to linearize the complicated system to deal with the complex networks by using fuzzy theory.It is an available way to investigate the interconnected dynamical agents of complex networks.Then some new subsystems can be obtained, which are easy to be analyzed.Now, the main result is stated in the following theorem.
The proof is thus completed.
Remark 7.For the delay-dependent synchronization problems of complex networks, the Lyapunov-Krasovskii condition has been attracted owing to the structural advantage.
The key point is the introduction of the integral inequality technique, a fundamental trick to derive delay-dependent stability criteria containing the size or the bounds of delays and their derivatives.However, almost results in this field have employed partial information on the relationship among delay-related terms.Being differently from the common construction, we use not only the time-varying-delayed state but also the delay-upper-bounded state to exploit all possible information when constructing the Lyapunov-Krasovskii functional.Our approach in Theorem 6 reduces the conservatism of the existing methods to a certain extent.
The aforementioned results can be extended to the case of bound constant time delay.If the time-varying delay () is a constant time delay in system (1), then fuzzy system (4) can be expressed in the following model: We obtain the following corollary. 2 with appropriate dimensions, such that the following LMIs hold for all  = 1, 2, . . ., : where then the asymptotic synchronization of system (22) in Definition 1 can be achieved.
Proof.Select a Lyapunov-Krasovskii function as The rest of the proof is similar to that of Theorem 6; thus one can easily obtain the result.Thus it is omitted here.The proof is completed.
Remark 9. Corollary 8 presents new hybrid synchronization conditions for fuzzy complex networks with constant delays.
We consider the delay which involve general form of delays.
Based on Lyapunov-Krasovskii function method, stability criteria are obtained in the form of LMIs which can be easily solved.And the results are usually less conservative than delay-independent ones especially when the size of the time delay is small.

Numerical Example
To illustrate the previous results we obtain, we consider the following complex dynamical networks with time-varying delays consisting of three nodes: The eigenvalues of  and C are () = λ( C) = {0, −1.5, −1.5}.
Using MATLAB LMI toolbox, the upper bounds on the time delay for different values of the coupling strength  can be obtained from Theorem 6.A detailed comparison is given in Table 1, where the achieved upper bounds of time delay in the previous system are listed for their respective lower bounds.
Assume that the coupling strength is  = 0.4; it is found that the maximum delay bound is ℎ = 0.73 in [27], for which the synchronized states of the network are asymptotically stable.By Theorem 6 in this paper, however, it is found that the maximum delay bound for the synchronized states to be asymptotically stable is ℎ = 0.851.It can be seen that the method proposed in this paper is better.
For random initial conditions, Figures 1, 2, and 3 show the synchronization errors between the states of node  and node  + 1 with ℎ = 0.5.We find that the synchronization errors converge to zero under the previous conditions.

Conclusions
In this paper, we have proposed a class of general complex dynamical network models based on T-S fuzzy theory and investigated hybrid synchronization of the proposed complex dynamical networks.Time-varying delays in network couplings of dynamical nodes have been considered.New delaydependent synchronization criteria in terms of LMIs have been derived based on an appropriate Lyapunov functional.Synchronization criteria are obtained in this paper which can be applicable to networks with different topologies and different sizes.Numerical simulation is also provided to illustrate the usefulness and advantage of the synchronization criteria.

Table 1 :
Upper bounds of ℎ for different  and .