Duration of of Low-Temperature Storage, Clove Topping and Gibberellic Acid on Emergence, Yield and Yield Components of Garlic

Dormancy of freshly harvested garlic cloves does not allow early emergence, and preplanting garlic clove treatment is critical for more than one cycle of production in a year. This field experiment was conducted to assess the effect of treating cloves on emergence, growth, and yield of “Tseday” variety during the main cropping season of 2014/2015 and off-season of 2015/16 at Haramaya University. The experiment was arranged in a factorial combination of four (cold stored at 7°C for the duration of 10, 20, and 30 days and stored at room temperature 21°C for 30 days as control), two (whole and topped clove), and four GA3 treatment at concentration of 0, 125, 250, and 375 mg/l and distilled water treatment as second control laid out in randomized complete block design with three replications. The three main factors (clove type, cold storage duration, and GA3) and growing season showed significant influence on phenology, growth, bulb yield and yield components, and all size categories of cloves, while GA3 showed nonsignificant effect on days to emergence of cloves. Clove type interacted with cold storage duration and GA3, and cold storage duration interacted with GA3 significantly to influence all characters of the variety. In addition, the growing season also interacted with clove type and GA3 to influence all categories of clove size, bulb diameter, average bulb weight, and total bulb yield. The three main factors (clove type × cold storage duration × GA3) interaction significantly influenced all characteristics of the variety. However, 30 days of cold-stored and topped cloves reduced dormancy period and days to maturity by 18.84 and 19.50 days, respectively, and increased total bulb yield by 70.32% as compared to the control treatment. In addition, this treatment combination significantly increased most of the growth and bulb yield components, while the number and weight of small-sized cloves were decreased. Hence, it can be concluded that 30 days of cold storage and topping of cloves without soaking under GA3 could be recommended to enhance early emergence, good vegetative growth, and total bulb yield of the garlic variety both under rain-fed and irrigated conditions.


Introduction
Garlic (Allium sativum L.) belongs to Alliaceae family, and it is believed to be originated in Central Asia (India, Afghanistan, West China, and Russia) and spread to other parts of the world through trade and colonization and used worldwide as a spice, functional food, and medicinal plant [1]. Garlic bulbs have a dormancy period of more than three months. Its sprouting and emergence are controlled mainly by temperature [2]. e early growth stage of garlic is suited by exposure of cloves to low temperature. Such exposure could be achieved using controlled temperature chambers such as refrigerators [3] or planting in a cool growing period, and this treatment is essential for proper development of shoot and good yield of bulb [4,5]. e chilling requirement for improved bulbing in garlic can be supplemented by low-temperature treatment of mother bulbs prior to planting [6]. Siddique and Rabbani [6] reported that the treatment of mother bulbs at 6°C for 50 days before planting shortened the dormancy period and increased the bulb size and yield of garlic, particularly when the crop was planted late in the season.
Many studies have indicated that the application of growth promoter gibberellic acid can affect the growth and development of bulb crops and total bulb yield [7][8][9]. e treatment of seed bulbs (cloves) with gibberellic acid solution stimulated sprouting and bulbing and its development [10]. Ouzounidou et al. [11] also found that gibberellic acid promoted the total plant height in onion and garlic by 35% and 25% over the control, respectively. In addition, the number of leaves per plant and fresh and dry weight in both onion and garlic increased significantly under gibberellic acid.
Likewise, bulbs receiving cutting (topping) treatments sprouted earlier and uniformly than whole bulbs in shallot, Allium wakegi, and onion [12,13]. is could be due to the removal of ABA; a sprout inhibiting substance existed in the removed portion [14].
One of the constraints of garlic production in Ethiopia is scarcity of planting materials since bulbs require the intermediate rest period and, thus, do not suit for immediate use. Hence, preplanting treatment such as low-temperature storage, clove topping, and GA 3 for freshly harvested garlic clove seed would be imperative for easy sprouting and possibility of having two crop cycles per year. However, there is scarce information regarding the effects of these treatments on growth, yield, and yield components of garlic cultivars. us, the objective of this study was to determine the effectiveness of low-temperature storage, clove topping, and GA 3 on growth, yield, and yield components of improved garlic variety, "Tseday."

Description of the Experimental Site.
e experiment was conducted at the experimental farm of Haramaya University (Raare, 505 km east of the capital, Addis Ababa, at 9°26′ N latitude and 42°03′ E longitude and an altitude of 2,022 masl) in eastern Ethiopia and done twice during rainy season and under off-season using irrigation in 2014/15 and 2015/16, respectively. Haramaya is situated in the semiarid tropical belt of eastern Ethiopia. e area has a bimodal rainfall distribution; the short rainy season stretches from March to May and the main rainy season from July to September. During the field experiment, the mean monthly minimum and maximum temperatures were 8.55/11.85°C and 24.83/25.6°C with 56.23/42.86% mean relative humidity during the rainy season (2014/15) and dry season (2015/16), respectively.

Treatments and Experimental Design.
e treatment consisted of 2 × 4 × x 4 factorial combinations of clove types (whole and topped cloves), cold storage durations (10,20, and 30 days) at 7°C plus one stored at room temperature and gibberellic acid concentrations ((0 mg/l or nonsoaked and soaked in distilled water), 125, 250, and 375 mg/l GA 3 ).
Cloves were soaked in distilled water as the additional control treatment, but the results of statistical analyses showed nonsignificant difference with mean values of nonsoaked cloves for all characters; therefore, only nonsoaked cloves are considered as check/control treatment. e treatments were arranged in a randomized complete block design with three replications.

Planting and Agronomic
Practices. Experimental plots were ploughed, thoroughly pulverized, and leveled, and ridges of about 20 cm high were prepared. e plot size was 3.6 m 2 (1.8 m × 2 m). A distance of 1 m between the plots and 1.5 m between blocks was maintained. A garlic cultivar called "Tseday" was used for the experiment. e cloves (2.5-3.0 g) were planted on June 15, 2015, during the rainy season, and on October 15, 2016, during off-season according to the standard planting density of 10 × 30 cm with 20 plants per row. Fertilizer was applied at the rate of 105 N kg ha −1 and 92 P 2 O 5 kg ha −1 in the form of DAP and urea with the equivalent amount of 200 and 150 kg ha −1 , respectively, where all the recommended rate of DAP was applied at planting. Urea was applied in split, one-third during planting, one-third at active vegetative growth (three weeks after plant emergence), and the rest one-third six weeks after plant emergence as side dressing. Weeding, chemical sprays, and harvesting were done as per the recommendation made for the crop [15].

Data
Collection. Ten sample plants from each plot were randomly tagged from the middle four rows, and data were recorded on the growth parameters of garlic. Growth parameters measured from the sample plants were plant height (cm), leaf length and width (cm), and shoot dry matter (g). Additionally, days to 50% emergence of shoots and 75% of maturity of plants were recorded. Yield components were measured after harvest from each treatment viz. neck diameter (cm), bulb length and diameter (cm), average bulb weight (g), clove number and average clove weight (in number and gram, respectively), total dry biomass (g), and clove size category (in number and gram). Clove size categories were determined as follows: very large (>2.50 g), large (2.0-2.50 g), medium (1.50-1.90 g), and small (1.0-1.49 g) [16].
Total bulb yield was calculated from total plants harvested from the central four rows of each plot and expressed on a hectare basis. To determine bulb dry matter, cloves from five randomly selected bulbs were chopped into small pieces with the help of stainless steel knife and mixed thoroughly, and the exact weight of each sample was determined and recorded as fresh weight. e samples were placed in paper bags and dried in an oven at 70°C until a constant weight was obtained. Each sample was immediately weighed using a digital sensitive balance and recorded as dry weight. Percent dry matter content for each sample was calculated by the following formula: where DW � dry weight, CW � container weight, and FW � fresh weight.

Data
Analysis. Data obtained were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA) using the general linear model (GLM) of the SAS Statistical Package Version 9.2. Combined ANOVA over seasons was computed after homogeneity of the variances of the two seasons for all characters of the variety was tested by the F-test [17]. All significant pairs of treatment means were compared using Duncan's multiple range test (DMRT) at 5% level of significance.

Effect of Clove Treatments on Phenology and Growth of
Garlic. e three main factors (clove type, cold storage duration, and GA 3 ) and growing season had significant influence on phenology and growth of "Tseday," while GA 3 did not influence significantly the days to emergence of cloves. Clove type interacted with cold storage duration and GA 3 and cold storage duration × GA 3 interaction significantly influenced all phenology and growth, while growing season interacted with clove type and cold storage duration to influence days to emergence of cloves. All phenology and growth characteristics were significantly influenced by the interaction of clove type × cold storage duration × GA 3 ( Table 1).

Phenology.
irty days of cold-stored and topped cloves treated as control emerged about 18.84 days earlier than the control (non-cold-stored, non-topped, and non-GA 3 -treated cloves), and plant maturity was reduced by 19.5 days. However, cloves stored at ambient temperature, topped, and GA 3 -treated resulted in the longest duration for maturity. e application of GA 3 at a rate of 250 and 375 mg/ l on ambient temperature stored and non-topped cloves showed significantly earlier emergence and delayed maturity as compared to 0 and 125 mg/l GA 3 -treated cloves ( Table 2).
Earlier emergence and maturity of cold-stored and topped cloves could be due to the earlier sprouting of cloves and subsequent faster sprout growth. Earlier sprouting by clove topping could be due to the removal of sprout inhibiting substances contained in the removed scale portion as suggested by Lin and Roberts [18] and Wang and Roberts [19] in Easter lily. e substance inhibiting sprouting in the bulbs of Allium wakegi has been proved to be abscisic acid [14]. Similarly, Yamazaki et al. [20] and Teaster et al. [21] also reported that the decrease in endogenous ABA content led to early sprouting. In agreement with this, Arifin et al. [12] reported that bulbs received cutting treatments sprouted earlier than whole bulbs in all accessions of shallot and Allium wakegi.
Solomina [22] and Takagi [2] reported the early emergence of seed cloves stored at 7°C and attributed this to the effect of low temperature in reducing the proportion of growth inhibitors and increase in growth-promoting hormones, especially gibberellins. Silva and Casali [23] also reported that cold storage for 30 and 40 days reduced the dormant period and increased field emergence. In addition, Langens-Gerrits et al. [24] observed that shoot emergence from dormant bulblets of Lilium speciosum occurred more quickly with greater uniformity after a longer chilling (6 weeks) duration at 5°C.
Several researchers have reported the early maturity of garlic and onions after a preplanting low-temperature treatment [25,26]. e findings agree with the research of Aura [27], Butt [28], Palilov [29], and Khokhar et al. [26] on onions; under low storage temperatures (0-7°C), the vegetative cycle is reduced and bulbing is accelerated, while under high temperatures (18-30°C), both bulbing and ripening are delayed.
Rahim and Fordham [30] also showed that garlic cloves treated with cold temperatures at 5 or 10°C for 15 to 30 days before planting had accelerated maturity of bulbs relative to those stored at 15 and 20°C. is is due to the ability of long cold storage duration to effectively break dormancy followed by early emergence rate for easy stand establishment and initiation of bulbing and thereby ending its physiological activity of growth and development than non-cold and nontopped treated cloves [12,25,31,32]. e earlier sprouting and longest duration of maturity by GA 3 could be due to rapid stimulation of sprouting and vigorous vegetative growth. In line with this, Rahman et al. [33] reported that the sprouting percentage of Allium sativum increased in bulbs treated with GA 3 , where the highest percentage of germination was achieved at the concentration of 250 ppm. On the other hand, Rahman et al. [33] indicated that GA 3 treatment at 250 ppm delayed bulb maturity compared with those treated with lower concentrations and nontreated ones. GA 3 delays maturity because of its physiological effects in the stimulation of vegetative growth [33][34][35].

Growth Characteristics.
Storage of cloves at cold temperature for 30 days coupled with topping and no GA 3 application resulted in the highest plant height, leaf length and width, and shoot dry mass. However, cloves stored at ambient temperature, topped, and treated with GA 3 gave the smallest values of these parameters followed by 10 days of cold-stored, topped, and GA 3 -treated cloves. A significant increase in plant height, leaf length and width, and shoot dry mass was observed by the application of GA 3 at a rate of 250 and 375 mg/l on ambient temperature stored and nontopped cloves as compared to 0 and 125 mg/l GA 3 -treated cloves (Table 3). e increase in growth characters by GA 3 could possibly be due to early sprouting of cloves and proper growth of vegetative parts by GA 3 application that lack sufficient amount of cold temperature exposure [11,36]. In accordance with this, Ouzounidou et al. [11] reported that 100 ppm GA 3 application after three weeks of germination promoted elongation of onion and garlic plants by 35% and 25%, respectively, over the control. On the contrary, Rahman et al. [37] reported that plant height decreased with e Scientific World Journal increased concentration of GA 3 to 200 ppm spry application. Rahman et al. [33] reported a difference result that showed nonsignificant effect of GA 3 on plant height and enhanced initiation and development of garlic leaf growth. e significant increase in growth characters by clove topping and cold storage could possibly be due to early sprouting of cloves, which enabled proper vegetative growth. Such an increase in vegetative growth by topping [38,39] and cool temperature [4,5] resulted in increased leaf growth of the plant. In agreement with this, Dutcher and Powell [40] and Singha and Powell [41], who used apple (Malus domestica Borkh cv Northern Spy) buds, found that ABA inhibited bud break and shoot elongation.
Satin and Lopez [25] indicated that bulbs that received low-temperature storage had increased plant growth compared with nontreated counterparts. Lucidos et al. [42] also showed that exposure of bulbs to 4°C for 65 days promoted stem elongation in Lilium hansonii. In addition, Kurtar and Ayan [43] reported that exposure of tulips to low temperature increased the production of gibberellins and auxins, which were necessary for stalk elongation.

Effect of Clove Treatments on Yield and Yield Components of Garlic.
e growing season and the three main factors significantly influenced bulb yield and yield components of "Tseday" variety. Clove type interacted with cold storage duration and GA 3 to influence all bulb yield and yield components of the variety. Interaction of growing season × clove type and growing season × GA 3 significantly influenced bulb diameter, average bulb weight, and total bulb yield. In addition, the interaction of growing season × cold storage duration significantly influenced bulb diameter and average clove weight. All bulb yield and yield components of the variety were significantly influenced by the interaction of clove type × cold storage duration × GA 3 , while bulb diameter, average bulb weight, and total bulb yield were significantly influenced by the interaction of season × clove type × GA 3 (Table 4).  e highest neck diameter, bulb length and diameter, and average bulb weight were recorded from 30 days of cold-stored and topped cloves treated with no GA 3 . However, cloves stored at ambient temperature, topped, and treated by GA 3 gave the smallest values of these parameters followed by 10 days of cold-stored, topped, and GA 3 -treated cloves (Figures 1-3 and Table 5). ese bulb characters were also significantly increased by treating with GA 3 at a rate of 250 and 375 mg/l on ambient temperature stored and non-topped cloves as compared to 0 and 125 mg/l GA 3 -treated cloves (Table 5). In addition, significantly higher values of these characters were also observed from 30  e Scientific World Journal days of cold-stored and topped cloves with no GA 3 as compared to 30 days of cold-stored and non-topped cloves with no GA 3 treatment (Figures 1, 3-5 and Table 5). e increase in bulb size by low temperature could be due to the increase in auxin and GA 3 production that in turn stimulates clove differentiation and development of larger bulbs [44]. In line with this, several authors reported that low temperature before planting the cloves increased the bulb size of garlic that eventually reflected in bulb length and diameter [6,25,45,46]. e increase in bulb characters due to cold storage, topping, and GA 3 could be the results of early emergence and an increase in the vegetative growth status before moisture and nutrient reserves dwindle. e vigorous vegetative growth accumulates more net photosynthates, which are then translocated to bulbs forming larger bulbs.
In agreement with the present result, Rahman et al. [33] and Ade-Ademilua et al. [5] reported that the pretreatment of garlic cloves with cold temperature and GA 3 could have helped the plants to improve their ability to use available growth resources, moisture, and nutrients.

Clove Characteristics.
Preplant cold treatment of cloves for 30 days and topping with no GA 3 application resulted in the highest number of cloves per bulb, while average clove weight was significantly higher for 30 and 20 days of cold-stored and topped cloves treated with no GA 3 . Clove number and average clove weight were significantly increased by the application of GA 3 at a rate of 250 and 375 mg/l on ambient temperature stored and non-topped cloves as compared to 0 and125 mg/l GA 3 -treated cloves ( Table 6). e increase in clove number and weight due to GA 3 [10], cold storage [25,44,45], and clove topping might be due to the earliest sprouting and the subsequent development of large bulbs caused by vigorous vegetative growth [47]. On the contrary, Rahim and Fordham [48] and Youssef [46] reported that preplant cold treatment of cloves reduced the number of cloves per bulb.

Bulb Dry Matter Percentage and Total Dry Biomass.
Cloves cold stored for 30 days, topped, and with no GA 3 treatment resulted in the highest bulb dry matter percentage and total dry biomass. However, cloves stored at ambient temperature, topped, and treated by GA 3 gave the smallest values of these parameters. e application of GA 3 at a rate of 250 and 375 mg/l on ambient temperature stored and non-topped cloves showed a significant increase in bulb dry matter percentage and total dry biomass as compared to 0 and 125 mg/l GA 3 -treated cloves (Table 7). e higher bulb dry matter percentage and total dry biomass by low temperature could be due to the vigorous vegetative growth that accumulates more net photosynthates, which are then translocated to bulbs and forming a higher dry matter accumulation in the bulbs. In line with this, Qaryouti and Kasrawi [47] reported that higher dry weight of bulbs was produced from cloves stored at 0 or 10°C than those stored at room temperature (17-22°C) as a result of the vigorous vegetative growth. De Klerk [49] also reported lower values of dry weight of lily bulbs exposed to 15°C than 4°C. e increase in total dry biomass and bulb dry matter percentage by GA 3 could possibly be due to the early breakdown of clove dormancy and its effect on cell division and elongation, which enhanced shoot growth. In addition, Daykin et al. [34], Hisamatsu et al. [35], and Rahman et al. [33] reported that the application of GA 3 stimulated vegetative growth, which could increase the dry matter content of bulbs. Rahman et al. [37] also reported that the spray application of GA 3 significantly increased total dry biomass.    e Scientific World Journal e increase in total dry biomass and bulb dry matter percentage by cold treatment [4,5] and topping [38,39] might be due to earlier sprouting and the subsequent vigorous vegetative growth of the plant, which increased dry mass of the plant.

Total Bulb Yield.
e highest bulb yield was recorded from 30 days of cold-stored and topped cloves treated with no GA 3 treatment followed by 20 days of cold-stored and topped cloves treated with no GA 3 application. However, cloves stored at ambient temperature, topped, and treated by GA 3 gave the smallest total bulb yield followed by 10 days of cold-stored, topped, and GA 3 -treated cloves (Figures 1-3 and Table 7). A significant increase in total bulb yield was observed by the application of GA 3 at a rate of 250 and 375 mg/l on ambient temperature stored and non-topped cloves compared with 0 and 125 mg/l GA 3 -treated cloves (Table 7). A significantly higher value of total bulb yield was also recorded from 30 days of cold-stored and topped cloves with no GA 3 treatment as compared to 30 days of cold-stored and non-topped cloves with no GA 3 treatment (Figures 1, 3-5 and Table 7). In addition, a significantly higher value of bulb yield was observed from 30 days of cold-stored and topped cloves with no GA 3 treatment as compared to 30 days of cold-stored and topped cloves with all rates of GA 3 treatment (Figures 1, 3, 6-8 and Table 7). e increase in total bulb yield by GA 3 could be attributed to the positive impact of optimum concentrations of GA 3 on vegetative growth that resulted in higher bulb yield. In agreement with this,   Rahman et al. [33] reported that the application of GA 3 stimulated vegetative growth, which could increase the bulb yield of garlic. e production of higher yields from seed cloves stored at 7°C and topped may be due to the development of higher vegetative growth, measured as plant height and leaf number, before initiation of bulbing as compared to lower vegetative growth obtained from seed cloves stored at room temperature. Plants need to achieve adequate growth before bulbing commences, so that the foliage can produce large bulbs and high yields [50,51]. Satin and Lopez [25] reported that total bulb yield was higher when cloves were stored at 0°C and 7°C for 30 days than cloves stored at 25°C for 30 days. Bhuiya et al. [4] also reported that low-temperature exposure is essential for proper development of shoot and good yield of bulb.
In addition, Bandara et al. [52] found that increasing the chilling treatment (4°C) period up to 45 days prior to field planting increased the bulb yield, while a further increase in the treatment period reduced the yield. However, there are many contradictions on the effect of the preplanting lowtemperature treatment on garlic yield; some researchers have reported increases [53], while others have observed no significant differences [54]; still, others have reported depressive effects [55].

Effect of Clove Treatments on Clove Sizes of Garlic.
e growing season, three main factors, the interaction of clove type with cold storage duration and GA 3 , and the interaction of cold storage duration and GA 3 significantly influenced all categories of the clove size of the variety. In addition, the interaction of growing season and clove type significantly influenced cloves under large (in number basis), and very large and small size (in weight basis) categories. e growing season also interacted with cold storage duration to affect significantly large and very large cloves, while it interacted with GA 3 and with clove type × GA 3 significantly influenced cloves under large size category on weight basis. All categories of the clove size of the variety were significantly influenced by the interaction of clove type × cold storage duration × GA 3 ( Table 8).
Planting of 30 days of cold-stored and topped cloves treated with no GA 3 showed the smallest number and weight of small-sized cloves per bulb. On the other hand, the same treatment resulted in the highest number and weight of medium-sized, large-sized, and very large-sized cloves per bulb. Cloves stored at ambient temperature, topped, and GA 3 -treated recorded the highest number and weight of small-sized cloves and the lowest number and weight of medium-sized, large-sized, and very large-sized cloves per bulb (Tables 9, 10).
Gibberellic acid treatment at a rate of 250 and 375 mg/l on ambient temperature stored and non-topped cloves showed a significant decrease in number and weight of small-sized cloves per bulb and an increase in number and weight of medium-sized, large-sized, cloves per bulb as compared to 0 and 125 mg/l GA 3 -treated cloves. GA 3 application at a rate of 250 mg/l on 20 days of cold-stored and non-topped cloves showed a comparable weight of smallsized cloves, number and weight of large-sized cloves, number of medium-sized cloves, and weight of very largesized cloves with 30 days of cold-stored and non-topped cloves treated with GA 3 (Tables 9, 10). Similarly, this treatment showed a comparable weight of medium-sized cloves with 30 days of cold-stored and non-topped cloves treated with 125 and 250 mg/l GA 3 application. e number and weight of medium-sized, large-sized, and very largesized clove increment by GA 3 application could be due to early sprouting and bulbing and its development. In agreement with this, Moon and Lee [10] reported that preplant treatment of cloves with GA 3 produced positive impact on the number and weight of cloves. e consistent increase in number and weight of mediumsized, large-sized, and very large-sized cloves and decreasing number and weight of small-sized cloves in response to planting of 30 days of cold-stored, topped, and no GA 3 -treated cloves could be due to the effect of clove topping, low temperature, and GA 3 in early sprouting and bulbing. Clove topping treatment results in earlier and uniform sprouting that favors bulbing [12,13]. is is due to the removal of ABA, and a sprout inhibiting substance existed in the removed portion [14]. Low temperature also increases auxin and GA 3 production that in turn stimulates clove differentiation and development of larger bulbs [44]. Youssef [46] also reported that decreasing temperature (10°C) and increasing storage duration  Means with different letter(s) in columns have significant differences according to DMRT at 5% probability level, and BDM � bulb dry matter, TDB � total dry biomass, and TBY � total bulb yield.    ns, * and * * nonsignificant, significant at P < 0.05 and P < 0.01, respectively.

Conclusion
For cloves stored at ambient temperature (0 day) and nontopped, gibberellic acid application at a rate of 250 and 375 mg/l significantly reduced dormancy period by 5.84 days while increasing days to maturity by 2.84 days and yield by 9.72% compared with the control. On the other hand, for topped cloves stored at 0, 10, 20, and 30 days of cold storage, GA 3 treatment significantly delayed days to maturity and decreased yield of garlic, while it did not show a significant influence on days to emergence as compared to the controls. e 30 days of coldstored and topped cloves with no GA 3 treatment significantly reduced dormancy period and days to maturity while increasing the yield of garlic as compared to the controls. In addition, this treatment significantly increased most of the growth and bulb yield components, while the number and weight of small-sized cloves were decreased. us, the combination of cold storage for 30 days and topping without soaking under GA 3 could be used to treat fresh garlic cloves for early emergence (19.16 days), good vegetative growth, and higher yield (13.66 t/ha) both under rainfed and irrigated conditions.

Data Availability
e data used to support the findings of this study are included within the article.

Conflicts of Interest
e authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.

Authors' Contributions
BDA is the first author of the research article, whereas the coauthors have contributed equally for the literature collection, data collection and analysis, manuscript documentation, and its revision. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.