Biology of the Endemic Endangered Swallowtail Butterfly, Papilio desmondi teita (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae), on Wild Citrus Species in Taita Hills, Kenya

, was reared in captivity on wild citrus (


Introduction
Butterfies are among most signifcant component of biodiversity within the ecosystem [1].Some butterfies such as papilionids and pierids and some groups of nymphalids and hesperiids are pollinators of wild fowering plants and cultivated crops [2].Approximately 87.5% of fowering plant species depend on animal pollinators for their production [3].In the agricultural sector, 87 of the leading world food crops and 35% of the total crop production volumes are dependent on animal pollination [4].Most butterfies are typically herbivores in their larval stages and majority are host specifc with a close relationship with their host plants [5].Also, most adults have a specialized mouthpart, the proboscis which is long and tubular for extraction of nectar, a primary source of nutrition for adult butterfies [6,7].While feeding on plants' nectar, butterfies play a critical role as pollinators through the transfer of pollen from one fower to another [6].However, some butterfy species particularly in the family Nymphalidae feed on other liquid substances including fruit juice, rotting fruit, tree sap, and even animal droppings [6][7][8].
Swallowtail butterfy species are endangered and have been experiencing a reduction in diversity, occurrence, and abundance across the globe [9][10][11].Te loss of pollinator swallowtail butterfies is linked with the reduction in plants that they depend on through habitat change and destruction activities such as deforestation, agriculture conversion and intensifcation, alteration of pastures, and urbanization [12].Tese alterations within their natural habitat have a negative impact on their fundamental life functions such as mating, breeding, foraging, and many others [13].Tis has raised concerns about the stability of ecosystem function and food security [14].Tese factors may also cause a local extinction or migration of the endemic swallowtail butterfies due to the loss of their preferred host plants within their habitats [15,16].Among the tropical swallowtail butterfy species, Papilio desmondi teita (Van Someren) (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae) is an endemic and endangered species to Taita Hills in Kenya [9,17] that form the Eastern Arc Mountains (EAM) [7,12,18].
Te knowledge of the relationship between swallowtail butterfies and their host plants is very scanty.According to a recent study, compared to farmlands, forest edges are home to a greater diversity of butterfy species [19].A crucial step in achieving the conservation goal of swallowtail butterfies is through understanding their biology within their natural habitats.Once biology is understood, a more sustainable management and conservation strategy could be designed and adopted for use.Currently, there is no known information on the biology of P. desmondi teita with very little information documented on its larval host plants by Larsen [20] and Congdon et al. [21].Terefore, the present study was conducted to document the biology of the swallowtail butterfy P. desmondi teita on wild species of citrus (Rutaceae), horsewood Clausena anisata (Willd) and orange climber Toddalia asiatica (Lam), which were previously reported as the species' larval host plants according to Larsen [20] and Congdon et al. [21] as well as to understand the larval host preference between the selected host plants.
Clausena anisata, a wild citrus species, is a small, deciduous shrub with imparipinnate compound leaves that are heavily gland-dotted and have a strong, anise-like scent when crushed [22].According to Mukandiwa et al. [23], the shrub is the only member of the Clausena genus found in tropical Africa [24].Its country-specifc geographical range includes bushveld, riverine thickets, and forests throughout sub-Saharan Africa, with the exception of the driest regions.Toddalia asiatica, a woody liana that is a wild citrus species, can grow up to 10 meters high in the forest [25].According to Gopal et al. [26], it is extensively distributed throughout Madagascar, Asia, and Africa's tropical regions.In the Maasai and Kipsigis communities of East Africa, the plant is traditionally used as a hedge and as a browser for goats [27].Te host plants in this study were specifcally chosen as the larval host plants due to their frequent occurrence in the Taita Hills and their utility to the local butterfy farmers during the reconnaissance survey.Tis study will yield valuable information for the broader conservation of swallowtail butterfies and the plants that serve as their hosts in Kenya and throughout sub-Saharan Africa.

Te Study Site. Taita Hills which form part of Eastern
Afromontane Biodiversity Hotspot [7,28,29] with an elevation range of 1,200 to 2,200 meters above sea level are home to an exceptionally high number of endemic plant and animal species (Figure 1).Te study was conducted at the Dawida Biodiversity Center, which is situated in the coastal region of Wundanyi Subcounty, Taita Taveta County, Kenya, at the Ngangao Forest fragment of the Taita Hills.
Te study was carried out at two locations within the study site: a garden (a) and a laboratory (b) between March and September of 2021.In a garden under shade, oviposition was observed in buckets holding the mated females and the two host plants, C. anisata and T. asiatica.Te garden recorded ambient temperature and relative humidity of 23.87 ± 0.93 °C and 66.83 ± 3.22%, respectively, during the frst season (March-May 2021) and an ambient temperature and relative humidity of 18.25 ± 0.57 °C and 74.83 ± 1.51%, respectively, in the second season (June-September 2021).Subsequent studies on development from egg (collected from oviposition experiment) to adult were conducted inside the laboratory at an ambient room temperature and relative humidity of 22.19 ± 0.09 °C and 73.86 ± 0.33%, respectively, during the frst season (March-May 2021) and ambient room temperature and relative humidity of 18.26 ± 0.13 °C and 74.71 ± 0.50%, respectively, during the second season (June-September 2021).All the experiments were carried out at 12L : 12D in both seasons.Two wild citrus species, Clausena anisata (Willd.)and Toddalia asiatica (L.) Lam.(Rutaceae) were chosen as the host plants for the experiment on swallowtail butterfy, P. desmondi teita developmental attributes.From the forest edges, young branches with new leaves from each host plant were gathered and brought to the laboratory.After washing the branches to get rid of dust and any potential predators, they were submerged in water to prevent desiccation.Te branches were placed in plastic buckets (325 mm dia.× 375 mm•h) labeled with the host plant species for use in colony maintenance.

Swallowtail Butterfy, Papilio desmondi teita, Culture.
A colony of P. desmondi teita from eggs (collected from an oviposition experiment), larval instars, pupae, and adults was maintained inside the laboratory (situated in Ngangao Forest) in plastic buckets (Figure 2(b)) on C. anisata and T. asiatica.Te stock colony was established from the adults collected at the forest edges in November 2020.Te adults were collected using a sweep net while foraging on the fowers from various plant species, and some females were collected on the selected host plants while laying eggs.To avoid rubbing of the scales on the upper surface of the wings, the butterfies' wings were folded above their backs before being placed in waxed paper envelopes.After being brought to the laboratory, they were placed in rearing fight cages that were 70 cm by 70 cm by 70 cm in size.A mosquito net was placed over the cages to provide ventilation.Tey Psyche: A Journal of Entomology were also kept from escaping by the nets.Twice a day, they were given 10% sugar solution soaked in cotton wool as food.To ensure successful mating, the males and females were artifcially mated after 24 hours using the hand pairing method [18,30].Mated females were individually placed into laying buckets containing either young branches of the host plant, C. anisata or T. asiatica, for oviposition.From the oviposition experiment, all eggs laid on the same day and at the same age on each host plant were collected and placed into clearly labeled transparent plastic   Psyche: A Journal of Entomology buckets that measured 325 mm in diameter by 375 mm in height.Tese buckets were then used for incubation and further development in the laboratory.Troughout both seasons, the P. desmondi teita rearing cultures were kept at room temperature and relative humidity.Te mesh-covered, detachable lids on the buckets improved air circulation.After hatching, the young larvae were placed in clean rearing plastic buckets (325 mm Dia × 375 mm•H) with young, fresh host plants inside, and they were separated from the unhatched eggs using a soft camel-hair brush.Te young, fresh leaves of the selected plants were fed to the larvae.
Te pupae were removed after they had pupated by gently pulling them of and scratching the corner of the silk girdle that the cremaster was attached to.Te pupae were moved to the new buckets, and twigs and white serviette paper were added to the base to support the emerging adults.Up until their adult emergence, the pupae were kept in the same laboratory conditions.After a day, the newly emerged adults were fed with a 10% sugar solution and separated from the pupae.By using the hand pairing method, six pairs were chosen from the population that was reared from each host plant, and they were mated after two days [30].Within the rearing bucket, the mated females were exposed to their host plants in preparation for oviposition.Te second season experiment followed the same procedure used during the frst season.

Efects of Host Plants on Egg Incubation Period and
Mortality Rate.After being separated from the other adults, six mated females were put in buckets with young, fresh branches from each host plant in preparation for oviposition.Eggs of the same age (laid on the same day) were kept in the buckets as mentioned in the previous section, with their lids turned upside down for ventilation, to determine the egg incubation period on each host plant.Until they hatched, the eggs were watched every day.Te incubation period was determined by counting the days until the eggs hatched.To determine the egg mortality rate, the number of unhatched eggs from each host plant was counted.Mortality was calculated as a percentage.
Percentage egg mortality � number of unhatched eggs total number of laid egg ×100. (1)

Efect of Host Plants on Larval Development Period, Mortality Rate, and Larval Weight.
In plastic rearing buckets with adequate ventilation and a branch of young, fresh leaves from the host plants, a cohort of 165 larvae (in the frst season) and 192 larvae (in the second season) was placed.Te duration of larval instar was determined by recording the number of days taken to complete each instar stage identifed by diferences in size, marking and pattern, and head capsule coloration.Te larval weight was determined by weighing 60 individual larvae using JA-SERIES (JA203) electronic analytical balance (0.001 mg accuracy).By monitoring larval cohorts at each instar and keeping track of the number of survivors from the start of each instar to the fnish, the mortality rate was determined.Te mortality rate (by instar) was calculated with the formula larval mortality rate � number of dead larvae at the end of instar total number of larvae at the beginning of instar ×100.

Efect of Host
Psyche: A Journal of Entomology the experiment, the pupal mortality rate was also recorded.Te time taken from pupal formation to the adult butterfy emergence was recorded in days as the pupal period.An electronic analytical balance (Type JA203H; JA-SERIES) with a 0.001 mg accuracy was used to weigh each pupa.To calculate the pupal mortality rate, the number of dead pupae (those that did not fully transform into adults) were counted and recorded.Abbott's [31] formula was used to calculate the mortality rate: pupal mortality rate � number of emerged adults total number of pupae formed ×100.
(  Immediately upon hatching, the frst instar larvae were feeding on their empty eggshells before moving toward the host plant that was provided.Te larvae fed on T. asiatica successfully completed the fve instar stages of development.Tose reared on C. anisata died between 2 and 3 days in both seasons.Te larval development period on T. asiatica varied from the 1 st to 5 th instar larvae in both seasons.Te longest period was recorded in ffth instar stage for both seasons, and the shortest period was recorded in 1 st and 2 nd instar in 1 st and 2 nd seasons, respectively (Table 3).Te total larval period for the larvae reared on T. asiatica was 44.55 ± 0.27 days in the frst season and 66.05 ± 0.66 days in the second season.Te larval instar mortality rate observed on T. asiatica during the frst season varied from 8.51% for frst instar to no mortality for the 5 th , with 24.34% mortality for all larvae reared on T. asiatica.Similarly, the mortality rate observed on T. asiatica in the second season varied across the instar stages with the highest rate recorded in the frst instar and lowest rate in the ffth instar.Te overall mortality rate for the larvae reared on T. asiatica during the second season was 32.61%.However, the larvae that were reared on C. anisata recorded 100% mortality in the frst instar, hence leading to the end of the experiment in both seasons.Terefore, the overall larval mortality recorded in both seasons for the larvae reared on C. anisata was 100% (Table 3).

Egg Incubation
Te host plants signifcantly infuenced the weight of the frst instar larvae at t � 3.637; df � 188; P � 0.0004 during the frst season.Te frst instar larvae reared on C. asiatica were heavier (1.42 ± 0.03 mg) than those reared on T. asiatica (1.29 ± 0.02 mg).However, the frst instar larvae reared on    4).Te female to male sex ratio was 1 : 0.97 and 1 : 0.95 during the frst and second season, respectively.
During the frst season, females of P. desmondi teita reared on T. asiatica had a mean weight of 481.47 ± 11.85 mg which was signifcantly higher than 300.80 ± 8.51 mg recorded for males (Table 4), and the same trend was recorded for the second season.Te number of eggs laid by the females of P. desmondi teita on T. asiatica and C. anisata did not difer signifcantly within the frst two days.(t = 0.65; df = 4; P = 0.550) during the frst season..However, during second season, the host plant species signifcantly infuenced the number of eggs laid by the butterfies at t = −2.94;df = 4; P = 0.042.Te mean number of eggs laid was 42.00 on T. asiatica and 35.00 on C. anisata.

Discussion
Te host plants selected in this study were found to infuence the development and oviposition of P. desmondi teita.Te study showed that the female laid eggs singly on the upper and lower sides of the fresh leaf, bucket surface, and branch surface.Te highest number of eggs was laid on the lower leaf surface of T. asiatica while on C. anisata, it was observed that most eggs were laid on the bucket surface.Te higher number of eggs laid on the lower side of T. asiatica leaf was meant to protect the eggs from being washed away by rainfall, direct sunlight, and natural enemies including predators and parasitoids [33].Tis observation was consistent with what Stamp [34] reported about the majority of papilionid butterfy species.However, the observation made when P. desmondi teita was exposed to C. anisata for oviposition could be attributed to the contact chemical stimuli on the host plants which plays a great role in female fnal decision to lay eggs [35], which in the present case, the females were trying to avoid this host plant which was unsuitable for their larval survival as exhibited from this fndings.Te same observation about egg-laying habits was also made in a study on P. demoleus and P. polytes in Bangladesh by Islam et al. [36,37].Te habit of laying a single egg prevents the possibility of larval feeding resources being depleted, allowing for the efcient use of host plant resources [38].Higher nutrient accumulation and smooth textures lead to the oviposition observed on the host plants' young, fresh leaves [33].
Te egg incubation period for P. desmondi teita eggs varied on each host plant.Generally, eggs laid on T. asiatica had a shorter incubation period as compared to those on C. anisata.Te variation in incubation period might be accounted for by the diferent host plants due to the variation of accumulated secondary plant semiochemicals [39].Findings by Reddy and Guerrero [40], Hardie et al. [41], and Kahuthia-Gathu [42] confrmed that plants' semiochemicals play a major role in female oviposition preference to host plant choice.Te incubation period might also vary due to fuctuations in temperature during the period of study as observed in our study.Te frst season in March 2021 recorded the highest mean temperature compared to the second season in June 2021.Tese results are similar to the fnding of Al-Mehmmady [43] who reported incubation period of Earias vittella (Fabricius) at 2.42 days during September at 31.3 °C and 2.15 days during August at 32.6 °C.Similarly, Syed et al. [44] reported the shortest incubation period of E. vittella during September when the average laboratory temperature was 32.6 °C and the longest incubation period during October with an average temperature of 30.6 °C.
In this study, no signifcant diferences were registered in the percentage egg mortality between the host plants for P. desmondi teita in both seasons.Tese results could probably be attributed to the female oviposition behaviour as a determinant of successful reproduction [45].Similarly, females have the capability to invest in the survival of their progeny by inducing mechanisms such as secretion of sticky substances that protect the eggs against parasitism, endowing the eggs with substances that deter predation, and increasing the egg size [46,47].However, the percentage mortality recorded during the study could be associated with host toxins and infection, environmental factors in the two seasons, and host contact with xenobiotic factors beyond control during the experiment [48].However, we could not justify whether the mortality rate registered on the eggs was a result of the host plant response factors or due to the natural causes within the environment, thus creating the need for further investigation on the actual causes of death.
Te developmental periods and larval mortality varied considerably within the two seasons.Te observed variation could be associated with biotic and abiotic factors such as diferences in nutrition components and semiochemicals released from the host plants and changes in environmental conditions experienced during development [49].Tis study revealed that P. desmondi teita larvae could only complete all successive larval instar developmental stages on T. asiatica and were unsuccessful on C. anisata.Tis observation could be related to unsuitability of C. anisata as a host plant for P. desmondi teita [50] which led to the death of frst instar larvae as a result of starvation.Congdon et al. [21] reported a similar observation that T. asiatica was host plant for P. desmondi.Te present study however did not confrm the report by Larsen [20] that Clausena species was the host plant for the butterfy species.100% mortality was recorded in the frst instar larvae reared on C. anisata in both seasons in the present study.In addition, the frst instar larvae of P. desmondi teita were observed avoiding the C. anisata host plant.Te 100% mortality on C. anisata could have been a result of larvae starvation due to avoidance of the host plant.Tis could be attributed to the biochemical compounds present in C. anisata that might be repellant to frst larval instar of P. desmondi teita.Tis conforms to the fndings of Visser [51] who reported that herbivorous insects have developed adaptive mechanisms to identify suitable hosts and evade nonsuitable hosts using their scents.Te study also showed that young larvae had a greater mortality rate than older stages.On the Anaphe panda (Boisduval) Psyche: A Journal of Entomology 8 Psyche: A Journal of Entomology (Lepidoptera: Taumetopoeidae) at Kakamega Forest in Kenya, Mbahin et al. [52] reported similar fndings.In the present study, P. desmondi teita registered higher mortality in frst instar and ffth instar stages as compared to other stages of larval development on T. asiatica.Te factors that might have likely contributed to mortality of the frst instar larvae were unknown; however, the mortality registered on ffth instar larvae was likely caused by sharp internode spines present on the stem and lower surface of the leaves of T. asiatica [53].Tese fndings are consistent with those reported on the survival of silkworm, A. panda, in Kakamega Forest of Western Kenya by Mbahin et al. [52].Duration of development can prolong when the amount of food consumed is reduced, and this results in the insect's reduced length and weight [54] as on P. desmondi teita for the larvae reared during the two seasons on T. asiatica.When P. desmondi teita was reared on T. asiatica, the ffth instar's larval duration was longer than the frst, second, third, and fourth instars.Te ffth instar also recorded the highest weight which was a result of the longer feeding duration registered during the study while compensating for the low feed intake observed in the previous instars.Carvalho and Vasconcello-Neto [55] found a similar observation about the larval performance and host plant selection in Mechanitis polymnia casabranca (L.), a species of neotropical butterfy.Similar fndings on P. polytes, a distinct species within the same family reared on citrus plants, were documented by Suwarno et al. [56].Te results on P. desmondi teita showed that ffth instar larvae had the highest weight which difered greatly from the weight of fourth instar larvae in both seasons.Tis could be attributed to increasing feeding at the ffth instar stage and prolonged feeding duration as reported by Hochuli [57] and Tithi et al. [58].
Te pupal period of P. desmondi teita reared on T. asiatica varied within the seasons, ranging from 27.31 days to 31.73 days in the 1 st and 2 nd seasons, respectively.Variable pupal period and total development period could be a result of diferences in climatic conditions between the seasons.Furthermore, the nutritional stage attained during larval development typically determines pupation after the larval phase [42].Once the ffth instar larva has accumulated sufcient reserve for successful pupation and adult emergence, pupation takes place.Te reserve accumulation is greatly infuenced by the host plants [59].Findings reported by Al-Mehmmady [43] showed that the pupal period of E. vittella during August and October were 6.45 and 7.78 days with an average temperature of 32.6 °C and 30.5 °C, respectively.Furthermore, the duration of the development period increases with a decrease in temperature as reported by Syed et al. [44] on Earias vittella when reared on okra, Abelmoschus esculentus L., China rose, Hibiscus rosasinensis L., cotton, Gossypium hirsutum L., and Indian mallow, Abutilon indicum L. Tey conducted their study of the three life cycles of E. vittella, keeping the temperature regime at a difference of 2 °C between diferent life cycles in a laboratory and recorded an increase in the duration of the life cycle when the temperature decreased in July.
Up to 80% of the food provided to the larva during its ffth instar is devoured by it; hence, its growth increases in direct proportion to the amount of food it consumes.If the amount of available food is limited, this could result in small pupa with low weight even if the diet is nutritionally suffcient [60].Tis could be the case with P. desmondi teita reared on T. asiatica which had a variation in pupal weight in the frst and second seasons.Te lowest mortality rate was observed at the pupal stage of development as compared to the larval stages in P. desmondi teita.Tese results are similar to the fndings reported by Kahuthia-Gathu et al. [42] on Plutella xylostella (L.) (Lepidoptera: Plutellidae) reared on cultivated and wild crucifer species.Islam et al. [37] reported a mortality rate of 7.69% on the same genus P. polytes reared on citrus species in the laboratory which was within the range reported in the present study.Halloran and Wason [61] reported the highest mortality during the egg stage.Additionally, Suwarno [62] found the highest mortality at the ffth instar.Te variations reported in mortality rates from previous fndings and the current study may be associated with weather changes, human error, and host plant efects.Tese fndings are indications that the adoption of bucket rearing technology has great potential to increase the survival of the species to adults which could contribute to its conservation and management.Also, the technology could be adopted for commercial butterfy farming for the species used for trade.
In the present study of P. desmondi teita, the highest adult longevity was recorded in the frst season and the lowest in the second season.Females generally lived longer than males.Te higher longevity in females could be related to the need of fnding mates as described by Pereira et al. [63].Similar fndings were reported by Al-Mehmmady [43] on E. vittella male and female longevity reared during August and October in Saudi Arabia.However, the present study was in contrast with Syed et al. [44] who reported that males of E. vittella within the same order Lepidoptera lived longer than females.Jahnavi et al. [64] reported that females of Papilio demoleus (L.) (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae) lived longer than the males when reared on acid lime in Tirupati.Females were generally heavier than the males in our study.Mackey [65] and Lederhouse et al. [66] reported that females achieve their greater size than males because of their larvae in various larval stages which feed more and develop for a longer period than the larval stages of the males.A previous study by Scriber and Slansky [67] observed that Lepidoptera females often weigh more than males over the majority of their life cycle, a characteristic that has been linked to the function of laying eggs.Swallowtail butterfy, P. desmondi teita, had a female-biased sex ratio in the present study.Tis fnding showed that T. asiatica was a suitable host plant for the mass production of the endangered swallowtail butterfy species endemic to Taita Hills.
Te result from the present study showed variation in the efect of the host plants on female fecundity of P. desmondi teita exposed to both C. anisata and T. asiatica.Generally, more eggs were laid on T. asiatica compared to those laid on C. anisata.Te fnding of this study was clear evidence that P. desmondi teita larvae reared on T. asiatica produced females that showed generally a better performance on T. asiatica than on C. anisata, a clear demonstration that T. asiatica was a more proftable host plant for P. desmondi Psyche: A Journal of Entomology teita female oviposition.Kahuthia-Gathu et al. [42] observed that adult P. xylostella reared on wild crucifers produced females that performed better than those reared on cultivated crucifers.Following a previous study that demonstrated that most female butterfies will make higher oviposition within the frst two days after mating [18], this study explored oviposition on both host plants within the frst two days after mating.Similarly, David and Gardiner [68] discovered that females have a greater egg load at this age following mating.Findings reported on the same genius P. demoleus by Patel et al. [69] showed that the fecundity ranged at 110.80 ± 4.46 eggs per female on citrus.Similarly, Maheswarababu [70] reported almost similar fecundity of 112 eggs per female P. demoleus on citrus species.In the present study, the fecundity ranged between 35.00 to 53.33 eggs per female P. desmondi teita were recorded on the target host plants, which was lower than those reported above by Patel et al. [69] and Maheswarababu [70] on P. demoleus in the same genus.
Te fndings of this study revealed that P. desmondi teita could only complete development on T. asiatica and was unsuccessful on C. anisata.Tis was clear evidence that T. asiatica was the most suitable host plant for the species, and thus the study recommends the conservation of T. asiatica within its natural habitat for the survival of this species assessed as an endangered species according to IUCN [9] species red list assessment.With this knowledge, more sustainable conservation strategies for this endangered swallowtail butterfy species may be designed accordingly.Furthermore, policymakers and other stakeholders should use this study's fndings as a starting point when developing policies aimed at achieving long-term conservation goals for this butterfy species and its natural environment.

Figure 2 :
Figure 2: Egg-laying site outside the laboratory at a garden (a) and laboratory rearing in the laboratory (b) within Ngangao Forest, Taita Hills.
Toddalia asiatica (L.) Lam., Tabl.Encycl.2: 116 1797.(syn.Aralia labordei H. Lév.; Cranzia aculeata (Sm.)Oken; Cranzia asiatica (L.) Kuntze; Cranzia nitida Kuntze; Limonia oligandra Dalzell (Unresolved); Paullinia asiatica L.; 7 2.7.Efect of Host Plant on Adult Longevity, Sex Ratio, Weight, and Oviposition.By examining the morphology of the forewing, hindwing, and abdomen, adult butterfies were sexed.Te sex ratio was calculated by counting and recording the number of adult males and females.Te adult longevity of males and females fed on 10% sugar solution was investigated by recording the time from each individual emergence to death on a daily basis.Te number of eggs laid in the frst two days was used to calculate the oviposition.
[32]r a day, at 6 pm, when they were less active, sixty newly emerged adults were weighed individually on an electronic analytical balance (0.001 mg accuracy; Type JA203H; JA-SERIES).All experiments were replicated three times and in two seasons.2.8.Statistical Analysis.All the data were analyzed in R statistical software package, version 4.1.1[32].Mean and SEM (standard error of mean) were computed for the duration of developmental stages, egg incubation period, oviposition, egg mortality rate, larval and pupal mortality, and weight of developmental stages.Te independent sample t-test was used to compare the means from each host plant.Te Shapiro-Wilk test and the Bartlett test of homogeneity of variance were applied to the fecundity data on various substrates and submitted to one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) using general linear model (GLM) procedure of R statistical package software.Tukey's multiple comparison test was used to separate the means between the substrates.P ≤ 0.05 was designated as the signifcance level.

Table 2 .
P < 0.001) the incubation period with the eggs laid on C. anisata hatching in 8.35 days compared to 7.27 days for those laid on T. asiatica.However, during the second season, the host plants did not signifcantly infuence the incubation period at t = −0.53;df = 182; P = 0.595 for eggs laid on C. anisata and T. asiatica host plants.Te percentage mortality for the eggs laid on both host plants did not difer signifcantly at t = −0.14;df = 4; P = 0.895 and t = 0.00; df = 4; P = 0.998 in both rearing seasons as outlined in Period and Mortality.Te females of P. desmondi teita laid eggs singly on the branch, lower and upper sides of the leaves, and bucket.Tey laid signifcantly more eggs on the lower leaf surface (F 3,76 = 50.19;P<0.001) compared to other oviposition substrates when exposed to T. asiatica while on C. anisata, most eggs were laid on the bucket surface followed by the lower leaf surface and the least was laid on the stem surface as shown in Table1.In the frst season, the host plants signifcantly infuenced (t = 16.15;df = 188; 3.2.Larval Development and Mortality Rate.Swallowtail butterfy, P. desmondi teita, larvae recorded fve instars in both seasons.

Table 1 :
Oviposition preference and mean (±SE) number of eggs laid by Papilio desmondi teita on Clausena anisata and Toddalia asiatica (as per plant) in March 2021 under feld conditions.Means (±SE) in the same column followed by the same letter do not difer signifcantly at P ≤ 0.05 (Tukey's test).

Table 2 :
Mean (±SE) incubation period (days) and mortality rate (%) of P. desmondi teita eggs laid on Clausena anisata and Toddalia asiatica in the frst season (March-May 2021) and the second season (June-September 2021) under laboratory conditions.

Table 3 :
Mean (±SE) of larval instar duration (days), total larval period (days), and larval instar specifc percentage mortality of Papilio desmondi teita reared on Clausena anisata and Toddalia asiatica during the frst season (March-May 2021) and second season (June-September 2021) under laboratory conditions.Journal of Entomology similar trend was recorded for the second season during which females recorded 6.89 ± 0.08 days and males 5.12 ± 0.11 days at t � 12.69, df � 68, P < 0.001.Overall, the development time from egg to adult ranged between 81.13 days in the frst season and 112.15 days in the second season both reared on T. asiatica (Table

Table 4 :
Mean (±SE) adult weight, fecundity, and development time to adult of Papilio desmondi teita reared on Toddalia asiatica in the frst season (March-May 2021) and second season (June-September 2021) under feld conditions (for fecundity) and laboratory conditions (for development time to adult).(±SE) followed by the same lower case letters in the same column and same upper case letters in the same row do not difer signifcantly at P Means