A Study of Rockburst Hazard Evaluation Method in Coal Mine

With the increasing of coal mining depth, the mining conditions are deteriorating, and dynamic hazard is becoming more likely to happen. This paper analyzes the relations and differences between rockburst in the coal mine and rockburst in the metal mine. It divides coal mine rockburst into two types including static loading type during roadway excavation process and dynamic loading type during mining face advancing. It proposes the correlation between the formation process of rockburst and the evolution of overlying strata spatial structure of the stope, criterion of rockburst occurrence, new classification, and predictive evaluationmethod for rockburst hazard that rockburst damage evaluation (RDE) = released energy capacity (REC)/absorbed energy capacity (AEC). Based on the relationship between RDE value and its corresponding level of rockburst hazard, the rockburst hazard can be divided into five types and evaluation index of each type can be achieved.Then the ongoing rockburst damage level can be classified in one of the five types, and the relative parameters, such as hazard extent, controllingmeasures also can be achieved.This new quantitative method could not only assess the impacting direction of rockburst occurrence, but also verify the effect of preventive measures for rockburst.


Introduction
With the increasing mining depth and mining intensity, dynamic hazard, such as rockburst, is becoming more likely to happen, which threatens the safe and high-efficient mining [1][2][3].According to the statistics [4][5][6][7], foreign mining of over 1000-meter deep metal mines has more than 80 seats, of which, up to South Africa, Anglogold Limited Liability Company's western deep gold mine, mining depth up to 3700 m, and India Kolar gold mining area have three gold mining depths of more than 2400 m; Driefovten West gold deposit occurred in the underground 600 m extended to 6000 m; Krivoy Rog Russia's iron ore district has Dzerzhinsky, akilov, Communist International, and other 8 mines, mining depth of 910 m, to explore the depth of 1570 m, which is expected to reach 2000-2500 m.In China, there were 32 coal mines in which rockburst occurred in 1985, and the amount of such coal mines was up to 142 in 2012.Meanwhile, there are more than 50 coal mines with the mining depth of more than 1000 m.During the period of 2006-2013, more than nine coal mines, like Xinwen coal mine, Yima coal mine, and so forth, had occurred 35 times rockburst, 300 people died, and more than one thousand people were injured in these accidents.The degree of damage in coal mine rockburst is becoming increasingly severe.
With addition of the complexity of mining geological condition, the problem of rockburst is particularly acute, so a scientific solution to predict and control the rockburst is urgently needed.

Definition and Classification of Rockburst in Coal Mine
2.1.Definition of Rockburst in Coal Mine.Rockburst in coal mine is a dynamic phenomenon with sudden severe damage, throw-out of large quantity of rock or coal body, and loud sound in the surrounding rock of roadway or working face, which is induced by instantaneous release of elastic deformed energy of the surrounding rock and occurs during the mining process.It usually leads to severe supporting device damage and large deformation in the roadway and working face, casualties and coal mine collapse in the worse situation, and even ground collapse that induces local earthquake.It is one of major hazards in coal mine [8,9].The typical characteristics in the coal mine rockburst are as follows.For the occurrence time, it usually occurs during the large-area working face weighting period induced by the upper hard roof breaking; for the occurrence area, it usually occurs in the high stress area 100 meters in front of working face; for the reason of rockburst occurrence, it is usually induced by dynamic impact like impact of hard roof breaking and blasting; for the appearances of the coal mine rockburst, it usually leads to up to 90% of reduction ration of roadway section or the mining equipment damage like working face supports.
Rockburst in metal mine or underground tunnel occurs in the geological condition of high stress area and is a dynamic phenomenon of rock crack and damage or rock ejection induced by the sudden release of rock mass stored elastic energy during the excavation process [10,11].The typical characteristics of rockburst in the mental mine or underground tunnel are as follows.It usually occurs with obvious sound.The level of sound depends on the level of rockburst; the obvious feature of rock damage attitude is sheet; its occurrence is related to the direction of tectonic stress.
Considering economic factors and temporary requirements, deformation or little damage of the surrounding rock is allowed in coal mining projects, as long as the structure of the surrounding rock does not fail and meets the production safety requirements.Underground tunneling projects do not allow big deformation or little damage.Moreover, mininginduced stress is another characteristic in coal mine, which is much bigger than that of underground tunneling projects.
The similar parts between rockburst in coal mine and rockburst in metal mine or underground tunnels are a dynamic phenomenon with rock breaking and throw-out because of sudden release of surrounding rock stress.The difference between them is that, in mining engineering, the sign of rockburst occurrence depends on whether this dynamic phenomenon can induce serious damage and geological hazard or not.With no serious damage or geological hazard, the treatment measures are not needed.So the dynamic failure phenomenon which needs to be taken in treatment measures in coal mine is called rockburst, and its hazard evaluation criterion should be the induced serious damage and the geological hazard.

Main Factors in Rockburst Mines. Many researchers
propose different classification methods of rockburst from different perspectives.According to the position of rockburst occurrence, coal mine rockburst is divided into three types including rockburst of coal seam, rockburst of roof, rockburst of floor.According to the energy source of rockburst, it is divided into the gravitative type, the tectonic type, and gravitative-tectonic type.According to the magnitude of impact energy, it is divided into microimpact type, weak  [13].The geological factors mainly include hard and thick roof, overlying strata with large thickness, hard roof-and-floor, geological structure, great inclined coal seam, change of coal thickness, and natural earthquake.The technical factors mainly include gob-surrounded coal pillar, upper coal pillar formed in the mining coal seam group, and blast-induced vibration.
This paper, based on the energy viewpoint, redivides the coal mine rockburst into two types including static loading type during roadway excavation mainly induced by the compressive elastic energy release of coal seam (Figure 1) and dynamic loading type during mining face advancing mainly induced by elastic stored energy release of overlying strata in the stope (Figure 2).In Figure 2, the dynamic pressure is generated by the whole process of overlying strata breaking.Whether it is static loading type or dynamic loading type, the occurrence of rockburst is related to unreasonable mining distribution design, which leads to mining stress concentration in certain partial area and overlimits accumulation energy of coal body.So the distribution of mining stress should be considered in the prediction and prevention of coal mine rockburst.

Formation Process of Rockburst and
Movement of Overlying Strata Spatial Structure of the Stope 3.1.Mechanism of Rockburst Occurrence.For high strength coal or rock seam, high level elastic stored energy and high level stress concentration induced by tectonic movement and mining face advancing are the root cause of coal mine rockburst [14,15].Without preventive measures of stress and energy releasing, rockburst most probably occurs in the positions of high level stress concentration and elastic stored energy when the working face advances.In the mining process of deep mines, dynamic evolution and development of stress field and energy field create conditions for the formation, occurrence, and development of rockburst.Rockburst is an energy-releasing process with instability in time and nonuniformity in space.Namely, from the time perspective, if the energy releasing rate in coal or rock body is greater than energy consumption rate, then the process of system failure is instable [16].From the space perspective, the energy releasing amount at different points forms the gradient of energy releasing in space.Under the condition of the same total releasing energy, if the releasing energy distribution in the space is nonuniform and it concentrates on one or several points, the releasing energy at these points may overcome the resistance of the surrounding rock or coal body; then dynamic hazards, like rockburst, occur.In the mining conditions of deep coal mine with high stress and strong disturbance, the space-time evolution process of energy field in mining space directly determines the characteristics and formation condition of rockburst.This viewpoint about the energy field of rockburst will be helpful to study regional monitoring technology, such as microseismic monitoring technology.the laboratory test.Mining stress is the dynamic factor for rockburst occurrence.Rockburst usually occurs in intake or return airway close to the working face.Its range is between zero and 80 meters in front of working face.The movement of overlying strata in the stope leads to stress redistribution, which may result in instability of the surrounding rock and the occurrence of mine dynamic hazard.The evolution of mining stress is a dynamic process and is related to the advancing distance of working face, coal mining method, geological structure and distribution, and characteristics of overlying strata spatial structure.

Relationship between Rockburst and Evolution of
With the development of overlying strata spatial structure in the stope, there are two characteristics of mining stress distribution, including first weighting of overlying strata and periodic weighting of working face advancing, during the formation process of breakage arch that consists of the overlying strata.With overlying strata breaking, each hard roof weighting will impact high-level stress concentration zone, which possibly leads to bursting failure.The breakage arch usually consists of several groups of hard roof.So, in order to scientifically and quantitatively study the bursting proneness of high stress zone with mining disturbance, bursting hazard for every group of hard roof rupture should be evaluated, as shown in Figure 3. ℎ 1 stands for the height of caving zone; ℎ 2 stands for the height of fractured zone; ℎ 3 stands for the height of sagging zone;  stands for covering depth.

Criterion of Rockburst Occurrence for Static Loading Type
during Roadway Excavation.In Figure 2,  max represents the maximum value of surrounding rock stress.According to minimal energy principle of rock mass dynamic failure, the energy needed in the breaking process of rock mass under the mechanical condition of one-dimensional stress state, two-dimensional stress state, or three-dimensional stress state, equals the consumption energy of rock mass rupture under the mechanical condition of one-dimensional stress state.So, failure condition for instability rupture of main bearing zone in roadway sides is that, whether it is uniaxial compressive failure or shear failure, the stress exceeds the uniaxial compressive strength or shear strength, namely,  >   or  >   .The corresponding energy consumption criterion is given by [17] where   is the consumption energy needed in the coal or rock body rupture,   is the rock uniaxial compressive strength, and   is the rock shear strength.At the position of maximum value of surrounding rock stress, the energy condition for rockburst occurrence is not only the concentrated static load, but also the accumulated elastic strain energy which is greater than minimum energy needed in the rupture process of coal or rock body.The impacting energy (  ) transmits to the roadway space through the medium and carrier of shallow coal body in the roadway sides, which destroys the roadway, working face, and equipment.The energy criterion for rockburst occurrence is given by (2)

Criterion of Rockburst Occurrence for Dynamic Loading
Type during Mining Face Advancing.Mechanical structure of dynamic loading rockburst during mining face advancing is shown in Figure 3.During the advancing process of working face, compressive elastic energy of coal seam is concentrated due to large area hanging overlying strata applied on the coal seam.Meanwhile, elastic energy is stored in the roof due to the bending deformation of high strength and big thickness hard roof.When hanging overlying strata is long enough, it will break, the compressive elastic energy in the coal seam will be released, and then the rockburst occurs.The smaller the distance of working face and neighboring roadway and centrum is, the more dangerous the impacting failure and corresponding accidents are, because the releasing energy from the centrum decreases progressively in the process of transmission.
From Figure 2, the impacting energy   transmits from roof rupture-induced elastic energy to limit equilibrium area of coal wall which is given by where  0 is the initial releasing energy induced by roof rupture, which can be obtained by the microseismic monitoring,  is the distance of the position of roof rupture and limit equilibrium area of coal wall, which can be obtained by microseismic positioning calculation, and  is the energy damping index when the elastic wave travels through rock or coal mass.
The energy condition of rockburst occurrence is that the sum of elastic strain energy accumulated in the limit equilibrium area and dynamic loading energy from the roof rupture should be greater than the minimum energy needed in the rupture process of coal or rock mass.The criterion is given by where  0 is the accumulated energy in the investigated area representing the stress state in the area under investigation,   is impacting energy generated by seismic event monitored during mining, and   is the consumption energy needed in the coal body rupture.

Assessment and Preventive Process of Rockburst Hazard
Many researchers study the mechanism of rockburst by using strength theory, energy theory, damage and fracture theory, and catastrophe theory.According to these mechanisms, they further study the criterion of rockburst occurrence.The criteria used widely include E. Hoek method that uses the ratio of shear stress of coal wall and uniaxial compressive strength of rock as a criterion, Kidybinski method that uses stored energy, Hou F. L. critical covering depth method, Tao Z. Y. method that uses the ratio of uniaxial strength and maximum principal stress, and analogical method of surrounding rock classification [18].Due to the various and complex reasons of rockburst, using a single factor to predict the rockburst is not appropriate.Based on the information mentioned above, rockburst is closely related to the mining stress distribution and mining disturbance, so multifactors comprehensive evaluation method including mining stress and mining disturbance should be built.

Rockburst Damage Potential Evaluation Methodology.
The magnitude of the seismic event causing the damage should be considered, and whether or not a damaging seismic event is likely to occur at all should be considered also.Meanwhile, it is necessary to consider the distance from the event source to the damage location.It shows that when a significant dynamic load on an excavation occurs (after a rockburst), there is a relation between the seismic events disturbance and the degree of absorbing energy ability.

Released Energy Capacity (REC).
Rockburst damage is known to be highly variable.For any given seismic event at a given distance from an excavation, there can be considerable variation in the amount of rockburst damage.Released energy capacity describes the relationship between the elevated energy condition due to seismic events and the general accumulated energy in the investigated area: where   is the evaluated energy condition due to seismic events based on the seismic wave propagation at distance  from the seismic source in viscoelastic homogenous medium,  0 is the accumulated energy in the investigated area representing the stress state in the area under investigation,  is the attenuation coefficient,  is the relation of, and  is distance to seismic cluster.The evaluated energy condition is based on seismic wave energy propagation at distance  from the seismic source.Accumulated energy (induced stress) in the investigated area is tested by stress sensors.In situ stress measurements have been performed through an application of overcoring technique.

Absorbed Energy Capacity (AEC).
AEC is represented by a rating scale dependent on installed support.Absorbed energy capacity equation includes the current installed reinforcement and its support load capacity in the risk estimations.The higher the capacity of the support to withstand dynamic damage, the larger the AEC.It is considered to account for the energy absorbing level of the rock support in the seismic rock failure process: where  3 is absorbing energy of the installed reinforcement per square meter,  4 is release energy in the anchorage area,   is the maximum support load of the installed reinforcement per square meter, and  local is measured/estimated local stress in the anchorage area.
In general, it is difficult to calculate the real local stress in the anchorage area because of lack of high accuracy instrumentation.Therefore, the absorbed energy capacity (AEC) can be evaluated using qualitative scale of ground support capacity that represents basic support types in coal mine (see Table 2).
The scale of projected damage determines the necessary dynamic capacity of installed ground support.Proper ground reinforcement that can withstand dynamic loading and large deformations is required in order to reduce the rockburst hazard and protect worker and mine infrastructure and sustain safe operation [19].The presented formula will be applied on real seismic data for the first time in coal mine.The obtained results must be evaluated and classified for their risk potential.Therefore, documented damaging events due to seismic activities in the coal mine will be used for general identification purposes.Nevertheless, further assessments with detailed result interpretation and benchmarking should be carried out to verify the assessment formula/approach.

Rockburst Damage Evaluation (RDE).
To consider the likely magnitude and the distance of the seismic event responsible for rockburst damage, the REC index can be combined with the AEC.For assessing rockburst risk, the amount of seismic event energy can be used, which is directly obtained from the seismic events testing system.The combination of the two parameters is termed "rockburst damage evaluation" (RDE).
Based on probabilistic analysis of over 120 instances of rockburst damage, RDE values for which certain levels of rockburst damage are expected to occur are given.The rockburst damage was categorized using Table 3.The detailed value of RDE should be referenced by a specified mine.

Analysis of Typical Cases.
During the advancing process of working face number 9103 in Junde coal mine, the equipment had monitored 118 times microseismic phenomenon, five of which are rockburst that threw a large amount of rock or coal mass out and threatened mine safety production.Combined with microseismic monitoring data, we studied the energy, magnitude, and frequency of microseismic events before and after the rockburst.rockburst in different roadway with same supporting method of bolt-mesh-cable support is shown in Tables 4 and 5.
Based on the RDE value shown in Table 5 and its corresponding damage level, the threshold of each rockburst damage potential level can be determined, as shown in Table 6.In the following mining activities, we can apply this classification method to evaluate each seismic event damage degree to mining space, including instruments and personnel.Different RDE values can be obtained by putting the five event times into the RDE formula.According to the hazard level in combination with the monitored microearthquake events, the rockburst damage potential classification for other working faces can be predicted, especially for the same mining area.

Conclusions
Rockburst occurrence is closely related to the accumulated energy in the impacting zone.Based on the energy factor, it can be divided to two types including static load type during roadway excavation and dynamic load type during mining face advancing.The first is induced when the roadways excavate high concentration area of tectonic stress.The second occurs when the bending deformation that stored elastic energy of overlying strata induces the compressive elastic energy of coal seam.Compressive elastic energy of coal seam is concentrated due to large area hanging overlying strata applied on the coal seam.Elastic energy of overlying strata is stored in the roof due to the bending deformation of high strength and big thickness hard roof.
The formation process of rockburst during the advance of working face is related to the movement of overlying strata of the stope.The impacting energy generated in hard roof when breaking exceeds the upper limit energy that is stored in stress concentrated area.The criteria for static load type during roadway excavation and dynamic load type during the advance of mining face are built; that is,   =  0  − when excavating roadway and  0 +   −   > 0 when mining.
The quantitative method to evaluate and predict rockburst damage evaluation level was studied based on the existing rockbursts' parameters and its hazard appearance.The rockburst is divided into five levels with different RDE values by using the influence of hard roof rupture process on the disturbance of energy accumulated in the area, in combination with previous microearthquake and rockburst events in the mining area.Then the ongoing rockbursts' hazard level can be predicated.

Figure 2 :
Figure 2: Mechanical structure of dynamic loading type during mining face advancing.

Figure 3 :
Figure 3: Structural model of the stope.
Qianqiu coal mine; Jisan, Dongtan, Baodian, and Jiyi coal mines; Xiezhuang coal mine; Zhuangji coal mine; number 11 coal mine in Pingdingshan; Tangshan and Zhaogezhuang coal mines Upper coal pillar formed in the mining coal seam group 11 Huafeng coal mine; Tongjialiang and Xizhouyao coal mines; Junde coal mine Blast-induced vibration 6 Liangzhuang coal mine; Zhaogezhuang coal mine; Nanshan coal mine; Muchengjian coal mine Overlying Strata Structure of the Stope.Rockburst occurrence depends mainly on impacting properties and stress state of rock or coal body.Bursting proneness is the internal property of coal or rock body, which can be obtained from

Table 2 :
Absorbed energy capacity scale for ground support.

Table 4 :
Statistics of previous rockburst in Junde coal mine.